Came here for lunch and it was pretty empty, the food did take some time to come but the service was pretty good. I ordered the salmon poke bowl and my friend ordered the tuna poke bowl. These dishes were on the lunch special, which was a reason we got it and we wanted to be healthy for once! They were pretty decent poke bowls, but nothing special. The interior was very modern and clean and the place is pretty massive, but I can see the restaurant filling up during dinner times and on weekends. This place is located in Downtown Markham as well. read more

Good Catch Boil House - Salmon and Tuna Poke - $13 Oyster Sliders - $14 - Cajun/Creole Near Me - Markham, Ontario

Actually enjoyed our stay here while dining at this type of establishment for the first time - as in.. since I was a baby I don't remember the last time I've ever had to wear a bib while eating something. But anyway, my experience was positive, therefore I give this place a high rating. I ordered a bag of shrimps with the house sauce, and a lobster roll meal for $22! The lobster roll was pretty amazing and it had just the right amount of butter, everything was covdered. The only thing I will say is that I just wished that the bread was more harder and crunchier - that would have offset really well paired with the soft lobster bits. The meal came with a salad and fries, and both were done pretty well, even for standard dishes. Although it was a busy night, our waitress came and we were promptly served and attended to throughout the night so I appreciate that. Would recommend and come back for that lobster roll! read more

See all

I came with a small group on a Wednesday night and it was pretty packed for such a large area restaurant. It's funny how many people rather wait than to be seated on the high tables. Anyways, we wanted to see what the hype is all about. We only ordered the bagged seafoods and half a dozen of fundy bay oysters that night. I must say the seafood were pretty fresh, clean, and tasty. However, I wasn't too impressed with their sauces. Of course, the best was their special in house sauce. However, the garlic butter, lemon pepper, and cajun definitely has room for improvement. The garlic butter tasted very buttery and watery at the same time and barely any garlic. It tasted very weak. As for the lemon pepper, it was very salty. The cajun was just okay, nothing exciting. Therefore, for the bagged seafood, I might just head back to their rivalry, Captain Boil. Overall, service was alright and I would come back to try the other seafood dishes that they offer instead (such as their slaw, poke bowls, fried oyster sliders, lobster nachos, etc.). read more

See all

MESSY is the theme here. At your table waiting for you is a giant plastic bib and large plastic gloves! No forks and knives! We had to ask for those. But when at Good Catch, Do as the good catchers do. I was all up in my plastic bag of shrimp mutilating their heads and tails with Cajun sauce flying everywhere.. It turned out to be pretty fun! It's a good experience. They serve seafood by the pound in plastic bags just plopped down right in front of you. I don't know how I feel about plastic around my food, it's a bit of a turn off for me. (Reminds me of dexter)...It does keep all the flavour in there though. I would recommend ordering a plate of rice so you can dump your bag on the rice and mix it. That way you actually get a plate! The lobster roll is really good, and it's ready to eat. No prep required by you. I ordered a pound of shrimp with eyeballs, whiskers and everything. It's as if I just shoved my hand in the ocean and pulled out cooked and sauced shrimp. Really fresh, really good. But it takes some work to get all the inedible parts out first. The oyster sliders are a MUST. Three decent sized sliders of lightly deep fried oyster. So light and flakey. A little greasy but all worth it. The reason there is one less star is because the service was honestly just hectic. Granted it was a Saturday night, but still. I reserved a table that afternoon. Then when I got there at 830 it seemed as though they needed to clear up a spot for us. It's one of these restaurants where you have 5 different people serving you. Everybody does everything kinda vibe. But to us the tone just comes across as "HELP", "DO SOMETHING, ANYTHING", I wouldn't wanna work there. Chaotic. That's the restaurant business I guess? I dunno. I've definitely seen more organized Saturday nights elsewhere. read more

Good Catch Boil House - Good Catch Boil House Cajun Shrimp - Cajun/Creole Near Me - Markham, Ontario

The food got lots of variety and tasted good. However the serving size was small and price a bit steep

