Truly awful pizza. Imagine cooking frozen pizza from the supermarket in the microwave instead of the oven add some disappointment and there you have it. read more

I've been going here for years. Love the pizza. Bartender is no nonsense and down home. He loves what he does and the lifestyle. Quality guy. My wife and I love the Greek Salad and the wings are outstanding. Always get wings with my son. My one knock is take out pizza isn't even half as good as being eating it there. I know you can say this for all take out but the pizza only seems half as good when we take out. We don't even do it anymore it's that noticeable. read more

I know this place is noted for its pizza, but try the Lasagna. A generous portion, with spicy Italian sausage, and wonderful marinara sauce makes this the best lasagna I have ever eaten. Great service and a nice selection of beer. This is a great family place with a unique and friendly atmosphere. read more

Place was way better when the servers didn't wear collared shirts, this isn't LODO!! And only 1 tiny TV in the corner really?? Still 5 stars for the bomb pizza and service. read more

Liked the food but our server was rude and told us we weren't ordering enough food. We spent 75$ for a family of five so I felt we weren't wasting table space. read more

I have to give it a one because the service we had was so horrible. We LOVED the food, but Valery was one of the worst servers We've ever had. She was so crabby and even sighed when we asked for lemon in our tea. She basically didn't speak to us and was completely unwilling to help us with our order. It's unfortunate that a dining experience can be completely ruined by such an unhappy person... Ps - she charged us gratuity... UPDATE... Thanks for the kind response, Like I said, the food and atmosphere were awesome! We were a family of 5 so not sure about gratuity. We were in Saturday July 30. read more

I was in such a good mood here! Mostly because I'd just finished watching Stranger Things. Stranger Things is incredible! The Duffers got everything right with this 80's style thriller! They've not only captured the aesthetic of classic films we grew up with, but they've found a way to recreate the feeling you had when you first saw The Goonies or Poltergeist. There lives an emotional connection between these young characters that far exceeds their ages, genders, or character stereotypes. The plot is simple yet fantastic, and the visuals are both high quality and familiar. Netflix has a truly instant classic on its hands. read more

Best pizza in town , can't beat it . get there early or you'll have to wait . But it's worth it . Most the servers have worked there forever , obviously the owners give a shit about their employees . read more

We always go here when we are in Winter Park for skiing or biking. It has never disappointed. Great pizza, atmosphere and beer. In the summertime a table out on the deck is a very pleasant experience. This is one of the reasons WP is better than Breck, Aspen, Vail and all those other resort towns. read more

Great service, walls are crazy and full of dollars, spent most of my time staring at them lol we had a pizza which was good. Pizza dough is soft and fresh. read more

We LOVE this pizza place and always look forward to coming here when we visit winter park. We eat here several times when we come because everything is so good! read more

Best dining experience we had in Winter Park. We ordered a split column 1 and Mediterranean pizza with garlic crust. The crust was delicious and the best part of the pizza. The wait staff was prompt and the atmosphere was really cool with dollar bills lining the walls. We will be back on our next visit to Winter Park! read more

This place is HORRIBLE. The food is ok but the service is unbearable. There was a gentleman with blondish/grayish hair that was very rude. We called ahead and put our name on the wait list and were told that it would be a 30 minute wait. When we arrived our name was not on the list at all and they told us we had to wait another hour. When we had explained our phone conversation this gentleman replied with rude comments and told us that it was our fault. We have been to this place many times and now we will never go back. I strongly encourage you to go enjoy many of the other great restaurants that Winter Park has to offer. read more

Ordered pasta for the family while in Winter Park. Very disappointing. We ordered fettuccine and spaghetti with marinara and spicy sausage. They were without flavor, incredibly bland. Even the kids were disappointed by the lack of flavor. I would not recommend. read more

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Vegetarian friendly. We ordered the Simone Garlic styled crust for the Mediterranean pizza without the sausage but added broccoli. Easily finished a large between 2 people. read more

Great atmosphere- it was very busy but still felt cozy with all the fire places. We loved The Jerry pizza! Honey on the crust is a game changer... we were skeptical but it was amazing. We will absolutely go back! read more

We make sure to eat at Henando's every time we are in town. Classic pasta place, and always busy. Best tip is to get there early (5pm) to avoid waiting in long line for a seat. read more

The pizza was good even if the decor of dollar bills lining the walls was a bit unusual. I'd recommend it if life finds you in Winter Park.

An average pizza pie, but definitely the best in the Winter Park-Granby area. It looks like a German Brewhouse from the outside, strangely enough, so don't miss the sign. Bench-style seating in a cozy atmosphere complete with a fireplace. Pies are thicker than average, sure to fill you up after a hard day of skiing. Ingredients were pretty fresh. I'll definitely be back when I'm up that way again. read more

It has been years since I have been here but I miss it so much. SO MUCH. One of the best pizza places, ever. I honestly want to go to Winter Park just to eat here. I loved the atmosphere. I think its pretty cool how they stick dollar bills all over the walls. Its unique. I also love the idea of the honey and bread crust. Simply delicious!! If you are looking for a cool place, to chill and eat good pizza come here. You wont be disappointed. read more

We're in winter park for the first time and we ordered take out from Hernando's on our way into town. It had been a long day of driving and we were anxious to get to our cabin. We had heard great things about this place and we wanted to try it too! It was a Sunday night, and really busy! The food was delicious! I'd definitely come back. However, we walked away with the wrong order. Not sure if we somehow grabbed the wrong one or if the order was messed up. About half of the items were correct. So I'm not really sure what I ate, but it was really good! read more

Definitely a place to eat when up in the Winter Park area. Classic mountain style pizza. I'll definitely be back.

