Staff welcomed as soon as you entered the restaurant. Pizzas on display that you can purchase by the slice. Refrigerated cooler had different types of salads including chef salad, caprese salad and pasta salad. Various drinks are available for purchase as well as soda machine. TVs displaying sports games are placed throughout the restaurant. Comfy cosy tables and bench seating available. Pizza and breadstick was amazing. Crispy crust and fresh ingredients. Very clean and the ambiance is so authentic displaying pictures of many different types of people associated with Goodfellas read more

See all

We got here around 6:30pm on a Saturday night. There were a few options for by the slice pizzas but we opted to order two whole pizzas while I friends did the single slices. My husband was set on trying the fuhgetaboutit which has EVERY topping available. When I say every one I mean all 26 toppings. The nice thing in hindsight is that the guy taking our order gave us a realistic idea of what that was going to be like before we ordered so we weren't disappointed. Good of him to do that. We waited for about 20 minutes for the pizza which wasn't bad. I had ordered a half and half. Mix of a meatball option they have and a meatlovers. Respectively called the Nonna's Pie and the Goodfella. The crust was a bit chewier than I prefer but it wasn't bad. I happy ate it. They don't put a lot of toppings on so the big slices make folding it up to eat a must so you get all the flavors in your bite. I was pleasantly surprised that all those topping on the fuhgetaboutit blended well together and nothing seemed to overpower anything else. You'd expect it to be jammed with toppings but it's not. Hence the reason I'm sure he warned us. It's almost like the more toppings you order the more they cut back on each one. Sad really. After owning and working in a pizza shop for years that's just not the way to build a pizza. It should be artwork. Luckily it tasted good. We got boxes to take our leftovers home with us. They were good warmed up on day two. read more

Went back with friends for lunch. Different vibe and crowd. Lots of families. Service was friendly. Pizza was so good. Great crust! Think about it, how many pizza joints do you actually want to hangout in? I couldn't think of any, until now. read more

See all

Due to previous unfavorable review - room temp pizza, I was given a generous gift card to come back and try again. I brought the same 2 dinner nf companions. When I ordered I politely asked if my pizza could be served piping hot. Said yes. It was NOT piping hot. It was better than last time which was room temperature and cheese not melted. This time it was warm and cheese was melted. I'm used to getting served pizza that I have to wait a few minutes to eat. It doesn't seem like the workers at GF really care . It's a shame . Taste wise pizza ok . I've had better I've had worse. The proper temperature would definitely enhance the flavor and might lead to a more positive review. read more

This was my first trip to the Cincinnati area. Walking into Goodfellows, it felt like a typical sports bar, with plenty of TV screens on the wall. However, I quickly realized this was not a typical sports bar. They specialize in pizza, sandwiches, and other items. I will say Goodfellows had a very comfortable atmosphere and plenty of people in there. Always a good sign! Our waitress was extremely friendly as well. Being in a new part of the country, I decided on a very different pizza. I went with Simpson's Way. This has Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce, pulled pork, bacon, pineapple, and crushed BBQ Grippo's chips. I will first say the crust was the perfect thickness and prepared perfectly. It was a magnificent balance of flavors with the BBQ sauce, pulled pork, bacon, pineapple, and chips. After a coupe bites, I was surprised by the spice, which I assume comes from the BBQ chips. Honestly, this was one of the best pizza's I've ever had. Everyone talks about getting pizza in New York, Chicago, etc. But I've had incredible pizza in Ohio, Alaska, and Oregon. Each place preparing pizza's utilizing local ingredients or just preparing a great pizza. If you find yourself in the Cincinnati area and are in the mood for some pizza, please give Goodfellows a try. They have a large selection along with build your own. You won't be disappointed. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Simpson's Way - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Waited longer than what originally was told for pizza and also had to clean off our own table before sitting down

Great place to get a nice affordable NY size slice of pizza Great customer service very friendly and knowledgeable read more

See all

Cool pizza joint with amazing pizza. The staff were super helpful & friendly. Love the decor too. I grab a couple slices and enjoyed the relaxed environment. read more

See all

Giant slices, excellent service, yum pizza, easy go to spot! In town visiting for Sonic Temple, definitely a go back spot next year! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Giant slices, excellent service, nice bar area, easy go to for pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Tbh overpriced mid pizza. Big slices but nothing special. In a part of town with a bevy of food choices, it's pretty disappointing.

some of the best pizza in Columbus. Amazing service and the music and vibes are sensational.

