Great food yet again. Love celebrating my birthday here. Dennis said hi and he mentioned there was a new manager Mary. She was busy with another table but I will say hi next time. Jermaine our server was a character but great times read more

Came just for dessert this time as it never disappoints. Croissant bread pudding and crème brûlée were spectacular!!! It's hard to choose between the two so we needed both. Hands down the best crème brûlée anywhere!!! So creamy. The presentation on the bread pudding is the most beautiful I've seen and the flavors were amazing. I'll be back! read more

Horatio's - Bread pudding - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

Went here for a bday brunch and it was alright. I think the appetizers were better than the entrees. The crab dip was fire! We ordered a small sampler app and everything on the board was delicious. You can probably order this for your meal and be satisfied. I ordered the cajun pasta and added shrimp, suggested by our waiter. It was tasty, but not outstanding. They also had a brunch menu which wasn't given to everyone on the table so half the table missed it. It's a classic place and it gets busy. It's not hella fancy, but it is pricey. Nicely located by the water and with plenty of parking. Cocktails were served in random cups, it seems, that didn't really match the cocktail. read more

We visited Horatio's because we had a gift certificate. Our server and hostess were both really nice. But, unfortunately, the food was pretty disappointing. We probably won't be going back. We ordered a Maple Pear and Blue Cheese salad and a Grilled Chicken Club sandwich. The salad was ok, but had some wilted lettuce. For $12.75 it was not a very good value. The grilled chicken sandwich was flavorful, but they split the chicken breast very thin to reduce costs. The result was that it was quite dry. Not a good value for $16.50. Our meal included a crispy garlic bread, which was similar to a Vietnamese baguette with garlic butter. It was good. There are so many other good restaurants in the area. We plan to try those before returning to Horatio's. read more

See all

We hadn't been here in years it was nice coming back. We made a reservation arrived on time and was seared immediately. They have a nice menu a full bar and a extensive wine and beer menu, our server was nice she suggested an appetizer but we got a bowl of clam chowder it was delicious. My husband ordered the crab and shrimp fettuccine and I ordered the Fish and Chips. For desert they brought the Creme Brûlée for our anniversary. We enjoyed it and now that Red Lobster has closed Fremont and Milpitas this will be our new stop read more

Been a long time since I have been in, years! Soon as I walked inI noticed it still was the same like I remembered and I liked that. Was not too crowded, very calm a relaxed vibe. We started with the oven roasted artichoke and crab dip. Comes with thin slices of toasted bread. I took one bite and closed my eyes... off to flavor paradise. So so so good! My wife had the shrimp and crab fettuccine. She is VERY picky about her pasta but the sound she made after her first bite "mmm mmm hmmm" I knew there was not going to be any for me to pick at later. She loved it. The fisherman platter is what I ordered. Everything on this plate, the fish, the shrimp, the scallops all done to perfection! Maybe.. the best scallops I have ever had! No... for real! The view with the planes landing and the water, the wonderful staff, the low noise level, made this a perfect dining experience. Plenty of parking. read more

See all

Don't let the 3.5 star average rating fool you. This place is pretty good. The buttered bread starter was yummy. The salads were super unique and really tasty. I had the pork chop entree and it was delicious. Our server Kayla was fantastic. To be fair, the visit did have a couple flaws. My wife's steak was overcooked and the soda came in super small glasses which resulted in lots of refills. Overall, I was very happy with the dinner experience and I'm sure I'll be back soon. read more

See all

Such a lovely and spacious nautical-inspired restaurant overlooking the waters by Marina Park in San Leandro. Came on a Saturday with a noon reservation, and there were lots of parking. Once entering the restaurant, I really enjoyed the ambiance and feeling like I was in a beautiful old-school ship with tall windows letting in a lot of natural light. We got grilled salmon, fish and chips, and key lime pie for dessert. Service was warm and attentive, they were really wonderful. This is a great spot with an upscale feel in San Leandro, perfect for dates and nice outings. read more

See all

First time visiting Horatio's and it was nice to try. We believe our server may have been a little new because we made some alterations to some of our orders that did not come through, but she was very pleasant and was trying her best, which we appreciated! The food came out nice and hot, which is always appreciated, and overall we enjoyed our meals. Would recommend the oven roasted artichoke and crab dip to start. My friend said the cajun chicken fettuccine was on the spicier side, so just be aware if you don't like to eat very spicy foods. Both my companions ordered the clam chowder and agreed it was well worth it! We had lunch on a lovely day too, so we could enjoy the views of the marina. I will definitely like to try more options here in the future :) read more

