Good old fashion steak house vibe. Excellent menu including side dishes. Wait staff very experienced and friendly. Small but fun bar too.

Great service and steak selections. Reasonable prices for wagyu. Lobster cooked perfectly. Sides are served on cast iron so they stay warm. Very nice, moderately priced wine selections. The Hyperbole Pinot noir was top notch. Perfect if you want a great steak in an unpretentious atmosphere. read more

Jimmy P's Charred - Tomahawk steak and lobster tail. - Steakhouses Near Me - Naples, Florida

Superior cuts and dining atmosphere is very nice ! Service is great and the food is delicious!

Salad good, beer good, service very good. Sides were good and my wife's burger was good. Now the steak.... My daughter and I both ordered ribeye. They were nothing like the ones in the meat display case. Ours were at make 1/3 of an inch cut and At least 25% gristle. Not marbling but nasty chunks of fat. Cooked to correct temp but can tell the steaks were not rested. Later we were told they are known for the NY strip. Too bad cause the steaks in the case had great marbling and looked awesome just let down with the ribeye. read more

Delicious food. Service was good. Bathroom was a little messy. I hate that. I will be back

Monday at Jimmy P's Charred is prime rib night. Not just any prime rib but wagyu prime rib. A prime prime rib as it were. The prime rib comes in two serving sizes 16 and 20 ounces. Served with mashed potatoes and asparagus. Mrs. K likes her beef served medium well done. I asked if they had an end cut available as this is usually the most done piece of the roast with a bonus of all the spices on the outside. They had one but it only came in the 20oz cut. Mrs. K. and I also spit a Cesar salad. Very good. Since this is a Monday only deal I would tell you to make reservations. But it was not crowded and I do believe you can walk in and score a table. This was one of the most tender and tasteful prime rib I have had in a long time. read more

Always get an outstanding meal at Jimmy P's. The meat comes first here for sure. The place isn't much in terms of atmosphere and the service is good but not great... but the food is always superb. The steaks are always perfectly cooked... Most recently I had the 16 oz #7 NY Strip au poivre. Great sear and perfectly medium rare. read more

Jimmy P's Charred - 16oz #7 NY Strip - Steakhouses Near Me - Naples, Florida

Yum just had lunch here last week. Great selection of steaks. Always very good service and I love the food here. Mary - Naples read more

Not like it was a year ago. Terrible service. Waiters, waitresses, kitchen staff aimlessly walking around. Kitchen and dining area was dirty. $200.00 for 2 steaks, sweet potatoe fries, and 2 glasses of wine. Steak was terrible and very tough. Horribly cooked with a bitter, burnt taste. Waitress was awful. Never smiled. I am sad because i used to love this place. Don't waste your money. Go to Outback Steakhouse instead. If I was the Owner, I would fire all of the employees and start over!! WILL NEVER GO BACK AND WILL SHARE MY EXPERIENCE WITH FAMILY AND FRIENDS! read more

A most disappointing meal. My Waygu steak was ordered medium and came out well done and had no steak flavor. Sort of a chalky taste. The onion straws were cold and it was served on a cold plate. The steak was difficult to cut with a steak knife. My wife said her burger was nothing special and the fries were not warm. The table next to us had a group of men who were so loud and obnoxious (dropping F bombs etc.) They were out of control. Management did nothing to quiet them as they ordered lots of wine and expensive food. Also, when we got home we realized that our clothes need to go to a dry cleaner as they smelled like a greasy kitchen. read more

The moment you enter, the ambiance is subdued and elegant, but not stuffy or pretentious. Our server was polite and attentive, guiding my friend Sue and me through the menu. Our steaks, as predicted, were perfectly medium rare and delicious. I work just up the Trail from the restaurant and intend to come back many more times. read more

Not a super huge deal but was just a little thrown off guard. Been hearing such great things about their Philly cheesesteaks - was in the area a few days ago and thought hey I should call and place an order to pick one up! I call around 2:15 and a young woman answers the phone and I tell her I'd like to place a takeout order. She says "sorry but can you call back in 15 minutes I'm kinda busy right now" then hangs up the phone... I work in service and this is just crazy to me?! My boss would be LIVID if this happened at my restaurant. Very odd and not good customer service... obviously read more

i think we met the owner - he was so so accommodating. We came in on a busy night and he made it work! Incredibly nice and the burger is amazing!!! thank you jimmy p's!!!! read more

Steaks were out of this world! All of the food was delicious but believe the hype the steaks are worth every penny! Service was exceptional! Drinks never went empty and our server was so friendly and welcoming! It's kinda like a hidden gem, restaurant isn't flashy and you walk through the butcher shop to get to the dining area but it's really neat to look at the many options! Dining area has a cozy warm vibe! Definitely add it to your list! read more

