Overall good food, portions ,nice delivery but $7.00 for A tiny slice of carrot cake ? read more

Hometown Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

Ordered a large sausage pizza and was very disappointed. The crust was more doughy than usual and the pie was light on sausage, cheese and sauce, basically very bland. We've had some good pizzas here in the past but the quality is not always consistent. Don't understand why since it's a family business. read more

What do I think of Hometown pizza in Prospect? Answer: Well, it's a three star pizza; The crust was good, but the pizza was extremely floppy. The sauce was good, but a tad sweet in a good way; The cheese pull was nice though. To sum up, I tried the pepperoni slice and the mushroom slice. Overall, this pizza gets the job done when you have a pizza craving for a New York slice. That's a review. read more

The food was surprisingly amazing! It was so yummy, it kept us in a happy mood. Yum! We sat out in the patio. It was a great space with flowers and it's much quieter than inside. The inside doesn't have any sound dampening so it gets quite loud when it's packed. The staff was friendly. read more

See all

I am writing to file a complaint about my recent food delivery. The delivery person left my order on the floor outside on my steps and lied about knocking on my door. Food should be delivered handed and not left outside on a dirty surface. I was home the entire time and received no knock on the door. When I called to report the issue, the owner responded rudely and unprofessionally, which made the situation even worse. This kind of behavior and lack of respect for customers is completely unacceptable. I expect an apology and assurance that this issue will be addressed with your staff to prevent it from happening again. I also believe a refund or replacement would be appropriate given the poor service I received. read more

Good pizza. Wide varieties of pizza. Good prices. Bar on premises. Plenty of seating and parking. Definitely worth a try if you've never been. They have other items on the menu but I still go for just the pizza. It's that good. I'll get around to the other items eventually. read more

Hometown Pizza - Mashed potato and bacon slice Sausage and cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

Oh yeah, was I blown away by this small pizza joint with some big time flavor and character. Coming to this quiet area for work, I sought out a quick bite to eat next to the bank and with this being next door, it was a no brainer. Entering and it's already slowly getting busy with pizzas being made, a deliveries being sent out. Having some time to sit and relax, I decided to grab a slice of shrimp pizza and a chicken bacon ranch pizza to accompany my Dr. Pepper with the local news playing on the flat screen TV. I was able to beat the crowd as all the tables were filled up with different parties and more people in line to place orders and take out. I sat there enjoy my freshly made pizzas that were crunchy yet chewy with depths of flavor and filled with all the proteins. The slices were huge pretty much filling a dinner plate with the two slices. I liked that the toppings for each slice was filled with so many pieces; every bite I had of the shrimp pizza had a shrimp in it which is how it should be while the chicken bacon ranch pizza had crispy chicken cutlet diced with the bacon and a heavy drizzle of ranch. With the employees chatting up with the clients and the whole place being pretty homey, this place is a great place for lunch. Two slices of pizza $6 and a $2 Dr. Pepper...ummmm YES!! read more

Hometown Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

Decent food. The inside is nice, since they moved locations a few years ago, overall a cheap decent place to eat or takeout from.

This is a great place with one of the best pizzas I've had in CT. Wish they would have a location closer to Danbury, but I'm willing to drive for great pizza. Don't understand the so-so reviews of the place. I've only had pizza and grinders, so can't speak about the other items on the menu. They don't skimp on toppings at all. Great crust, sauce and fresh toppings. 43 different pizzas to order from in addition to if you pick your own toppings. That's crazy! The new location is bigger and has more parking. Staff is very friendly and helpful. No complaints, the pizza and grinders has been consistently great. read more

Hometown Pizza - a half eaten pizza with vegetables - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

Food is ALWAYS good.. service is pretty good too. The inside of the restaurant is really nice. Me and my kid go there sometimes for lunch. He loves the meat ball pizza. I live in town so it's nice to grab a quick bite and support local business. read more

Hometown Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

One great place to eat. Service is excellent and the pizza and all the meals are delicious! Don't miss out!!!

