The stench of a chemical toilet close to the bar is unbearable. Guys, you have to change something here. Move the toilet or clean it.

I'm posting my original review from last summer, which was three stars. I'm removing a star because claiming to 'MOVE' in a town with exactly ONE restaurant (and a pizza place), a wine shop, a supermarket and a fire house as a way of removing reviews is sleazy and the antithesis of the town Jean Georges has decided to set up shop in. "Stand by: full disclosures abound. Disclosure #1: I've been coming to Fair Harbor for many years, and have eaten at Le Dock on occasion. mostly I would wander in on hot afternoons straight off the beach for a margarita, or sometimes to pick up a to-go drink to take out for the sunsets. It was a very casual place, almost tiki lounge-like, with laid back staff and clientele. I think those days are if not over, at the very least they will be at odds with the gentrification the new Le Dock brings to my sleepy little hamlet. Sunday night was jam-packed with a crowd alternately over groomed and sporting sportcoats and high-hair who water taxied or boated in from other towns or the mainland, and the flip-flop and tee shirt-wearing traditionalists. It's an uneasy sight to behold in the re-vamped space, but aside from a few people who just want to complain for the sake of complaining during a soft opening (including here on Yelp: btw, joel s, he's 'Jean GEorges), people seem willing to give Le Dock 2.0 the benefit of the doubt. Disclosure 2: I didn't eat. I'd made a reservation Saturday night, but when several houseguests ended up staying over I knew that not only would this hot spot not be able to expand our reservation (it was a challenge even in the old days), but that even if seating were possible, several people would have been priced out. I watched the dishes coming out, listened to people's experiences, asked customers who dined, and get the feeling that when they're open, and if you can afford it, the food is pretty good (though I hear wildly conflicting reviews of the buttermilk chicken; some say it's brilliant, some say the sauce that accomapnies it is too hot). The pirces are STEEP, for the most part. Like, SoHo steep. (But there are silver linings; keep reading)... They gain a star with me for being incredibly accommodating with the locals in a big way; Douglas, one of the managers, worked at the original Le Dock, is a longtime resident of FH, and opened up the wine store for this ning-nong who forgot what a ghost town FH can be in mid season, even this late in mid season. They should, however, perhaps be a little more accommodating when someone calls twenty minutes before the kitchen closes to say they're running over (a literal three-minute sprint); that's a really great time to offer said caller to put our order in (we were willing to order right there) as opposed to saying that the kitchen will be closed by the time we get there. Not a big deal, and I'm sure this will change as LD2.0 finds its sea legs, but this is very much the spirit of the Fair Harbor I've grown so fond of these many years. The new bathrooms are a HUGE improvement. They also get props for making sure to have items on offer "simply prepared" (seafood) that are more in the traditional LeD price range; a good thing because not only do people who get their tans on a beach and not a salon like fresh simple fish (especially on the island), they are going to be the mainstays there, I suspect. Likewise, I applaud the fact that while actually offering $18 designer martinis and (I hope I'm remembering this right) $15 twee margaritas, Le Dock 2.0 also makes regular drinks for the masses at the old price points. If only it didnt have that 'poor-door' feel. Maybe the clientele will loosen up and embrace the town as much as they're embracing the name. Because I actually think (or at least hope) that this place won't over-gentrify a sweet little corner of the world. (For those who wonder, the pizza place is still up and running). All in all, thoughtful staff hard at work on a soft opening, and a potential looming culture clash that I think may iron itself out should the 1% not SoHo the crap out of the place. And provided the locals stay loose, and the awesome staff loosen up just a little more as they get the lay of the land. I'll hopefully be back again this summer, and look forward to seeing LD2.0 in full swing. I'll eat there next time, and can't wait. And not for nothing, but I miss the old "CREW" staff shirts. But that's me. See you soon!" read more

Le Dock - Saying you 'Moved' to wipe out reviews of your 'old' address isn't what Yelp is about. - Seafood Near Me - Fire Island, New York

Food is excellent and pretty much perfect for this end of Fire Island. Don't go expecting the same service you might get in the city. The service is fine. Go for the food, the conversation and the view. I've had the pasta in clam sauce...it was perfect. The mussels are excellent. The salads fresh. The drinks generous. The menu is small and offers something for everyone. The food is well prepared and has never disappointed us. The prices are average for the Island. Reserve a table outside and before sunset, enjoy your dinner as it sets. It's worth the trip. read more