This restaurant is conveniently located in the Cinneplex theater complex. It's very spacious and nicely decorated, nice ambiance. Staff were friendly. I like how they have a hand washing station by the bar which is prefect for before or after our meal. Warning: the good catch blend medium is quite spicy. The sauce was garlicky, buttery, spicy and salty. I like putting this sauce on top of white rice. Yum! (How Asian of me). Shrimps and mussles were both fresh and deliciously sauced. Calamari was just ok, too breaded for my liking but it wasn't bad. Good catch slaw was delicious; many ingredients in the salad; however it came with a high price tag of $19 and it's not that large. Salad was good but price was too steep for just a vegetarian salad IMO. read more

See all

The staff working there are all friendly and with 　cordial service. The food all tastes good, fresh and creative. I love it. read more

Good Catch Boil House - Cajun/Creole Near Me - Markham, Ontario

Food Quality: Acceptable ; sauces are all covering the taste of seafood. If you enjoy this way, yes go for it. Service Quality: Excellent Price: Overpriced - better quality of seafood you may get from other places at these prices Worth to try but considering other choices of seafood restaurants read more

Overall: 4.5 stars Parking: Accessible parking, but I came on a busy Tuesday movie night so I had to loop around multiple times to find parking even when I drove to the far corners of the lot. Service: Very nice and pleasant server. She explained the menu and was attentive to our needs. The owner/manager(?) also came around to ensure we were looked after. The restaurant is new, so it's quite nice inside. It is spacious and comfortable. I like how there's big screen televisions playing a few different sports at once. It's spacious and I don't feel like I'm crowded with other people. Food: I enjoyed the food here. My friend and I ordered the oyster sliders, lobster roll (with Caesar and Cajun fries), and a pound of garlic butter shrimp. The boil was as expected. Shrimp was reasonably fresh, not sandy/crumbly, but not extremely crisp either. The garlic butter was nice because they put tons of garlic in there. Delicious! The oyster sliders were the highlight of our meal. I highly recommend them. The mayo and fried onion complement the fried oyster quite well. The lobster roll surprised me in price as the dish seemed small for 22ish dollars. However the roll probably had as much meat as a lobster tail, so I wasn't disappointed. The fries and salad were a bit small and did leave me wanting more. Comparisons: The one that comes to mind of course is The Captain's Boil. This restaurant has similar offerings, but adds to it with more a la carte, deep fried and non boil items. I think this restaurant wins in diversity as well as a more hip and inviting atmosphere. Impression: I was impressed and I will be visiting again! I just can't eat here as often as I would want, cause the food can be a bit heavy (y'know.. if you wanna be health conscious ) read more

See all

I've been here twice, and I'm loving it more and more! My first visit was on the first day the lunch menu was launched. I visited around 12:30pm and the server told us we were the first ones there today. We ordered the lobster mac & cheese, lobster grilled cheese, avocado grilled cheese, and lobster nachos. The lobster nachos was loaded with lots and lots of cheese with lobster bits scattered around. I would say it's a little heavy for an appetizer especially because everything else we ordered had cheese, but it wouldn't be such of a problem if everything else was less cheesy. Everything else was very delicious. We left around 2pm and there was still only 3 tables. Today we visited again around 12 and this place was packed (Father's Day). This time we ordered the soft shell crab fried rice, fish sliders, oyster sliders, beef poke bowl with zoodles, and the lobster supreme (the yelp). I personally preferred the fish sliders over the oyster. The lobster supreme was a little cold when it arrived, but I understand that it's a busy day and it might've sat a bit before being served. The beef from the poke bowl is very high quality and perfectly seasoned. The servers are always very friendly and helpful. Left at around 2pm and there was still people waiting for a table! 5 stars for sure! I would highly recommend! read more

