Very good. Prices are reasonable, food was very, very good. I got stromboli with spinach and mushrooms. Very good. My husband got a small pizza, also very good. Large choice for beer.... Great atmosphere, great service. read more

Got pick up. Gluten free pizza was decent. Antipasto salad was super small for a single portion, and being Italian I've never had ranch dressing mixed in with it. It's traditionally served with vinaigrette so that was weird. Spaghetti and meatballs came with only two small meatballs and no bread or anything for dipping so also weird for any Italian place I've ever been to. It was ready pretty quickly but 3 stars for just weirdness. read more

This place is terrible 60$ for 3 pizzas that were just as good as ellios and about the same size too absolute scam would never go again

Awesome pizza joint. We came for spring break and it was the best pizza I've had in a longtime. We ordered 4 different kinds of pizza and one of us had the lasagna and they were all excellent. Would most definitely come back every trip we make from now on. read more

Fantastic food and staff, even when crowded the bartenders were very tentative. Worth the visit when in winter park!

Waitress was terrible. Left cash tip and she charged more tip on my card. Confronted the manager about it and he rolled his eyes and just gave me the money back she charged. Very unprofessional. read more

We ordered a pizza & lasagna for take out a couple nights ago. Both items were really good! When we called, they immediately told us pick up time would be about an hour & 20 minutes later. It was worth the wait - Definitely recommend. read more

Just amazing!!! We went with a big group and ordered lots of different pizzas... And they were all delicious!! The garlic pie adds just the right extra taste to the pizzas! Well worth the wait for these pizzas!!! read more

This place is great for the family. Prices are reasonable and the food is oh so tasty. The atmosphere is fun, with dollar bills hanging everywhere. Not too noisy and yet still kid friendly. The service was also fast and friendly, with no wait at 7:00 on a Saturday night. We started with a family size garden green salad, BBQ wings and garlic cheese sticks. The salad was fresh and there was plenty for the five of us. The wings were about mid sized, nicely cooked, and had good flavor. The garlic cheese sticks were really better described as a garlic cheese bread. Excellent with the marinara for dipping. We shared a few different entries between the 5 of us and still had leftovers. We had a 10" sausage pizza, the meat lasagna and a Stromboli. I'd say the lasagna was up there with one of the best I've had. Nothing super fancy about it. Just nice texture, with the right amount of meat, cheese and sauce. I only got one bite of the Stromboli because my son would have stabbed me if I tried to get more. He liked it a lot. The pizza was also delicious. Not sure how to describe it other than delicious. Nicely cooked and what I considered to be the right amount of ingredients. read more

See all

Wonderful pizza, friendly staff and a fun atmosphere. Just dropped in with friends since we were in the mood for pizza and this place really surprised us. Cool decor as well... a nice place to kick back and relax. read more

Hernando's Pizza Pub - Good times, better pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

The decor is fine, the service is exceptional; I was treated better here than anywhere else I've ever visited. They stock Pepsi products and a large selection of alcohol, delivered by a friendly staff. Their pizza selection is beyond broad - I ate a Column 1. Unfortunately, the crust takes up quite a bit of real estate, and I didn't get quite as much as I felt I paid for read more

Hernando's Pizza Pub - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

Ordinarily, I love Hernando's. Fast service, good food, good prices. We ordering a kid's serving of noodles for $5.50 the other day. We got 10 noodles. When I asked if that was all we got, the server just said yes and walked away. A box of noodles is $1.00 at the store, this is just wrong! We love Hernando's, but this time we felt like we got ripped off. read more

Hernando's Pizza Pub - This how many noodles we got with the $5.50 kids meal. Pretty disappointing for a restaurant we love! - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

Friendly, laid back service makes the pizza taste even better. Their Pizza Dough is the best I've ever had....don't hesitate to use that honey on the crust, you won't regret it. If you sit at the bar, be sure to take the opportunity to have a conversation with whoever your server is, they'll make sure that you get at least one laugh in. read more