See all

Looks like menu has changed since i was here last. Ordered mahi mahi with carrot slaw was a little spicy for me. Tasty though. Very hot in dining area ac not on. Had made reservations for my hubby bday they did not acknowledge. read more

Haven't been to Horatio's in years. Food was decent, ribeye was juicy and cooked well. Hubs got the scallops and he said they were tasty. Place seems a little dated and could use a nice remodel. read more

Horatio's - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

See all

We found this place online and liked the idea of the ambiance setting as it's on the water. BIG MISTAKE. Mediocre food, mediocre Service, and DECEIVING!! Drinks from the bar took quite awhile, although it was legitimately busy on a Sunday afternoon with a lot of church folk. (Got a modelo at one point and it was poured in like a hurricane glass, not a real pint glass which just irked me.) We started with the trio appetizer which was honestly good! The crab and shrimp artichoke dip was a bit on the oily side, but good tasting all the same. The problem were the entrees. The food took long as well. The waiters at one pint came to us and said "I saw your food in the window but we've got runners today so they should bring it out shortly." Basically saying that she was going to leave that for them entirely instead of her just bringing our meals out herself. That really confused us as to why one around even admit that, and we still just hope we interpreted wrong. My brother in law got the burger and asked for medium, it was way overcooked so much to the point where he asked for them to make a new one. I get it this happens from time to time. They also put my Cajun seasoned fries on his plate when I was supposed to get them; instead of just making some new fries they brought me out a whole new French dip which was nice. The French dip was ok, a little too heavy on the horse radish for me. My brother in law told me his burger was average at best. Here's where it went south for us. My sister ordered the shrimp scampi, expecting a shrimp scampi. Instead she got some shrimp with mashed potatoes. We inquired with our waitress immediately who told us, "oh no that's definetly a shrimp scampi." We immediately asked again and she poti de out the menu description where it did indeed list it as pretty much shrimp and masked potatoes. Accepting the fact that we didn't read the menu description, we also told her we never really thought that a shrimp scampi would require a look in on the description. We then told her nicely and politely, that's just not a shrimp scampi. She then chose to gaslight us, saying that the way we know shrimp scampi's are "from back in the old days" whatever the hell that's supposed to mean. After that she continued to insist and gaslight us further. Us being Sure of ourselves we looked up shrimp scampi's on our phones and didn't see anything that fit the image of what my sister had in front of her. We got annoyed at that point, lost our appetite with the mediocre food and the deceiving menu and asked to close our tab and take the food home. Someone should have a serious talk with the chef and explain to him/her what shrimp scampi is. And from now on if you insist on still naming it a shrimp scampi while still serving an entirely different dish, at least communicate with guests on what they will actually be receiving. My brother in law asked for an Irish coffee and instead got a watered down coffee with some Jameson in it. We thought about saying something but didn't want the waitress to start in with her "back in the old days" bs again. Needless to say we won't be returning read more

See all

Haven't been to Horatio's since I was a teen. It's sits off in the marina by El Torito's and Marina Inn. Nice size parking lot but not very well lit. The restaurant itself is a little on the darker side but the aesthetic gives port or ship vibes. The service was a bit slow. It took an hour to receive the incorrect order, while noticing that larger tables sat after us already had their food. We received the taster platter but the bread was burnt. 4/10 I had the grilled shrimp scampi with mashed potatoes and asparagus. Good flavor but wasn't hot. Nice size shrimp. The potatoes had seized and the asparagus- thin and overcooked!! 6/10 Lobster bisque was flavorful but came late. 8/10 The crab and shrimp pasta was well seasoned and a nice portion. Quite rich. 8/10 Perhaps just an off night. Willing to try again in the future read more

See all

We came here for dinner on a weeknight and were seated promptly. They have tables overlooking the Bay which make for a great view of the sunset and the water. They also have some kind of an outdoor patio seating. Parking is plentiful and the restaurant has a nautical themed decor. Our server, Jessica, was great! She walked us through the menu, informed us of the popular dishes and checked on us often. We got some drinks which were well made. We started off with the crab and artichoke dip - a tasty dip with some crispy baguette. They also bring you their house garlic bread which is delicious! We got the Admiral's feast - a three course menu where you can choose a soup/ salad, main and dessert. The clam chowder was good and the Caesar salad was standard. Next, the sirloin was perfectly cooked as requested. This was served with some asparagus (which sadly lacked seasoning) and mashed potatoes. The salmon was also cooked to the desired done ness (medium rare) and served with fingerling potatoes and fresh vegetables. Dessert was creme brulee the only option in the set menu which was standard. Portions are decent sized and I needed to take some of my food back home! Overall, a decent place for a leisurely meal. read more