We visited for dinner last night when we were supposed to be evacuating due to Storm Hermine. Restaurant was pleasantly full with ample seating for large groups - both indoor and outdoor. We had heard the service wasn't amazing; however, we were pleased with our wait staff. They were attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. Menu does not disappoint however there are limited vegetarian options. We tried the following: Starters Sweet Pea Guacamole - delicious and lightly flavored but not spicy Calamari - the sauce was nice, however the calamari was slightly gummy Mains Lobster and corn - delicious and lightly flavored Truffle and cheese pizza - very thin crust, nicely seasoned Desserts Molten chocolate cake - standard but delicious Sundae - creatively prepared with Carmel corn on top Almond cake - a standout! Delicious and lightly flavored. The side of sorbet didn't go super well with it, the cake could be served alone read more

Le Dock - Outside Le Dock. - Seafood Near Me - Fire Island, New York

I have been eating here each summer for the past three years. I can honestly say the food is sub par and much more expensive than Ocean Beach and Kismet. I am not blaming the chef or the service people who are terrific. Its the actual food being served... old calamari, small tasteless mussels being two examples. Please buy better food and produce for the kitchen. read more

I sure hope the new owners do something with that horrendous raw sewage smell. We were gonna eat there until I almost threw up from the smell. GROSS read more

I've spent every weekend this summer on Fire island and this was by FAR the BEST meal i had. I enjoyed their watermelon arugula salad which was delicious and refreshing. For a main course I enjoyed the crab cake sandwich which was light and flavorful and was served the best fries -perfectly well done as ordered. The drink menu was filled was good choices. I tried the velvet sunset made with Tito's, basil simple syrup and strawberries which was a perfect choice for a hot summer day. Great location, fantastic service and excellent food and drinks. Can't ask for much more than that! read more

Do not order the penne alla vodka, total waste of calories & money. No flavor & way overcooked pasta. Seriously the worst I have ever had. A box of Ronzoni & jar of Ragu would have been better. read more

This is thee perfect restaurant for Fair Harbor. Hater's gonna hate (see mean-hearted comments elsewhere) and those who know know. This is the game and the party. read more

Dinner overlooking the bay. Great choices for all palates. All tables are placed with social distancing. Waitstaff wearing masks and gloves. The menu is scanned on your phone. I enjoyed the most delicious lobster taco fiesta. 3 tacos with chunks of fresh lobster. Sorry no pics. Highly recommended this place. Open fir lunch dinner and take out. read more

Spent a breathtaking weekend in Fair Harbor and enjoyed takeout and outdoor dining meals @ Le Dock. The monk fish special and lobster tacos were off the chain delicious! The grilled octopus appetizer was cooked to perfection. Did I mention this was take-out! Our meal was so delicious we returned for outdoor dining which is spacious, safe and lovely especially as sunset nears. Our server was attentive, sweet and fun. With such high expectations set, it was hard to think they could deliver again but did. The tuna tartar and salmon entree were fresh and delicious. The specials are high quality and fresh. The wine and cocktail list is impressive too. Michael, the owner and chef, came to our table and shared his story of buying the restaurant. Despite restaurant limitations amid a crisis, the food and experience @ Le Dock has kept the bar high. read more

Le Dock - Sunset steps from Le Dock, enjoy! - Seafood Near Me - Fire Island, New York

We had the most delicious and relaxing meal here. What a treat! With all out door seating, these guys have seamlessly elevated dining in the age of Covid. The food....fabulous menu and each dish better than the previous. Greek salad was fantastic. Same for the salmon. Also tasted the steak AND the tuna. It was all perfectly seasoned. (And we're a bit picky!) Just an overall great dining experience. Although it was busy, the service was incredibly attentive. And the live music that was set up on the dock was a great background. So too the setting sun. Making reservations for next week before we leave. If you're in the mood for a lovely and delicious dinner, you will not be disappointed. read more

The guys that own it are an integral part of everything going on and the community. Food is good - a little limited in choices, but good. We are disappointed when we cannot get a roll or bread and definitely pricey, but a fun, tasty evening out! read more

We had our wedding rehearsal dinner (about 35 people) at Le Dock last month, and it was fabulous. Michael and Lance and their team were attentive, and the food was excellent. Our guests were very pleased with the chicken and salmon entrees, the multiple dessert choices and the ambience. We will happily be back next summer! read more

The food is terrible. I so want this place to be good. The view is great and it's a good vibe but again the food and prices are horrible.

