I dine here frequently. The staff can tell you exactly how the foods are prepared and they are friendly. The bus staff will make sure your table is cleared and your water glass is full. This is the bare minimum we should want..but there's more. This restaurant offers high quality food. I think they use fine ingredients and prepare each dish with precision. The flavors intentionally meld perfectly. Loved my steak, scallops and salad. My sister loved her tacos. Thank you for always being consistently great! read more

This place is great. The wait staff couldn't be better. The food is always consistent and delicious. And the changing selection of oysters is by far the best in the area. I am very picky when it comes to restaurants and I love this place. read more

Boring food and drinks. Went for Sunday brunch, and had Eggs Benedict. Nothing exciting at all about the food. An Egg McMuffin would have been more interesting. A party was going on downstairs, so our waiter didn't do much for us. Do not order a Bloody Mary; this was possibly the all-time worst Bloody Mary I've ever had. It tasted like watered down tomato juice, with a dash of pepper. BORING!! The waiter removed it from the bill, at least, although he just stared at me when I told him how bad it was. Maybe they're used to hearing that a lot, and are used to removing it from the bill? Unless you want boring food, and watered down drinks, find somewhere else to go for brunch. read more

What a horrible experience. We remember when this was a top flight restaurant. We ate there last night (Saturday night) and had the bad fortune to pay $75 for a meal that included a bowl of bland macaroni (can't even call it pasta) that was advertised as spicy Udon Noodles. Service was beyond bad - waitress rude, combative, brought the wrong beer, left our dessert in the kitchen, and then tried to charge us full freight for the alleged Udon Noodle dish. Waitress MIA most of dinner. I guess she had better things to do than her job. Yikes. We will not be coming back. read more

After all these years in town, this place still has it together! My date and I had the most amazing evening there. From beginning to end, everything that was put down on our table, was perfection. I would recommend this place to anyone. read more

Found this great place on Google when looking for places to eat near us. My husband and the kids love trying new places and this place did not dissapoint!! I tried a delicious pizza with goat cheese and arugula, so yummy! My son had a great margarita pizza and my daughter loved her ravioli. Everything from start to finish was perfect. Can't wait to come back!! read more

I've always loved this place but I had an incredibly disappointing experience today and was really shocked by the terrible customer service. A waiter spilled an entire tray of drinks all over me, literally soaking my clothing and my purse and did not even offer to buy us a round of drinks (there were only two of us), comp part of me meal, or anything. I couldn't have been nicer and more understanding when it happened but I couldn't believe when the check arrived and he had done nothing at all. I've never heard of such a thing. After asking him about the check, he removed ONE drink (not mine, but my friend's because it was cheaper) and the manager literally tossed the check back on our table without so much as a word. My friend and I were honestly shocked by the way the whole thing was handled as typically if that happens at a restaurant the waiter or certainly the manager does something to 'make good'. Unfortunately this really makes me not want to return which is a shame because their food is wonderful. It's really too bad. read more

It's a pleasant place where you can get a good burger or steak sandwich and enjoy some cocktails. Other items on the menu are hit or miss. I'm not a big fan of the menu; they try to offer some creative dishes but don't provide good descriptions. So on a few occasions, I was disappointed with what what I go vs what I thought I was getting. They're famous for their creatively decorated cakes -- it's a good place to special order a cake for an occasion. We once had a party for 20 teenagers in the upstairs room and it was handled very well. Overall, a good place for socializing but not for fine cuisine. read more

