After having Jersey Mike's I can't imagine ever going anywhere else for a Sub ever again!! Quality ingredients are a thing folks. Pay a few extra dollars for Goodness and great service! Do it "Mike's Way" those sweet onions seriously call my name read more

5 stars for friendly and attentive service. It was my first time at this restaurant and the experience was excellent. I've never had such wonderful service on Maui. The sandwiches were excellent as well. I will be a regular! read more

I come to this location quite a bit and I've always had okay service but during this visit I was very disappointed. They ran out of bread first of all. Then they served people in line after me. Finally when they were making my sandwich I asked that they change their gloves due to the fact that I'm allergic to banana peppers, and I got a bit of sass from my simple request. Very upset by this visit. read more

I ordered a big ol' sub on January 30th and had an AWESOME experience with the crew working that night. They were fast, included all of my customization requests (ordered through the app) perfectly, and they even went above and beyond with my pick-up bag. Honestly an awesome experience with the service, and the sub was delicious. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Pick up Bag - Sandwiches Near Me - Kahului, Hawaii

Takes gluten allergies seriously. Puts on new gloves, uses new knives and lays down paper before cutting the gf bread that is opened in front of you. They also ask if you want mayo from the package because of cross contamination. Extra points to the manager who offered to let me use his phone when mine wasn't working and I needed WiFi. -Thank you! read more

Last night Husband got some subs from JM. A ham with vegis and pulled pork. The pulled pork was a hot sandwich which didn't have the Hawaii flavor to it. Sandwiches are "good" quality! Husband said he seemed rushed because when he ordered his sandwich he told guy he would like a soda but was never given one. Though it was busy it was a Saturday night around 8pm. Check them out if u craving a sandwich. read more

We usually go to the Maui Lani one but my husband was running errands in town and picked up dinner from this spot on 5/20/19. I ordered the big kahuna but when I got it the onions were stringy and sad, the peppers were all skin, there were no jalapenos and it was so soggy it was falling apart. I figured they just didn't make them as well in the other location and ate it anyway. BIG MISTAKE. The next morning I was so nauseous and puking nonstop for the next seven hours. It was so horrible, I had to miss work. My husband, who ordered and ate the exact same thing, also got sick later that same day. I used to love Jersey Mike's, it was my pregnancy craving - now I don't think I can ever eat it again. Thanks for the food poisoning, Jersey Mike's Ho'okele! read more

This was a first experience at a Jersey mike sub shop in Kahului and I have to say , This was one of the most delicious sandwich I have ever had . I ordered the chipotle cheese steak sandwich and it was delicious 10 stars rating on that sandwich. One thing I do have to say is when I got my sandwich and I sat down to eat it , the table that I sat at was so dirty I had to clean it my self . As I was eating I was looking around at the other table and I noticed they were all dirty. The employees were all in the kitchen area talking. I feel that if they are not serving any guest they should at lest come out to the eat area and clean the table and push in the chairs for the next customer to come and enjoy a delicious sandwich at Jersey Mike's Subs. read more

See all

I'm a huge Jersey mikes fan, but this particular location has horrible customer service. Employees had the most terrible attitude, and not inviting at all. They charged me extra for a sandwich that didn't contain the ingredients that were supposed to already come with the sandwich on the menu. I tried calling the location multiple times to get a new sandwich made or a refund but they didn't pick up the phone during their hours of operation. If I'm paying almost $20 for a sandwich you would expect it to be made the correct way. I might as well have taken myself to subway. read more

My Jersey Mike's sandwiches were the best sandwiches I've ever had! The service is top notch for a sandwich joint. Make sure that you order your subs to be put on the grill, they are much better warm and grilled. Ovar was nice to talk to and a very efficient employee! Even though it's a little pricy for a sandwich, you get what you pay for. I'm back home now and still wish I had Jersey mikes right now!! read more

See all

Usually, sandwiches and service are very good at this location. However the sandwiches we ordered last night had less than half the amount of filling that they usually do. The sandwiches were mostly bread. read more

Big shout out to the employees at Jersey Mikes in Kahului!! You guys rock! Thank you for the awesome hospitality and friendliness you showed my daughter and I during these crazy times!! We will definitely be back and appreciate your kindness! And, as always, the sandwiches were delicious! Thanks again! read more