Every thing about this restaurant is on point. The frozé? Immaculate, and a must try before the summer ends. The Food? Spectacular, and more often than not, a culinary adventure that satisfies. The sunset view? A picturesque sight to behold. The pizza side of the restaurant is also fabulous, exactly the level of pizza quality that I, as a native New Yorker, expect and demand. If you find yourself in Fair Harbor and hungry, it's a no brainer, you gotta do to Le Dock. read more

We adore this place !!! Love the Frosé , the bartenders are incredibly friendly , fast , and professional. Tell Chef Mike that his food is so outstanding and we can't wait for next summer. Keep up the good work guys !!! read more

I have been dining at Fire Island for years and LeDock has exceeded expectations! I went for dinner on Friday night with a large group. The ambiance was beautiful, the service was on point, and the food was delicious. We all shared several apps and main course so we were able to taste most of the menu. Everyone was impressed. Michael, the owner, was so hands on and accommodating! We had a fabulous experience at LeDock! read more

Went here last night with my family because we had heard it did a 180 since the new owner took over. The marinated skirt steak was delicious. NY strip melted in your mouth. The calamari was beyond delicious. Not tough or chewy at all. The stuffed artichoke was awesome as was my husband's penne ala vodka. My mother has celiac and the owner called us directly after my dad contacted them to see if they could accommodate. He came by several times during our meal to make sure everything was ok. Service in general was phenomenal. Definitely a new option in the area for delicious food. read more

Nice outside seating. Comfortable outside or inside. Really good food. Best fried calamari, light and not greasy. Our service was great. Very attentive. read more

Go here! Best restaurant on Fire Island by far and I like to think I'm a tough critic. When I say really good drinks I also mean it. Started off with an extra dirty martini and it was 100% up to par and amazing with tasty olive juice (those who order dirty martinis know that not every restaurant is an 'order a martini' place and trust me - this one 100% is). The cucumber martini I got to follow was complex and delicious- definitely one of the best I've had. My partner wanted something more sweat and he had what I believe was called the GT (?) something with raspberries, basil and a sugar rim and it was so tasty as well. For food we started off with the crab cakes which were perfect, super high quality and amazing and came with an equally tasty side cabbage salad. As my main I ordered the panko crusted salmon which was so tasty and came with a really, really good red salsa-like sauce. My partner got the red snapper special which was equally tasty and unique, the snapper was chargrilled and came atop various veggies. We made reservations in advance which I'd recommend to be safe. One note - if you want views of the sunset you should specify that in your reservation notes! read more

See all

I've been here once a summer for the last 8 years and have always enjoy the space and the atmosphere of the neighborhood - I'm not a foodie so the chef doesn't ever impress me, however, the $50 truffle pizza is amazing. It's not on the menu so you have to ask for it. Tonight's service was uniquely spectacular: our server, who was too busy to take care of us at first, busted out at the end of our meal and orchestrated a 6 minute getaway plan to help us make the water taxi back home (they only come once an hour). The pizza was boxed, leftovers packaged and a check split two ways - no joke, in 6 minutes. It was outstanding. Thanks, Cameron! People say it's over priced and the service is terrible but it's fire island! If you can afford to be on FI in the first place AND the $10+/pp water taxi there and back to wherever on the island you're coming from... just relax and enjoy. read more

And on the third year, Le Dock rose again. The two fellows who have taken over management, both in the front and the back of the house, have gone a long way to return Le Dock to its former glory. Amazingly pleasant and accommodating service, wide menu selections and plentiful food -- the precise and diametric opposite of the nightmare that was Jean Georges, the failed McRestaurant corporate-robot. To remind of those dark times: https://www.yelp.com/biz/le-dock-fire-island?hrid=B1fuil_SfU-DUyZKMdSHqA&utm_campaign=www_review_share_popup&utm_medium=copy_link&utm_source=(direct) Well, on Fire Island at least, the nightmare is over. Le Dock is back, and the tricycle twins are long gone. read more

I went to dinner at Le Dock with a large group of friends last night. Michael and his staff were amazing! They did a great job of taking care of us all evening. The food and drinks were delicious! Everything came out quickly and the correct temperature. We even enjoyed a beautiful sunset. I will definitely be back! read more

Important note. Le Dock is under new ownership. Ate there yesterday for dinner, and sampled several items from each meal. Seafood, meats, ap's, etc. Excellent to say the least. In attendance was a person with extreme Gluten issues. Not only was the menu perfect for her, but the chef was more then willing to accommodate changes and needs, checking several times, and giving suggestions for tweeks to the meal to help her. I have had meals there in the past, and this was a far superior experience. I would highly recommend the NEW Le Dock, and feel free to order most anything confidently. read more

We tried this place again recently. We all get they have to make money during the season, but where is the lube! The place still smells like raw sewage. Its worth the effort to make sure your prepared and have hamburgers and hot dogs while in Fair harbor lAnd buy 3 big bottles of Grey Goose which would be essentially be 3 rounds of drinks for 2 couples! Food is fire island good. Try it once. Make a reservation outside at for the sunset. Beautiful spot! read more

