Loved the sing along piano man in the bar. Jealous of the people who claimed the seats around the piano... looked like they were having a lot of fun! We had fun listening, even though we were sitting at the bar. Dinning experience was only so-so however. Thing I really liked was the French Roquefort dressing (for salad). My Prime Rib was better than average, but my wife's steak was so underdone (for her, medium well tastes) the center was not even medium rare! Her Haddock was tasty however. We both also ordered hash browns as a side, my wife's browns came out first and they were great. I was told that that mine would be out in a minute. What came out was definitely freezer burnt, gray and oily. My browns did not even look like my wife's, and tasted terrible. Because we had plenty to eat, I just shared my wife's and left mine. I did show the waitress. . She told me I should have told her earlier, she would have had them remake them. That would have been great if she would have been at the table more than the one time she said "how are the first few bites". Never got a refill on my water, even though I asked. (It's funny... she did ask if she could refill my alcoholic beverage multiple times when that was empty!) I'll say we did really enjoy the barroom entertainment, dining experience... maybe not so much. Plus.. kind of thought that when I didn't eat my hash-browns that my wife didn't eat most of her steak that maybe they would have offered a dessert or something.... read more

George's Steak House - Prime Rib - 22oz. - Steakhouses Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Old school and awesome. Been here a few times with our Pierce fire truck rep. Brought my wife this time since we were only 45 minutes away. She loved it too. The onion soup is great. The steaks are always on point and so are the scallops. You will never go wrong with the prime rib. Service is always friendly and outstanding. read more

Old school vibe. Classic steakhouse menu. Charming staff that hustles. My husband had the Tenderloin Stroganoff. It was rich, decadent and he loved every bite. I had the smaller Ribeye and asked for char on the outside, med rare on the inside. It was perfect. read more

See all

Welcome to 1977. The wood paneling, the oil lamp, the ambiance you would expect from a steakhouse that never let the 1970's out of their sight. Phenomenal steaks, loaded bake potatoes & homemade garlic ranch. Service with a smile and just the perfect amount of Northern Wisconsin charm. Definitely a great experience!! read more

George's Steak House - Front Entrance - Steakhouses Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Georges is the most romantic restaurant to eat at in the valley They have a piano playing for you and you can sing along if you want to and of course the food is so delicious I always get a steak because the seasoning on it makes it taste so good read more

Took our son out for belated birthday dinner. Great service and excellent drinks, steaks, and dessert! Crystal, our server was friendly and efficient. She helped make our dinner a wonderful dining experience! read more

An early Valentine's dinner for my wife and I, we decided to revisit George's​. Even after ten years or more since we last were here, the food, ambiance and staff were as good if not better than the before! Jan was so wonderful to us as our server! I had a delicious perfectly prepared Poerterhouse while my wife had the Rib-Eye. The steaks, the French Onion Soup and the salads were perfect! Thanks to the staff for making our special dinner that much better! read more

Went here on a whim for a birthday dinner and boy were we happy we did! Excellent ambience, service, and food! We order the chicken and the cheeseburger soups which were hot and delicious! Next we had our salad and this is one of the few places still in the valley to serve hot bacon dressing too! After being told so much about it i was glad to finally try it! We had cheese curds appetizers with home made ranch which was also amazing! Our server recommended after-all the owner has been snacking on em for decades (something we saw with our own eyes here too ) Our steaks were cooked perfectly too! We will definitely be back! Oh and can't forget the cherry desert! read more

George's Steak House - Ice-cream dinner drink! - Steakhouses Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

We went out for our anniversary and what a great dinner, Food was superior. Excellent service and the atmosphere was awesome.

Amazing experience! The hostess seemed a little overwhelmed but once we got seated it was all perfect. Server was very patient with us out-of-towners! Drinks and food were delicious. Great portion sizes and the prices are amazing! read more

Came in early in the week. Probably my new favorite restaurant in Appleton. I only ate at the bar, but love the old supper club vibe. Incredibly well maintained. Want to come back for the piano players. All the food was impeccably prepared. Bartender was wonderfully attentive even though the entire bar area was packed. read more

