I wasn't quite sure where to begin with this place--but honestly, it starts the moment you walk through the front door. The space is elegant, classic, and unmistakably upscale Italian. There's a subtle pop of orange throughout that somehow makes everything feel fresh, warm, and inviting--like the room itself has a pulse. The lunch got even better thanks to the company. The friend who invited us was absolutely glowing--and we quickly found out why. He had just married his soulmate. That kind of energy set the tone for the entire afternoon. The rest of us were equally in awe, soaking in both the ambiance and the news. We did what any group of happy, hungry people would do--we ordered everything and shared it all. Homemade pastas across the board: fettuccine Bolognese, shells in a rich vodka sauce, and ravioli in a delicate white sauce finished with shaved black truffle. Each dish felt like it was competing to be the favorite. The appetizers didn't hold back either--sautéed zucchini, clams casino, and more dishes flying onto the table than we could keep track of. At one point, it felt like controlled chaos, but the best kind--the kind where no one cares because everything tastes incredible. The staff elevated it even further. Our waiters were attentive, warm, and clearly proud of what they were serving. Watching the pasta prepared right in front of us added to the experience--it felt personal, almost theatrical. By the end of the meal, we were full, slightly overwhelmed, and completely happy. Elegant, flavorful, and unforgettable. We were told to come back during white truffle season--and after this, that's not even a question. read more

See all

excellent! stopped by mid day for lunch and glad that we did. food was perfect service impeccable ambiance lovely. we shall return! read more

Beautiful ambiance, but food was disappointing and the service was poor given high prices they charge.

Catching up with friends for dinner in a very comfortable dining room with white linen covered tables, walls with framed artwork featuring the movie behind the restaurant's name and other iconic actors. The hosts and wait staff were wonderful, looking forward to dining there again. Enjoyed one of the very best pasta dishes I've had in the last year, Fettuccine with Porcini, the pasta was perfectly cooked, glazed in olive oil, with a generous portion of Italian porcini, mildly earthy, velvety long strands that seemed to never end as I twirled the pasta onto my fork. As good as any pasta dish I've had in Michelin starred restaurants in Italy! read more

See all

We were in a large group. The bill must have been around $4k (9 people) because the hosts were ordering everything and anything and also top notch wine. The food was good. I had some appetizers and chose not to have a main course because of the appetizers. What really gets me about this restaurant is the mediocre service. The waiters are very hard to understand- they recite the menu to the table and it's fast and with their accents (no one is Italian by the way) you forget everything they tried to say at the end. I had to ask for a paper menu. Then, they kept pushing all kinds of appetizers and entrees because they saw that our host didn't care about money- so it was obvious that they saw a lottery ticket and kept pushing things and bringing way more than needed but the host didn't care. Then, the other annoying factor is that they keep coming back and interrupting us while we are having conversations. Essentially, they can't read the room. Poorly trained. For a restaurant that is known for hosting high end clients, the waiters have a lot to learn. Very underwhelming and tacky service. I would not return to this place because of the service aspect but the food was good. And we had fun despite of all the constant interruptions. read more

Il Postino - Wine - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

One of the best Italian restaurants in the city. Home made pastas are fabulous. Also loved the squash blossoms and frankly everything. Moreover the service was impeccable. Love the soft lighting. read more

Amazing food, service a s a beautiful Resturant. I'm just sad it took us this long to dine here. The waiter and all the staff were so attentive. The back room is fantastic and the orata, wine, octopus and salad were all delicious. We will be back many times read more

Great for special occasions!!! Pricey but worth the money. Very cozy atmosphere and the wait staff is excellent read more

OMG! Best NYC Italian restaurant. Hands down. My sister suggested it and I was skeptical. Service, ambiance, food quality, menu diversity (ignore the menu - a ton of specials and they will make what you want). This is THE quintessential NYC white table-cloth Italian restaurant. My new favorite. read more

The aroma hits you when you walk into the dining room. Your mouth drools in anticipation. The waiter describes the Angelotti with fresh shaved White Truffles. The dish is delectable! Little soft pillows of heaven in a surprisingly light cream sauce. The truffles taste as great as they smell. Life if glorious! Until the check comes... $220.00 (TWO HUNDRED AND TWENTY DOLLARS) for this plate of food. Enjoy! Beware and be careful! read more

Il Postino - Angelotti w Shaved White Truffles - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