See all

This spot is quite close to Oakland Airport, making it a convenient stop on our way home. We've visited here four times, but my husband has said it will be our last. I genuinely love the cozy feeling of sitting in a boat's hull and enjoying the beautiful view. Our waitress, Angelina, was incredibly sweet, though she seemed overwhelmed with too many tables, and we saw the bartender step in to help. Our son's Fisherman's Platter came out first, and he finished it before our Lobster Bisque and Salad arrived. Everything was good, but the timing was off--we prefer to dine together. I had the Duckhorn Cabernet, which was $17 a glass; I didn't take a photo, but I felt the pour was fairly short. My husband enjoyed his Expresso Martini, which he said was delicious. I truly want Horatio's to thrive. I hope these tips are helpful and support their success. read more

See all

Horatio's is a very nice spot at the San Leandro Marina, that we've had the pleasure of visiting a couple of times now. The location couldn't be better. Overlooking the water, this is a great place to have a romantic dinner or drinks while watching the sunset. The interior is very nice, with a nautical motif. The restaurant is very spacious, a good choice if you're hosting a party with a large group. Horatio's is affiliated with Skates on the Bay and Kinkaids, of the Landry's Restaurant Group, which I picked up on right away, since they have a similar menu and motif. Skates fell out of favor with us after a really bad service experience there years ago, but we won't hold that against Horatio's. So far we've only been in for drinks and appetizers, but I'm looking forward to having a full dinner here soon. Appetizer-wise, their crab and artichoke dip is a must. They also start you off with warm garlic bread, which is yum. They have a very nice menu of creative craft cocktails. Reminds me of a really swanky cocktail lounge called Petrus we went to when we were in Serbia a few years ago. Service is excellent. Staff is welcoming, attentive, and professional. We look forward to returning soon. read more

Horatio's - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

The Maple Pear & Blue Salad from Horatio's tasted like somebody dumped maple syrup on a Costco spring mix and prayed the blue cheese would distract you. Also... where were the pears? I think I found one witness-protection-program slice hiding under a leaf. And the Cajun Chicken Fettuccine? Menu made it sound like New Orleans. Plate showed up tasting like microwaved spaghetti with commitment issues. read more

See all

This is one of the prettiest restaurants I have been to. The view as the sun was setting was out of this world. All of the food we tried was quality including the sampler, Cesar salad, and the fettuccine. The only downside at the time was the waiting. It took our food about an hour to come out with little to no check ins and we got so hungry. Luckily the complimentary bread was able to keep us occupied for a bit but other than that it's worth a visit! read more

Horatio's - Tasting Sampler - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

See all

I like the bread they serve in the beginning Our waiter attends school he seems like he was in space land he took forever to bring items we I think he had to make the ice for our water and took forever to bake the garlic bread we asked for the crab artichoke sampler w/ teriyaki and coconut shrimp he only brought the crab artichoke dip sooo frustrating They didn't have the first thing I ordered so I had to order what I didn't want fish and chips I had a cocktail that I've had several times before it was excellent prickly pear jalapeño margarita mmm although the bartender didn't add all the fixings it was good I complained about nothing since I've been here several times before read more

Horatio's - Prickly Pear Jalapeño Margarita - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

We were celebrating a special day and decided on Horatio's because we hadn't been in years and it once had a nice view. We were seated immediately and assigned a waiter who introduced him self and took our drink and food orders. That was literally the last time he came to our table From that point forward we never saw our waiter again. A manager came and introduced herself walking around with black gloves she had on in the kitchen I just saw her in on our way in. We had to inquire about our order to the second manager that came over. By that time we had been waiting over thirty minutes for our food. The food finally came and it was just ok. We had the fish and chips platter, pasta with shrimp and crab, hamburger and crab artichoke dip. There was no crab in the artichoke dip. They could be so much better if they hired more wait staff. Our assigned waiter was given a party of 15 people that were seated in another section across from us. Read the reviews ? I did and still made the mistake of going . read more

See all

Stopped by for a quick bite after making a reservation through Open Table. We were promptly seated by the large picture windows overlooking the SL Marina. Hubby ordered Prime Rib sandwich au jous with french fries. I opted to venture away from my usual. Had a small Blue Cheese salad with sliced almonds, chopped egg and added salmon. The entrees came out within an ample period of time. I asked Kayla, our server, where's the beef? There was two paper thinned slices of brown beef, was it even prime rib? Kayla came by to check in a couple of times, she was excellent! Personally, I'd reconsider coming by again read more