Dropped in for dinner on our last night in Winter Park and wished we had tried it sooner. Great food and the unique environment was very much appreciated. The staff was super nice, food service was quick and delicious. I think my family will always be thankful for being introduced to honey on the pizza crust! We had Antipasta Salad, Fettuccine Alfredo w/ shrimp, lasagna and supreme pizza (great crust). All super fresh, great food. read more

The food was amazing the restaurant has a great atmosphere, definitely would recommend the only bad part was the service the waitress Leah was very impatient and was talking to another waitress saying "Why are they taking so long" try not get this waitress. read more

Delicious pizza! The difference was the super fresh mozzarella and the crust - crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside. I tried the crust with the honey and it really does take it to the next level. We tried the BBQ and the pepperoni - both were great! read more

Hernando's is a must if you're in winter park. Busy, but cozy environment. Delicious pizza - Mediterranean is my fave. And you have to get the rolled crust to enjoy it with honey as a dessert in true mountain fashion. read more

The pizza is amazing! Almost a deep dish! A little noisy, but that's understandable for the amount of people. We came on a Sunday and it was pretty packed with a 45 minute wait! The pizza was all worth the wait though! So good! Would love to go again! read more

Loved this place so much! They have the place decorated with dollar bills which is fun itself! The pizza was super good as well and people seemed really nice here. Everyone else seemed really pleased with the food. Would recommend. read more

First pizza we've had in months. It was good. We wanted carry out. They got it made super fast. Definitely a good pizza. If we make it back to winter park, I think we'd try it again. read more

Terrible service and terrible pizza. A frozen pizza from the gas station warmed up in the microwave would taste better. We will never go back. The server Leah just as terrible as the pizza. I was disappointed because we heard such great reviews. Go to elevation pizza it's much better. read more

It's alright nothing special. The pizza is decent but there's way to much crust. When I order a pizza I want pizza not a fucking loaf of bread. What's up with the honey? This Colorado thing with honey on crust is stupid. Bring out some marinara or ranch or something but honey?! Price is fine for a mountain town...not to taxed. It's a jungle in this place though with kids running rampant so don't go there if you want a nice night out. read more

This place is everything a pizza restaurant should be. I've been eating here on snowboard / mountain bike vacations for over 15 years and it is consistently amazing. It actually inspired me to begin baking pizza myself in hopes of recreating it...I've nearly perfected it, but as good as it is, it's not Hernando's. Go see Matt at the bar for dinner and a show. Hilarious guy, and equally awesome of a server. If you consider yourself a pizza lover and you're checking yelp to find good local eats, let your search end here. read more

Wow! Incredible food and service. We will definitely be back for future ski , back packing excursions. It is crazy busy so call ahead to be put on the waiting list. Our first time through incurred a 1 1/2 hour wait so we learned and came back the next night. We were seated immediately! Can't wait to go back! read more

I've been going here for years. Love the pizza. Bartender is no nonsense and down home. He loves what he does and the lifestyle. Quality guy. My wife and I love the Greek Salad and the wings are outstanding. Always get wings with my son. My one knock is take out pizza isn't even half as good as being eating it there. I know you can say this for all take out but the pizza only seems half as good when we take out. We don't even do it anymore it's that noticeable. read more

We went on a very busy night, so we made a reservation. When we walked in, the whole place was packed, but they were fully prepared for our table of 12. The waitstaff was fast, efficient and friendly. We ordered the family style salad, pizzas, meatball sandwiches, pasta and stromboli. The food was fantastic! The whole family loved the fun surroundings - go! It must be seen. The owner was there working hard right along the waitstaff and came over to our table to say hello and check on us. We'll go back the next time we are in Winter Park! read more

Wow, this place is amazing! I had no idea where to grab dinner when i arrived for a weekend getaway to winter park as it had been over 10 years since id been here last. I stopped into Hernandos, and boy was I glad! This is some of the BEST pizza i have ever tasted. Homeade crust was to die for,and the fresh Parmesan to top it off was just perfect! I wish there was a hernandos in Longmont! I might have to make a once a year trip, just to eat here. Also, the decor(dollar bills everywhere!) was awesome read more