This is hundred percent the best dinner place I have ever went to. There's sure their service was just so nice and polite and their food when it got out it was freshly made cooked very thoroughly and when I say this, I mean it for me personally I would recommend the Jay's favorite or instead of Cajun chicken I would want grilled chicken. That is the best pizza that they serve, their boneless wings are also just amazing. They're cooked so well and they're just like so good. I recommend this place if you wanna go to a fancy food tasting great service restaurant because hometown pizza is the place you would want to go to. if there was a sixth star, I would hundred percent give it to them. By Lucas.A.Fontes Shout out to Kelmend Pacuku. read more

We used Home Town Pizza to cater our work secret santa party this year. AMAZING! Incredibly helpful when loading up my car at pickup even though it was raining, generous portions for the price, and the food was clearly made with love. Even the leftovers are fantastic today! Thank you so much, we'll be coming back for sure read more

Not a huge fan of this place. If you prefer more of a New Haven style pizza this is not the place. The staff is not always attentive and the other food options are pricy and not tasty compared to other local places. read more

We were running really late and thought we would order takeout from Home town. Terrible! Everything we ordered was mediocre or worse. The pizza was like tasteless cardboard. The appetizers were inedible - the brushetta had a barely passable topping but the bread was horrible, the calamari had no taste at all. The chicken wrap tasted like nothing. Will never go back here. read more

Again i return to hometown pizza in ct It is fresh seafood this time.. so good.. you will love it. And the lady at the desk is SO NICE. I DRIVE FROM WATERBURY TO GET THERE PIZZA.. read more

Hometown Pizza - Eggplant pizza home town.. they use real dipped Eggplants.. it covers the pie. And cheap and great taste.. - Pizza Near Me - Prospect, Connecticut

See all

It's too bad that their service is by far the absolute worst!! Because the pizza is pretty damn decent. There's NO STRUCTURE! Last TWO times I've ordered to PICK UP was HORRIBLE! First time; after getting there in 30 mins they NEVER EVEN PLACED THE ORDER IN THE SYSTEM to be made! This 2nd incident they say it'll be ready in 25 mins.. get there in 30 mins and have me waiting in the tightest area in front of the cash register another 25 mins because a small pizza is STILL NOT READY! Like make it make sense?! Do you need to hire more people? Do you need people who answer the phones and take orders learn etiquette? I'm just blown away.. and then ZERO apologies. ZERO accommodations. Like this is what it is mentality. Absolutely garbage customer service. read more

excellent food and service. fast delivery, food is very good. We order delivery and go to restaurant Staff is always friendly We really enjoy the excellent food read more

Home Town is the place to go locally. Outsiders are welcome, of course. You'll love the pies, the servers and the relatively new ambiance. Just try it! My review may imply I am connected to someone who owns or works at Home Town. I don't know anyone at Home Town Pizza, Prospect. I live in town and just depend on their pies and onion rings for special nights. read more

We have been patronizing Hometown since their opening many many years ago. We have been loyal customers ordering at least once a week. As of late the rudeness of a few of the staff especially one in particular has left us disheartened. No longer our Hometown restaurant. read more

I ordered the meatball calzone with xtra cheese, it was delicious the meatballs were very good and it was full of cheese. Sauce was a little sweet but very tasty.Did I mention it was gigantic ... read more

Hello, I recently moved to prospect and have ordered 3 times from home town pizza and I must say all three times have not been that pleasant but I gave them a couple chances because it is very close to my house. A couple times the food I ordered was luke warm or the food was just not that tasty and satisfying. The pizza is ehh, I guess it's good for drunk munchie pizza if you will. Idk if it was the chef that day who cooked it but I would suggest DO NOT order the eggplant parm. It was so mushy and the blandest sandwich I have ever eaten, I ate it because I was hungry and got all the way home so didn't wanna ask for refund. I don't think my dog would have even ate it. They just barely made three stars from me because the sausage parm sub was actually delicious the first time I ordered it and probably best sausage parm sandwhich I've ever had. It was made with fresh homemade Italian sausages. read more

Well let's start this out by saying the meatball grinder I ordered was supposed to be well done and it showed up almost an hour later looking like a ghost barley cooked with hardly any sauce and 2 pieces of American cheese not even melted the meatballs were less than desirable looking as well I took a picture of it but it was so white the phone couldn't register the image if you are looking for the worst grinder in town definitely call and spend your hard earned money here so they can pay for the power to cook the rest of the food read more

Hometown is always on point and good! Their pizza is good, but no flavor, like add some salt...I think they forgot the salt.. their pizza is great..crust and sauce on point, just add some seasoning. Always busy! Maybe they don't like salt in these parts lol read more

Great food and atmosphere! They have everything, from pizza, wings, steaks, subs and delicious appetizers. Must try!

