Quick stop on our way to Jersey shore. Two great slices and an eggplant sub. All were perfect ! We…read morecame off hours and had the place to ourselves.

Great pizza with seating and cold bottled drinks. $4.25 for a pep slice. Restroom. Great for kidsread more

Aside from being voted The Best Pizza in Rockland County and having some of the best food and…read moreportions in my opinion, the Burgers here are the best I've had hands down. I've eaten all kinds of food, all over the World and always look forward to eating at Pieman. The recent new addition of The Smashburger which I had yesterday (in addition to a Cheeseburger) was again, big, bold, flavorful, savory and sweet with its own toppings. Perfectly seasoned and my new favorite. Now, I'll order both burgers, take one home with Sweet Potato Fries that are a home run and the only Fries I won't have with Ketchup, they don't need it. Seriously, go eat this. Like, now.

Update! Yup, Pie Man…read moreis still solid. Just came back with some coworkers to grab a pie, and I seriously underestimated a 10". Thought it would be enough, but that's definitely a personal size. My bad, lol. No worries though, we just grabbed another pie with zero regrets. When we got to the restaurant, they whipped up a fresh 16" (legit only $3 more) in just a few minutes. Love to see it. The Salty G.O.A.T. truly is the GOAT. Already planning my next visit to try the Sausage and Spicy Pickled Peppers pie since I've heard it's a fan favorite too. Their beer selection is nice, and the staff is super friendly with good energy all around. I've only ever done takeout (with a drink at the bar), but their outdoor seating looks nice, and there's plenty of room inside too. The whole place feels really welcoming. By the way, don't get it twisted. This isn't just a pizza spot. They also host events with live artists, making it more than just great food. Backed by their delicious menu and cold beers on tap, Pie Man provides the full experience. Definitely worth the visit! Looking forward to many more visits :)

The best pizza period!!! I have been going here for pizza for over 40 years and have never been…read moredisappointed!! A individual brick oven pizza with extra cheese and mushrooms please!portinoy from Barstool should do a one bite review! Blow him away!

Everything was great from the pizza to the service! I'm a…read moreretired chef from Boston and I was traveling from Delaware were I trying to enjoy my retirement! I had the best pizza that I remember in the USA! Congratulazioni!

This is my second trip and after the first trip and todays this was very necessary! This is a…read morepizzeria you can come to and the people remember you and show love. It's a small spot a few tables, tv's and coolers for drinks. It's feels like nostalgia in the best ways without feeling dingy. Ordered a Large pepperoni Pizza, beef patty and zeppoli's. The pizza has a great flavor that compliment by a little spice to the pepperoni. Each bite goes so well and the pizza bone aka crust, is great. Kind of crust you enjoy to eat vs tossing it aside. The beef patty was cooked right and the zeppolis slap! Price is right. Try this local spot out, 5/5 stars

Ordered a Stromboli and a mushroom pizza. The Stromboli was probably the worst thing I have ever…read moreeaten in my life.... I swear it was microwaved... the cheese had this rubbery oily taste and the meat tasted like plastic leather... no way this was heated up in the oven. Mushroom pizza was lackluster. Mushrooms were not fresh but canned, could smell it immediately, and taste verified it, and crust was just average. Cheese tasted cheap quality.. only redeeming aspect was that sauce was well seasoned and not sweet. I don't enjoy giving a bad review but the Stromboli wa just downright shameful.... It could not even be eaten... it was literally inedible and gave indigestion all night, and the pizza was not much better considering what the local competition offers. Prices are cheap, and people at counter were nice, but can't return for the food quality.

I am obsessed with their Chicken Marsala pizza and if you need a quick slice or lunch in the…read moreClarkstown area, this is the place to go. I've also enjoyed their rolls (spinach rolls, especially) and chicken parm.

I normally order the sausage and peppers slice. I usually order whatever pizza is available. I…read morethink the reviewer who said the onions and peppers were raw was because he ordered a regular slice and had them add it. Happened one time to me when they did not have any sausage and peppers available. I also get the pasta fagiola soup. Best pizza especially when u have them heat it up in oven. No flop.

This was the first time we experienced Village Pizza and what a GREAT experience! From our first…read morephone call to the delivery to the taste of their DELICIOUS food... it was beyond our expectations! Dina, who answered our call, was delightful to speak with... James, who delivered the food was a gentleman! The experience was definitely a reflection on the pride of ownership! WE FOUND OUR NEW PIZZA RESTAURANT! We HIGHLY recommend Village Pizza!

Friday, 6/12/2026 at 12:11 PM, we ordered delivery from Village Pizza at 64 S Broadway in Nyack…read more The pizza itself was just average for us -- nothing special, and the crust was dry. Even when you're hungry, it didn't taste delicious. Later that night, we realized the order was missing the one Diet Coke can that we paid for. We were charged $1.80, even though the same soda at a grocery store might cost around 50 cents. I don't know what happened or where the mistake occurred -- whether the restaurant forgot to include the soda or the delivery person didn't bring it -- but the fact is I paid for it and didn't receive it. Today, Saturday 6/13/2026 at 12:27 PM, we called and spoke with Tattiana. She said she would talk to her boss and ask what to do. When I asked when she would call back, she said she didn't know. It shouldn't take a manager to fix a missing $1.80 soda. Any staff member should be able to resolve such a simple issue, but instead it was delayed and ignored. At 3:36 PM, I called again, and no one answered the phone. It felt like they didn't want to pick up because they were avoiding responsibility. I called twice, and I'm not going to keep chasing a can of soda. Until I posted this review, I still didn't receive any call back. This is not about the price -- it's about honesty and giving customers what they paid for. When I called, they could have simply said, "Please come pick it up." Instead, she only said, "I'm so sorry," without offering any solution. I don't like paying for something and not receiving it. As a business, they should be responsive and not ignore customers. Mistakes happen, but they should fix them. When I post this review on Google and Yelp, other customers will read it and take a lesson from this experience. Next time I order from any restaurant, I will check all items upon delivery instead of trusting the delivery person. I will not order from this place again.

Been trying different things on the menu, nothing disappoints. Pizza, soups, appetizers and…read moresandwiches are all good. Compared to others pizza in the area, by far much better. Included pics showing my favorite Sicilian type slices. Just look at the crust, a Brooklyn pizza in rockland!

The pizza is delicious, always consistent and they care about customer satisfaction. You will not…read morebe disappointed!

Hands down, THE BEST PIZZA and hero sandwiches in New City! Service is excellent with consistent…read morefriendliness and hospitality, both on the phone and in person, no matter lunch or dinner. The ambience is enhanced with a clean vibe, both restaurant and staff. A real treat to look forward to!

Cooking of food not Dealing with situation…read moreConsideration when called about problem Not resolved at