Jimmy P's Charred - Homemade Sliced Key Lime Pie & Passion Mango Cheesecake - Steakhouses Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

Tried to get in on a Friday evening to no avail, I was told I needed a reservation. Made a reservation for Sunday evening. We were sat down right away and greeted by the waiter in a timely manner, he was very good and attentive. We ordered drinks and a couple of appetizers, the pork belly on crispy bao buns and the escargot. Both were great. Our problem started with the steaks. We ordered 2 butchers cut boneless ribeyes medium rare and a New York strip also butcher's cut and also medium rare. My ribeye was perfect my wife's New York strip was however more black and blue. My son's ribeye was overcooked and it was an end cut. We called the waiter and pointed it out, so he returned it to the open kitchen where my son saw the chef and waiter interacting. Another steak was sent out to him and this time it was practically raw. My son being a chef picked up on the end cut right away. The manager happened by our table to ask how everything was. We told her what happened and she explained about having all new kitchen help. She did take off the steak from the check and offered 2 complementary desserts. read more

See all

If you like barbq then this is the place! The food was delicious. Want to also try tge connected market.

I ordered a Waygu Strip MS 4 and requested it cooked medium-rare. Unfortunately the steak was closer to medium-well. When the server looked at it, he he insisted that it was "close enough". After we were finished with our meals, the manager said he would take my steak off of our bill. That would not rectify the situation and we insisted that we pay for our entire meal, which we did. We will not go back to this restaurant ever again. We also purchased steaks from their butcher shop to prepare at home. Those steaks were delicious after I cooked them correctly The restaurant should be ashamed of their incompetent kitchen staff and their dismissive servers. read more

Jimmy P's Charred - Overcooked Waygu Strip MS 4 - Steakhouses Near Me - Naples, Florida

Best steak in Naples bar none- amazing service and amazing food. Can't recommend enough. Have been twice in the year I've lived here and will be back again! read more

The exterior took me off guard as the restaurant is in an old shopping mall but there is more than meets the eye, once inside, you are transported to a quaint and warm enviornment. Excellent 3 course meal and superb service! Love the rustic feel and stepping into the butcher shop, felt very european. Our server's name was Chris, he was personable, told us the history of the butcher shop, had the menu memorized and provided excellent advise! Thank you Chris for your attentiveness! Thank you Jimmy P for such an exquisite meal! A little advise though; table linen would be nice, not a fan of my utensils touching a bare table, but love how all the servers wear aprons like butchers! Great concept! We will be back! Also, a must are the truffle fries! Bring your appetite! read more

See all

Love this place if you want meat this is place in Naples Florida They have Butcher shop with ribs and sausage and meat and brisket !" Next time we will order to take back with us !" Will be back !!! read more

Jimmy P's Charred - French dip Steak sandwich - Steakhouses Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

On the fence about this review. I rated lower for several reasons.We came in for lunch last weekend (6/21/20) with a group of 7. We arrived in Naples from FLL for a family staycation at our annual time share and needed to get a quick lunch in before our rooms opened. It was completely our fault for not calling ahead for a table reservation but seeing as majority of us haven't really been "out" it wasn't something we were too worried about. They weren't terribly busy and happened to have a table available to accommodate us. We were sat in the middle of the dining area which was fine. Upon entry it looked as if they had a deli/to-go situation in one half of the place and the restaurant in the other half. No signage telling people where to go. They have an awesome selection of meats to purchase in refrigerators around the market area. I did notice a few tables that had signage and weren't being sat to respect physical distancing which was nice but the only person I saw wearing a mask amongst the staff was the hostess. No other staff member in the restaurant, including the deli area and kitchen staff had a mask on. I was very uncomfortable the entire time and had it not been for being hangry and being with family I definitely would have left. I also didn't see anyone walking around wiping high touch surfaces either. The food was decent. Portions of all the meals were huge! I got the Cobb with grilled chicken and ended up taking half home. However, all of the burgers ordered weren't cooked to the specifications requested. Mostly overcooked. I'm not one to send food back in general but we weren't going to send anything back since we were all super hungry and due to COVID. I also inquired about a beer on draft to our server when she came by and asked her for one and the beer never came. Trying to be understanding and patient with the current climate and everything that's going on right now but the experience wasn't overwhelmingly safe and I'm not sure I'd feel confidant returning to this establishment next time we're in town. read more

See all

Amazing!! Great service! Perfectly cooked steak! Mashed potatoes are scrumptious. Unique breads with a yummy blended butter. Don't let the street view fool you - this place is perfect!! read more