We went here last night for dinner with some friends that are like family. They're all Italians, except Lorenzo and I and they told us it's the best Italian food in NYC. I would disagree I think it's the best Italian food in America! Some of the best ravioli I've ever had, their truffle sauce is what dreams are made of! To top it off the service was even better. The waiter is friendly and knowledgeable, the chef comes by to make sure we liked our food. It was just a fantastic experience all the way around. It was one of those meals that made you realize just how good a dining experience can be and should be. Oh and the dessert! Wow! It's so incredible! We ordered the dessert sampler and it fed 7 people and we had some we had left because we couldn't finish it. The cheesecake melts in your mouth. Also the wine selection is wonderful and the waiters make sure your glass is never empty. This place is magical, the decor is spectacular and the way you're treated is like you're royalty. If you're in NYC this place is a MUST! read more

Il Postino - Pete, Shayne Lamas, Lorenzo Lamas, Me, Ron, Vanessa and Kathy by the fireplace. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Amazing service amazing food amazing atmosphere. One of my new favorite restaurants to go to in NYC. I give it a 10!

Great food and wonderful service in the best atmosphere you can wish for .. Everyone made us feel so welcome from the moment we walked in . Great experience..! read more

Wonderful food and service. Great experience. I've been back since and it's always consistent.

Stopped in yesterday afternoon for a drink at the bar since we were in the neighborhood, and had the nicest time. Beautifully elegant restaurant, friendliest waitstaff, and our lovely bartender Erica and host Renato could not of been more welcoming. read more

See all

Had the pleasure of being invited to dine with a frequent at Ilpostino. We were treated like royalty. The restaurant is small but well laid out. The chef/owner came to the table. Greater is with open arms. Great wine list. We shared a 1999 bottle of Soldera. Would strongly recommend this place to anyone who enjoys a intimate Italian night out. My hats off to Ilpostino and it's staff. read more

Last night was our second time dining at Il Postino. We had some friends in from out of town, and were excited to take them for their first time. The service is exceptional. We had a waiter who I assume may be the head waiter, and he was phenomenal. He knew the menu and specials thoroughly, but also noted that the chef would make any special requests we could think of. He had several recommendations and also even brought some samples of apps. We were treated like family all evening and everything we ordered (and some things we didn't.. )was all delicious. We will be returning soon! read more

Amazing ravioli- I am not a ravioli person but for my birthday my friends recommended me try. I never had this good creamy tasty delicate mouth-melting ravioli ever. A+. Pretty tasty tiramisu. A! The reason I put 4 stars is that 1. A server dropped a dish on our chair and the ravioli and its sauce got in and on my daughter's moncler jacket (while they immediately clean) 2. I am a vongole bianco spaghetti person and I cook myself and eat everywhere. It was not good as the best vongole spaghetti with flavor. It was not bad but not the best for the price . Beautifully served, though. Overall, it will not go wrong at this restaurant. It is a fancy restaurant. read more

My late husband and I dined here for our anniversary in 2009 before he was seriously sick. I had the Farfalle Ulpia and he had the filetto di Manzo Al Porto. We shared the Affettato Misto. For wine we had a montepulciano. The chocolate dessert was beyond delicious. I'm sorry this review is so late. Molto Bene. Grazie. The service was very helpful in helping us decide what to eat. Thoroughly romantic and we were very happy. read more

Loved the ambiance. Had higher expectations for the food especially at the prices they were charging. My parpadelle looked and tasted like my mother in laws homemade thick and misshapen noodles. Not good!! The rest of the food was meh, although my husband's linguine dish was on point. Service was excellent except for the poor Swiss junior waiter who most likely has been fired since we dined there. I feel like there are much better Italian places in NYC. Probably why they ask for a credit card number when you make a reservation. read more

Il Postino - Linguine with Frutte di mare - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

We had an incredible and delicious meal at il Postinio last week. The service was five star; the food was five star; and the entire experience was absolutely stupendous. The irony is the place where we had a reservation that night -- Sistina -- turned out to be run and owned by a horrible, nasty human being -- we ended up walking out with the owner cursing us as we left. Class all the way eh? As we were celebrating a birthday, we really wanted to find a great place and despite the fact that we called last minute and Il Postino was near full, the owner/manager of this restaurant did all she could to rescue the evening. Also, the food was excellent, plentiful and well priced. I'd give this restaurant six stars if I could. read more

Charged us double for our dinner till we pointed it out to them. Gave us another tables bill , they claimed.

