New Yorkers are picky about pizza, but for us out-of-towners, any pizza here is probably better…read morethan pizza we get at "home". Forest Ave is no different. It operates a lot like most places where you can go in, select from their myriad of slice options, and they heat it up in the oven where it gets a nice, crispy bottom. I'm assuming you can order pizza pies to go as well, but for lunch and "by the slice" options, this place was pretty good. Staff was friendly and the pizza was good. The slices look bigger on the plate than they do behind the counter, so you might regret getting 2 slices!

Been going here for years, best pizza in GC. Toppings are a little pricey but other than that…read morealways fresh and loaded.

Ralph's Pizza is an absolute gem. Hands down the best veggie pizza I've ever had--piping hot,…read moreperfectly cooked, and you can taste the difference because they roast the vegetables before they go on the pie. Total game changer. The slices are insane, and the grandma pie is equally incredible--crispy, flavorful, and done just right. Honestly, this is the best pizza I've had on Long Island. Must try. Do not sleep on this place.

My go to spot for pizza in Bayville for decades. They have a delicious NY style slices. The…read moreingredients are fresh, the pizza is delicious, and the service is fast. The restaurant itself has very old school pizzeria vibes. I love it. I recently discovered how good their chicken sandwiches are. I can't believe I've been sleeping on those for so long! And they have Italian ices for dessert!

Not the best pizza but good if you get a fresher pie. Would…read morenot recommend the food sauce is not great.

Best pizza in Glen cove ! If you want a real New York slice this is it …read more Always consistent, fresh and delicious. Clean pizzeria , very friendly service . Parking gets a little crazy in the evening (shopping center)

What an amazing authentic Italian Gem.... This one is truly the closest to eating in Italy w/o…read moreflying there. All pastas are handmade, Neapolitan pizza second to none, outstanding Italian wines with some Napa ones thrown in as well. The vibe is a very cozy and warm chalet feel, with fantastic background music to set the mood played at the perfect volume. Different levels of seating and a few round tables for the perfect dinner with friends or family. Price point perfect and what is coming out of the kitchen fantastic. Great cocktail menu and they have Moretti beer one of my favorites. Owners are from Italy and Two25 has been open for the past 3 years and they're working on another restaurant opening soon in Glen Head. Definitely will be back, highly recommend

I loved everything about this restaurant. It is so pretty inside. The food is fabulous and the…read moreservice was amazing. Jessica our waitress was so nice and super friendly. She made our first time dining here a great experience. I'll definitely return.

With so many places to grab pizza on Long Island, it takes a lot to impress me. My mom was in…read morerehab near this venue for a significant amount of time, and with the awful food she was forced to eat, I needed to bring her "treats" when I visited. First, let's talk about their sauce and dough for their regular pizza. The sauce is appropriately seasoned, not too heavy on oregano or basil, the tomatoes are high quality and the dough rises to perfection with the exact consistency I prefer. They have all kinds of speciality slices/pies; I highly recommend the margarita slice (their sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil). There is a casual sitting area with servers and a menu to order from. They have a thriving takeout option, and they also deliver locally. They accept credit cards, but be prepared for a fee. Their prices are competitive for the quality of their food. Vito's is Dining Deal Foodie approved--I purchased a shrimp parmigiana hero for my mom with a bottle of diet soda, both of which cost me less than $20. That is a bargain in today's economy! Give them a try--you won't be disappointed!

Under its new management, Vito's Ristorante & Pizzeria in Glen Cove feels revitalized. From the…read moremoment you walk in, service is polished and efficient--Brian keeps everything running like clockwork, adding a welcoming, family-style touch. What starts as a simple pizza counter evolves into a spacious, stylish dining area. The dark cherry wood, stone accents, and prominent wine wall give it a cozy yet refined vibe--relaxed, not pretentious. The food is stellar: flavorful, fresh, and served with care. Everything feels clean and thoughtfully prepared, creating a genuinely enjoyable dining experience. In short, Vito's strikes the perfect balance between warmth and sophistication--ideal for casual meals or special events.

We got a chicken roll and grilled chicken today for the family! They absolutely loved it, and the…read morechicken roll was so fresh. The service provided by the staff was really good, and the store was very clean. It was surprisingly empty for a Father's Day weekend, but regardless, the food was great and my father-in-law really enjoyed it! Hoy compramos un 'chicken roll' (rollo de pollo) y pollo a la parrilla para la familia! Les encantó a todos, ¡y el 'chicken roll' estaba súper fresco! El servicio por parte del personal fue muy bueno y la tienda estaba muy limpia. Estaba sorprendentemente vacío para ser el fin de semana de Día del Padre, pero de todos modos, ¡la comida estuvo excelente y a mi suegro le gustó mucho!

In the area on a Saturday and called ahead to see if we needed reservations for an early dinner and…read morewe were told "no". It's been a very long time since coming here last and we had many other local options but wanted to revisit. Parking was a non issue in the busy shopping center. We walked in and were greeted by the gentleman behind the counter. Eventually someone came to the edge of the seating area to seat us. We sat (4) in a clean booth. There was only one other occupied table at 5pm on a Saturday and the pizza side had one person at the counter. A gentleman named Felix came over to take our drink order. He was kind but didn't really check on us throughout the meal. Instead, another server? stopped by at the end. I was confused and asked if there was a shift change. She said no, she was just checking in. Drinks came with a basket of bread that resembled pizza crust and packaged butter. It was dry but tasted ok. Table water tasted like it was straight from the tap and was not good. All served in plastic cups. Ordered was 2 regular slices for a child, one personal margherita pie, and 2 orders of chicken francese over linguine in the same sauce. The 2 slices came out 1st, which was ok being that the child was hungry. Then the Margherita pie came out, and about 5 minutes later, the chicken dinners came out. It would have been nice to get everything all at once but I understand it was being cooked it 2 separate places. (Back kitchen/front pizza oven). Everything was hot. The waiter did not check on us, we had to ask for extra napkins and grated cheese. The regular slices were "a 7.2" on the pizza scale, says the tween. Nothing left behind. The personal Margherita pie was ok. The crust was so thin that the tomatoes on top completely soaked through and made it impossible to pick up. A very wet pizza for a thin crust. The chicken francese dishes were also just ok. The sauce was insanely lemony, and we love lemons! It was also heavy, not a light refreshing sauce. It was on the thicker side. The chicken was very chewy. I don't know if it was overcooked or just not great quality chicken. Good portions, but very chewy. The linguine underneath was perfectly al dente. No one took any used plates off the table or offered drink refills. Bread wasn't even used to sop up the sauce. They charge extra for using a credit card. It's stated on the menu (as a cash discount). I thought that was not allowed any longer in NYS, but we didn't have a choice. This place is convenient. And each time we come, we're hoping to be wow'd, but it never happens. As we were leaving, one table had joined. You'd think it would be packed on a Saturday night. The same gentlemen at the pizza counter greeted us on the way out. We may try other places when back in the area but we may return. Nothing was bad, it just wasn't as memorable as we wished it was...except for the company!

Good service! Nice and courteous…read more Fried calamari - Must try! First the batter taste excellent. Not oily and very crispy/crunchy. Garlic knots - loads of garlic flavor. Spaghetti with clam sauce - Lots of garlic and clams, pasta was very hot. Really enjoyed it. Chicken Parm ala Volka - Loved it. I only took a few bites but the chicken parmigiana done really well. Sauce was excellent.

Food is delicious & the service was amazing efficient and courteous. Close to home so travel was a…read morebreeze