Jimmy P's Charred - Surf & Turf - Steakhouses Near Me - Naples, Florida

I found out about this place through my husbands flying...lots of pilots that fly into Naples know of this place and come with a cooler. I read reviews to know that Thursday is steak special day. This place did not disappoint. The drive was well worth it. We ordered the steak special that was salad with a NY strip. The dressing is balsamic vinegar. Was able to share it with my husband. The steak is really thick. And the kids got burger which was a good size. I wonder what the adult size would be. They said the burger is waygu. Definitely great price for the burger. We also got onion rings which was crispy. Everything was great portion. Enjoyed the cole slaw also. Definitely will be back! read more

See all

Very disappointed. I know w covid we should be more lenient w reviews but I was totally disappointed. Start w covid...Staff had masks on but no social distancing at all. So for those not comfortable dinning out please order take out. We sat in a booth , there were people right behind and in front of us plus table next to us. It felt crammed especially w the new covid seating. Food were fair, way overpriced on what we got. We got the pork belly and octopus as appetizers. Maybe it only meant for one person so not to be share. There were only 5 pieces of pork belly for $16, octopus one tentacle and too charred for another $16. We wanted different steaks but due to covid they only had limited selection, which was disappointing but understandable. The main entree was good. We waited 30mins between appetizers and entrees, which was a long time. I don't know if I'd go back it's easy over $100 per person so expect more than fair on food and service. read more

Never had anything bad here. I recommend the cheeseburger & my husband recommends the steak & cheese. When we visit Naples this is the first place we stop at. They also have a meat counter where you can purchase your own meat to cook. They also ship to you. Hope to visit again soon read more

See all

I have eaten at Jimmy P's several times, and have always enjoyed the food and service. I ate there again tonight, and had a great time: the escargot were very good, Caesar Salad, and the 16 oz. wagyu strip steak was excellent. BUT, I ordered a bottle of wine and when the bill came, it was on the bill at almost 50% more than on the wine list. I didn't notice this until I was about to sign the check, and then mentioned it to the waitstaff. after a few minutes, he came back and said I was right, so therefore he had taken the wrong price off the bill and charged me the correct price, claiming that it was an error that someone had put in there system, but no harm now, as it was resolved (at least on MY check). We asked for the manager, and when he finally came by, he also claimed it was a computer error and that there was no harm because WE caught the problem! When we asked if he could give us a discount for a future visit, he said he did not have the authority; interesting in that earlier in the conversation he had said they were trying to figure out if my check had already been run, in which case all they would have been able to do was give me a discount to a future visit. serious case of double-speak here. I want to know: how many other people have been overcharged at Jimmy P's because they haven't closely reviewed the bill? normally, I would not complain or write a poor review, but the management's complete lack of customer service was appalling. There are lots of good steakhouses in Naples. I will be going elsewhere next time. read more

I paid nearly $100 for Wagyu steak and did not receive a steak at all. Instead I got a piece of meat shaped like a steak full of connective tissue. I guess someone in the restaurant got that meal instead - maybe one of the staff for themselves or their friends? The knife could barely cut through it. You should be ashamed. Thanks for helping me save money - it will be a long time before I spend money in a restaurant again. Also, before you leave a response saying I do not know what steak is, I most definitely do. read more

I asked for a Caprese Salad ... this is what was sent. WHO thought this was okay? The price was $15... which I would pay for an ACTUAL Caprese salad read more

Jimmy P's Charred - Supposedly, a $15 Caprese Salad - Steakhouses Near Me - Naples, Florida

Had an exceptional meal and experience back in May of 2022. Visiting Naples again we decided to go back. We were seated at the smallest table in the restaurant that was extremely uncomfortable. We made reservations in September for November. I asked to move to another table but was told they were reserved. They were all eventually filled with 2 people. My filet had fat and grizzle at the end. I told the manager and he said that happens with "end" cuts. Unfortunately my experience was that I'll never go back there or recommend Jimmy P's. Too many fine dining restaurants in Naples read more

My friend and I had heard about this place and had to try it. I had ordered the burger special and my friend ordered the brisket but wanted it without the fixings. Our order came out incorrectly but close to what we asked for. We mentioned it to the waiter and the owner came over and was going to comp the meal. We declined and just said we wanted you to know that's it. I think in this era of time we need to go with the flow and just be happy there are restaurants open and ready for business. I would recommend this place in a heartbeat. We will be back read more

Thank you for best 5 lb. turkey breast ,I used a clay pot for 90min. Perfect meat every time. Desiree and staff behind meat counter are the most helpful for what is our best selection of what we want, best advise and cooking instructions!! read more

Great steaks. Great everything. excellent staff. In this day and age, the steak better be worth it. Home run. read more

Great highest quality steaks and tremendously attentive and engaging waitstaff Jimmy P's.....the "P" stands for PERFECT read more

Best steak I ever had. Cooked to perfection. Went off-season and sat at the bar. Bartenders lack personality, but that really doesn't matter. I had the Waygu ribeye and creamed spinach. I was craving a Manhattan, but they only serve beer and wine. High recommend! read more