See all

Valentine's Day... Probably the worst day to head out to dinner but it was fine when we arrived at 8:30. No wait needed and the restaurant was only about half full when we got there. We were about to order a few drinks to start, until we were told they had nothing on tap until Friday Feb 17th as they are still under soft opening and still trying to figure things out. Ended up getting bottled beer and soda. Ordered 1lb of mussels, 1lb of shrimp, softshell crab basket, oyster sliders and some Wings. We were starving! The good catch sauce for the seafood was really yummy. Not overly garlicky which I liked in comparison to other boil places. The oyster sliders were delicious and actually quite big for sliders. Definitely worth the price. My bf wanted the wings which were okay... But the cajun fries it came with were seasoned very nicely. The soft shell crab was pretty good, but I think would have been better to have it in a sandwich, which I'll come back for and try! Our server was great and super friendly. Came to check up on us multiple times and made sure we were satisfied with our food. To our surprise, there we 10% off our bill because of the soft opening. Overall a great experience and will be back. read more

See all

There is nothing better than wearing plastic gloves with garlicky sauce dripping from your elbows and a plate full of empty King Crab shell fragments. Since Captain's Boil closed in Newmarket, my last fix of "crab in a bag" was at Hot and Juicy Crawfish in Orlando. That place is a reference point for me, and Good Catch holds up the Canadian end. Big, juicy crab legs sauced to your liking with some extras and served in a bag. I like this place better than Captain's Boil. For starters, they serve the bag on a plate, so instead of fishing around in the bag, you can dump the whole mess on a plate and work from there. For the discards, they hang a big bucket off the side of the table to toss in scraps. Nice! Also, there are more options for sides. I almost went for the Brussel Sprouts, but the potatoes allowed me to do a full comparison. Good Catch uses a smaller red potato, which holds up better than a larger, mushier potato. And the bonus for me was the Chatime just around the corner for a drink for the road. Until next time... read more

Today was my first time trying this place and I m so glad I did! First, the service is wonderful. I first really want to give credit to the hostess who works at the front. I didnt get her name but she was absolutely wonderful! I had a party of 9 and had initially requested to sit at the front patio but unfortunately the table requested was only available for take out. The hostess was so gracious to accommodate me as I was pregnant and concerned about the crowding and said we could use this room that was completely private and closed off from others. She was amazing, and i really wanted to give credit to her! Thank you! Also, the other servers were just as wonderful. They are all very attentive and so so great with customer service. The food was delicious as well. The garlic butter clams and okra was so good! Hands down the best My first time here and so happy for the great experience! Will be returning! :) read more

At first try originally we didn't like this place due to the salad and smaller portions. But since we have given more chances and have been very happy with the outcome. They are fast and efficient in serving up your order quickly and especially with takeout. Now come here weekly for a seafood staple for dinner. Oysters, shrimp, clams are always amazingly fresh. I love that they put so much garlic chunks in the sauce as well. Mostly other places are cheap with that ingredient. Definitly love this place over captains boil. I recommend this to anyone craving seafood and especially for the oysters !! Another notable item is their soft shell crab ! read more

Good Catch Boil House - Yum kushi oysters - Cajun/Creole Near Me - Markham, Ontario

Amazing food Amazing alcohol menu...owner recommended the Canuck and it was delishis... Service was also amazing & she was very attentive to all our needs. Amazing tv's to watch the raps beat the blazers! Definitely going to be my go to place for sporting events... So much more to go & try! Until next time...definitely go try it read more

See all

Okay first time trying boil seafood in a bag and I loved it clams prawns In super garlic base very flavorful added on lobster grill cheese clam chowder and fish taco to complete the meal so good and no mess with the provided bibs and gloves. Lobster grill cheese was a dream pretty good chunks of lobster in ooey gooey cheese and delish sauce. Clam chowder was regular can skip and fish taco was good too. Our server was very nice and friendly and helped us decided what to order and check up on us and and asked if it was our first time and filling us in on the little things. Definitely will come back. read more

See all

I enjoyed dining here with family or just hanging out with friends. They have better food and good ambience compare to the other restaurant that serve seafood in a bag. The portion of their serving is also a good amount for the price you pay. I ordered shrimp with garlic butter sauce along with corn and potato as well as the salad called Good Catch Slaw which is a special salad known in Singapore from Susur Lee's Restaurant. It is made of rice vermicelli, carrots, cucumber, taro root, some edible flowers with peanuts and apricot dressing. It was quite a rewarding salad. I will definitely order it everytime I come here. read more