Great pizza! It got a little rowdy on a busy holiday weekend so some loud guests in the bar. I sat on a plastic fold up chair but the food and great service made up for the small inconvenience. read more

Not possible for me to come to Winter Park without coming here. Looooong waits, but they give you buzzers that work as far as the parking lot. I'm not a huge pizza fan but make an exception for this place. The thin wheat crust is great for the pizza (I like artichoke, red onion, and spinach) but be sure and sit by someone who order the thick crust so you can smother it with honey. read more

I'm a self admitted pizza snob. The pizza here is very good and for me the only thing that separates very good (4 star) to great (5 star) was the crust. A little more crunchier would have been wonderful. The thick 'rim' of the crust with honey is very nice. Good menu options. Friendly staff. read more

Ordered a Moscow mule from the bar - no flavor! Asked them to fix it and they added cheap ginger ale not ginger beer. Still lousy. Will not order a drink here again read more

Amazing Gluten Free Pizza, great atmosphere, what more could one want?

This is a great family dinner joint after hitting the slopes. They have bench style seating, so good for large parties. Great for pizza/pasta (hence the name). A wide variety of chohices on the menu, great beer selection. We got there early - 5:30pm found a table easily, but by the time we were done around 6:30pm, there was a 30 minute wait already. Get there early or be prepared to wait! read more

This place is a bit overrated. For my taste, it has a very tacky atmosphere. All the walls, tables, and even ceilings are covered with defaced $1 bills. At least $20,000 of wasted money. The pizza and pasta were okay. The wine okay. The beer list was lacking. The place is super busy and you should call ahead for seating unless you want to wait 2 hours for a table. Why was so busy? Because it's overrated by Yelpers. If you are okay with takeout pizza, try Elevation Pizza further down the road in Fraser. Much better. However, if you want to put down some beers and eat some hearty pizza on a cold winter night, this is the place for you. Addendum: I do appreciate the managements response to my original review. It shows they are very attentive to their customer base. To improve the pizza here I would recommend more tomato sauce, less cheese, and better definition of the individual toppings that we ordered. They all seemed to blend together. I couldn't really make them out when I looked at the pizza. As far as the dollar bills being posted everywhere, I was aware of the original story. I had read it on the menu when I wrote my original review. I really don't think anybody comes to this restaurant to see the dollar bills on the wall. They come here because the food is good, the service is excellent, and the management clearly cares about the customers. Why not take down the dollar bills and make this place look more classy? read more

Thank you to Matt and his great staff for an awesome night for our son's rehearsal dinner! You all did a great job with service and the food is awesome, as always. We couldn't have asked for a better night. We have been coming to Hernando's for years' and are never disappointed. Thanks again, you all rock!! read more

Best pizza in the valley! Always busy and crowded, so expect a wait if you go during the holidays or busy ski weekends.

This is the place to be in Winter Park for dinner any night of the week, and the packed parking lot is proof. Best pizza in Winter Park, no contest. This place can compete with any pizza place in the metro area as well. I'd love to see a second location in Denver! The dough is perfect, not too heavy. Actually, it's so good, the crust with honey is a perfect dessert. Don't skip this place if you're in Winter Park around dinner time. You'll be missing out! read more

I loved this place! Waiters are a little pushy... Food was very good, and a great choice when in the Fraser-Winter Park Area. Must visit at least once! read more

One of my favorite places to take visitors when they come to visit. They have a great atmosphere and the friendliest staff. I always get the Alfredo and add a bunch of toppings. Always worth the wait. read more

I see no reason to write a detailed review... But, my two cents are: service was great (no questions asked), food was top notch (it wasn't bland like most places around here), and the price was well worth it... I have found a place to eat over and over again when I'm in Winterpark!!! read more

Just moved to town and stumbled upon Hernando's.. Very tasty drinks and pizza's! Unfortunately, staffing seemed a little on the sparse side. After waiting a few minutes to be seated by the busy bartender we had to wait a good 20 minutes to be asked our orders and drinks by the only waiter there! All in all the tastey food made up for the wait! read more

Honey on rye crust, really good and super unique. Apparently it is a Colorado thing .

Great atmosphere and good food. However, tables have benches not chairs. After a day of skiing or cycling it's nice to have back support when one sits down to a meal. read more

Well worth the 1.5 hour wait. We stayed in WP for 5 nights and ate there twice. The antipasta salad is a must!

GLUTEN FREE PIZZA, GLUTEN FREE "BAKED" BUFFALO WINGS, be sure to stress the preparation (like not using the same sauce on your pizza that is used on all of the other pizza causing cross contamination when the ladle spreads over the gluten pizzas), also their hot sauce has gluten so you the buffalo wings have to come out with with barbecue sauce. Tip: have them char the barbecue sauce because it comes out covered in wet sauce and charring the sauce makes it so much better. read more