Whenever we're in Kauai, this is always one of our must-stop spots for pie. On this visit, we…read morearrived just before closing after spending the afternoon at Salt Pond Beach. We picked up a whole Island Lemon Pie to take with us (forgot to get a photo). I got myself a slice of the Macadamia Nut Pie to go, which was delicious, especially with vanilla bean ice cream. Everything we've tried here has been consistently good and we've never had a bad experience. If you're planning a visit, try to get there early since popular flavors can sell out. Definitely worth a stop!

(Tookout 04/28/26 TU @ 2:30pm): it appeared every slice was the right choice!…read more I met up with a friend for the day, and she insisted on taking me to The Right Slice! In town for the day simply to show me an investment property my family and I might be interested in the very near future, before she departed she had to pick up an order of pies to bring back to her family. Of course, I came along for the ride because I liked pie, but I was curious how good they were if she was willing to fly several of them in her carry-on. Founded by Sandy in October 2009, she quickly adjusted her business model from doing six community events a week to her first retail location in Lihue in 2011. The business continued to grow that led to a second location this time in Kalaheo in 2014. Fast-forward to today, the Kalaheo store is the only one standing, and she has cultivated a strong following both near and far of pie fans and the continued support of the local community. Did I choose the right slice for my first time here!? PURCHASE(S) Mango Lilikoi Pie Slice ($8.50): Their most popular pie, they had me at mango! Filled with plump juicy mangoes combined with the just right amount of lilikoi (passionfruit) and topped with a sugar crust. Juicy sweetness burst in every bite, and I was in pure heaven! https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw&start=120&select=-IUMWv6HB5wpv9AiQ-Y_bg Macadamia Nut Pie Slice ($8.50): This time, they had me at macadamia! Made with a ton of island macadamia nuts, roasted to a perfect golden brown combined with butter, eggs, sugar, and fresh spices for a nutty tropical sensation, this pie reminded me of a pecan pie but so much better! It was heavy, thick, and required a cold glass of milk to perfectly pair it with. I went nuts for this pie! https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw&start=120&select=JfthjT1sMLgeXqbfMPGzhA To-Go Containers ($0.50 x2): For my dessert, I've never been charged this before, but I understood businesses needed to cut/pass along costs as much as possible - c'est la vie. Credit Card Surcharge 3.00% ($0.57): Another pass-along fee that has become more prevalent - oh well. SERVICE I was warmly greeted by a young woman behind the counter who gave me time to review the menu while she offered recommendations. Once I ordered, my items were quickly packed and ready to go - mahalo! PARKING (FREE): We were lucky to grab one of the five small spots in front of their shop (it was very difficult to back out due to the heavily-trafficked thoroughfare). Otherwise, I wasn't sure where else you could park nearby - be prepared. ATMOSPHERE, DÉCOR, AMBIENCE A country shop-like and ice-cream parlor feel with a couple of wooden tables, pie display https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw&start=120&select=5gAkOcUYZ1pbgpC8UZq5xg cases, a pie menu https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw&start=120&select=vSyaGOufl1cmq9OBOppvPw hung from the ceiling behind the counter, counters and shelves with merchandise, and an open entry way that welcomed you https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw&start=120&select=jSiOeD6ISWVAot4Qkz2e1A in for a treat. Plenty of natural lighting came through the large front doors and windows while soul-sucking fluorescent electric ceiling lights filled in the rest. There were no TVs, while pop music played in the background. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?userid=8jVT2inwc8GIQ6sH2UG9Vw&start=120&select=53zRcRMKuNaS23ufwnBORw ATTIRE Totally casual, so I would normally be in a t-shirt, boardshorts, and flip-flops. OVERALL The Right Slice offered magical pies both savory and sweet (I must return to try a savory one!) all made from scratch and with a ton of love. The care and pride was tasted in each incredible bite, and I wished I had one to bring back with me after I ate each slice back at the resort. Everything tasted phenomenal, the prices may've been a tad high (but well worth it!), and the service was calming and straightforward. Plus, I always loved to try and support small local mom & pop businesses. I found complete value based on the prices, service, and experience noted above (TOTAL paid experience was around $19.00 BEFORE any discounts, points usage, and/or tip). And, they accepted my credit card of choice... AMEX! 5.0 STARS

Bonnie and the whole crew at the Sueoka's snack shop. They do an excellent job. I'm really thankful…read moreI love the mahi-mahi burger with cheese. I love their aloha spirit, and everybody should get a raise.