Good Catch Boil House - Cajun/Creole Near Me - Markham, Ontario

I come in each week for work and I stay at a hotel nearby. Never thought to try it as I like the seafood in a bag option but you have to have a taste for it. I changed my mind when I came on the yelp page and saw they had many options outside of the boil options. I go in and sit down, I try to order the crab cake sliders. They tell me they don't have it. He then proceeds to tell me they don't have the majority of the options (outside of the boil options, of course.) I settled for the fried rice which was subpar to say the best. The staff was very bland and didn't tell me about the menu limitations before I sat down to order. I gave it an additional star as they did have alot of options for the boil. read more

This is my second time at a boil spot, really trying to like it! Got the Poke Bowl, and my Mom got the snow crab legs with cajun seafood rice. All were delicious! Very messy to eat. The cajun fries are like fried sticks - not a fan of these at all. The waitress comped us in the end for these which was awesome! We were happy! Overall, good experience this place is a little cleaner than most but there were still marks on the booth walls.. needs to be cleaned! read more

See all

The shrimp was meh, it was overcooked and not very seasoned other than too much garlic and SALT. The soft shelled crab was coated in a super thick layer of breading and it was simultaneously oily yet slightly soggy. Also ordered the lobster roll which was the highlight of the night. The set up and lighting is nice for dates though, if you don't mind the overpriced sub-par food. I'd rather go elsewhere for seafood in a bag. read more

Interesting take on the fad that is boil bars, boil houses, boil anything. Good Catch is on the end of the plaza, sharing presence with the theatre, Ruth Chris, the Keg, Marriott, and a number of other places popping up on that end of town. The premise is the same - seafood with spices and butter in a plastic bag, tossed into a vat of boiling water to be cooked. Comes to you bag and all, and you dig in! They'll equip you with disposable gloves and bibs, but trust me it's not a foolproof method to stay clean and scent-free, so dress accordingly and plan ahead. The nice thing about this place is that there's actually a variety of items on the menu beyond the boiled items - sliders, fries, wings, fried rice, and oysters! They're also an oyster bar! I haven't tried them myself, but there is a lunch/dinner special on weekends. Unfortunately, I actually didn't like my sliders, and wasn't super impressed by the other items beyond them being decent for a pub/bar kind of setting. Staff was friendly and helpful but not overly pushy, and generally attentive which I enjoyed. The place was bustling with small groups and big parties all night, so it was lively! There's also screens to catch your sports game, if that's a necessity. The price was not excessive and I appreciated there being (affordable!) filling alternatives on the menu meaning I didn't have to pad my hunger beforehand to avoid breaking the bank. I don't know if I'll be back just because boil houses don't have that much allure to me - but I will make at least one more stop in to check out their oyster special and report back! read more

We shared the Good Catch Slaw (9/10), 1lb of mussels with the Good Catch Blend sauce (7.5/10), and the seafood pasta (8/10). The Good Catch Slaw comes with this reallly greatt fig sauce that we both loved. The mussels are really big, and the seafood pasta has a good creamy sauce .with a decent bit of seafood. Overall a great experience! read more

Went with a large group of people for a birthday. I've been to a different Seafood Boil before and pretty much the same concept. Order your seafood & sauce, they throw it in a bag and it comes out piping hot, ready to eat with your hands. Definitely a fun way to eat food if your not fussy about getting a little messy. I was impressed with the menu selection because they also had some nice appetizers, sandwiches, salads and a decent selection of beers (which you can also get a flight if you like to try different ones). I tried the fried Calamari & the Oyster Sliders. The calamari was good and the oyster sliders were REALLY delicious! For the mains I shared the mussels, clams and shrimps. Personally I really liked the mussels in the good-catch blend between the 3. The waitress was great! Very attentive and friendly, considering we were a big group of about 20 people. She knew the menu pretty well and was able to give good recommendations. All-in-all a good dinner with moderate- to little but more expensive prices depending on what you get. read more

