Will say, not the best lobster roll or clam chowder I've had, but it's really close by the cape cod chips tower so we picked it up along the way. Didn't leave much of an impression and the lobster inside the roll had a lot of cartridge pieces that I had to sift through while chewing. The service was friendly and the place was well maintained. read more

NOT the "Best lobster roll on Cape Cod" by any stretch. False advertising. Who voted for Lobster Shanty and when? I should have known, 6 total customers at 12:00 noon. My husband also thought that his grilled chicken sandwich was the worst sandwich he has ever ordered. So disappointed read more

We came by after coming back from the beaches at National Shore and this restaurant was close to our hotel. We were seated right away and I asked to sit indoors. We like that the parking is very convenient. The lobster in the rough was just ok. Didn't have any flavor at all. The deep fried haddock was great. I would skip the pink lemonades as well, tasted pretty watery. If you are looking for fancy, this is not it but it is convenient. read more

Lobster Shanty - Whole lobster Fried haddock with fries and Cole slaw. - Seafood Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

I stopped here on a quick jaunt to the Cape Cod National Seashore. I dropped in for a lunch to go. There was no one else in the location, so you could say it was quiet. The service was okay, I was somewhat confused when ordering my fish sandwich to go where they were telling me to grab stuff. Given there was no one ahead of me it did take a while to get my order to go. The fish itself was okay. Given the price and location I would have expected a better experience and quality, instead it was just acceptable. read more

We enjoyed our dinner and the staff was very friendly and attentive. Kids meal came in a beach bucket toy which was cute, my 3yo loved it. All you can eat fish & chips was good - breading was light and our server came by and offered a second helping as soon as he noticed we were done with the first. Hot lobster roll was decent. Admittedly I'm very picky about a lobster roll - it's rare I have one that blows my mind. IMO this one was the same as many of the other well known ones in the area. read more

I'd like to amend my review after 8 years a bit. Obviously being very frustrated in the moment didn't help but allow me to explain in depth a bit more. We arrived to an empty restaurant, we were the only ones seated and we placed an order for 2 fountain drinks, and 2 mains a chicken sandwich and clam strips. We waited over an hour. The strips came out cold, and the sandwich wet to the point it went through the bread, and overall just really unsafe to eat. We asked for the bill, they took 20 minutes, they then came back and verbally told us if I recall, about $40. We asked for a physical copy and they really didn't like that. To double check, we referenced the prices on the menu and came to about $20. The physical copy was still for about $30. Big red flag. We paid cash at the table and left. They chased our car as we were leaving saying we owed more and attempted to block the car from leaving. Will not return. Please be aware of the situation at any restaurant. If things don't feel right, if the food doesn't seem safe, don't attempt to ride it out like we did trust your judgement and leave. read more

We popped into the Lobster Shanty on a Monday afternoon. We had our dogs with us so we were glad to be able to have them with us at the outdoor tables, although the cars wizzing by wasn't exactly a desirable vibe. The onion rings were great, definitely the star of the show, a very classic New England style. The hot lobster roll was ok, the lobster was a little chewy and overcooked. The fountain soda was a great compliment. read more

See all

We have been coming to the Outer Cape for a very long time and this is by far the worst food we have ever had and extremely over priced!! The service was very nice and attentive, but it took 40 minutes to arrive during a slow time, although it was hot . The bisque at 9 dollars a bowl that was the size of a cup was ok. The crab cake was gross and it was deep fried. They did not serve remoulade sauce and instead gave us a side of bisque. The lobster roll was flat with zero taste. The onion rings were very good. If you want excellent seafood in a nice atmosphere, stop at Arnolds a bit before this restaurant, or go down the street to Moby Dicks in Wellfleet. Both restaurants are on 6A and are casual. Moby Dicks is also BYOB. SKIP THIS PLACE!! read more

Great priced lobster and i got a burger, it was also great! Only bad thing was it was on paper plates but honestly that didn't matter to me at all! read more

We loved the lobster rolls so much that we went back the next day! Tried both the warm and cold lobster rolls and loved them both. Highly recommend! read more

Lobster Shanty - Lobster roll meal - Seafood Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

There are much better places to dine out in Eastham. My family planned to dine in Rock Harbor but found the place we wanted to eat closed down for some reason. A quick search for lobster rolls led us to the Shanty. Parking lot nearly empty. Indoor seating was plentiful because there were no diners. The outside patio near route 6 was empty for obvious reasons so we chose the outdoor seating to the side near the parking lot. The food: I'm not into lobster but my family all got lobster rolls and fish tacos. I had a burger. The seafood was ok according to them. They've all had better. The chowder was decent, but again there is much better on the Cape. My burger was a frozen patty and over cooked. Stick to the seafood options I guess. Staff is fine and did a nice job waiting on us. Probably because we were the only patrons there when we had left. read more

