Love it here. They don't serve pork anywhere in the building, so I get the luxury of trying all the slices with pepperoni and sausage. I adore NY-style pizza, and this has easily become one of my favorite little go-to spots in Buffalo. The pizza is consistently good, the staff is always kind, and I've never left disappointed. 9/10. read more

Joe's Ny Style Pizza - supreme personal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Great tasting New York style slices at reasonable prices. Good selection of different toppings. Plenty of bottled drinks to choose from as well. Staff was very friendly. read more

Joe's Ny Style Pizza - Pepperoni and mushroom slices and a slice of steak amd cheese - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Stopped at lunchtime for a sub. While waiting, I watched the pizza/sub "constructor" at work. I was absolutely taken aback noticing that he was using his BARE HANDS on All of the ingredients he was working with!!!!!! I told the "manager" who said that they recently had a health inspection and wasn't written up for no gloves!!! I got my money back and left. Make sure your health insurance is paid up if you eat there!!! read more

Staff is incredibly rude and trashy. People loitering outside begging for change. I was a regular customer for a long time however, this is unacceptable and I will no longer go here. The pizza is not even good anymore, it just isn't worth it. read more

We happened to walk in when they had a fresh cheese pie coming out of the oven. They slices were excellent. Reminds me of Stromboli pizza in New York City's East Village. I'll come back to try the rest of the menu -prices are good, there's a large dining room. I'm holding back one back one star because it's kind of dirty in there. The windows are dirty as you walk in and the doors are dirty. read more

Place isn't all that clean .. I've seen people outside that work there that look absolutely filthy . I watched a man rub his head with his hand of sweat and wipe it on his rag and moved on with the time .. I won't eat from here anymore read more

Best NY style pizza around! Fast hot and delicious. Lots of choices. Haven't had the opportunity to try other menu items but other coworkers have, and have been very happy too. read more

What more can I say this was hands down the best pizza I've ever had. The crust was perfectly cooked, the toppings were fresh with a nice garlic taste,The service was solid and friendly, and the menu had tons of options to satisfy everyone in my family. Definitely a spot I'll be coming back to! read more

he needs to get the older gentleman back that was there a couple years ago because their pizza just ain't the same no more they changed the pepperoni and the crust. It is lousy now first time being back there in over a year. read more

What an awesome don't this was during our trip to Niagara Falls. Everything they sell is by slice! Very unique combinations. Everything we ordered was super tasty!! read more

Stopped in to get some NY style pizza! Grabbed 2 slices Buffalo chicken wing and sausage pizza. The pizza was good but a little too greasy for me. Slices where nice and thin. My boyfriend ordered mild chicken wings. They were crunchy as in overcooked and on the smaller side. The staff was friendly and place was clean. read more

See all

Delicious! We wanted some NY Style pizza while we visited Buffalo and this was fantastic! read more

Joe's Ny Style Pizza - 16" Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Honestly, not the best pizza I've had in Buffalo but not the worst either. Atmosphere is fine and the staff was friendly. It's a small hole in the wall restaurant with decent food if you're in a pinch. read more

I love this place and have been going for years, they have the best deep dish Buffalo chicken pizza. You can get a slice or the whole pie. It's right by Buff state so its easy to get to. Prices are reasonable and comparable to other places. I can't really say of the other food is good because I usually just get the Buffalo chicken pizza, but I will try something else next time and update. read more

Joe's Ny Style Pizza - Deep dish Buffal chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Checked out Joe's since it's a nearby pizza spot. Got the Pizza and 20 wings combo ($35.95). Didn't love the pizza as much as I would have liked, but I think it was just that the crust wasn't for me. Could have stood for more sauce on the pizza as well. I also ordered wings (Medium and Garlic Parm) which I did enjoy much more. Also ordered the garlic bread, but recommend passing on this if you are looking to add a side item. It was very underwhelming and was essentially a Hoagie sub buttered and garlic-ed. read more

Joe's Ny Style Pizza - Medium and Garlic Parmesan wings. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