See all

Great lunch date Large free parking lot Well decorated building, quite themed Slightly dimmed but still bright, spacious, high ceiling, bar is nice and well selective in drinks View of the ocean was nice Joined their program, thanks Daniel Got a few strong drinks, tasty food (taco was so good), good laughs and great service read more

See all

What a great find by the marina! This seafood spot totally nails the coastal vibe -- the interior feels like you're dining inside a ship, with tons of nautical décor that makes the whole experience feel fun and immersive. Pretty neat place overall, and the atmosphere really sets the tone for a relaxed, waterfront meal. The food was so good. The calamari was perfectly cooked -- crispy on the outside, tender on the inside AND had fried artichokes too! -- and the salmon BLTA sammie was absolutely amazing. Super fresh, flavorful, and piled high with all the good stuff. Definitely a must-order. They also have a great selection of beers on tap, which paired perfectly with everything. And shoutout to our server, David! He was so sweet and attentive, checking in just the right amount and making sure we had everything we needed. Service like that makes such a difference. Can't wait to come back and try more from this yummy menu. Highly recommend if you're craving seafood by the water! read more

See all

do not order take-out from these fuck-ups. missing (expensive) items, no plastic implements or condiments, they ignore your simple requests for lemon or ketchup. drive home and find out they fucked you. no thanks. never again. you have been warned.... read more

My daughter chose this restaurant for her birthday dinner. I asked for a table near the window when I booked the reservation, and we were seated near the window. It was a nice view at sunset.The wait staff were very friendly. They did forget some things. For example, the waiter forgot to put in an order the entree for one member of our party. But they were apologetic, and they quickly made her entree. The food was pretty good. The fried calamari was a highlight. read more

This is the place where it all started. Our fav of all is their Broadway Pea Salad ... so refreshing and very tasty!! Everything is delicious and cooked to perfection as always read more

See all

Location- this is by the water and near another restaurant and hotel. Lots of free parking all around so there shouldn't be an issue. Food- I've been dying for this crab pasta and let me tell you.. THE FLAVOR IS FLAVORING it's got a tiny kick but the crab is fresh and cheesy! Sparkling water was the best match to it but wine is great too. The steak was cooked exactly how I like it. This place is a must because it's got it all. The server was extremely helpful and kind. Cracked a few jokes but the staff is amazing! Definitely would come back here again. They got me now read more

Horatio's - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

See all

Upon entering you are greeted with a inviting presence and amazing atmosphere. As we sat down we were quickly served water and fresh already buttered bread. The three of us all ordered the fish and chips and I can't begin to describe how great the fish tasted and was breaded. Overall a wonderful dining experience with great views and art pieces. read more

Horatio's - Right outside the restaurant - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

See all

Went here for our anniversary. Loved everything about the place. Location, decor, service, food, and pricing.

Shannon is the best bartender. San Leandro Restaurant week for the win added with happy hour, you can't lose. read more

Horatio's - Starting happy hour with alittle drink - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

We have been here no a few times and I have to say it is on the list. It's closer by but out of town. Need to meander through San Leandro neighborhoods to get there. The drinks, food and service are all great. I guess it's been here for close to forever and not sure how many people know about it unless they live close by. It does seem to have alot of regulars. A great view of an empty marina due to I think a bankruptcy and legal issues but hey, still on the water. The other perk is watching the planes coming in to Oakland, low and slow. We have only sat in the bar area but they have a massive dinnig room also. Overall a very nice place to hang out with a very chill ambiance to escape the daily crap. read more

Horatio's - Nice Martini glasses. Lemon Drop to the left and Impresso Martini to the right. Can't tell looking at the from the side. - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

See all

Made reservation but they were not ready to seat us until 15 minutes after reservation. And we intentionally did early dinner time slot. So my advice is to plan accordingly and just show up early for an earlier reservation time since they may not provide you your table at the appointed reservation time. Food was a mix bag. The slow roasted herb crusted ribeye was delicious - had it cooked medium rare. But the seafood trio was a no go - taste was mediocre. We ordered kids a pasta and a fish and chip. I would say it's kind of a joke - pasta was cooked on the mushy side and too salty, while the fried battered fish seemed like those frozen ones pumped with water (it had that slight spongy and watery texture that my kids didn't eat it after the first bite). Service was poor. Server had to be reminded multiple times just to bring either a coloring sheet for the kids, or for some napkins. The evening that we went seemed to be on the average loud side and since we were seated at the corner upon entry to the lower dining space, it was a constant buzz - one would have thought being in such a spot there would be greater service but nope. Overall a disappointing experience considering the $$$ paid for a meal there. Only thing that made it tolerable was the view. read more