The food here is delicious and every staff member was very kind. I really enjoyed the ambiance and found myself dancing along to the music. I will definitely be back! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Service is terrific, with friendly and welcoming staff, combined with ample seating and a great location at the south end of Short North. The pizza, tho, is entirely average for a pizzeria in such a hip area. Got the sausage and onion as it was available immediately, it did the job, crust wasn't super thin but wasn't too thick either. Pepperoni came out later and did not look any more impressive to me. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Sausage, bacon, red onion. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Ordered the 22 inch pizza and was blown away by how large and delicious the pizza was! Best priced pizza in town and best taste! The pizza gets shown to you once it's finished cooking to make sure it's to your liking, and it has the classic brick wall exposed pizza oven look any great pizza joint has! We loved it so much we ordered two pizzas to take on our trip home! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - 22 inches of delicious pizza crust to crust! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Best pizza ever! I took my family here for my wife's graduation celebration and we enjoyed every moment being there. The service was top notch and the atmosphere was laid back. We will definitely be back again! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pizza was really good. The team was super friendly and I had no issues. Good variety of pizza by this slice. Music was super cool and the Lounge in the back of the building look like a lot of fun. I was there just for lunch so didn't try cocktails but the bar look like a fun place to have a drink! read more

See all

Loved the pizza slice, thin and crispy crust and excellent flavor. Walked in around midnight, good crowd. They had ready pizza with banana peppers and pineapple. Looked interesting, turned to be an excellent choice. Loved their hot sauce. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Came here in a Saturday after doing some shopping. Ordered a large cheese pizza to share with the family. We opted to dine in. Pizza came out faster than the 35 minutes we were quoted. Pizza was hot and fresh. The place was well lit and had adequate seating. Now as far as the pizza, it lacked flavor all around. Very bland pizza. I was very disappointed. Nothing about the pizza had the robust NYC flavor. The sauce a bit too tart for my liking. I'd say it's a spot to grab a slice quickly, but definitely will never order a full pie again. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Large cheese pie - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I really enjoyed the lively atmosphere and the friendly service. The staff genuinely seemed happy to see and serve guests. I loved the pizza-by-the-slice option, with a perfectly crisp crust and fresh, flavorful ingredients. The sauce had a lovely sweetness that complemented the toppings. The place was spotless and conveniently located near the convention center, making it a perfect go-to spot. It's spacious enough for a large group if you're with friends or colleagues. Plus, they stay open late, serving up delicious mixed drinks and beers. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Goodfellas is right. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Spring mix salad, fresh with lots of veggies. Calzone with shrooms and spinach, spot on. Cannoli, rich filling and choc chips with perfectly crispy pastry shell. Left with a slice of cheese pie, $4.50 and big enough to fold in half, cant go wrong. Great location, fast service, good atmosphere. Adding this place to my list of favorites. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

This is one of my favorite pizza places in the whole Cbus metro area. Authentic ingredients, made fresh, perfectly thinnish crust - a little crispy in places, a little soft, gooey cheese, the right amount of sauce. The staff are cool and the place is always clean. Bonus points for a perfect health score! We need one Pickerington. :) read more

As far as the food goes, it was excellent. On a 1-10 scale I'd easily give it a 9.5 Service...we came after a concert. They close at 12. We made it at 1150. Along with ten other people. They let us in and we placed our order. When we went to pay, the young guy said just pay for ur four drinks now. Ur pizza will be up soon then u can pay for it. So we got drinks and sat down. After waiting 20 min, I went up and he was like omg I forgot to put it in...I'm so sorry. So he went and told the girl and she yells...yells..." uh uh...you don't order down there she gotta come down here to order. " so he apologizes again...I go to her nd now the line is longer bc no one locked the door at closing and some crept in. So this time I order from the loud female employee. She says it'll be right up...so I go to pay and just stand there. Now keep in mind others r getting their food. At least 20 people have been served. So I asked him....again. finally he got my money and within a few minutes I had my pizza. He apologized profusely. Meanwhile, Ole girl was still back there yelling about any and everything. I get that ur working late. It's not our fault u didn't lock the door. I have worked in the food industry. Ur guest should never hear ur complaining. Service 4/10 Ambiance: clean store. Bathrooms acceptable and fully stocked. Dining room decent, but it was the end of the day so understandable. Good music. Good decor 8/10 Would i recommend or come back. Yes. The food is great, the ambiance is nice. Roman really cares about the guest experience and should be commended. The worst thing was the yelling lady. Be more professional. When we left she was sweet as sunshine and invited us back. I get she was ready to go home but first impressions are everything. read more

The pizza here is excellent! It's a large slice, great cheese, very fresh, and a great dough with good flop and chew! The ambiance is very cool and there is a little bar attached! The service was great and they were very friendly! This might be my new favorite pizza joint! I know pizza....and this is great pizza! This pizza is "slap your grandma" good! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Green pepper, red onion, and banana pepper pizza slice...and The Beard! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