This New York style pizza joint is awesome. I have never had a bad experience going here I always get a large ny style (thin) pepperoni to go. It is always perfectly made. Staff is professional and tends to the customers. The location is always clean. read more

I read the reviews pizzeria. I figured I'd give it a shot. First of all. Yes the pizza is huge. Jimmy looks really good. It has absolutely no taste to it whatsoever and it taste if you do get a taste it doesn't taste good the chicken wings oh my God, they give off an odor. I don't know what it was. I thought the food was spoiled but definitely not for me. Is there any place in Erie county in Niagara County close to Grand Island the kid make a good pizza so far here 12 years so far not one place. read more

Great pizza the xl is massive however wings were not anything special, worth giving a try if you haven't !

One of my friends raved about Joe's pizza and practically comes here every chance she gets so I had to see for myself how good the pizza is in the restaurant. I remember ordering from here a few winters ago, and it was not that great but I'm willing to chalk it up to the travel time versus eating fresh out of the oven. I ordered a 16" half cheese and half beef pepperoni pie. I've never had beef pepperoni so this was interesting. There are plenty of booths and a long table in the center to accommodate large groups. It was warm in there with two ceiling fans running. It was definitely a different experience eating in than getting it delivered. I had the beef pepperoni while it was piping hot and it was so good! However, being born and raised in NYC I gotta say I know my NY style pizza and this was not it, especially after trying the plain cheese. The bottom of the pie has the familiar burnish look, the cheese was the right amount and oozing off the slice but the taste isn't quite the same, and the dough still a bit too thick - is it because I ordered a 16" and not the 18"? I'm not sure but the pizza I ate today did not have the usual floppy style of the NY style I know. So to summarize: try the beef pepperoni hot out of the oven in the restaurant it's good, but don't expect true NY style. Note: very oily compared to other pizza I've had and the bathroom was annoying: soap dispenser took forever to drop out soap and the sink is one of those you've to tap continuously not to mention only trickles of water come out so be warned. read more

See all

This place was surprisingly very good. They have a variety of pizzas by the slice or whole. We had chicken wings, a Mexican beef patty, and a fish fry too. For the most part the prices were not bad. Of course the chicken wings were very expensive. You can't blame the restaurant for that. It is Biden's fault it is not the fanciest of places. However, good food, not so bad prices, makes this a place worth recommending!!! I see above that they want keys words such as service. I had to serve myself from the counter. I am under a lot of pressure to give myself five stars for that!!! read more

Whenever I'm in the mood for some New York style pizza I always stop at Joe's. Really good pizza! read more

See all

My favorite place, when not in The Bronx. Excellent service, great crust, and you can dine-in.

Joes is such an underrated pizza place. It is not anything fancy but it is just solid tasty pizza. It is my go to place for a perfect cheese pizza in Buffalo. read more

Joe's Ny Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Buffalo has it's own style of pizza. As a transplant I'm not in love with it. Joe's makes a very decent NYC style pizza. Big, flat, crispy/chewy tasty crust, tangy savory sauce, and lots of cheese. I've only had it delivered and I've always gone for a pepperoni and garlic or pepperoni and mushroom. Mushrooms are fresh. Pretty sure the garlic is that chopped stuff that comes out of a jar but beggars can't be choosers up here. If someone knows of a pizza place that puts actual cloves of garlic on a pizza let me know. As far as Buffalo is concerned this is the best pizza I've had here thus far. Stay away from their Caesar salad, it came with store bought croutons, grated parm (maybe) and Ken's dressing. Was also nice and toasty from riding on top of my pizza on the way here. When I order a salad anywhere that isn't a drive-through I expect at the least a homemade dressing. If you're from the south, please note that they only have Pepsi products. read more

Joe's Ny Style Pizza - Pepperoni and mushroom. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

