The Bethel Park Jersey Mike's is always consistent as was the case Friday. I ordered #7 and #5 and the staff prepared the freshly made sandwiches as I waited. I highly recommend this location for the excellent service and food. Thanks for being a great location in Bethel Park. read more

Went to the location in Pleasant Hills last Sunday afternoon. I always order a #7 turkey , provolone, Mikes way. The sub had lettuce( which was yellow and should not have been served) tomatoes (mostly white) and onions. I usually have a great sub but not this time! So disappointed ! read more

I have to ask... how do you run out of all breads but white and at 7 pm on a Friday? Very disappointing - because we always get the rosemary bread. Usually we go to the one out in pleasant hills but we were going to listen to music in the park... so decided to get from this location instead. The subs are still good ( got the original Al Italian..#13) mikes way with pickles, mayo and banana peppers). Drink station was a bit of a hot mess... many not working others needed a good wipe down. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Dinner and music at the park! - Fast Food Near Me - Bethel Park, Pennsylvania

The chicken Philly on their gluten-free bread was delicious! Kind and welcoming staff members. I was able to sit down and enjoy a meal with my best friend. Thank you! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Gluten free bread, #16 Mike's Chicken Philly - Fast Food Near Me - Bethel Park, Pennsylvania

I was so disappointed in my sandwich I got there. I have eaten there before and got the portobello sandwich and it was good.This time it was so soggy and way too many onions and hardly no mushrooms I don't think I will eat there again read more

I have been a Jersey Mike's Customer since they opened this store a few years ago. At first there was enthusiasm and customer concerns were a priority. Lately things have gone downhill, very fast. The last 3 times I have ordered online, the pickup times have grown exponentially. Yesterday I ordered a Giant Tuna and pickup times were over 30 minutes. The store was virtually empty at 8PM with 4 visible employees. 2 guys working the counter and 2 girls were in the back just talking, in fact one of the boys said to the girls " we need some help here". When I arrived to pickup the order, they hadn't even started to make. Again the store had only 2 customers. I asked for the order under the name Daryl Renzi, and they replied " we will make it now". This is when the boys had to ask the girls just standing around and talking. They hastily made the sandwich and asked how I wanted it dressed? I replied " just as the order was placed". They set the sandwich on the back counter, I had to ask again for the sandwich, as I was standing there and waiting for it. The order was paid for online, with a small tip. When arriving home and opening the sandwich, it was a sloppy mess. There was no way it could've been any more sloppy. I realize it was tuna salad, but tuna and mayo were coating the paper wrap and entire bun, making it impossible to eat as a sandwich, I had to use a knife and fork to keep it from sliding out of my hands. Jersey Mike's to me has the best sandwich. My sandwich was just short of $20, not inexpensive by any means. But for $20 I expect more from your franchise than I do from a Subway or Jimmy John's. Please pass this along to the local management team, and express my opinions and concerns. Thanks. read more

I'm a delivery driver that picked up an order here recently. Often, items are missing from our orders from other restaurants. Uber tells us to verify that all items are present. When I received the bag, it felt almost empty so I wanted to check that the chips were in the bag. I peaked in the corner, making sure not to break the seal created by stickers. While doing so, the OWNER, Mike, began to say "mam." I looked behind me to see who he was talking to and he proceeded to raise his voice and yell "mam" louder. He then, with a raised voice, stated that I was allowed to open the bag. I said that I wasn't. That I was making sure it was all there. He said "Well it's all in there. You can't open the bag." I reiterated that I wasn't opening it but that I wanted to double check. He again snapped that everything was in the bag. I've delivered for over 4 years and I've never received this kind of service. I've also never had a manager, let alone an owner, speak to me the way that Mike did. It was excessively inappropriate considering we are told to verify that items are present and even upon asking employees and being told everything is there, often times they are completely wrong. I will not be returning to this location for myself or my customers. The "owner" needs more training on how to appropriately handle customers and how to speak to them. This was ridiculous. read more

It's a Jersey Mike's - consistent with the other locations. A quick and easy lunch for good prices. My favorites are the chipotle cheese steaks. I wish there were a few other hot subs but no biggie. read more

Great sub. Dressings we're delicious. Plenty of meat. Fresh meats & bun. Nice, friendly staff. We'll worth the price. read more

As someone who travels as often as I do, I look for consistency in the restaurants I go to. Because of that, I really favored Jersey Mike's. I can count on them to provide quick service, delicious food and a clean location. Shout out Kendall and his team for providing us With not only a great sandwich but plenty of kindness as well. Thanks y'all! read more