Mediocre pizza for a premium price. You can also get ripped off at pepes in waterbury if you want ok pizza at a high cost. I won't be back I only came here because someone got me a gift card. Don't leave prospect you guys won't make it anywhere else. I'll stick with Anna's sorry. My basic mashed potato pizza was raw and sliding off the wet crust amd my daughters pizza has wet ricotta just falling off to reveal an under cooked wet crust as well. I put them in the oven and the slices were falling between the oven grates. read more

New location, clean, very attentive staff, quite hectic on the weekends, great people.

Super bummed that the takeout we ordered took almost 2 hours. Waited for 1.5 hours after it had been confirmed ready for pick up via Slice app to be ready!!! Great pizza, but horrible takeout service unfortunately. read more

Food has gone downhill the last few years. Pizza is still decent but grinders and meals are nothing like what they used to be. Staff inside is different also read more

Ok, so I don't post on yelp ever, but I had high hopes for trying this place after reading reviews. I was sadly disappointed. The chicken wings were absolutely not fresh, but as tough as leather, like they were sitting under a heat lamp all week, unacceptable. Specialty pizza had barely any cheese or sauce, and no taste, the crust was ok. Garlic bread was "chewy" like it had been made the day before and microwaved to order. Party pizza was undercooked and probably a frozen crust per my kids complaint about cold wet spots in the dough, for the money I spent was definitely not worth it. read more

We have gotten take out from here a few times! Food has always been great. Once we were sent the wrong pizza, and when we called they sent a new one out right away. I especially enjoy the calzones!! My husbands go to is the Aribiatta! read more

Ordered a small pizza and wings for delivery at 7:30 pm, it finally showed up at 10:30 pm. 3 hours for a delivery 3 miles away. My food wasn't even remotely warm it was probably sitting for 2.5hrs just getting cold. I also ordered a slice of cheese Cake and asked for utensils as I was staying at a hotel. No utensils, delivery driver dropped it off at the front desk and took off. Food was gross especially cold, I asked for a refund and was ignored for two days. They finally offer me only a 20% refund. I would definitely not recommend this place. read more

Honestly, we don't want to order from anywhere else anymore because we love supporting this business. They are ALWAYS accommodating and beyond friendly. Food is good, service is amazing. Once a week take out and catering when needed for as long as possible because they rock! read more

The chicken, Bacon, Ranch pizza is amazinggggg. Like completely unmatched. So good! I had my food delivered and it was hot and fresh when it arrived. read more

This is one the best pizza place in Waterbury/Prospect area! The pizza, soups, salads, and chicken wings are the DEELISH! Customer service and delivery service are truly the best. read more

Great pizza and dinner shop, very friendly staff and good quality ingredients. Love the meatball grinders, soups, salads, and veggie pizza slices( always with Rigotta) Many varieties of pizza slices ready to choose from the case. Nice crunch at the bottom of the slice read more

Always can count on HomeTown! Never get disappointed can count on them like hotshot Bob

Fantastic food and amazing customer service!! If you ever have any problem with the food, the staff is extremely accommodating and will make sure your problem is solved!! read more

Ordered 2 pie's to take with us to a relative's home - when doing so they took my name and number and told me 25 min. -- when I arrived to pick up the order I was told it had been picked up already ---- now I have no food to take with us and they have no idea how it could have happened but would be willing to replace the order for free in another 25 min.-- well I have been ordering from here for a long time but it would seem they have gotten too big for their new shoes ----- I will never give them another nickel and would not eat here nor would I recommend it to anyone else read more

OK... I'm pretty sure my brother was conceived, and nourished on Hometown's Pizza! This spot is a family favorite for about a decade!!! And no, they are not anywhere as good as Modern in New Haven... or Baki's in Waterbury... But they are good!!! I can't think of one time in the past 8 years that my order has been messed up. They are all friendly, and catering, one of the biggest selling points. Seriously... if you knew my mother, you would know that she is NOT an easy woman.... she basically tells them how to make a pizza, every time she orders... and they still havent blocked her phone number! So give them a try, you'll be satisfied! read more