I went to this Jersey Mikes today, welcomed w a nice "Hello guys". Ordered my food and asked for a MEAL. Get to the register and the guy rings me up w/o a meal. I ask for my drink cup and he says "you got a meal??" and i say "yes". They then ring me up again for $3.75. I'm pretty sure he already rang me up for one then charged me again. I didnt care and left, come into the car and start eating. No napkins. Then I find a long ass hair in my sandwich. Honestly fuck you guys and male at the register read more

Worst service and took a half an hour in line with only one family in front of me. Then they got my order wrong of course, and to top off the nightmare the stupid ass point of payment wouldn't accept my card after 4 or 5 tries and I finally had to input my card info manually. What a pathetic joke; definitely don't think I'll ever return. Also, the guy who took payment seemed completely unconcerned and not a nice guy at all. Never returning again. read more

So I've been regularly ordering sandwiches from here since they opened. I've genuinely loved all my experiences until today. Today I ordered a giant #7 and when I opened it the end of the bread had what I appeared to be green mold. I called to let them know and a young girl named Natalie answered. She yelled to perhaps the manager my situation and I clearly heard the other employee groan like ohhhhhh great! She said bring it back we'll make you a new one. I explained that I already threw the bad half in the trash and I live half hour away (upcountry). She said some more stuff to the manager and then repeated it to me: bring the sandwich back. So you want me to dig a sandwich out the trash and drive half hour to have that kind of service I can already tell what it's going to be like. NO WAY! Especially during this Covid time when I already shouldn't even leave the house and I have kids. Disappointed because 1: the mold 2: the lack of customer service (no apology whatsoever) 3: the nerve to tell me twice to bring it back in. All I was hoping for was a future sandwich on the house maybe or at least an apology. Lame! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Moldy stale bread. - Sandwiches Near Me - Kahului, Hawaii

Non existent manager. This place is filthy, the floor is disgusting, the people behind the counter have no idea what they are doing. Almost 30 minutes for 2 sandwiches. How does someone buy a business and let it run into the ground like this? I don't understand. Please clean your place and train your staff properly. read more

I was told that Jersey Mike's had the best pastrami sandwich in Maui. I was skeptical. I tried a few other places and at best dog food......actually worse, I wudn't let my dog eat it. So I was there today and I began to order the Italian and then tossed out "I heard you do pastrami?" The worker said yes "It's off menu....." So I said "How u make it.....?" and she explained......she inquired about my paranoia and I told her "I can't find nada for pastrami here....it's like they don't know how to cook it." She said "Gimmie a try.....ours is legit." So she whipped it up, tossed on some kraut, a little TO dressing and BOOM. I gives it a 4 as it's sub bread and not rye which I can't get out of my head, think Canters in LA, Nate & Al's where Larry King is kvetching in the corner to anyone with 2 ears......so as for a 4, that's pimpin' in Maui....a good but rare find. Props to my man on NextDoor for informing me....good times....good eats.....bada boom bada bang.... read more

The food was really good and so was the service and drinks..but the floors and tables did not look regularly cleaned I would go there again but I would have enjoyed my time there more if it was cleaner. read more

I love this place I hate chains but this place is very good . Service is very slow My favorite any hot sandwich. read more

Had been looking forward to trying these subs, but on a rather slow Monday, it took more than 40 minutes to get one Philly cheesesteak. Even in these days of short staffed restaurants, this can hardly be considered acceptable. When it finally arrived, the sub was very good but I doubt we will be coming back. read more

Jersey Mike's was ok, nothing special about the sandwiches. But the price was higher than you think it would be. The service was terrible, we dealt with high school kids who were anxious to talk to each other more than anything else. My order was wrong and they fixed it after the 3rd try. Nothing against high school kids but maybe interviewing process wasn't the best. My food and service wasn't even close to the best but the money I should have brought out the best. First and last time for Jersey Mike's in my family read more

Bummers had the Grilled Pastrami Reuben...they cut the meat nicely and then broke up the meat on the grill and mixed it with the sauerkraut it then tasted like a corn beef sandwich mixed with cabbage....tasted very porky and the bread was not grilled nicely. Basically a foot long sandwich for $18. Maybe don't call it a reuben. Anyway gave them a try. Not recommended at this time. read more

I really like the sandwiches it is a bit pricey but the overall service you get is great