On my visit to Lexington Square Café I was with a group of about 8 people celebrating my cousins 30th Birthday. Perfect- I get to see and taste a ton of dishes! We started with five appetizers to share for the table. Chili Salted Calamari was presented in a bamboo basket with a zesty lemon aioli for dipping. Flatbread Margarita Pizza on a wooden bread board, and steamed shrimp dumplings with an orange soy sauce also served in a bamboo basket. The highlight of the appetizer selections would have to be "The Boston Lettuce Wedge." LSC has combined two of my favorite things (the classic wedge salad & Boston Bibb lettuce) to make the most divine knife & fork salad. Topped with crispy bacon, creamy Maytag blue cheese, and cherry tomatoes the rest of the table devoured it leaving me with only one bite. Although not on the menu LSC serves oysters on special daily. Our server informed us that today's market selection was Blue Points from Long Island. Blue Points are great because they are a meatier oyster with a good amount of liquor so they are jam packed with flavor. I have to give kudos to the shucker because these oysters came out ice cold with not an ounce of grittiness. For bread service long homemade bread sticks were nicely seasoned, piping hot, and served in a cute metal bucket with whipped butter in silver ramekins. I do honestly enjoy the fun gimmicky presentation trending right now in the food industry. I remember back in the day when presentation consisted of the Chef adding a spring of parsley to give the dish some color or a sprinkle of paprika along the rim of the plate as an artistic touch. Now I see things such as sauces in mini mason jars, bread baskets lined with waxy newspaper from Europe, and noodles propped up with chopsticks on the plate. Food presentation is 50% where it's at these days the other 50% goes to the importance of ingredient sourcing. The eclectic menu made it tough to choose my entree (in a good way). There are six hefty sandwiches to choose from including a Burger for those of you who must have a burger. But there is so much more to choose from so please don't order a burger. Interestingly there are two noodle dishes with an Asian flare - Shrimp Pad Thai or Teriyaki Soba Noodles with Skirt Steak. And for more starch options dished up Italian style there is Linguini and white clam sauce or Orchiette pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage. "From the sea" entrees include traditional New England favorites such as a Maine Lobster Roll, Pan Seared Chatham Cod, and Crab Stuffed Filet of Sole. "From the Land" lovers can choose from Braised Bone in Short Rib, Duck Two Ways, or New Zealand Rack of Lamb. I ordered the Steak Frites served with a mini Caesar salad and Pomme Frites. This was just my style because I managed to get a little bit of everything all on the same plate. The most stunning entrée at our table was the Braised Bone in Short Rib. The portion was ginormous, tender meat falling off the bone, red wine jus drizzled on the bottom of the plate, garnished with delicate micro greens. In order to spend as much time as possible chatting with the big group of people I was dining with I didn't look at the wine list and instead asked the waitress for my easy go to wine an Italian Pinot Grigio. Usually I would check out the wine list at home on the web but unfortunately LSC does not list it on their site so I can't comment on the wine program. For dessert we ordered an assortment of selections that piled sweet upon sweet including a warm chocolate lava cake oozing with a creamy chocolate center, torched crème Brule, and a Tollhouse Chocolate Chip cookie pie. A unique concept LSC has going for them is their specialty cakes which are displayed prominently when you first walk in the door. Triple tier fondant laced cakes sit upon an ornate marble counter worthy of any elaborate wedding or celebration. This is a particularly smart move considering the restaurant is perfect for hosting a large social gathering so I assume they do sell allot of these cakes. From the evidently trained service staff to the consistently good dishes in front of all 8 people at our table I was not surprised to find out LSC is one of six restaurants run by Pearl hospitality group. I can only guess that once you find the key to make the clock tick it's easy to make more clocks. Great job LSC. read more

I go to the café often every time I go there I get great service and the food is very good as usual, the decor is very nice as well a must check out !. read more

Always excellent food. Courteous and attentive staff. Lexington Square is an often stop when we're shopping or visiting in Northern Westchester. If you go, you will not be sorry.... read more

I have lunch at this place a few times and it has always been nice, although pricey. Just wen there for dinner. Never again. Service was terrible. No-one checking to fill up the water glasses. No written kids menu and when the waiter said he'd check on the prices of the kids meals, he never did. I ordered the butternut squash ravioli, I dish I have enjoyed at other local restaurnts. This was was truly disgusting. The meal was incredibly sweet. It was like have pancakes with syrup. The ravioli filling was like canned pumpkin pie filling - only drier - and the sauce was just syrup. 6 ravioli for $22. Total rip-off. Couldn't wait to get out of there and I won't be back. read more

The summer menu features Ribs, They tasted like leather covered in sauce. Don't forget the lukewarm reheated corn on the cob. It use to be my goto place but i think it needs a change. read more