This is one of the most traditional old-school Italian restaurants if you don't like what's on the menu they will make you whatever you want. The food is always fresh and the wines are amazing. The salted Bronzino fantastic the ravioli with truffles spectacular even their grappa is amazing. . read more

See all

I think what set's Il Postino apart from other similar establishments is the service. There was no question that not only had our waiter worked there for years and knew the menu like the back of his hand, but he was overly accommodating in substitutions and off menu items. Our dinner started with some lovely prosciutto and burrata, and my dinner was followed by some epic seafood stew. This spot is a little off the beaten path and totally worth it for the experience. Ask to get a table in the back if you want to talk as it can get a bit crowded by the bar. read more

See all

Interesting food and ambience. Expensive, but it's in Midtown East. It's named after the movie Il Postino. It is classy and good for a business dinner or an occasion. We had a nice waiter from Norway. It's traditional in style. I would have to go back again to order more. An Italian display table adds to the decor and posters of the movie and Hollywood stars. read more

Amazing food and service. Nice for a special occasion too! Pricey but food is excellent! Enjoy

This is an absolutely gorgeous spot on the Upper East side...back room has no windows or outdoor light so could be day or night, but very pretty room... Service is bordering on "Old World", but does require vigilance...prices are high and the food is inconsistent..the soup was delicious ($16 for small bowl) but the calamari looked like cold rubber bands tossed in a red cabbage leaf... the bread was OK, kind of stingy with the olive oil & no butter was offered. The main course was OK, if you liked under-cooked, tasteless vegetables with your entree, but it was a relaxing respite on a busy day... read more

100%!!!! The Lotte New York Palace recommended IL Pastino for real homemade delicious Italian food. The staff was beyond great and friendly. They were very accommodating and stayed open late too!!! The bartender was so sweet and the manager was so kind!! We felt like family by time we left!! I totally recommend this beautiful restaurant!! Its gets a 10 for the delicious food!!! read more

See all

I love this place. The food is so consistently delicious and the menu is varied with interesting options. Save room for dessert and set a spell - The service and hospitality are old world class - top notch! I highly recommend adding this neighborhood spot to your list! read more

The best fine dining service in all of NYC. Entire staff made you feel welcome from beginning to end. Gorgeous room. Total celebratory experience, but could be just as lovely for a solo meal. read more

The service was excellent and the food was fabulous. The chef stopped by my table after dinner and chat for a couple minutes. Amazing!

Wonderful ambience with professional wait staff. Food was excellent. We ordered food that wasn't on the menu and they were very accommodating. read more

Wonderful classy Italian restaurant great for dinner with friends, family or a date. Service. Bartender, hostess and servers were extremely friendly and attentive from the time we arrived to the time we left. Ambiance. White linen tablecloths, black chair covers and small fresh flowers on the tables contributed to a comfortably formal and classy atmosphere. The table where we were seated couldn't have been more perfect, set apart from the rest, private feeling, and overlooking the tables on the first level of the dining room. Food. We had dinner here restaurant week, and everything was great. - bread with oil - mussels in a light broth - fantastic - burrata- very good - veal- tender, excellent - seafood with green and white pasta- the pasta was cooked perfectly, and the sauce was delicious. - tiramisu- - chocolate cake- delicious Definitely recommend for a great italian dining experience with outstanding service. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious and feel so lucky to have randomly found while walking and hungry. This spot doesn't show up on Yelp when searching for restaurants so we walked by it at first and went back because we were curious about the menu. The interior is really chic and we were warmly greeted despite not having a reservation. The place was full and lively and we were seated on the top floor by the bar. Service was impeccable and the food was delicious. We had a fresh pasta dish and the branzino fish that was cooked is salt and very fresh. What a treat! read more

Phenomenal food. Beautiful ambiance. Romantic. Great service. Pricey, but worth it. Don't come here looking to save money. Come looking to eat authentic and delicious Italian. read more

We live in the neighborhood and come here often. What really sets this place apart is the customer service and the fact that they will make virtually any Italian dish you ask for, even if it is not on the menu. Do you feel like a particular pasta and sauce, such as linguine with clam sauce or ravioli and pesto? If you ask your waiter, there is a very good chance that they can make it! This is not a trendy restaurant that everyone knows about, so it tends to be mostly locals. Come join in and be pleasantly surprised! read more

Just had my second meal here in 4 months. It is superb. A lovely atmosphere, impeccable service, great food. A very extensive menu, multiple evening specials, but they will make you ANYTHING you ask for, within reason. A Large loud family group was seated next to us. The hostess repeatedly offered to move us, but we were fine. Very thoughtful. Eat here! read more

Absolutely love this place. Everything I've eaten there has been so delicious my mouth is watering just thinking about it. Not inexpensive but 100% worth every penny. Highly recommend! read more

I went here with my sister. it was so great.Neighborhood place very pretty. The service was suburb . Food was yummy I do recommend it here.

Service is absolutely amazing! Food is pretty solid. Beautiful ambiance. I would definitely go back again