The pizza here is fantastic!!!! You all should try it!!!! It's NYC style pizza. Usually I always prefer Buffalo-style pizza but I was headed to a show at the Sportsmen's Tavern (across the street) and I enjoyed myself the last two times I was here. They have pre-made slices that they'll reheat for you. If you order anything else off the menu, they make it right then and there for you. I ordered a slice of pickle pizza. I like trying new (to me) things. It was a thin crunchy slice of cheese pizza with pickles on it. It was weird but delicious and it made me happy. I also had a slice of meat lovers. It was fantastic. It had chopped bacon and many other types of meats on top of a thin crunchy slice of cheese pizza. It was delicious, filling, and it made me full and happy. I had both slices with a Vanilla Coke. The staff is super friendly and kind. Their quick and efficient and their jobs. There is usually little to no wait. If I'm in the area again, I'll definitely be stopping here!!! read more

See all

Hell yeah! These are my dough boys. I really can't stand the traditional buffalo style pizza and am always looking for the best ny style thin slice. I have tried numerous thin slice options in the buffalo area and these guys continue to stand out. Thankfully for me, they are a quick 5 minute ride. They also don't judge me for FaceTiming my husband while picking up our order to find the perfect speciality slice :) read more

So first off I'm from long island but moved to buffalo almost 2 years ago .I miss pizza. I'm not bashing buffalo cuz our pizza is just different. Someone told me to order from here so today I did and omg. Thank you so much because this is the closest I have had since I have been away from home. AWESOME JOB!!!! read more

Very good pizza! The slices are huge. Price is good, service is awesome. I highly recommend this place.

This is no paid review or fake review no bull crap this is the best pizza I have ever ate in my life!!! I'm going to make it a point to come to this place every time I'm close!! read more

Joe's Ny Style Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I chose to get a simple salami sandwich from here. In my mind I'm thinking how can you mess this up. Well upon receiving this sandwich I have NEVER seen a deli meet look the way this did. Silly of me to even consider eating the sandwich after the way the "salami" looked but I was starving and I figured it was probably fine but took the meet off the sandwich just bc it looked gross. Well that was a terrible decision because I ended up waking up at three in the morning with food poisoning. I don't know how a place could even serve something that looked the way this meat did but definitely will not be returning here. read more

When I moved to Buffalo in 2011, I was NOT happy about the pizza choices until I stumbled upon this gem of a pizza shop! To all my NYC people: this is legit the only place where you'll find real NY style pizza. As we all know, you can get 2 slices and a can of soda for about $5 in the city. At Joe's, the price is only slightly higher - slightly less than $7 for 2 slices and a fountain drink. If you want to venture out and find your favorite buffalo pizza spot, try Bocces or Picassos. But if you're feeling a little homesick, walk on over to Joe's and you wont regret it! read more

Some doomsday Bible Thumpers run this place, they are followers of Jesus's Dad (no, not Jorge... Joseph!)... and they keep yelling out "the end is ny! the end is ny!" I told them, you're spelling "ny" wrong, but they ignored me and continued to yell it. In fact they do this so much, that locals have decided to name this place "Joe's ny pizza", for obvious reasons. Joe's NY Pizza is pretty fantastic, and it's also pretty popular. It's facing sideways, in a strip mall next to Wegmans on the south side of Amherst Street, just across from the infamously infamous Sportsmen's Tavern, where Sportsmen go to, well... do Tavernish activities and stuff. The slices are big, as are the crowds at lunch time. This seems to be a popular destination with cops, so if you are the kind of person who has been, shall we say, a bad boy or girl, then you might want to give this place a wide berth. Not a wide birth, which would just mean a lot of pain for you and then probably some stitches. One letter can make all the difference. I got a slice with pepperoni and sausage and I loved it. All the cops apparently loved their slices too. I've never seen more Buffalo cops in a shop that didn't serve donuts. Burn. That wasn't a suggestion that the pizza here is burned. It really isn't. So much amazing pizza in Buffalo, since Buffalo is one of the best Pizza cities on earth. This place isn't top ten, but it's definitely very good and worth a try. Nom nom nom. read more

Eh. It's fine. I came here because of the rave reviews from many NYC pizza lovers. I have a great appreciation for NYC pizza myself. This is a large place located in the Tops plaza on grant, by Amherst. Easy location for me as I pass by there often and visit Tops and the Dollar General next door as well. I came late one evening and found it well lit, always good. I got a cheese only slice and its a generous size, no complaints there. But it wasn't warm enough for me, even though I asked for it to be warmed a little longer than usual. It also wasn't as flavorful as I'd hoped. It'll do in a pinch, but I'm not craving this pizza. read more

So these folks called me 4 times to complain about canceling a order when they messed up my total...