So. We were tooling around the cape and decided to stop in for lunch. We sat outside as it was a nice day. You are basically looking at a parking lot but that was okay we wanted to grab a bite and get back to sightseeing. The staff was friendly. Our food came out nice and hot. We ordered clam chowder which was good. Not the best on the cape but good. We both had broiled scallops. They were fresh and delicious. I asked if they could make mine spicy. They tossed a few pepper flakes on mine and with the garlic butter they were quite good. The waiter looked at me like I had nine heads at first. Lol. The vegetables served with it were standard restaurant style frozen begs with no flavor. We didn't eat them. The baked potatoes while cooked were dried out like they were cooked much earlier and sat in a warmer for a very long time. read more

See all

The food is really bad, the ambiance terrible. Other than that, it is ok. Ignore the sign that says "Best Lobster rolls on Cape Cod", should be Best lobster rolls on this corner" read more

Fabulous food. My ENTIRE grad came here on and despite us not telling them that MANY kids they served us tons of food without any complaints. The ambiance was great as it had the perfect aesthetic to go with the food. Delicious!! read more

They changed my tip amount!! They added $6 to the bill AFTER I left. Luckily I took a picture of the receipt because I did not trust them at all, but what?? NOTE this was not an "an error" with my bill, this would be considered fraud. read more

Lobster Shanty - Credit card charge vs receipt - Seafood Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

We visit Cape Cod yearly and this has become a regular stop for lunch. Pictured is the Shanty lobster roll with mayo. Lobster roll was delicious and the fries were great, crispy and hot. Service was also very good. Would have give 5 stars, but we ordered onion rings, extra crispy and they came barely crispy. read more

Lobster Shanty - Shanty lobster roll. - Seafood Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

Lobster rolls were tasty treats, we had both because one of us prefer cold and one prefers warm. Clam Chowder was not our favorite, too many potatoes and not enough clams for my liking. Not as creamy as most. Also if you're looking for oysters this isn't your place as they don't have any. Fries were good too. Overall, great choice to stop on your way out of the beach. read more

Lobster Shanty - Shanty Roll and Warm Roll - Seafood Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

See all

OMG, on one of the hottest days of the summer, my husband and I stopped in on our way back from hiking some of the National Seashore. We were starving and thrilled to be seated and served quickly. THEY DO HAVE THE BEST LOBSTER ROLL! No lie! We ordered the calamari too and all the food is just straightforward good. Can't wait to stop in again! read more

We were in Provincetown for one night (two couples from CA) and we saw this place on the way in. After a disappointing dinner in Provincetown, we thought we would try the Lobster Shanty on our way out. Food quality was beyond our expectations and the prices were very reasonable. Clam chowder is awesome and the boiled lobsters were much better than the overpriced ones we had in Provincetown. The staff is accommodating and friendly. Highly recommend this place. We will be back for sure! PS forget the view, it's all about the food!! read more

Lobster Shanty - Seafood Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

There are signs everywhere saying that they have the best lobster roll, but this place actually does!!! I was so impressed with the amazing and delicious roll I got. Super friendly staff and happy we found them! read more

This charming little place lured us out in. The hostess acted put out at best. We were seated in the bar and that was the only service we received. Upon exiting a man asked if something was wrong; a nice gesture. Full beer bar and we were only customers for food. No one ever approached us with water, silverware or to take our order. 2:45pm. Maybe you will be luckier. A really cute place with high prices and no service! Really? read more

My dad had the all you can eat fish n chips which was delicious! I had the lobster roll which was very flavorful. We both had the clam chowder which was also hot and delicious! Received our meals very quick and fresh! read more

Lobster Shanty - Seafood Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

We stopped as we were hungry prior to watching thirst encounter sunset.. we hesitated due to the lack of good reviews, but we tried anyway. Glad we did!!! Clam strips were light, and fresh, clam chowder was awesome, and the shrimp tacos were amazing! Don't listen to the haters.. try this place! read more

Lobster Shanty - Clam strips! - Seafood Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

We had the scallops and lobster tacos. I am already wanting to head back for more! The service was fantastic. Our server couldn't have been nicer or more attentive. It was a quiet spot which is exactly what we were hoping for. read more

The food was delicious and such a nice server. Going to go back again for dinner tomorrow night

Had my doubts about Highwayside dining but we stopped in after a bike ride to Coast Guard beach. Quick service, great people, genuinely excellent lobster roll (I know EVERYONE has the "best lobster roll in Cape Cod" but we left happy after four different lobster rolls in the last five days!). I had the fish and chips - I didn't have the appetite to test their all-you-can-eat policy but the fish was excellent. Fry chef knows how to keep the oil hot! Even the fries were among the best we've had in the area. Highly recommend! read more

Stopped in the other day on our way to Cap Cod. I had grilled chicken sandwich and my boyfriend had clam chowder and the all you can eat fish and chips. He only had one plate. He said it was more than enough. He told me the chowder and fish were okay but not the best he ever had. My grilled chicken sandwich may have been the best I've had. Big piece of chicken and mildly spiced to taste. Wait staff was very friendly and we were seated within a couple minutes. Drinks came fast. I was happy with service and the food I ordered. Wasn't enough to get me back a second time. But I have no complaints. read more