We do not have these in Rochester, NY.. I miss them Yes I know they don't toast them but who cares. I really enjoy the RoastBeef and get it"Mikes Way" lettuce, tomato and etc. I add mayo, hot red pepper spread.. yum. The staff here is really nice and helpful. The inside is clean and everyone inside seems satisfied with there sub. My husband gets the turkey one and loves it too. Yum, Yum, YUMMY get yourself a sub this is a nice location and they open at 10am.. so They share a lot with other stores. Party on! read more

Looking for some variety, I decided to try Jersey Mikes. I ordered using the app, and selected curbside pickup. The process was perfect, the food available when the app said it would be. Within 1 minute of me clicking "I'm Here" button in the app the food was brought to my car. The food was great. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Curbside pick up - Fast Food Near Me - Bethel Park, Pennsylvania

See all

I enjoy eating their subs because they have a gluten free bread option , where as many other sub shops do not. My only recommendation would be for the food to be ready at the time indicated when you place an order online. read more

Even though Jersey Mile's is a chain, it deserves a review for how good their hoagies are. The bread, the meats, the toppings, everything is always super fresh and high quality. Some of my favorites are the turkey, Italian, cheese yak, and buffalo chicken. The seasoning and dressing they use for the cold subs makes for an incredible flavor. read more

wonderful food!!! always made in a condistent manner. Never disappointed!! I like also that they give to chairities

Staff slow and not professional. I placed an order online and arrived 1 hour after placing it. Upon arrival it was not ready, talked with the cashier and she said couple of minutes. 20 minutes passed and 5 customers came in and were served. I asked again and the guy preparing the sandwiches said probably another 5 minutes. I left and call GH to cancel the order. Jersey and Mike's, please hire more professional and reliable personnel. read more

First time at the new location. This place has so many different sub options. It was nice because they had a lot of chicken and steak options. All that we had was very good. This isn't like subway. The meets are super fresh. They cut and put back in the freezer. The lines are long and they have a lot more people working. Happy they're in the neighborhood. read more

I got a Buffalo chicken bowl, and ordered a 2nd salad/bowl while I waited. (Big Kahuna extra meat). What a WONDERFUL team of hard-working and KIND people. They were so busy, and everything was wonderful. Have to give credit to such good people. I can't wait to come back and try something new. read more

Excellent subs!!!! I will definitely be back. My whole family LOVED them! We all had something different and they were all awesome!!!

Disgusting. Paid $20 for a sandwich plus delivery fee. Arrived TWO HOURS later. The sandwich had obviously been sitting the entire time..they couldn't remake the sandwich after seeing how long it had been there??? Bread a soggy gross mess, not even cold, room temperature is generous. It's a freakin cold cut sandwich! Just threw it in the trash after one bite. I feel physically ill. NEVER AGAIN will I eat Jersey Mikes or use Uber Eats. read more

I first tried Jersey Mikes a few months ago and to say I am obsessed is an understatement. I went four times in the past week because it's just SO GOOD! All of the meat is sliced to order, the bread is so fresh, and the veggie toppings nice and crisp. Make sure you get your sub "mikes way" which includes tomatoes, lettuce, onions, seasoning and oil. The onions, seasoning and oil really make the sub! The nice thing is they have a lot of options. I do not eat steak but they have a chicken cheesesteak which was outstanding! You can also make any sub into a wrap. I usually get the turkey sub but got it in a wrap this week and it was so yummy! You can also cut the carbs all together and get everything in a bowl. Make sure you sign up for their email club and app. You get "shore points" which add up to free subs and you also get a free sub, drink and chip on your birthday! This is actually what got me to try Jersey Mikes! Can I also mention how nice everyone is here! They always greet you and say goodbye. Each time we are here they strike up conversation and they just really make you feel welcome :) read more

My friend and I stopped into this sub shop for an early dinner. The restaurant was clean. It has a lot to choose from on the menu. I ordered a Meatball sub. They made it fresh which was nice. The meatballs were a nice size. They could have been warmed up a bit more. There was a nice portion of melted cheese on top. I would have liked a little more though. I'm a true believer in "no such thing as too much cheese". The meatballs were ok, not a lot of flavor. The bun was the proper density to hold up to the meatballs and not get soggy. The sub was good but not outstanding. I would go back to try another type of sub. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Bethel Park, Pennsylvania