Good Catch Boil House - Fried Calamari - Cajun/Creole Near Me - Markham, Ontario

See all

Favourite boil seafood restaurant in gta! I've tried two other places but nothing compares to here, great staff and delicious flavours! They also have large TVs around the restaurant for those sport nights and a large selection of craft beers on tap! Among all their flavours the garlic butter has got to be my all time favourite. Their lobster roll is amazing too, pricey but sooo good, can't get enough of it and don't even get me started with their oysters. Great oyster selection! Their oysters sliders was also amazing, very unique. Always a pleasure coming here Side note: unlike other boil seafood restaurants, they use napkins instead of paper towel rolls, much more convenient!! read more

See all

Every time I finish eating at Good Catch I always leave feeling really satisfied! My usual choices are the mussels in the Good Catch blend (mild) and the snow crab legs in the garlic butter. If you go between 3pm-6pm there are Happy Hour specials (wings, mussels, and fried oyster basket). I tried the lobster nachos for the first time recently and it's very filling! Between 3 people, we couldn't finish it, especially since we ordered other food as well. There are chunks of real lobster in the nachos but the whole lobster is also presented to you on your plate. The oyster sliders are one of my favourite as well. It's lightly battered on the outside and has so much flavour when you bite into it. The order includes 3 small sliders. read more

See all

Went here with a group of friends last night and had a fantastic time! Big, loud, hopping busy space on a Saturday night. This was our first experience at a seafood boil type restaurant. Plastic bibs, plastic gloves, and lots of napkins required. Great beer selection, perfect choices for a accompanying seafood. Lots of sports on big screens, which is right up my alley but maybe not the most conducive for chatting with friends. Upbeat, fun servers make you feel welcome and the food comes really fast. Tons of options, and a great 'build your own boil' selection. My only critique of this part would be the lack of a traditional southern boil, which would feature several seafood choices with corn and potatoes included. The sides are extra, and each seafood choice is separate. A handful of raw Brussels sprouts for $5 is a bit off. However, the food was great! The lobster roll was a tender, juicy, butter-rich delight. Cajun fries are a bit addictive. But the side salad is lame, just some romaine with flavourless cheese and little to no dressing. I had the Dungeness crab, which was absolutely delicious. Another big oversight is the fact they don't have metal lobster/seafood picks to dig out all the tender morsels of meat. We asked and were given a long narrow plastic spoon that didn't really fit into the openings. Took a lot of work, but with great reward. The soft shell crab sandwich and sliders were a big hit at our table, as were the chock-full-of-garlic mussels. A big star was the shared lobster nachos. At first I thought, cheese, sour cream and lobster? No way. Yes way! Yum yum yum. We'll definitely give it another go, the next time we're looking to be covered in butter, garlic and grins. read more

Good Catch Boil House - Lobster nachos. Wrong, and SO right. - Cajun/Creole Near Me - Markham, Ontario

Great for lunch/late night. Meh for regular dinner. PARKING 2/5 Markham VIP's got to have the worst parking situation in all of the GTA. Every member in our group of 8 spent 30 mins attempting to find parking. What a mood killer. TIP: the parking lot beside milestones is free, but it's just a bit of a walk. DECOR 5/5 Very spacious, well decorated and lots of TVs to watch sports. They have a huge golden Popeye statue at the front (the same one as the Wynn hotel in Vegas??). It's nice to know that you'll always have a seat when you come here, and there's plenty of room for a group. FOOD 4/5 Our favourites: poke bowls (lunch), oyster sliders, wings (late night special). $5 late night drinks are great too Do not recommend: soft shell crab, seafood boils (they plate the boils onto places which although looks better, loses flavour and gets cold fast. Also Captain's boil's sauce tastes better imo) SERVICE 3/5 Huge restaurant and not enough servers, so it'll take a while to flag someone down. One of our servers started cleaning up our table at the end of our meal and then forgot to come back for the other half for a good half hour. Our bills were mixed up a bit despite informing them how we would be splitting them at the beginning of the meal. This is a great place for a nice lunch or a late night bite, but if you're looking for a nice spot for dinner I'd probably try somewhere else. read more