June 2026 I loved…read morethis small and quaint super market. We grabbed the poke bowl and a few bento boxes to go. The poke was delicious! It had just a hint of sesame seed oil and that made it so fabulous.

Yummy Yummy Yummy donuts were great Malasala was great. Yummy goodness. I would definitely come…read moreback again. I will come here next time every time I can.

Good food poor coordination Do nit follow line of people…read morewaiting Though the customers tend to gang up in the staff.

So happy to have found this little gem. They have dairy free and gluten-free items. Even dairy free…read morechocolate! When we were there there were eight different options for us with dairy allergies.

Cute little Gelato shop. When you come you have to line up outside because they only let one or two…read morefamilies at a time. And the two times we came to visit there was only one person working. So be prepared to wait. The gelato was good. But not one of the best I've tasted. Also we came after dinner so it looked like hey weren't refilling any more gelatos. But maybe I'm wrong? But if you like Gelato I'd still recommend this spot.

I wanted to give this place 5 stars, but their poke was not it it was the taste and flavors for…read moreme. It tasted almost citrusy for me- not my preference, but if you like that flavor for poke, you can get it lol I tried their spicy and oyster sauce poke. My boyfriend got one of their mixed plates and that was very good! I'd probably get that or a diff plate next time. I liked how crispy their chicken and shrimp tempura was! My boyfriend and I wish they'd give more on their plates though lol I love their small store at the entrance. I was visiting Kauai so I was able to bring back some items back to Oahu

Stopped by to get some cookies as souvenirs for everyone back on the mainland. They have a wide…read morevariety of snacks and treats. The cookies are always buttery and sweet. The only reason I knocked down a star was because I also got a box of peanut butter mochi. The mochi was kinda tough and not my favorite.

WARNING!! This place will ruin you for all other shave ice! I am not kidding. It's that good…read more When my son-in-law texted that the barber shop had shave ice, I was worried. (It's NOT a barbershop... but easily mistaken for one.) All made with real fruits. Orange is real orange; not a sugary syrup. We heard them say they had swap out the açaí cone for blueberry-basil one of our days because Costco didn't have the açaí juice. This is by far the best shave ice I've ever had anywhere and I don't know if I'll ever have another shave ice without thinking about this one. Only problem we had was going back for a second time. First time we tried, they were out of all the fruit recipes by 4:00. The next time we got there by 1:30 and the store was closed for maintenance. We are trying again today. Crossing my fingers I can get The Caterpillar.

Not a fan, sadly. Don't order the chai shave ice unless you want super watered-down chai ice. I had…read moreto request for the worker to add more syrup, which did not make it better. They could make that syrup wayyyy more concentrated and added a thicker topping as their cream. The ice is acceptable but not as soft as other shave ice places in Hawaii. I would skip. Perhaps their other flavors are better. I give 2 stars for the cool mustache/barber theme and the effort from the workers.

Amazing coffee! One…read moreof our favorite coffee places in Kauai. Very flavorful coffee and espresso. We enjoyed their macadamia nut lattes and would love to go back to try their food. Plenty of tables outside when we went on their cute little patio.

Tropical tonic (espresso with ginger hibiscus and tonic water) was so unique! It was delicious…read more Surprisingly all the flavors went well together. It'll surprise you. Lil Green alien smoothie was so good and I felt good giving some to my 1 year old to get some spinach and fruit in. I don't recommend loco moco. Gravy had zero flavor, and that's what I typically get most excited about. Patty was overcooked. Eggs were cooked perfectly, though. Sadly we threw it out. BUT, their homemade Portuguese sausage is yummy! We had it in sandwich and burrito. Line gets long but moves at a decent pace. It's cute little outside dining was perfect for a quick breakfast. Tables turn over fast. Order in line first, then find a seat. They have super cute merchandise!

I hadn't been here before until this past Sunday night. Treated myself to ice cream after Game 7 of…read morethe World Series (Dodgers suck!). I had no idea that it's the sister store of Mango's, just up the street! Super casual, indoor or porch seating. I love their choices of coffee available and, like Mango's, a lot of high quality Roselani ice cream! I love the friendly staff and the historic photos of the Kōloa Mill and Kōloa little league teams on the walls.

I called them at 8:54 to let them know we are 5 minutes away, and they said if you are here before…read more9pm you will get service. So we drove there with a sense of urgency and got there at 8:59. I go to the door and they just look at me like I am not there, whilst I am showing them the 8:59 time on my phone. These people are so rude and liars!