I had a darn good half of a Sicilian slice today. The square was so large, we decided to share and it was cut diagonally which was clever.. I used to frequent this corner pizzeria years ago but have been equally absent for several years. For one thing, I have been loyal to a couple other local favorites. In addition, your order here doesn't come with a smile. While many, if not most, of the pizzas on the counter looked a bit dried out, this Sicilian slice was so delicious: airy dough/crust, perfect sauce with the right amount of cheese. Once warmed, it immediately came back to life and was delicious.. They make personal pies as well as other pizza varieties. Buffalo anyone? Speaking for myself, I love the traditional style. Since I just made a comeback, I'll have to revisit a few more times to solidify my review or change it. But for now, it was real good. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The staff was buzzing and busy when I arrived, but they were really nice. They helped me choose a slice (Square, with fresh mozzarella) and it was pretty good. I wish the crust was a little crisper, but I was a solid Brooklyn offering. The ingredients were fresh, bright, and savory. I'd definitely try other slices if I'm in the area. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Fresh mozzarella slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Foods not nearly as flavorful with new owners. I kept adding parmesan and red pepper. The energy is not friendly anymore. What a bummer!

This Places Pizza is awesome. My friend suggested it and oh my god, what a great pizza. I will deffinetly be ordering from these guys again

Best slice I've had in a while, good quality cheese and plenty of sauce, perfect for the "saucy" types. Crust perfectly soft and crispy. These days it seems like every pizza is essentially a white pizza without sauce, maybe as a cost saving measure? but theirs has restored my hope. Super fast, friendly fast service. Next to the G. Ate so fast I couldn't savor it with pics, totally worth eating it at its hottest. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Excellent Pies , calzone.. .Better than anything on Court St. plus a nice outdoor space.

Giardini Pizza is a neighborhood treasure. The pizza here is beyond delicious--perfectly crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. You can tell they've been doing this a long time, and for good reason--the owner has been here for 30 years, and his passion shows in every pie. He's incredibly kind and welcoming, the kind of person who makes you feel right at home as soon as you walk in. There's a real community vibe here--no gimmicks, just amazing pizza and great people. If you want the kind of local spot that keeps you coming back, Giardini is it. Can't recommend it enough! read more

The worker was nice, but every time I want to give this place a chance since it's a neighborhood staple but the taste of the pizza just seems off, both the cheese and sauce. Also when I got to the crust all I tasted was flour on the bottom. read more

Excellent slices and squares! When I used to live in the area back in the 90s, this was my go to spot. Decades later, the pizzas are still as good and I enjoyed it just as much. My daughter enjoyed it too, and the outdoor seating gave it a nicer experience. Good quality ingredients, great staff, and decent beverage options. I highly recommend having the square slices, you'll definitely be satisfied! Cool for groups. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pepperoni and Sicilian pizzas. Same great taste when I came here as a teen! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

First time customer, traveled from Los Angeles to try their pizza. Wow!! Was it worth it!! I had a slice of white, a slice of mushroom spinach, and a slice of pepperoni. All were awesome, but being old school, the pepperoni slice was my favorite. The sauce was so good and pure. Then Tony, the owner, surprised me with a couple of Zeppoles. They were puffy clouds of heaven coated in sugar, and oh so good. Can't wait till my next trip back. I'm gonna try a few more. Highly recommend, it's worth the trip and it's directly next to the subway stop, which makes it easy. read more