I've been to another "Boil" restaurant but I wasn't too impressed. This time I was interested in Good Catch Boil House because they seem to serve seafood in various styles. Our party of three came on a Monday night shortly after the restaurant opened. Although it is still their soft opening period, both the food quality and presentation were very solid. Also, our server Carolyn was very sweet and helpful which definitely made our dining experience very enjoyable. We ordered a different variety of food including fresh shucked oysters (Galway Natives), the Soft Shell Crab Sandwich, Oyster Sliders, Lobster Nachos and clams with Good Catch Blend sauce as well as the Curry sauce. The oysters were very fresh and sweet. The Soft Shell Crab itself was crispy but not too dry. The mango salsa was a good combination with the crab in the sandwich. Both the Oyster Sliders and Lobster Nachos were very tasty and served with eye-catching presentation and was great to share. Both the Good Catch Blend sauce and Curry sauce for the Clams were bold and tasty and went well with the clams. Overall, it was a very satisfying meal. I am glad to have found Good Catch Boil House and I hope their service and food quality will be maintained after their grand opening. read more

See all

Edit: Though I've had nothing but good things to say about Good Catch since the beginning, my last two visits have me reconsidering my opinion. The restaurant remains lively even on weekdays, but I find they must be doing so well that they are neglecting what was making them successful to begin with. To start, they have been undoubtedly making their portions smaller than before - while in my family we were able to share 2 lbs amongst 3 people (we have small appetites) we find that we are no longer able to share. Their rice bowls have also evolved from a full bowl filled to the brim to a small pathetic half dome inside the bowl. This alone is fine, except their prices have also been hiked a few times. Secondly, Good Catch is mostly staffed with young employees. While younger staff are mostly more friendly/fun in the environment Good Catch is trying to be, their staff is also incredibly unattentive and inexperienced. Our orders were missed and forgotten, and when they ask if we'd like more beer they also brought the wrong beer twice - we didn't feel this was a big deal as we can have any beer so we didn't bring this up. Lastly, we ordered 3 side rice - only two were brought. Then we asked for extra bowls for sharing, and our waitress did not bring any spoons (for eating rice). We asked for spoons, and she brought only 3 for a group of 8. This kind of service stems from inexperience but is surprisingly irritating when you've got your hands full of sauce. Thirdly, their staff needs to know their menu better. We arrived during happy hour time and made an order for wings - our waitress did not make any comments that it was still happy hour. By the time we'd noticed, it was past happy hour time and the order could not be amended. The waitress should be informed enough to make a suggestion during our order. ****************************************************** Good Catch is located on the north side of the plaza, on the reverse side of Golf Town and Curry's. You can park in the back parking lot and walk around. A typical nautical themed decor but surprisingly spacious and has a good vibe. Lots of TVs around the place which is great for catching a game. There are a variety of choices on the menu which aren't by the pound - oyster slider, soft shell crab, lobster sandwich etc, but the star of the show is definitely the seafood in a baggie with their delicious sauces. You order shrimp/crawfish/clams/crab by the pound and choose from a variety of sauces. I'm a big fan of the butter garlic sauce! You can add a variety of sides into the bag (potato, corn, sausage, etc) which all sound great but will add up. I've tried adding them all in various sauce and must say the sausage and corn option is a bit of a rip-off - it's $6.96 to add sausage and it's around 1 whole sausage cut into bits. The corn is $2 and you get about 1/3 of a cob. For those with a bit of an appetite, the extra option to add rice or vermicelli is a must! For $2/$3, the rice will fill you up and will taste absolutely amazing with the sauce in the baggie. Items that are not yet available on their menu - raw bar, crawfish, lobster nachos. read more

