This is where I had my first and second slice of key lime pie. There is barely any room to eat there, so I picked up two slices to eat at the hotel. I ended up going here because they were still open (late). I liked the coconut key lime pie more than the key lime pie which was much tartier. It was good but not amazing (I liked Blue Heaven's meringue version more). If you want to get key lime paraphernalia, you're in luck. read more

Very good and TART key lime pie I am a fan. They also make great cappuccino's. Must try when in Key West

We visited both their stores which happened to be a few doors apart. Apparently the new store is bigger and does the majority of the business. the lady in the older store was nice and was able to find taffy for us where the other store was completely out. We also bought there key lime cake which was not too sweet but maybe a little heavy on the salt. We were able to take advantage of their yelp deal and get a free slice of pie with our $20+ purchase. Their pie is creamier and sweeter than Kermit's. I like it better but my wife likes Kermit's. Prices are touristy so expect some mark up versus a Walgreens. They do have wall to wall key lime stuff so check them out. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Key. Lime. Coffee. Need I say more? If that's not enough for you, how about coconut key lime pie? If you're still not interested then this place just isn't for you. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Key Lime and Coconut whole bean coffee - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

You must be a Key Lime Pie lover in order to understand what I'm about this. It's not easy to find a Key Lime Pie where you actually taste the flavor of the Key Lime; usually, you just feel the taste of flavorings and sometimes you don't even notice it... Until... You taste the real thing! If you come into the store you will get to try regular or coconut Key Lime Pie; my advise, try both. You can sit down, enjoy a piece of pie and a coffee or you can just take it home. Also, you can't miss the Tortuga Rum Cake at a very very good price, in a no-end kind of flavors, my personal favorites: original, pineapple and chocolate (I wish you could get a slice in the store like you do with the pies). The employees are very friendly and welcoming! Thanks you guys! read more

This I could eat a whole pie of. My wife loved this pie. It tastes like an Oikos and the crust is awesome. I would test this and key lime pie company and you can be the judge. The pie has a heavy lime flavor and a thick crust. We could eat a whole pie of this and not even blink read more

Ok, I was excited to to try an authentic Key Lime pie in Key West, but I was surprisingly let down... I ordered a slice and paid almost $5 for it, and the pie was very bitter and extremely tart, no sweetness whatsoever!!! If I ever tasted spit up or throw up, it might be as bitter as this pie. It was horrible and I was so let down! Someone told me I should have ordered the frozen chocolate dipped version instead, but I'm not willing to try it. By the way, I was disappointed to find out that these Key Lime pie slices are also sold in local gas stations for almost $2 less, be forewarned!! read more

You can see Sloppy Joes from here. Pie is refreshingly good.

I'm not historically a huge fan of key lime pie, but I've been told I've just never had a good one. I'm not an expert on them, but one of our friends who is a key lime nut told us we had to hunt down this neon green shack off of duval that sold key lime pie. We found this place, I sent her a photo, and she said that it looked like the right place (she hadn't been there in years). So, with a huge endorsement, we stepped in to this tiny little place. The guy who I think was the owner was pretty friendly and told us about the options and chatted with us about our trip so far. We ended up just getting a small slice of pie - a bit expensive at $5 for such a small piece - but if it's good, then no big deal. Unfortunately... not that great. Definitely not the best key lime pie we had during our trip. Most authentic? I don't know... I don't think so. This had more of a cheesecake texture to it than the other "authentic" cheesecakes we had. read more

This place was amazing. Bill and Robin let us try the best Key Lime Pie on the planet. But we really loved the coconut cream/Key lime Infusion. I'd give this place 6 stars if I could. read more

What's there to say? Excellent key lime pie! Nice and tart, sweet, luscious, all at once. About $5 a slice, whole pies are a bit steep though. There are a few tables inside, but not many. Likely one of the best key lime pies you'll ever have. They've been on the Food Network, if that sort of thing matters to you. They also claim to be the birthplace of key lime pie, but I don't think that is known with any real certainty. read more