Went for an early dinner with the family. Service was friendly and prompt. Nice wine by the glass selection. I found the menu a little boring. Had the special soup. Cream of chicken and it was very good. A family menu had the onion soup- not so great. The entrees were just ok. I will come back and try this place again. read more

Really good food and attentive service. Great for a celebration of any kind. They are very good at accommodating large groups. Highly recommend read more

Celebrated my daughters bridal shower at Lexington Square Café yesterday in Mount Kisco, Everything was just incredible. Food was amazing, Set up was great and staff was terrific. I need to specify that Zack and Mary were unbelivable servers and owner is very lucky to have them working there . I cant wait to go back and I am hoping in the future we will have another gathering there. read more

We were seated in the main dinning room for brunch and immediately I felt like I wanted to leave. The booths were cloth and had more stains then I could count. Each table had a white tablecloth with white parchment paper over the top. Out of curiosity I lifted the paper and saw many days worth of crumbs, which leads me to believe that they seldom wash the tablecloths and just place new paper after each customer. Everything I looked at was dirty, from the walls to the floor, this place needed a good scrub. The silverware desperately needs to be replaced it looks as if its over 50 years old. Against my better judgement I went ahead and ordered. When my fish tacos arrived they were bland with absolutely no seasoning. We will not be returning, we left feeling like we needed a shower. read more

I have been here a number of times and am completely bewildered by the negative reviews below unless someone has an ax to grind. The food is bright, fresh and lively with good service even when packed for Sunday brunch. read more

I hosted a bridal shower in the beautiful upstairs room. We enjoyed absolutely everything about it and the guests were all raving about it afterwards! The food was delicious and the service was exceptional. The wait staff even helped to carry gifts outside for us! It just shows the above and beyond service that they provide. Would definitely recommend for parties as well as regular dining. read more

We just celebrated our daughter's sweet 16 at Lex, overall we are very pleased with our experience. Eddie and Lisa were extremely helpful from the moment we visited the restaurant and made the reservation with them. They made the entire planning process so easy and painless. On the night of the birthday dinner they sat my daughter and her 12+ friends upstairs by the alcove while we dined downstairs. The table was beautifully set up for 14 teens with cute menu displays. I love that they also make celebration cakes in house and the cake I ordered for my daughter came out beautifully and was absolutely delicious! The waiter (forgot his name, sorry!) for the party was equally wonderful. He kept us updated on what goes on upstairs and he waited for us to finish dinner downstairs before bringing the cake out. The birthday girl was extremely happy how wonderful her birthday dinner had turned out. We couldn't be happier with the hospitality and services. We will definitely be back for more special occasions:-) PS they also have special fixed menu for teen parties, extremely reasonable with great options!! read more

yuck! we went to this restaurant for a special family occasion, and it was awful. i guess the linen tablecloths surprised us. For the quality of the food we would have expected greasy Formica table tops and paper plates. it was my first time and when we sat down my nephew said- he didn't like it- now i understand why. Plus, it is totally inaccessible with three sets of stairs. read more

Weekday lunch- very slow service, cold fries, tough steak, very boring (unseasoned) salmon salad, too loud.

Very attractive decor and always good service in this modern restaurant-- I've been here more than a dozen times and always enjoyed myself. Never a bad experience read more

We went to the restaurant with some friends and their child. The child was on a special diet, and the staff was very solicitous concerning his needs. Our own meals were very good. I had sole stuffed with crab meat, and my wife had fish also, branzini. Our friends had fish and duck, respectively. We also had a bottle of white wine, which was good, but not exceptional. We did not have dessert, but the desserts and fancy cakes looked very nice. read more