Stopped in because we were recommended to try it out for a good steak. We wanted an early dinner so we came right when they started seating dinner and we had a table instantly. This is an old building with a cool bar and you can tell this place is a blast from the past. It truly looks like it hasn't been updated in 40 years, but that's the vibe they are going for with this traditional "supper club". Our service was very quick and organized. She asked for our drink order but we never received a drink menu so she went and got one. That's when we noticed they had appetizers on the drink menu, which we also would have never seen. So we ordered some beers and cheese curds. The curds were delicious and she brought us their house made garlic sauce. For my meal, I got the porterhouse which included bread, a salad, soup, and a potato of my choice. The amount of food was incredible. The tomato bisque soup was hot and tasty. I wish my baked potato had more than just sour cream but that's all she offered. Overall, an interesting old building with pretty good food. The portions were massive for a reasonable price for a steakhouse. read more

See all

Solid steakhouse in the middle of downtown. Friends and family gather in this dark-paneled den for fine-dining. My steak was cooked perfectly, with just the right amount of sear, and it tasted great. Good cuts of beef, with a garden salad, and recognizable side-dishes ciled me up. I was too full for dessert. read more

George's Steak House - There is a lot of history here - Steakhouses Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

I heard this place gave the cheddar cheese and was a nice little steak house. We called and made a reservation. We were seated on time and it was a nice little place. The service was good but a little slower. Our dinner was 2.5 hours long. The soup was very good and flavorful. The salad was poor with a lot of pieces that were bad. The onion rings on the steak were thin and good. The steak was okay. Not the best but not terrible. I would eat it again but I wouldn't rush back for it. Overall it was a decent experience. read more

See all

The 5pm dinner time yesterday proved to be a slow night with not that many tables to serve, but the service was slow, and unfriendly. My wife and I (celebrating our 45th) started with a brandy Old Fashioned and we both asked for the traditional orange slice and cherries. There was no orange, but we did not complain. My wife had the tenderloin, and had no issues, but I ordered the Seafood Supreme. There was a good portion of shrimp, but only 4 tiny Bay scallops. The pasta was some sort of spiral shape, but the menu stated penne. The amount of sauce was far too much. It should have been advertised as a stew, and served with a spoon. The sauce had no flavor, no spices, and came with a small half sized bread stick completely soaked in the sauce. Only at the end of the meal did the server ask "how was the meal". I tried to explain we were out celebrating our anniversary, and we have been dining at George's for over 30 years, but this night was the 1st time that I had a bad meal. Before I could explain why it was bad, she cut me off in mid-sentence, grabbed a gift certificate as payment and walked away. read more

We tried this great little location while we were visiting EAA in Oshkosh. It reminded me of an old-school steakhouse and I absolutely loved it! The bar seemed old school and the drinks (lemon drop martini) was terrific and served by a friendly staff. The food was delicious! The menu has so many selections, you have a hard time deciding exactly what you want, everything looked so delicious. We had a great time there and at EAA. If, I mean when, we make it back to that area ,I can assure you that we will be coming back for another great experience!! read more

Went to Georges tonight after not having been there for over a year.The salad bar was gone and we were handed a basket of crackers and 2 small little plastic containers with a tasteless liver pate and the other with a very weak scoop of cheddar cheese. My wife ordered the salmon(after the waitress told us she was not very fond of their salmon)and I ordered the New York strip.This is probably the worst steak I have ever had here in the valley. Absolutely tasteless and at least 50% of it was gristle! A bitter disappointment. The waitress was short with us and acted like she had better things to do. I thought the crowd was not as large as I had remembered seeing at George's,it used to be packed to overflowing in the past. Now I know why. read more

We made reservations on St. Patrick's Day for our anniversary. We ordered dinner. Surprisingly, it was not very good. My steak was sour and appeared like it was taken from the freezer and thrown on the grille. There was no markings and light brown in color We've been eating there for over 40 years and it was usually good. Sadly we will never eat there again. read more

Wether you go to George's during the week or on the weekend, you'll be sure to have a fabulous dinner! Always craving a good steak, I can tell you that the New York Strip, T-Bone and Tenderloin are steaks I've ordered for decades and always meet my high expectations. The servers are always working hard to make sure your meal is exactly the way you want it, as do the chefs. It's always nice to support a family owned business and they certainly make it easy. The Piano Bar and after dinner drinks complete a nice experience. read more