See all

This place is clearly an institution. I confess, I only tried the samples, I didn't buy a pie- we were in the middle of a evening adventure and I had no desire to walk around with a pie in my hand for the rest of the night- but I noticed the small courtyard outside and we wandered in. There we discovered a lush seating area, and an amazing koi pond! There were beautiful carved wooden owls on the borders of the pool, a large moss covered waterfall feature, behind which was another bamboo wall waterfall. And the fish were huge, all with different features and very people curious. The energy of the place was super friendly and charming. Definitely worth stopping by! The samples were also delicious. read more

Great pies if course , but outdoor garden seating was GREAT. Shady,cool and tranquil place to enjoy your sweets and take a break. Gorgeous koi pond and bamboo full wall fountain! Had the straberry slice on a stick. Its covered in a white coating ("white chocolate") and frozen on a stick. Will try classic non frozen next time as this version was a bit too sweet and pie is probably easier to eat. Staff at counter super friendly!! Tip them as they dont have tip jar out but desreve tips for friendly service! read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Outside garden koi pond seating - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Delicious pies and nice selection of souvenirs for great prices. The staff here is very welcoming and knowledgeable. We tried all three pies they carry (key lime, coconut cream, and coconut cream and key lime). We left with two of the coconut cream and key lime pies-that's how much we loved it. Yes, we did a key lime pie tour of Key West and we liked the pies from here the best. read more

See all

Love key lime pie and had to try it in Key West. This had great reviews so gave it a try. Wasn't impressed. Tasted like many key lime pies I've had including one that I make from scratch at home. So it's not a must have if you eat it often. I guess those that don't would like it more. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Great pie. They no longer get have gluten free key lime pie due to lack of demand, which was a bummer for us. The filling is GF, but the crust isn't. read more

Good key lime pie and the pie slice on a stick dipped in chocolate was great also. The taffy was enjoyable but the wait was quite long. The young Latin man was so nice, he was trying to help get the next person in lines order ready as the other man with the glasses rang people up. At one point the man with the glasses told him to stop doing that because it was messing things up, so the young man walked around handing samples to the people in line. A young lady walked out and had the younger guy get on the register and moved the man with the glasses to the back which was a smart choice. All in all a cute shop with a little bit of seating inside so you can get some key lime pie or ice cream and cool off on a hot day. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Why buy a slice when you can take a while pie home for 17.95;) - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

I stopped in for some souvenirs. The guy at the register, had glasses on. He was downright rude and unfriendly. Get a job doing something you like already. He should not being working with customers. I will not be back. If you want great Key Lime pie go to Kermit's down the street !!!!! The best pie and friendly people who want to be at work !!!! read more

Tried a coconut key lime pie. It was good, but I'm sure you could get just as good key lime pie elsewhere. You get key lime pie in Key West for the experience, not because it's the best pie ever. This place ruined the experience. Checkout person was kind of rude when I asked about using the $1 coupon for the pie. I should have just gone somewhere else for the key lime pie. read more

Keylime pie in Key West is A+++++++ We came here for desert and the place was small and cute. We had a taste of their famous keylime pie and it was sooo jummies! I tend to like my keylime pie a little more tarty and it totally hit the spot! They also sell packaged foods such as a variety of cookies, pie on a stick, whole frozen pies, and some others treats I can't remember. Their keylime cookies were very light and tasty. When we got back onto the boat, i was craving the pie and sadden that i didn't buy an extra one to bring back :( read more

Definitely not the best key lime pie I have had. It was too sweet and I just could't taste the key lime. It was very clearly just too buttery and was all around mediocre. Louie's backyard did a WAY better key lime pie that was not so sweet and was much smoother in consistency. Also, there are two locations almost next to each other on the same street. It is NOT the one with the awning but just the other first key lime pie factory sign as in the logo here. It was confusing since their website hasn't been updated in like... since the 2000s. ONline it made it out to seem like it was the best in Key West or something, but I think they are just good at marketing and using social media. read more

OUTSTANDING Key Lime Pie!!! My group and I did the comparison taste test with KW and The Key Lime Pie Factory is so much better!!!! It's the perfect texture, authentic, creamy, tart, and downright delicious !!! We had the pleasure of meeting the owner and his team - they were super nice and generous !!! If you want the BEST pies in Key West, look no further !!! It's truly AMAZING !!! Oh yeah, we also tried their Coconut Cream Pie and the 1/2&1/2 Key Lime/Coconut Cream Pie and all three pies are CRAZY DELICIOUS !!!! read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - THE BEST KEY LIME PIE!!! - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