Horatio's - Grilled Seafood Trio - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

See all

Horatio's one of the most iconic places in San Leandro, California pros -setting ambience location cons - everything else what happened to you guys? You guys were a really great place to sit down and relax. Have a great seafood steaks drinks enjoy with family yesterday. We went there as a group this place really disappointed me. I cannot leave the comments. most customers had a very, very bad experience please fix yourselves. Food is completely terrible. Customer service is horrible. Let me know if you guys need assistance, I'm here to help a 40 plus year customer read more

Horatio's - Fired food - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

This was our first time eating at Horatio's and it didn't disappoint! We have always driven by this place when we go to the marina but never stop in. We went on February 12 for an early Valentines dinner and chose to get their Valentines Special dinner. The special dinner was $130 for two people and included 3 courses. Our waitress Maria was very nice! I loved the atmosphere of the restaurant, they played good music choices and very clean. First Course: The warm bread with garlic butter is delicious and is the perfect shareable size. I had the Pointe Reyes Blue Cheese Salad and the toppings and dressing was amazing! My husband got the Romaine Caesar and it was very good also, I am just a blue cheese fan! Second Course: I got the filet and shrimp, mashed potatoes, and asparagus. My steak was cooked perfectly...very juicy and tender on the inside and char on the outside. I loved that it was not over seasoned or salty... it had such a great flavor I didn't need to add anything else to it. The shrimp was seasoned nicely, the mashed potatoes tasted perfect and were very creamy, and the asparagus was very tender. My husband got the prime rib and it was delicious. I really enjoyed the creamy horseradish sauce it came with. Third Course: I got the crème brûlée and was so creamy and just delicious, loved the fruit on top! I stole a bite of my husband's chocolate dessert and it was perfect... very moist and chocolaty! Overall, I highly recommend Horatio's and give the food a 10/10! Everything was cooked and seasoned perfectly and great portion sizes. We definitely need to come to try more menu items and see the bay in the daytime! read more

See all

Have been patronizing Horatio's for decades now and will continue to keep going! It's a hidden gem in the east bay, a seafood / steak spot everyone needs to try. They have a food menu, full bar and epic maritime decor inside. I always would do the ole steak & lobster, also scallops. One of my favorites, for my birthday & other special occasions - is their crème brûlée. Such a damn good dessert. Excellent restaurant, has been around for an eternity & we definitely hope it sticks around. read more

I came in for a great view and an even better steak, and Kimberly my server that time absolutely delivered. She locked in on my order, stayed attentive the whole time, and made sure everything hit the table just right. The ambiance was smooth, the service was on point, and the whole experience felt like exactly what I came for. read more

Horatio's - Seafood Near Me - San Leandro, California

Decided to take advantage of the awesome happy hour. Sat at the bar as it was pretty busy for a beautiful warm Thursday afternoon. As soon as I sat, Shannon greeted and welcomed me. Handed the menus and gave me a moment to scan the menus. I had already made my mind and told her what I would like. Serve my drink and appetizer, she would periodically check on me and I appreciate it that. Kudos to Shannon read more

See all

Attended a birthday celebration for my 96 yr old Aunt last Saturday (8/22). The service was lousy as well as the food. The waiter dropped a Fisherman's Platter directly behind me. This resulted in all the sauces from the platter landing in my hair and on the back of my dress. No apologies and no assistance in helping me to clean up. Had to go to the ladies room and use cloth napkins from the table to clean my dress and hair. The Waiter did say that he informed the Manager, but no one ever came to address the situation. Customer Service is really lacking as well as menu choices and quality of food. Caramelized vegetables on my Pork Chop plate were hard as rock. I was not able to cut them. Dining at this establishment was a waste of money in addition to the bill I now have for laundering my dress (#Cleaners) and time spent washing my hair (I had recently visited the hair salon Thursday prior to the event). This is the 2nd time our family chose Horatio's for a family celebration and had substandard food and service. Prior experience they served cold Clam Chowder. We are definitely done with this establishment. read more

Cool spot I found off of Yelp for a last minute lunch. Food was good, and so was service as staff was kind.

Visited Horatio's with my brother to make use of a gift card. Just like the old days, their happy hour remains one of the best, classic and always worth it. read more

See all