If I could give this restaurant 0 stars I would. Lexington Square Cafe was one of my most favorite restaurants up until it recently must have changed management which has taken a nosedive in food quality and service. First I want to start off by saying that We visited the restaurant for my fathers birthday and when we arrived I told the hostess that when we order dessert could she please put a candle in it for him (this info comes in handy later). We sat down and ordered the flatbread and mussels as an appetizer. The flatbread came out first and was covered in an Alfredo type cream sauce and was barely edible. Then came out the mussels. When my mom and I each grabbed a mussel we saw that they still had their beards on them which was quite disgusting because that means they were not cleaned properly. We told the waitress who offered to have the chef remake which we appreciated. 20 minutes go by so we assumed the mussels would just come out with our entries (which were only salads by the way!!), nope the mussels came out alone. The waitress said our entrees would be out shortly. To my shock when my mom and I reached for a mussel there were still beards on them. The waitress came over and explained that this is how the chef prepares them!!! We were so disgusted and asked for the mussels to be removed. Another 20 minutes go by until finally our Salads come out. Then once we were done with lunch the waitress brought over a dessert (that we didnt order) with a candle in it and sang happy birthday which we thought was very nice and somewhat redeemed the situation......until we saw a charge for it on the bill?!?!?! WTF who brings over a birthday dessert that we didnt order and then charges us after all the issues we already had. A manager never came over to see what the problem was which I think is a huge red flag a I warn anyone from trying this place. To top it all off i booked my reservation through opentable and when i went to check my points balance today the reservation is not there anymore and i didn't get my points. looks like they deleted my reservation, perhaps so i couldn't post a review....such amateurs......this place will be outta business in no time..... read more

Not good. They try to be creative but they should try having good food instead. Not worth the effort.

Very disappointing Mother's Day brunch. French toast was more like plain toast with dried out crust, berry compote was "globby," with lots of thickener. Breakfast burrito could have been good if hot. After sending back French toast, the burger was good but the fries were oil sodden, cold & limp. Too bad, I had really been looking forward to it. We won't be back. Would like to NOT even give 1 star but it seems I can't post without doing so. read more

This was a perfectly adequate experience. Props for honoring the reservation. We got there at 7:30pm for our reservation and they sat us right away even though the place was very busy. Thank you for that. The service from the wait staff was friendly and prompt. The food was fine. Tasted good but generally unremarkable. If dinner all in was $80 I would say, yes I'll go back. But this was more like $140 after gratuity, and too me, it better be exceptional as there are too many other restaurants that I'd prefer to go to for much less. My wife and I each had one drink (mine a beer), shared an appetizer (large portion), two entrees (mine a pasta), shared dessert with two espressos (served luke warm). Everything was fine, but I want to walk away from an expensive restaurant saying, wow. This was ok. read more

Been coming here for about 2 years now....very relaxing and enjoyable...It can be both a formal location and causal which is nice...good bar, strong beer selection (important!), always a long list of good specials. Very Surprised to see mixed reviews! read more

Went there for the first time for brunch today. Firstly, we stood for about 5 minutes before a hostess arrived and sat us. The eggs were cold. The bacon was burnt. The salad was tasteless. The waiter did not tell us what the specials were - we only noticed them on the blackboard behind us after we ordered. Nice atmosphere - beautiful building that looks like it used to be a house. It would be perfect if the food was edible, which it isn't. read more

We have been going here for years (and even had a party here 5years ago). But our experience last week was not good. The waiter was very inexperienced, never told us the specials and kept kicking my chair when he passed by. He never once said excuse me. The linguini with clam sauce had a portion of linguini not even big enough for my son, and one of the clams had a big blob of black sand. My fish was good but too much sauce. Both glasses of white wine we ordered were on the sour side, I didn't even finish it. I don't think we will be back which is too bad, we used to really like this restaurant. read more

This restaurant has gone downhill..my fried calamari was under cooked & my tuna taco had no flavor. The chef has been there for a long time & probably doesn't taste his food...I would not go back read more

OK but not really good. Used to be our favorite in mt kisco but no more. Out of 3 dishes none had much flavor. Couldn't have identified any ingredients without looking. One dish was way too salty .. Burned my throat. The others were just so bland that we left feeling very unsatisfied. A sad decline indeed. (Service was good.) read more

I had a good dinner here tonight with friends tonight. We loved the chicken lettuce wraps starter. A friend got the steak sandwich and loved it. I enjoyed my signature salad (I think that's what it was called). We really enjoyed the cheesecake for dessert! Yummy! read more

We have dined here many times. Parking can be difficult at dinner time but, in a pinch, you can park across the street (be careful crossing). The steps to the restaurant are steep and in poor repair. When one enters one is greeted with attractive pastries. Service is usually good and the wait staff is friendly. If you order correctly, the food is uniformly good to very good. Prices are a tad high. Over all, a good restaurant. read more

Lot of my family's good times end up here. Nouvelle menu with good portions. Nice atmosphere, friendly staff. Not too pricy.