After a heavy day on the slopes and in the park we drove in here for some pie. Good choice, the place was super packed, so apparently everyone else had the same idea. Nevertheless to decrease our wait time we sat at the bar to have diner and shared some brew. The staff is friendly, the beer cold, and pie hot. What more do you need to know? Cheers! read more

So yummy! Definitely get the hand tossed. Delicious! We got one traditional style and one with the olive oil and basil base. Both were awesome! We started with the antipasto salad - large - which was more than enough for 3 of us. A fun joint with a little character. All in all a great experience! read more

This place is super good!!! Great pizza at a good price for the mountains. We got a thick crust wheat pizza "Simone" style. The ingredients were fresh and tasty. The vibe in Hernandos is very cool as well, and we had very friendly quick service! Great pizza place for a date or for family time. We'll be back for sure. read more

We LOVE this pizza place and always look forward to coming here when we visit winter park. We eat here several times when we come because everything is so good! read more

This place is HORRIBLE. The food is ok but the service is unbearable. There was a gentleman with blondish/grayish hair that was very rude. We called ahead and put our name on the wait list and were told that it would be a 30 minute wait. When we arrived our name was not on the list at all and they told us we had to wait another hour. When we had explained our phone conversation this gentleman replied with rude comments and told us that it was our fault. We have been to this place many times and now we will never go back. I strongly encourage you to go enjoy many of the other great restaurants that Winter Park has to offer. read more

Best dining experience we had in Winter Park. We ordered a split column 1 and Mediterranean pizza with garlic crust. The crust was delicious and the best part of the pizza. The wait staff was prompt and the atmosphere was really cool with dollar bills lining the walls. We will be back on our next visit to Winter Park! read more

Ordered pasta for the family while in Winter Park. Very disappointing. We ordered fettuccine and spaghetti with marinara and spicy sausage. They were without flavor, incredibly bland. Even the kids were disappointed by the lack of flavor. I would not recommend. read more

I have been here a handful of times and the experience, quality and service is always consistent. Go for the 14 inch Column 1 and add Jalapenos. The Stromboli and wings are a must. Ask for Jeff and buy him a shot. Enjoy and post a bill on the wall. read more

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Vegetarian friendly. We ordered the Simone Garlic styled crust for the Mediterranean pizza without the sausage but added broccoli. Easily finished a large between 2 people. read more

Great atmosphere- it was very busy but still felt cozy with all the fire places. We loved The Jerry pizza! Honey on the crust is a game changer... we were skeptical but it was amazing. We will absolutely go back! read more

This pizza is not the best. Tasted like a frozen Pizza. The sauce was just wrong. I know it's not frozen. Our server wasn't that nice either. I told her this was my first time there. She thought Big deal. That was my first and last time I eat there. read more

When my wife and I showed up we asked to be seated outside. They told us that none of the tables out there had been bussed. When I looked out the door there were about three tables finishing and all the rest of the tables full of dishes. The table next to us on the inside had not been bussed either. The food took a very long time to be delivered. The food was mediocre at best. read more

NomNomNom... Hernandos now has another very satisfied customer! Went there with my family while on vacation in Winter Park. Everything we had was great. Tried the family sized greek salad which had just the right balance of lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, peppercinis, feta cheese, and dressing..Delicioso We also tried two different pizzas, one with the thick crust and traditional meat toppings, and the other with the thin wheat crust with veggies. The two pizzas were very different, but both of them were tasty enough to justify every calorie each bite brought into my body. Thanks goes out to all the Yelpers whose glowing reviews led me to this glorious gem of a pizza joint. They also saved me time by recommending calling ahead for seating. While others were being told to wait for an hour and a half, we were able to be seated within fifteen minutes of arrival thanks to getting or name on the wait list ahead of time. read more