See all

Nobody can get it right or even wrong ALL the time. But this place gets it wrong often enough that I cringe at the thought of going there. I don't go there very often for the reasons I will be mentioning. I have never had a short wait, so don't go when you have time constraints. People in my office like the food, the food is good when it is right. I refuse to go unless it is ordered online so it "should" be ready. Don't go when you have time constraints. 50/50 chance your food is in the takeout rack or you have to look like a line cutter and go to the register. Today it was in both places. I gave the attendant my name, then waited and waited....don't go when you have a time constraint. I decided to go to the back of the room to check the rack, low and behold, rather than bring it to the register, they dumped it on the shelf. Okay, now I can go, except it was missing a whole sandwich, back to the register, they picked up a sandwich behind them and stuck in my bag. I left because now I am really out of time, almost a half hour past the time I was told on the internet.....don't go when you have a time constraint. I rushed to the bank and the other business I had to take care of, head home, read the receipt and a drink is missing. I am going to find time to go back and get my $3.00, I don't need the money, but this point needs to be made. Don't when you have a time constraint, you will be disappointed. The food is actually pretty good. Good enough to make me a frequent customer. The service, timing, accuracy, and, yes, even the pricing is enough to keep me away unless I am forced to go by someone else in the office. I can't lie, the food, if you get the right order, is pretty good, but the overall experience is incredibly frustrating and enough to dissuade me to go almost anywhere else. read more

Ordered go pickup a Philly steak hoagie. It was delicious with the fresh rosemary bun.

I use Jersey Mikes for all my catering! This time it was teacher appreciation week. The service is always excellent and the staff friendly. Special thanks to Chris for helping me with this specific catering order. We will be back again for our next birthday party, sporting event, family gathering, and any other occasion. read more

The staff was so friendly and helpful. The food was also great but would come back just because the customer service was top notch.

I walked into this location with my son and husband (both of which have asthma). We had on our masks and were standing 6 feet from the others. Inside waiting for food were not one, but TWO people without masks on. The sign on the door clearly stated that a mask was required, however not one employee said a thing to either person. Don't even put the sign up if you're not going to enforce the rules. The two people waiting should be glad I didn't call them out on the BS. read more

I'll buy a loaf of Towntalk bread and jumbo before I ever step foot in this Jersey Mikes again. Kids making subs and openly talking about customers. The meat slicer was disgusting. The owner needs to step it up. It's a great idea to hire people that don't give a damn about the product they put out. Good way to run a business. read more

Love the quality of everything at Jersey Mike's! Staff is very friendly and knowledgeable! Give their subs a try...best ones you will find! And make sure you get the subs Jersey Mike's style. They never disappoint! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs in South Park Shops is an excellent restaurant. The staff is very friendly and the subs are fabulous. A great go-to place for a terrific meal. read more

Hoagies from here are pretty good! Nice crunchy buns, decent amount of toppings and when you order catering, the sauce options are appreciated as well as the fact that the hoagie is pre-cut for you. Only thing I don't like is the stiff pricing and lack of newspaper deals read more

I love their subs. But customers should pay attention while your sub is being made. Spending over $30 on takeout, getting home and EVERY sub had everything I asked to NOT have on our subs. Not one was correct. I guess that money went towards a lesson learned! read more

I was so excited to see Jersey Mike's opened a shop near me. I've been there several times and have yet to be disappointed. Employees are courteous, have smiles on their face and look like they're having a good time ... And it shows in the quality of the Hoagies. Bread is always soft and fresh. The Philly Steak and the Philly chicken subs are to die for. I need to end this review and go get a sub right now! read more

Overpriced mediocre subs. Bread is decent but the meats are seriously lacking. If the price was more realistic I could be more generous with my rating but for $10 + tip for a basic Italian sub I expect much better. Either bring down the prices or bring up the quality. Will not be returning. read more

Visiting from New York City and stopped in with the family for a quick sandwich. Wow. Best sub sandwich ever. Great crew working that day. Shout out to Dillon! And we even got a selfie with the owner Mike. Thanks to Mike and the whole crew for a great experience. read more

Used online ordering for the first time to get subs for our recent fishing trip. They got our order entirely right, even with lots of special instructions (sauce of the side, cut in 4ths, etc) and pick up was so quick - skip the line. We kept them overnight before we went on the boat and they were still fantastic, even day old. If you sign up for their rewards program, they send you a coupon for free sub & drink on your birthday which is so nice! We love this place! Great food & service! read more

My husband and I loved the Jersey Mike's in NJ so when we heard they were opening up by us here in PA we were so excited. They dont toast their subs like subway and dannys. But their meat is fresh as they slice it as they are making the subs. Our order was done within minutes with no delays and it was FANTASTIC. We will definitely be coming back to the Jersey Mike's in South Park Shops. Their customer service and attention to detail is the greatest. read more

I went to jesery mike's in bethel park pa. Waited for 30 minutes, then I waited another 10 minutes for my order of 2 regular turkey sandwiches and a Jr one and 2 chips the cost was 30 dollars paid it left came home to find out I have 3 Italian subs I called to speak to a manager and was told to call back in a half hour. This manager was rude to my daughter as well. I worked all day went to the gym, I was hungry so I chose jersey mike's in Bethel park pa. NEVER NEVER AGAIN will I step into a jersey mike's I will be letting all people I know how unorganized this place is. read more