Have eaten here a few times and chose for my bday this year. There were 7 of us and we went to an early dinner. Although upstairs was closed, we sat indoors because of the heat at a beautiful table surrounded by windows and private. The good was delicious. My steak in my steak frites was cooked to perfection. The ahi taco was delightful, although as an aside I personally would have preferred the wasabi mayo on the side. Calamari was fresh and the steak wrap was a hit. Burgers were cooked perfectly as well. The Chardonnay was a great California pick and espresso with dessert finished off the meal the way it began-delightful! The chocolate chip dessert was unique and tasty. Our waitress was exceptionally helpful and I liked having 2 large glass bottles of water on table-helps waitstaff and helps patrons. I have never been disappointed here and highly recommend. Btw it was the first time I used open table and I loved it! Reasonable as well! Happy birthday to me! read more

It's simple, they want to kill you! The last time we were in was awhile ago and I vowed never to go back. They wanted to kill you! It was soft shell crab season and the crabs came out very green. They were uncooked! Let me say that again, THEY were UNCOOKED! I sent them back and the waitress brought them back out and told me that they were cook perfectly. HUH? you are going to argue with a customer when his wife, a professional chef is sitting next to him? The waitress proceeds to tell us how she is from Baltimore and this is how they are served. NO, I'm sorry honey, these bastards are raw! They took them back, and I ate a salad. Our friends could NOT believe what went down on that night at the totally crappy LEX Square. I have Never been insulted, or called a fool by any staff in any restaurant, and we dine all over NYC and the world! If you eat here, you could wind up in the ER!! Maybe the morgue? read more

This review is for bakery services. I ordered a celebration cake for my in laws 40th anniversary party at Rye Grill and cake was delivered there. When I ordered I specifically asked for polka dots on cake just like the celebration cakes have. I had a conversation at time with manager about how it was the perfect cake because she LOVES polka dots. I paid and didn't receive a written description of cake but did call to confirm cake two days prior to delivery. When cake came it was covered in stars. Not at any time did we have a discussion of stars nor did I ask for stars. I was super disappointed to not receive exactly what I paid for especially since it was ordered because of my mother in laws love of polka dots! When I called to speak to someone today, they were not very helpful. They claimed that it didnt state polka dots on order and that pastry chef must've taken liberty to do stars. I didn't realize I should have watched over manager's shoulder when placing order to make sure she wrote down what I was exactly ordering, I would assume that would be a given! They offered me free fondant next time I ordered a cake lol. There won't be a next time AND that cost about $5-10. Unfortunately, they lost a customer today and wouldn't have if they offered a nicer/better resolution! read more

My wife and I have eaten here once a week for the past two years. The food over that time had actually improved but about six months ago the downhill slide started. We used to love the fact that we could run in and get a decent piece of fish or chicken or a solid burger. No more!!!! After avoiding the place for over a month we decided to grab a couple of burgers tonight. They, in our opinion, were absolutely vile. The quality of the meat was poor and they tasted fried and greasy instead of grilled. My wife's side salad was watery and we both were totally unhappy and grossed out. Our last visit over the summer was pretty lousy also. The rotisserie chicken was poorly seasoned and my wife's salmon over salad was an inferior piece of fish cut up to hide its small size. They also cutback the number of sides with each entree from two to one to give a stealth price increase. Since the chef has been there a year and the food improved initially on his arrival I am guessing that management is trying to squeeze the last nickel out of every diner. This isn't going to fly and we are looking for a new "regular " spot. Shame on them . read more