This pie should come with a warning that it is EXTREMELY tart. Thankfully the whipped cream on top helped a little but with that. Taffies are really good however (and are also good at combating your tart face after taking a bite of the pie). read more

Awesome Key Lime Coconut Pie! Forget expensive desserts at the area restaurants, just stop by here for a slice of heavenly pie! Customer service was excellent as they helped us bag up an entire frozen pie to take home on an 8hr drive. We stopped by each night for a slice while on vacation and truly enjoyed our pie and visit! The key to great pie is fresh coconut and limes... read more

Good key lime pie, a bit drier/harder than the one from Kermit`s or the Key West key lime pie Company (my favorite), and again the original tangy and very sweet version with a nice and thick graham crust that was soft and delicious. The shop is small and you will be lucky to find a seat or a table, but you can eat the pie standing and it still will be an amazing experience! read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Delicious, very sweet, tangy and classical version of key lime pie with a nice soft graham crust - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Tried a couple key lime pies while in town. I'd call this 'traditional' key lime pie - it was very good. Not overly tart, but still good lime flavor. read more

Their Key Lime Pie does not taste as sour as the others I tasted around the island (which is good). Their best, however, is their Key Lime Coconut Pie which brought out the flavor of the island. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

I have been on the island for a week and still haven't had a slice of key lime pie. So today I decided to go get some. And I'm so glad I did because it was delicious. The pie tasted like they used fresh limes, which they probably do. The lime flavor overpowered any sweetner, which I loved, because I don't like extremely sweet things. I give it 5 stars. The coconut shop next door was pretty cool too. All kinds of different gifts. read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

This place is definitely worth stopping by for the hospitality alone. The woman working the counter along with her daughter were incredibly kind to us when we stopped by. We had the original key lime pie which was wonderful (not the best I've ever had, but still was great, which is why I gave it 4 stars) read more

The coconut key lime pie was outstanding! My husband really enjoyed it. It had a thick graham cracker crust and the texture was fluffy, airy and light. It had a low tart that he really enjoyed. I tasted it and it really was delicious. Definitely recommend it! read more

Omg wtf. Took one bite of the key lime pie and threw it into the trash. Cool Whip whipped topping, bug spray tasting pie. Don't eat here.

This was my First time having key lime pie and it was great ! I would recommend anyone coming to key west to visit this place.

I'll admit , I can in because I saw the show and wanted to see what Marcus was all about . Wow my jaw hit the floor when I tasted the candy . This truly is one of the best candy by sweet Peres I've ever had and the key lime pie is fantastic . Cute little place . read more

See all

Nice little spot for good Key Lime Pie. Nothing fancy but tourist shop and pie. Definitely good pie though.

This is our first vacation to Florida and of course had to try da all da key limes pies. This place is awesome. We tried da key lime meringue and regular key lime. My personal favorite was da regular. If u r down in da Keys b sure to stop this place n grab a bite. read more

Very average key lime pies in a small portion and at a high price. Probably better off walking past it.

Best key lime pie in Florida. The ladies behind the counter are so friendly and helpful. She even let me borrow her umbrella in a thunderstorm. Thank you for the delicious pie, laughter and great service. read more

Cute little place that is good at exactly what the name suggests. We tried the pie and the pie on a stick and both were good. The pie on the stick (chocolate dipped) is way over the top for sweetness and calories but was a delightful end to a too short day in key west. Nice service too, friendly and relaxed. read more

Absolutely delicious! This is the real deal, nice and tart key lime pie!! Neither the crust nor the whipped cream is over kill. It's all filling, the true star of the show! Highly recommend stopping here, in fact this is our 2nd year and we knew exactly where to go to eat the best! Additional items can be bought in the store. Staff is extremely friendly and will go out of their way to help you out!! Just a short stroll off Duval street, don't miss out!!! read more

Key Lime Pie Bakery - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

This pie won our taste test with but it was very close with another shop. This key lime pie is more dense like a cheesecake. Delicious.