Ordered a few slices from Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant on Saturday night. A value pizza spot, where you can get a solid slice quick. Quality: An underrated slice and a place I wish I had stopped at sooner. The pizza is a little on the doughier side and came out undercooked, but that worked well for me. Lots of cheese, and the red sauce had great flavor. The ricotta on the White Slice was excellent. Not too greasy or overly salty, found a happy middle-ground. I was not as crazy about the Garlic Knots, I wish I had gotten another slice instead. Quantity: Slightly smaller than usual slices, but the breading made it heavy. Value: $3.25-$4.75 for a Pizza Slice. $1.50 for 3 Garlic Knots. Ambiance: Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant is a huge pizza spot in Carroll Gardens. The inside space is massive and they have a tented outdoor area extending it further. It seems completely unnecessary, as I rarely see more than one or two customers inside. The inside area has two small televisions both squeezed in the same corner. A radio played music in the background. Crowd: Two other customers, one grabbing a pie to-go, the other enjoying a slice there. Service: The guys behind the counter dole out the pizza and don't make small talk. Parking: Parking depends on the time, but usually is tough. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Always pass this place on route to work and finally gave it try last week. Ordered a chicken parm sandwich, it was pretty good. Sauce could be better but the fact it was an actual sandwich and not what you get at a modern pizza shop. Do pizza places in NYC even make sandwiches anymore? Place is super old school but it adds to the charm. I dig it. It reminds me of the 90s in there, not a bad thing at all. Will be back to try their pizza. They also serve pasta, will be back for that as well. read more

Gen-X remembers a time when pretty much every single corner pizzeria was amazing in its own right. Going into the 90's, that started to change, and the trend has been monotonically trending downward ever since. In my neib, Midwood, we have Di Fara's, of course. But I honestly can't think of any other pizzas that knock my socks off. We have good ones, but other than Di Fara, none that really stand out. We were in Carrol Gardens and stumbled across Giardini. It looked good, so we walked in to get a pie and some calzone. The punchline is, Giardini really stands out. It's hard not comparing Giardini with Di Fara's, b/c Di Fara's is my "home turf", and I love both pizzas. The difference is, of course, that Di Fara's is known to be NYC's most expensive pizza, which is obviously not a contest anyone should want to win. What did I like about Giardini? The cheese was fresh and tastes beautiful. The average pizza these days is flavorless, but not this cheese! The sauce was not overly sweet. I still like *my* sauce better, but in terms of pizza sauce, this sauce is savory, not sickening sweet. It has a ripe tomato profile, which has sadly become elusive in the NYC pizza scene. To me, it screams "home made", definitely not canned. The sausage was savory and vibrant. Very fresh tasting, and not overly greasy. The same for the pepperoni. The vegetables on our pizza -- roasted broccoli and tomato -- was fresh, tasted delicious, and was done in just the right proportions. The calzone was unbelievably delicious (I ordered sausage - ricotta - meatball). What was I neutral on about Giardini? I wish our pizza box had a pizza saver since we were carrying the pie home. One one hand, a pizza saver really works when you're carrying a pie, but on the flip side, they're environmentally unfriendly, so I can't complain about this too much. What didn't I like about Giardini? Nothing. There's nothing I don't like about this place. If they were here in Midwood, we'd be going here exclusively for our pizza needs. read more

On the go great tasting pizza. The green stuff is the garlic knot juice they were nice enough to add for me. What a hidden Gem any one in the area want to grab a slice or dine in . Really affordable! Extremely tasty. Great neighborhood.i can tell they stay busy because the food is so good. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Sqaure and regular slice with added garlic knot sauce - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best slice, best people, best Sicilian, best garlic knots, best drink selection! Just THE BEST THE FRESHEST THE YUMMIEST

Not even 2 hours deep in my Brooklyn adventure and I hit gold. A single golden slice of gooey cheesy perfection, literally the size of a large baby. But let's be real, I ate more than one slice. Recommended by my kid nephews who KNOW exactly what NY pizza should taste like. RUN HERE. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - cheese cheese cheese! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I so badly wanted to deduct a star for the ambiance... ok as a designer I just can't get over the popcorn ceilings, the tiles, the terrible lights, the green walls....where do I stop? but as I sit here at home enjoying my individual pizza with VEGAN cheese and I'm going to go for it and give a high five! Awesome pizza, crust is amazing. Lots of toppings. Who said us plantbased folk had to suffer? Service was friendly and I even had a nice chat with the owner who was happy about my order and very interested in getting feedback about how I liked it. Bravo. I like people who are open to new ideas. Let's all support them so there's some cash in the bank for a restaurant makeover? I'll be back for sure. read more