I had very high hopes for this place and I left pretty disappointed. We ordered off the lunch menu at the counter and grabbed a table outside. My colleagues sandwich was ready in about 10-15min while my wrap took 35min. The buffalo chicken wrap had good flavor and the sauce was a great balance between spicy and flavor. The chicken however was chewy and tough. The tortilla itself was covered in sauce so it was extremely messy as well. The coleslaw was above average though and I enjoyed it. The staff was friendly but they were very busy at 1pm on a Saturday. read more

Jimmy P's Charred - Steakhouses Near Me - Naples, Florida

Had a phenomenal meal here the other night with my wife and friends. Got the pork belly appetizer that had the most perfect flavor that was a little spicy and so tender that it just melted in your mouth. I finally had a chance to get the Japanese A5 waygu and it did not disappoint. The garlic mash potatoes, mushrooms, and Brussels sprouts were awesome sides. read more

Jimmy P's Charred - Japanese A5 Waygu with garlic mash and Brussels sprouts. Cut like butter! - Steakhouses Near Me - Naples, Florida

Oh Happy Day! The question of "Where's the Beef in SW Florida?" has been answered. And the answer is: Jimmy P's Charred! I now know where I'm bringing my husband the next time he's channeling his inner carnivore. I've had Jimmy P's Charred bookmarked for a while now. Yelp friends, Martin N, Darrin B, and Matt P have all written great reviews and I was excited to see what they offered in person. The opportunity came when a trip to the Naples Zoo was planned. We decided to have lunch and then head to the zoo. The strip mall location doesn't immediately hint at the treasure inside. However, the parking lot was jam packed full. One industrious, although perhaps unwise, patron had opted to park in the grass adjacent to the egress by the road. Take your time coming and going and it shouldn't be too much of an issue. If you need to search for a parking slot, believe me, it's worth it. The entrance to the restaurant is also the entrance to the attached butcher's shop. When we arrived, there was a ten-minute wait for a table. We browsed the meat cases and I started to get an excited buzz. Everything looked great and I started planning to put a cooler in the back of the vehicle the next time we were going to visit, so we could bring some meat from the butcher's shop home to Cape Coral. When our table was ready, we walked into the crowded dining area and got a very good impression. Everyone looked very happy and every place my eyes settled gave me something new to consider. The lunch menu and the daily specials had many tempting entries. The table to our right said they were regulars and gave a list of personal favorites. The table to our left said they loved everything on the menu and you couldn't go wrong. My eyes were telling me it was the truth. With so much to choose from, the only problem was settling on an order. Eventually, I decided on a Philly Burger from the daily specials. It was a veritable mountain of meat with a heap of Wagyu steak over a Wagyu burger and topped with provolone cheese, mushrooms and onions. I had them hold the peppers. Every bite was amazing with juicy, full-bodied, flavor that comes from very high-quality meat that has been seasoned and prepared by an expert. It came with a side and I chose Cole slaw, which was also very good. At $15 this was a great deal. I would have thought that at least half would need to be boxed but, truth be told, I ate every bite. The restaurant was running smoothly and was very clean. Service was great and we were checked on regularly. Jimmy P's Charred absolutely gave me the experience that earns them 5 stars. That is, I was already thinking about my next visit, while I was enjoying the meal. Highly Recommended. read more

Jimmy P's Charred - Philly Burger from the Daily Specials - Steakhouses Near Me - Naples, Florida

Delicious food, inconsistent portions. We ordered the butcher shop salad and the wedge salad with wagyu steak. Both had delicious flavor, fresh ingredients, and beautifully seasoned and cooked steak. Reasonably priced for the quality and quantity for the butcher shop salad. We've gotten the wedge salad in the past and it was much larger than the one we had today. This is my only complaint. Very friendly service and phenomenal steak! Definitely will be coming back again. read more

I just moved to the neighborhood and was dying to get a good steak. My wife and I sat down and immediately were shocked by the prices. This is a nice place but by no means high end. I thought it was crazy that no one was wearing a mask. We have been out several times during the pandemic and every other restaurant we been to had masks and distance between patrons. My wife ordered a medium rare steak and it was cooked medium. It was very good but nothing special . I ordered surf and turf. Lobster was awesome but my medium steak was over cooked. I was very disappointed and will not return for dinner. It is a good lunch place. Sandwiches and burgers and pretty good. read more

Jimmy P's Charred - Nice lobster tail. Tiny over cooked steak. - Steakhouses Near Me - Naples, Florida

The food was very good though it took 90 minutes to get our order (& the place was less than half empty.) We asked for a both but was told they were all reserved. After being here 2.5 hours, the booths were never used. The 80s music blared over the sound system the entire visit and it was excruciating painful. But... the food was good. read more