TITLE: GUARD ALL YOUR FOOD! After a very long trying week, my hubby and I decided to go out Friday after work. We debated going to The Bar for wings or Georges Steakhouse. He thought we deserved a better meal that night so he called earlier in the day and made us reservations for 5:30 pm Friday night. After my longgg Friday was over, I made my way over to Georges. I was excited, I hadn't been there in over a year, I was hungry, I remembered the last meal I had there which was out of their world. I was stoked! I arrived before my husband and waited at the bar and ordered a drink. The bartender (woman) was very short with me as I ordered my drink. Whatever. I watched the tv as I waited. My husband walked in sat next to me and the bartender became a different person, bubbly, nice... what the heck? Rude. When our table was ready we made our way over there. We sat for maybe 30 seconds and our waitress KIM was standing there, "CAN I TAKE YOUR ORDER?" uhh no we just sat down. Give us a few minutes please we told her. She came back to take our order, in which she was extremely irritated to be doing so, didn't like answering questions about the menu, THATS EXTRA, THAT'S EXTRA! I replied Ya fine whatever! OK! We both ordered the clam chowder, I ordered the petite filet with blue cheese crust (wasn't crusty at all, just melted blue cheese), fries, and shredded onion strings. Hubby ordered Perch. She left, came back, dropped off the cracker basket, spreadable cheese, and liver pate. We started to snack on those items which were good. She came back and dropped off the clam chowder which tasted more like navy bean soup, with some mystery white stuff on top. Cheese I assume? No clue. She came back to grab the soup bowls and took the cracker basket, "OH ARE STILL EATING THOSE?!" UHH YA, she put the basket down. She was grabbing everywhere so fast to rid things it was unreal. I told my husband here she comes guard your food. She brought our entrees (and breadbasket?-usually it comes with soup) dropped them on the table and grabbed the crackers, spreadable cheese, and liver pate even tho we were still snacking on them without asking if we were done. Whatever. Then towards the end of the meal, she started to be slightly pleasant especially when she brought the bill. Nope. Not buying it. First impressions mean everything and they set the tone and experience for the whole dining experience that night. This person did not provide a pleasurable experience at all. HORRIBLE! RUSH RUSH RUSH. Not going back. It's a shame, we have had great experiences in the past, not taking the chance again. We should have gone to The Bar! As an Elite yelper, maybe I should wear my yelp button next time I go out! read more

I don't do steak houses and restaurants with multiple courses because I have a small appetite and I get full very easy but prime rib was on my mind so George's steak house was getting a visit from me. The main course comes with potatoe or vegy, bread sticks, bread and butter, relish bar, soup, and salad. Who eats all that. At 5:40 on a Saturday the lot was full but I did get a table. The place looked old school up scale from decades ago. There is rich wood beams on the ceiling. Rich wood and stone walls. It's multi level with a full bar. Dim lighting and candles on the tables. Chandler and wall sconces add to the decor. The crowd Is defined the older ones but there was a Dodge Viper in the lot and I wonder who owned that, see my pictures. Service was wonderful even though they were very busy and I have no complaints there. The menu is extensive with duck, beef, seafood, chicken, pasta, chops, sandwiches and etc. I went for the 16 oz prime rib and asked for the rarest they had with the soup and potato. I asked not to be given the bread sticks, relish bar, bread and butter and the salad because I didn't want to waste it. The 16 0oz prime looked killer and the menu says the meat is aged. The prime rib comes in a metal tray sitting in a lake of au jus. I had the chicken dumpling soup and au gratin potatoes with horseradish sauce on the side. The prime was very good and very tender, I actually didn't like how the horseradish sauce masked the flavor of the meat so I didn't use it much. I liked the tender juicy chew of the meat with that rich flavor from some of the fat but I did cut most of it off. The chicken dumpling soup was tasty with sturdy dumplings and not that mush from a can with big pulled pieces of chicken. The au gratin potatoes were very thick and good. I really liked how tender the prime rib was with no weird chewy pieces. This meal really hit the spot and and fulfilled my crave for prime rib. Over all the meal was decent and I really liked the prime rib along with great service so I give it two thumbs up. read more

See all

they were out of buns for my burger, I had to get alfredo instead and you would be better off going to Olive Garden.