See all

Best mozzarella and tomato pizza I've had in a WHILE. As a pizza snob, I usually visit my local shop in Midtown between shifts. Today, my eyes have been locked in on this establishment. Granted it's small, but the friendly service and smells of FRESH pizza make it worth the commute. Let me restate that their food is FRESH. Pizza dough is of local ingredients and also offer gluten free options. Always finding an excuse to come back and say hello! Nice work fellas. Y'all put a smile on my face. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I stopped into Giardini to grab two slices and dined outdoor on a sunny day. I felt as if I somebody had hit the rewind button and sent me back to the 1970's.The space was not beautiful and the restroom was out of order. I ordered a Sicilian slice and fresh Mozzarella slice. The Sicilian slice was very good , but the fresh Mozzarella slice did not work for me. My bill was $9.50, and the value was $8.50. Thank U next! read more

Nothing is harder to find, but more rewarding once found than a perfect Sicilian slice of pizza. As opposed to many round pies, the square goodness of a Sicilian has so many things that can render the slice an un-chewable mess. Giardini looks to have taken this to heart, and the outcome is a damn good slice. The place where every slice of Sicilian pizza lives and dies is in the base. If the slice itself is too doughy, its like chewing through a pile of rubbery tires. Too dry, the pizza tastes like eating a stack of matzo bread without any water. Here, the slice is, doughy without being overly dense or chewy. After securing a solid base, the sauce is the next place where pizzerias have been tripped up. Too sweet, its like eating a desert or some processed can of sauce. The sauce here was very good, but a little skimpy with the sauce and cheese covering. Finally, after the dough has been tossed, and the sauce and cheese have been laid, the cooking is where the magic happens. The slice I had had a perfectly cooked crust, without any of the usual burnt edges that are common in a lot of Sicilians slices. Overall, a fairly reasonable price for the neighborhood, and the ever escalating price of slices read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My (picky) mom is in love with the food from this place. She orders the same 3 items and each time it is spot on. I tried their Chicken Parm and they get 5 for that dish alone. We finally a local eatery with quick delivery and great food. read more

Ohhh Madone!! The pizza fuggedaboutit! Great sicilians and regular pizza. The owners and staff are great people also, greet you with a hello and a thank you goodbye. My tops is the Chicken Parmigiano, tender pieces and great sauce. Fantastic prices and food can't be beat. read more

The fresh mozzarella Margherita pie is very good. Tomatoes taste fresh, not sweet. The crust was great, you could taste some salt on it, which was unique. Honestly a plus pie read more

This is what we needed. We were looking for that "New York slice" and we were not disappointed. The prices are okay, but the taste is great. I guess I'm a thin crust pizza guy now. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Garlic knots, buffalo chicken, margarita. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Fresh made tuna taco I will come back again in great for for tourists Nice seating outside read more

I ordered for pickup & they forgot to add cheese to my garlic knots but other than that garlic knots were nice & fluffy. My pizza was cold too but vodka slice & knots are my go to. read more

been going here for about 6 years one of the best pizza spots in brooklyn workers are great

Walked in and didn't realize they were closing. We had a gang with us and wanted to sit and eat. Someone said you'd have to take it to go and then another gentleman said if you want to eat here, you can. He was so kind and patient and the pizza was probably some of the best pizza in Brooklyn. We will most definitely return and recommend to all our friends! Thanks so much! read more

No idea why this place has a bad rap! Really solid slice place, crust is good. Airy and not too bready. Gourmet it is not. But a great, classic Brooklyn slice joint. read more

I live on the Best Coast near San Francisco, but I do get out to NYC a few times a year. I know one thing, New York makes the best Pizza in the World. I have sampled probably 20 different Pizzerias across NYC and my favorite slice comes from this establishment. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza is amazing and is my favorite Slice in New York. This is a Great Neighborhood, Great Pizzeria and they also make tasty Garlic Balls! (If you visit San Francisco -- get a Slice at Golden Boy's) read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