I have been coming here relatively frequent since the establishment opened and I got to say; they have never once have me leaving dissatisfied. Food: What to expect from GoodCatch is a variety of seafood catch, sous-vide with a selection of flavours offered. I would say if it is your first time coming here, I would highly recommend going for this option. Otherwise, GoodCatch offers the best Lobster roll around the Toronto-York Region area. Of which, in my opinion, has yet to have been beat in comparison. Some of their deep-fried alternatives such as their Shrimp Basket has been well worth my money with the decent portions provided. Lets not forget the wide variety of craft beers on tap. Additionally, GoodCatch offers beer flights which will allow you to sample 4 beers at a reasonable price. Not a lot of places offer such option and I wholeheartedly welcome it. Service: Staff is friendly and welcoming. Although I have to say attentiveness is what suffers in this case. I'm not the type that wants the regular attention of the server. Quite the contrary, however, it could sometimes be difficult to wave down a server even while service is on a down time. Other then that, the wait staff have been great. Atmosphere: It's a sports bar, it will be loud and that's what I expect it to be like. I prefer quiet places where I can hold a conversation, but when I'm in a sports bar I expect it to be loud and upbeat. For that, big points for creating a vibrant atmosphere. Recommended? Yes! Absolutely. read more

Good Catch Boil House - Beer Flight - Cajun/Creole Near Me - Markham, Ontario

See all

As a seafood lover, this establishment has become one of my favourite places to "eat like no one's watching." It is refreshing to enter such a spacious restaurant where you don't have to worry about waiting ESPECIALLY considering how busy it may be since they are located in the heart of downtown Markham. Good Catch has made a great effort to create an open layout restaurant that delivers a variety of delicious dishes accompanied by amazing side dishes that hit the spot. I recently went and ordered the mussels and lobster nachos. The lobster nachos are a bit pricey but the mussels are super tasty and a must try for my fellow mussel lovers. My friends and I received our orders within 10 minutes, so asides from great dishes, the Good Catch staff/service was fast, friendly, and on point! Good Catch is more on the pricey side, however, their menu has a wider selection filled with unique dishes that are a total treat to your tastebuds. I can't wait to come back! read more

Good Catch Boil House - Cajun/Creole Near Me - Markham, Ontario

The environment is nice and the service is OK. There's a Big parking lot behind the building so parking is plenty. The reason I'm giving three is because the quality of the seafood is not as expected and it's rather small. We choose their most popular sauce for the seafood , and it's way too salty. Almost difficult to swallow. read more

Super cute interior! Love the graphics on the walls and the mini details put into the interior ties it all together. I love that they have a sink in the back left corner of the restaurant for everyone to use and keep their hands clean without having to go all the way to the bathroom. They have little touches that really show me they put alot of thought into making a cohesive theme for the interior. Ive been a couple times and am never disappointed. The lobster rolls are a good deal and come in two styles: hot butter and cold mayo. It comes with fries and a salad! Which makes it a full meal. It is also nice how the boils come in the option if being poured out onto a metal dish/ platter when it arrives! TLDR: Great service and amazing interior, lots of options on menu! Try the hot butter lobster roll! So yum! read more

Came in on a Friday night after work to satisfy my seafood craving. The server was fairly nice and polite as we sat down to reccomend us some beers. The place got a bit busy but not too packed however it was sad to see that they made two mistakes during our sitting. From bringing our drinks to the wrong table to forgetting an order we made and having 2 servers come back and confirm what we ordered - the first server wrote everything down too, so I don't know what happened! The food however was lovely as my dad and I enjoyed the boiled lobster with the cajun seasoning the most, the soft shell crab and cajun fries. The boiled shrimp was not as succulent as the lobster as the seasoning didn't quite marinate into the meat. Over all place was pretty good. Was just a shame to have somewhat unprofessional service. read more

See all

It's more like a 3.5/5 but I rounded up because of the friendly service! Their drink special after 9pm/10pm depending on the day of the week is a good deal - $5 for selective beer, wine, bar rail. Music was a bit loud though, so it was hard to have a conversation. But we weren't planning on staying long anyway, so it was fine. The creamy buffalo wingsss were the highlight!!! A lot better than the fries and the other food we had on previous visits. Still a nice casual spot to pop in before/after the movies! read more