Great new store, busy with a fresh team. Fun vibe and ono food. Thanks for the coupon for donations! Happy to have food options at Puunene Shopping Center! read more

I love Jersey Mike's and so glad they're on Maui. Fell in love with them when I lived in San Diego, then they finally came up to San Francisco when I had to relocate there, and now here. Prices aren't that different either -- much mahalo! read more

The floor was dirty. Like, FILTHY. No paper towels in the bathroom. Only one person making sandwiches while everyone else kind of stood around. I had placed an online order. It said it would be a 22 min wait. We arrived about 20 min after I placed the order and were told it wasn't ready. There was one other person in line, so they weren't busy, but it took about 10 more minutes to get the sandwich, which was strange. The Jersey Mike's in Wailuku at Maui Lani is waaaaay better. Go there. read more

Went in before a flight, ordered online about 45 minutes prior and they were still working on the order. Behind the food line seemed extremely chaotic. read more

Got a cold sub and a cheesesteak. The cold sub was their house club (Turkey provolone and bacon) it was very yummy, bread was fresh, lettuce was crisp and bacon ...well can't go wrong with bacon)The cheesesteak I ordered took a very long time to come out ...and they forgot I requested it without bell pepper, I thought it was my mistake but my receipt did mention the request..anyhow it was very good...maybe one of the best cheesesteak I had in a while. They are little pricey but the portions are also pretty generous. read more

Sandwiches were delicious, friendly helpful staff, George made great recommendations. Location was busy, but staff were quick to fill orders. Worth the price for a fresh sandwich! read more

Everything was fresh, but the pricing for the Sub made me feel robbed walking out. They were shy on the meat but over sharing with the lettuce. I'd rather have it the other way spending $27 for just two people. And only 1 was a combo. Food was alright. read more

The best submarine sandwiches ever. The service was top notch and Skylar was absolutely an amazing and helpful person. He went above and beyond to accommodate my request and made me feel welcome and like family. Mahalo Nui Loa to the staff. read more

Great location! Always looks nice and clean, staff is friendly and helpful! Sandwiches are delicious!

Good sandwiches but bad service took me 30 minutes to get my sandwiches after we had preordered and the staff clearly forgot about them. They didn't offer apology and frankly they all seemed mad that I was there. read more

This is a double meat Tuna from here.. We had never been to Jersey Mike's so decided to pick up a couple for our flight back to CA from Maui. I asked for Tuna #10. So little Tuna, we asked for double meat. Yes, that is what they consider double I guess. Mostly bread, and EXACTLY why I don't go to Subway. I like a little meat with my bread. The Tuna was good, just not much of it. read more

customer service is horrible. literally had To go out of my way to get his attention so I could order. Which was only followed by his rude attitude. It was really surprising cause I was the only one in there. Food is good, but people they choose to hire not so much. read more

Sorry, but I'm not a fan. The sandwich was bland, and portions were small for the money. Clean restaurant and friendly staff, but...yuck.

Saddest excuse for a sub sandwich I ever bought! This was my first visit to Jersey Mikes (Kahului, Maui). They have 3 sizes of grinders. I ordered the middle sized one. They told me it would feed 1 or 2 people. Cost me $10.95 plus tax. IT WAS 7 INCHES LONG! SEVEN INCHES! I could have easily eaten two or three of them myself. Costco hot dogs are bigger, come with a soda for $1.50 + tax and are a lot more filling. This is the smallest sub and most expensive sub I ever eat. Never going back. You can skip this place unless you are eat like a bird and don't mind paying double it's worth. read more

Haven't had a sandwich that good since leaving the East Coast 30 years ago! I had the Jersey sub the "jersey way" with lettuce, tomato, onion, S&P, oil and vinegar and than added on Pepperoncini. $10 for a 6" sub, but worth it. Nice staff. read more

Horrible. Put in an order online 40 min before I arrived and they had no clue about my order. What is the online app for? I would consider finding new employees if they can't keep up with the online orders. Entered an online order 40 min before to only show up and wait another 20 min. Terrible read more

the workers are so rude lol. my boyfriend and i were standing right on the side of the cashier and he pretended like we weren't there and when we asked for pickup he gave us a blank stare. the girl in the red shirt gave us attitude when we said the wrong name for our order. no friendly greeting or even a "thank you" lmfao read more