Ordered the porterhouse and it was very chewy. Informed the waitress and she said the owner was in the kitchen looking at the steaks....mine was on my plate. Not very much flavor on our steaks or the soup. Don't think I'd go back. Atmosphere was old, but they did have a piano and someone was playing it which was good. read more

Had a filet that was perfectly cooked and a delicious piece of meat. Out server was excellent and the bar staff was very helpful. All aspects were exceptional. read more

I'm in Appleton for work and have been too exhausted at the end of the day to go pick up food. I guess the first mistake was getting delivery from here but George's was literally one of the only places on the big apps that had anything healthy that wasn't a salad. I got the lemon pepper chicken, which was soaked in a weird gelatinous sauce. I ordered the "vegetable du jour" and it literally is a few small pieces of broccoli and slightly more cauliflower that was DIED. The broccoli and cauliflower were steamed to hell and literally didn't even have salt on it. read more

George's Steak House - Lemon pepper chicken - Steakhouses Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

My husband and I went to George's Steak House tonight. We had a fabulous time!! The bartenders were friendly and very attentive! We enjoyed the piano bar, and our dinner was superb! We loved the small supper club feel, and the food was delicious! I have a gluten allergy and had zero reactions. I'm definitely coming back! read more

It was ok ... not great food but the server was nice. The piano bar was ok the bartender was great

One of the most pathetic experiences I have ever had at a restaurant. Ordered a New York strip and a lobster tail with clam chowder as my soup. The soup was runny and no clam in it at all. The New York strip as quoted by my friend with my was like chewing on a tire, both of our steaks were over cooked. I would rather let my 10 year old try cooking beef for his first time ever then eat that steak again. We ordered lobster tails as an add on and they were over cooked and one of the most chewy lobster tails I have ever eaten NOT to mention it was $43 per tail!!! I just had steak and lobster Wednesday night at dick and Joan's the larger tail was only $15 and blew George's out of the water. Extremely disappointed in the entire experience. The worst $105 I've ever spent eating a meal. read more

Found this gem while searching for a steakhouse to take my customers to. Highly recommend stopping by and experiencing an amazing restaurant that has a great staff, and great food!! The ambiance alone will take you back in time, and it's worth it. read more

Sat immediately but our waitress took forever to bring our drinks. Half the menu was sold out. The waitress had a horrible attitude.

Such a nice evening we had! It's also rare to find a super club with scooter accessibility so that makes dinning with my Father in law all the more special. The staff was very attentive and the food was excellent. We tried the deep fried pickle spears from the appetizer menu to start and they were so yummy. We enjoyed our cocktails at the piano bar, that was fun and even though we were far from the bar tender she never forgot about us. My husband has the prime rib and didn't even leave one bite. I had a steak and scallop combo, I was eager to eat my left overs for lunch the next day. read more

Hungry for a great steak? Can't beat this place! My husband took me there all the time. Excellent food and great staff.

If you want to feel special and have a throwback vibe, this is the place for you! Excellent food with good drinks no matter your preference. I have never had a bad meal here and I have had several. read more

Good food good service, supporting local restaurants. That's how it should be done. I had a very pleasant experience here and service was phenomenal. Food was made to order and very friendly people. Will definitely return read more

Absolutely amazing experience tonight. Service was top notch and both of our servers gave us great recommendations. Old fashioned was delicious and the steaks were fantastic as well! Salads were great as well especially the hot bacon dressing. Had the tenderloin with scallops and potato peels with garlic dressing which was perfect. Overall a great experience and can't wait to come back next time I am here visiting family! read more

Great bar staff and waitress. Salad was fresh, steaks were excellent and best hash browns ever, crispy , the way I asked for them!

Always one of my favorite place for a steak. Down home feel with the best steaks anywhere.

Absolutely delicious! Excellent service and the live jazz piano music was an added treat. Being from Georgia we are loving the Supper Club style restaurant's here in Wisconsin. We had the clam chowder. I had the broiled haddock & my husband the deep fried perch. George's Steakhouse is top's in our book. We will definitely be eating here again. read more

See all

Amazing steak and lobster dinner! Cooked to perfection! Restaurant has an old school feel, the service was great and they even have a piano man playing near the bar. I highly recommend it this steak house for perfectly cooked steak and a great ambience. read more

My rehearsal dinner was held in the barrel room at George's. Brad and his team were a pleasure to work with. The room was very private and the food was excellent. We made a reduced menu and they let us bring in our own dessert. The bar staff were fast and were extremely accommodating. read more