Fantastic food, friendly staff. Amazing views of the bay, I love eating here while watching the sunset over the bay while I enjoy a fire island froze! read more

Don't go here. The portions are small and the food is WAY overpriced. The Bloody Mary was so small and in a thin cup. There are better restaurants on Fire Island (Surfs Up). Fair Harbor has a pioneer market, but other than that, there aren't many food options. Walk to Kismet and have a nice ocean sunset dinner at Surf Up and maybe take the ferry back. That's a real dinner. read more

Food is good but very expensive. Avoid the liquor store "special seating" as the sewer problem that has plagued the liquor store for years persists... read more

We had an incredible meal at Le Dock this past weekend. Everything was fresh and delicious, especially the mussels in marinara sauce (pair it with Great South Bay Blond Ambition beer)! The service was wonderful. Highly recommend. read more

Been eating at Le Dock for as long as I can remember.This season have eaten there 5 times so far.Service and food are great and we have never been dissatisfied with the unique salads,mains and great deserts.Drinks can be a little pricey but you only live once.Will continue to make this our go-to Restaurant on Fir read more

I've eaten in Le Dock several times this season, and I must say, not only is the food excellent, the service is as well. Daniel is very professional in managing the staff and has a welcoming personality. Chef Liam Beardslee is putting out delicious food at the perfect pace even when the restaurant is filled to capacity. Of course you have to try one of the specialty drink that Walter makes at the bar. read more

Ok. I have been here before, and it was meh. I don't know what happened, but this place is top.notch. What a change! Inventive, but approachable menu, human portions, and good wine menu. I didn't even recognize this place. Highly recommend the fried chicken. My friend had the heirloom tomatoes, and it was fresh & great. The beet appetizer was scrumptious, and those strawberries, are the best I have ever tasted. Wait staff is good. Manager is attentive. A great night out. read more

Have eaten 4 times over the summer and though the food is very good it is inconsistent. At times the main is served with the sauce.and accompaniments as described on the menu and other times they are entirely different. In addition the portions are rather small, which I feel do not justify the prices charged. The interior is beautifully designed but the acoustics are deafening. One has to shout across the table to be heard by fellow diners. Because of this most people opt to sit outside. That causes another problem. The reservation system is so screwed up that it is not uncommon to wait 30-90 minutes for your CONFIRMED reservation. I won't even comment on some of the wait staff as they are so clueless. What a shame world class chef Jean-George saddled with this less than amateur staff. read more

Food and svc just ok. Felt understaffed and we're out of key dishes. Would definitely like to see Fair Harbor have a dependable f&b.

I used to come here all the time (under previous owners) but the past two summers have been SUCH a disappointment. I ate there with my family last night and not only were the portions laughably small (even by chic NY standards), the food was average at best. Burger was over cooked. The tuna tartare used to be my favorite but it was mushy and bland. As if they had cut off the thick part of the tuna steak and used the flesh they scraped off the sinews. The cocktails were good but it was over priced and worse than underwhelming. AVOID IF YOU POSSIBLY CAN. NOT WORTH IT. read more

We were a table of 4 who stopped in for lunch on 7/7. Prices are high but that is no surprise for the height of tourist season on Fire Island. However, when you throw in average food, slow service, plus high prices - the result is plainly unsatisfactory. My friend ordered a 'shaved fish salad' appetizer and the wrong dish was delivered. When the waitress brought out the correct dish - we actually did a double take! A few shaved pieces of white fish in oil at the bottom of a saucer - that was it. Ridiculous for the price and the completely thoughtless presentation. We did not complain. We tipped appropriately - the staff are young people working summer jobs and need their money...but management/owners better get on the ball fast. Avoid this place- there are other, better places you enjoy on the island. read more

This is the best restaurant on Fire Island. Hands down. Make the trip if you are on the island. It's worth it. Great service. Creative dishes coupled with some very safe fare. Incredible sunset views. I'd be hard pressed to ask for more here on the island. read more

Fantastic Jerk Snapper. Just the right amount of spice. This place is the OG. Service setting drinks food. Has it all. Don't miss. Oh yea. And the Rocket Fuel is orbital ! read more

Run, don't walk, back home to your backyard grill...I've been here 6 times in the last two weeks and for my last reservation, the hostess (with the least-est) pointed my group to the table under the AC or the broken plastic table in the corner. The food is average tbh and it's all about the view. Please give some modicum of respect to loyal customers before you lose them. read more