Eat at Joe's! No, not the crab shack chain, silly. It's Joe's Pizza and they serve delicious NY style pizza - they said they're the only ones in the area who do it right - New Yorkers are awesomely modest as I am finding out! Actually, the guys who work here are super friendly and happy to talk with you as you pick up your order. I think jovial is the correct word to describe them. Granted I did play the ignorant southerner who's never had NY pizza. I had them give me a lesson on the difference between NY style and Buffalo style pizza, the former being thin and crispy in a brick oven and the latter being doughy and cooked in a pan. So their pizza is cooked in a brick oven which I think is cool. Cool BUT Mister Pizza is still my favorite. Joe's is now my second favorite. My friend and I destroyed a large pepperoni and bacon pizza (my special) and even tried some their BBQ wings which were pretty good as well. If you haven't tried their pizza here, it's a must. Special thanks to the woman at Rust Belt Books in Allentown who told me about it! read more

Joe's pizza is pretty good. I don't have much to complain about, but I also wasn't wowed. The garlic knots are ok - the dough seemed a little overworked/ tough.. but they are still garlic knots. However, what I really like about Joe's is the chicken wings... In my family when you go from eating medium wings to hot wings it's a coming of age - like going from the kid's table to the grown up table on holidays... I am one of those people who keeps Frank's in my house and pours it on everything... so a lot of the time, I find myself judging chicken wings primarily on their heat. I am not a suicide kind of girl - I don't like the weird stuff restaurants put on their food to get to that level, but I like my hot wings to be hot. Joe's hot wings have SERIOUS heat. I was proud as I watched my parents and sister all go "wow" when they took their first bite (all of them being serious about the wings being hot as well). I mean, really the wings weren't even saucy, just hot. They must have let the sauce actually soak in or something, I don't know their secret and I don't care - I loved these wings. Not sure if medium wing eaters would fully understand. The staff there is really friendly in comparison to your average local pizzeria, and the prices are good too. read more

Joe's Ny Style Pizza - Joe's delivers - yes those are my plastic target plates, mid-meal, not theirs. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Stopped in here for a quick slice and I was pleasantly surprised by how good the pizza was! I got a slice of cheese, and buffalo chicken pizza and I thoroughly enjoyed both. They've got lots of seating, and the staff were friendly. I think I paid about 6 dollars for both slices, not too bad and they were pretty tasty. Key for me was the flavor, good and saucy both and not too greasy, but with that more tart New York style sauce on the cheese, and a good mild spice on the Buffalo. Overall very happy with my quick meal I'd come back for sure. read more

Garlic knots...good, steak pizza delish...pizza sub...burnt to hell. Its hit or miss. read more

Joe's Ny Style Pizza - Gross pizza sub - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

This is the worst pizza I've ever had. I will commend the customer service as when I called to say it was not edible they replaced it. Unfortunately it was replaced with an identical pizza that could not be eaten. The dough is NOT COOKED. I am sorry to post this but none of us can afford to waste money. I did tonight read more

Good place. The guy who brought this place to Buffalo is from NYC so it's legit NYC style pizza. I go to NYC about twice a month and it's pretty much the exact same thing (thin crust & all) so the name of the place is true to its taste..... not common. I got the Buffalo Chicken pizza with blue cheese, just a slice. It was delicious, especially whatever seasoning they put on the chicken. Stayed for 3 hours chatting with a friend and asked for refills on my tap water 3X plus a to go box (I'm an obnoxious customer). They gladly assisted each time. Kind and quick service. Super casual typical pizza joint. I forgot to document a photo until after I took a few bites and made a mess, but at least it shows you how big the slices are. read more

Joe's Ny Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York