Lobster Shanty - Seafood Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

See all

Disappointing. The most charming thing about this place is the parking lot. Food is mediocre at best given the prices, and service is nonexistent. The dining area inside is musty, dingy, and noisy. read more

Look elsewhere for 'fresh' lobster. You won't find it here. I ordered a 2lb and started with the tail. Seemed to have been split before cooking. The meat was softer than usual and did look a bit stained from the roe, but I was starving so I plowed on. Claws were all mush though. Inedible. Our waiter was nice so I tacked on a star. Here is a tip when eating fresh whole lobster in a restaurant. Always start with the claws. The tail will almost always be somewhat edible (which is why you find them frozen in supermarkets). The claw meat is delicate though. If it has turned to mush, send the lobster back immediately and order something else. read more

Soft shell lobster, overcooked, with very meh service and prices. Strongly advise that you skip this one. They also don't specify who voted their dubious claim as the best lobster roll of cape cod. read more

We always stop at this place for lunch on our drive down to Truro. The staff is always friendly and the lobster rolls and fries were delicious. read more

I liked it very much. Our server was so sweet. Her name was something like carol-leen, not sure... we liked her a lot. Food was good, and we liked the building. read more

This says closed, but this place is open. So the kids have really cute beach buckets that their meals came in. My fiancé ordered the "all you can eat fish n chips" which ended up not being all you can eat. He wasn't asked if he wanted more. My lobster roll was quite small for the price, but the lobster was good. Here is the part that ticked me off. I ordered a side salad. $5 and change for this salad. It looked really tasty. Small bust I was starving. I went to open the "ranch" dressing and it was bleu cheese. I then waited about 15 minutes until our food was brought out and explained the mix-up. I was then brought tartar sauce. The cups were not labeled so they obviously were unable to tell which one they were bringing me. I gave up and wasn't asking again. The table behind us was playing the same game trying to figure out what was in their cups. My sons kids cheeseburger he said tasted very odd. He said it didn't taste like burger. I didn't try it myself and told him he didn't have to finish. Aside from the staff being very friendly and the kids getting the cute kids toys, we personally will not be back. read more

I'm allergic to lobster, but hot damn, the fried fish is awesome. It's not of the Englsh pub variety but rather a lightly battered, fried-to-perfection roadside treat. Nice spot to eat outside and brewskis after biking from the beach. read more

We thought we would try it out while in Cape Cod. DON'T EVER GO HERE!! The place wasn't all that clean and the server was sooooo rude. We left prior to our server coming back to take our order. Again I say, RUN AWAY!!! read more

Went in for lobster rolls to go which were pretty good but way overpriced. It was a cheap roll, lobster, a lettuce leaf and a lemon wedge for $18. I wish I made these at home instead. It tasted good but just not worth the price for take out. read more

Lobster Shanty - Seafood Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

Worst seafood I ever had!!!!! I wish I saw this before we stop! For 100 dollars I got lobster bisque with no lobster in it and was obviously can soup, lobster rolls were meh. And the fish and chips were terrible!!!!!!! I'm actually worried we might get food poisoning from this, I just stopped eating and walked away... but I did tell them It was the worst seafood I'd ever had!!!! What a rip off!!!!! DO NOT COME HERE!!! Also I come from seafood town, and have eaten seafood my whole life so good luck! read more

Passed it on our way to Provincetown, noticed the sign for "Best Lobster roll" and decided to stop by on our way back. I really wanted to love it but I wasn't impressed. Service was nice. Ordered the lobster bisque which was hot and delicious, and then it was downhill from there. The lobster roll was meh. I feel like my expectations were set up high and upon dining, the meal did not meet any expectations. It was missing something,,,Can't really pin point it but I do see lots of potential. read more

Pig skins were ok. We ordered a beer and wine. Waited 45 minutes after appetizer for our food when there was 3 other tables seated. Nobody came by to check on us or ask if we wanted a refill. We waited so long we just walked over to the register paid our bill and left. Not even an apology for the wait. Would not recommend. Never again read more

Lobster Shanty - Cute place mats - Seafood Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

See all

The good: Our waitress was very friendly. She seemed to enjoy her job. My lobster was delicious, as was the corn on the cob. The not-so-good: The chicken strips my wife and daughter got. Very dark, dry, and unpleasant tasting. The stuffing in my lobster (I got the stuffed lobster). There was a very large amount. Actually, too much. It wasn't very good, either. Soggy bread with a bell pepper flavor. That was it. No other spices that I could detect. I've had stuffed lobster at other places and the stuffing was always delicious and went well with the lobster. Not this stuffing. The so-so: The lobster bisque. Not bad, but not great, either. A little thin. Could have had a bit more flavor. read more