Good Catch Boil House - Cajun/Creole Near Me - Markham, Ontario

See all

I have seen mixed reviews on Yelp of this restaurant...and here is mine. I have been to this place twice. My friend and I have prefer to have early dinners to avoid the dinner rush...especially weekends, and so both times, we came just when it opens for dinner. Nice and quiet. First impression was great, fun decor and the hostess were friendly. Servers were good, they told us of the specials, what's fresh etc...and gave us time to review our menus....took our orders, if there were things they weren't sure of, they'd check. I appreciate that gesture. The only thing is that it takes them longer to refill water. I do understand that beverages make the most $$ but I love my water, I'd rather spend my $$ on food, that's just me. Food...we have tried crab legs, mussels, clams-with different sauces, their oyster basket, and their lobster bisque... Cajun - it was to the salty side for my liking, I'd prefer their "good catch" sauce- in which I think also contains cajun + a bit of each Butter + garlic- compliments the seafood, I added lemon juice for a little acid Oyster basket- bite sized oysters, crunchy, and fries were crispy- I like it Lobster bisque-well, the flavour is there, but it was served in a paper take out cup and by the time I got around trying other items, it got cold. For me, I ordered it because of curiosity---I know I'd appreciate it more if I get to enjoy it in a more relaxed setting, with proper soup bowl and silver spoon-and no greasy hands-after all, there is a lot of work behind the making of this bowl of soup Overall- I enjoyed my meals here, it is fun to go with a group of friends read more

See all

Such a great catch!!! If you're like me and always pass by this place you should definitely park and come on in next time. This place definitely hits the mark of a seafood dive! I thought there would only be shrimps/mussels available in those plastic bags that u eat with gloves but the menu is actually much more diverse. You can order lobster nachos, fried oyster sliders (HIGHLY RECCOMEND), fried rice, and even a slaw (very great tasting salad). I did get a chance to try some of everything and I have to say they've really spent the time curating their dishes to be so unique. Starting with the slaw, the dressing was this sweet & sour like sauce that enhanced the flavour of the crispy noodle topping, peppers, peanuts and dried figs. This would be something I would come back for! The wings are also massive and fall off the bone tender. I don't normally like buffalo sauce but theirs is so creamy and tasty that I'm sure you would be converted too! Onto the seafood, the good catch sauce is the best one in my opinion. It's sweet, spicy, smokey and delicious, I even spooned some from the bag to my rice!! The shrimps and mussels are a great hefty size which impressed me and super fresh tasting as well! The restaurant is HUGE and they've really thought of everything to improve your experience. My booth seat had space to tuck your purse and jacket in!!! How crazy is that?! You don't have to sit crammed with your belongings because you can store them IN the seat!! Loved that extra touch! read more

See all

Service is fast, food is good, value for money, overall place is spacious. Recommended.

You guys are a joke if you close at 10pm weekdays and 11 weekend!!! I will never come back.

5 stars for service, 3 stars for the food. Arrived last night for a Friday girl's night out. The place was pretty packed but we were seated around 15-20 minutes later, which wasn't as long of a wait as I thought. Service was friendly and attentive and our waitress came back often to refill our glasses, which was much appreciated! In terms of food we opted for the soft shell crab sandwiches as well as a tray of oyster sliders to share. The crab is smaller than what's pictured in the menu, but with cajun fries and caesar salad accompanying the dish at least we won't be leaving hungry. The batter was too thick for my liking which covered the flavour of the crab, but I loved the mango salad that was on top of it! The oysters in the sliders were tasty but again, too much batter. The oyster itself is very good- tasted fresh and sweet, but unfortunately was overpowered by the amount of fried batter put on it as well as being topped by more fried onions. I think next time I'd opt out of the fried onions for the sliders or ask if there's any alternatives to their condiments but otherwise it was enjoyable. Both sliders and sandwiches were put on cold buns which I found a bit strange - definitely would have enjoyed it if it was toasted at least. I would give this place another try to see what the boiled options are as that seems to be the main attraction of this place. read more

Good Catch Boil House - $12.95 soft shell crab sandwich. Crab is smaller than what's pictured in the menu. - Cajun/Creole Near Me - Markham, Ontario

See all