It pains me to have to write a review like this especially for a neighborhood pizzeria where we really enjoy the food. As of late it's been really challenging to call in an order because the person who answers the phone is not bilingual and understandably struggles with the order. We end up calling Francisco's. As a society we need to be more inclusive and welcoming of difference but this is just downright annoying. #wishispokespanish read more

Good pizzia and good people. I love their slices and in the summer the outdoor area to sit. Their best slices are before 4 PM when everything is still fresh so keep this in mind, but I love the variety and the flavor of real Brooklyn Pizza. Hope you like the photo I added. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Giardini Pizzeria in Brooklyn - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Amazing pizza! This pizza blew my mind at the simplicity but perfect taste! I usually only have a single slice but it was so good I went back for a second. The crust is so good! I had a sausage and green olive and a red pepper, onion, mushroom pepperoni and sausage slice. It's nice because there is our door seating. The pictures on the wall are of the building in the 30's which was pretty cool to see. Very close to the subway. Will definitely come back!! Thank you Giardini! read more

I've been to all the pizza places in Carroll Gardens and this place is by far the best. Quick, simple, not fussy, delicious. The cheese is great and the sauce isn't sweet like other other places like Via Roma. Perhaps others might disagree, but I actually like it more than Lucali's, which is an overrated place for fancy people who like waiting in lines. read more

Just had the best Sicilian pizza and zeppoli IN LIFE!!! I'm not even exaggerating or even have the munchies. It was just that good. They're giving you fresh pizza with the perfect amount of sauce and cheese.. that's so hard to find these days. The zeppoli were so warm and soft! They're not expensive at all. So much better than any fancy pizzeria. I'll come back every time I'm in this neighborhood. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ignore the ding dongs in the comments with their lame critiques. They can go down the street and spend $40 on a pizza at the trendy places. In the meantime this joint will keep killing it with people who truly know pizza. Their grandma pie is the most underrated pizza in BK. You won't be disappointed. And they're also one of the few places in the neighborhood that does gluten free. read more

Just visited recently. The pizza was ordinary. Nothing fancy, but I have to give credit where it is due---you do get a huge portion. The tomato sauce was average. Maybe I am used to more garlicky or tarty sweet flavors. My favorites are My Little Pizzeria and Napoli. So I guess I am accustomed to a different taste. The wait was 10 minutes at most, and if you do come at 3 pm like I did, expect a huge barrage of demanding, hungry souls just released from the local school to be fed asap. The price of a slice was $2.50 and the garlic knots were $1 for 4 of them. I have to say they have really delicious garlic knots with fresh parsley and real garlic slices. It was the highlight of my journey to this pizza joint. read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - Sicilian slice and an order of a garlic knots! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I was walking around the neighborhood looking for real estate to rent and I decided to stop here because just in case I moved to this neighborhood I need to know where I'm getting my pizza from! Let's just say this was a perfect first impression. I had a Sicilian slice and a square with mushrooms onions, zucchini and spinach on top. They were both amazing especially the one with all the veggies. The veggies were perfectly cooked and seasoned and were just the right consistency. Now I'm trying to set up my Chiropractic office near this place so I can eat this pizza often! New York Specific Chiropractic meets Giardini's gourmet pizza! Beautiful! read more

Giardini Pizzeria & Restaurant - One sicilian and a square with zucchini, mushrooms, spinach and onions. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The slice that brought me back to life! I really felt like I wasn't going to make it through the day when I stumbled upon Giardini pizza. I got a mushroom olive and pepperoni sausage slices and 5 minutes later...I felt better than ever! It was like magic. If you're struggling and need to be revived, Giardini pizza is the place to go! read more

Door dash has margarita for $17 while it's $26 and anyone thinking they ordered margarita is getting a regular pie.