After seeing this spot featured on Step Out Columbus, I had to give it a shot. Definitely wasn't disappointed. My favorite place to stop now after a night out on High Street. Pizza by the slice, 2 foot breadsticks, and a 22inch pie...if you're feeling it Jared and the bar team have an amazing summer lineup on the way! read more

I usually don't leave reviews but I was pretty disappointed with this pizza. My boyfriend and I tried the 12 inch pizza and added pepperoni, ground beef, peppers, onions, and olives. We both thought that the pizza had barely any flavor and we both rated it a 3/10. Also there was probably about five crumbs of ground beef on it. The crust was kind of like chewing on cardboard. Thankfully it was half off Monday so we didn't spend $28 on it. read more

Amazing pizza. Pepperoni and plain cheese are both great. Service was also good, only complaint was the length of time for two pizzas. Which was around 50 minutes. For takeout this wouldn't be an issue but we decided to eat there so we had to wait awhile. read more

I'm a sucker for New York style so had to try this spot as soon as it opened. You place your order at the counter, and there are two seating areas -- one with a more laid-back vibe and another that feels a bit more upscale (looks like that's where they serve alcohol). We went with a cheese pizza and a calzone -- both were delicious! Nothing will compare to NYC pizza, but this is still tasty for Ohio! Bonus: you can stop in and grab a slice to go! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Order time 7:39, pickup estimate 8:10. Arrived 8:00. Buffalo chicken cheese bread Crust 10/10 Sauce & cheese 10/10 Chicken 5/10, taste like it's out of a gfs bag Served fresh, hot; right from the oven Overall 8.7/10 Nacho cheese sauce 3/10, cooled and congealed. Cheez Whiz moreso than cheese sauce Banana pepper sauce Turned out to be banana peppers Pepperoni pizza Pepperoni 10/10, love they're big & thin Crust, 7/10.... Wasn't cut through soggy in the middle maybe from sitting Cheese & sauce, 7.5/10 Overall, 7.1/10... they gave me a cold pizza and made me wait 20 minutes past pickup time they provided read more

See all

Goodfellas has great vibes and great drinks! The patio is so fun and they had a food truck.

Great food and excellent service. Didn't get a picture of the breadsticks but they were amazing as well! Every pizza had great taste and the crust was perfect. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North - Goodfella's and the boss pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Pizza took 45 minutes. Crust was like cardboard. Overcooked and dry. Sauce was overly salty.

Giant, tasty pies. Good peeps here. And they care about their community. They recently donated some pizza to a crew I was working with who were volunteering to tidy up a local park. So vicariously, they tidy up local parks ! read more

In Columbus, Ohio, we ordered the medium size FUHGETABOUTIT, Every available topping pizza with 2 fountain drinks which came to almost $46.00. To say we were VERY disappointed is a MAJOR UNDERSTATEMENT!!! the toppings on this pizza MAYB would have been enough for ONE PIECE!!!!! I didnt even look nothing like the photo on website. I know that complaints fall on deaf ears and the companies don't really care. Just know and believe that i would NOT even go back there to get a FREE one!!!! I wouldn't waste my time!!!! even though is shows 1 star, this doesn't even rate enough to get that!!!!!! read more

Very pleasantly surprised! I enjoyed a "large" slice of "The Don" pizza while I watched them hand-toss the dough. I then grabbed a slice of cheesecake and a cannoli (to die for!) and headed to their bourbon bar, Wiseguys, where I sipped on some Tullamore Dew and enjoyed my dessert. I'll definitely be back for another helping. read more

Amazing pizza and great service. The Goodfella, Boss, Nonnas Pie, and Paulies Favorite are delicious!

Ordered the wrong size pizza (16" instead of a 22") tonight, instead of making me wait until another pizza was made the manager gave me a 22" pepperoni that was already done and the 16" I had ordered. Outstanding service and the pizza was amazing! read more

Immediately greeted by a friendly staff eager to get me taken care of. The AC was fantastic on a scorching hot day. I ordered a slice out of the case and a breadstick. Both items came out of the oven hot as cold be. The slice itself was what I envision as a New York slice, thin crust, crispy with gooey cheese. The breadstick was quite literally the length of my arm and it came with a dipping sauce, habanero ranch is what I got and it surely didn't disappoint! Definitely a must try in short north, delicious! read more

really great staff, pizza was delicious, would highly recommend! loved the bar area as well, very neat.

If you want HOT fresh slices this is the place to go! It won't break the bank either. I had the lunch special and it was only 10 bucks!

Fantastic food! Excellent service. We went after a party and they were super nice, provided good service and shared superior recommendations. The pizza was fresh and delicious. read more