This meal was just ok for most of us, although I loved my tamales!! We thought it was a lot like the Mexican restaurants back home. But it was friendly quick service and the food was ok. read more

Here now in Benson going on six months due to the "Virus". Magaly's continues to deliver on wonderful food. Of course you pick it up. Hot sauce #1. read more

Tasty food, yummy margaritas and good service. This is our go to spot for food in the Benson area. My ONLY 3 critics would be the guacamole is a little over priced for what you get and the shredded chicken always is a bit dry. read more

Cheese & green chili crisp!!! I am a big fan! Overall our dinner was pretty good. Service was very good. Price was decent. read more

This place is GREAT! Moderately priced, delicious Mexican Cusine! Very casual atmosphere, nice decor, and great service! Best red chili burritos cheese enchiladas, rice and beans! Try this place, and you will be glad that you did! read more

Just okay - really over rated. Margaritas were mainly chopped ice, used table salt for edge of glass. Servers were pleasant. Would not come back. read more

We were looking for some good Mexican food after Karchner Caverns and saw all the cars parked outside so thought it was a good sign. We came in right after the lunch rush so they were busy clearing tables and getting people seated. The service was was prompt and friendly. We were seated and brought the chips and salsa and the salsa was great and if you like it hot, you will be pleased. They also have a mild version. DH and I both ordered the chicken mole because the waitress said it was home made and it was amazing. DH says best ever. It's not fancy but good. If that's what you're looking for, you've found it. read more

The darker Salsa is exquisite- a little bite to it - but not enough to make you sweat. I did notice there seemed to be a bit more salt then I typically like but it really brought the flavor out. I consumed all of it and asked for more. The service prompt and attentive. Typical Mexican food menu. I ordered the red chili chimichanga and it was very good. Somewhat typical until I poured the 2nd bowl of salsa on it - made it amazing. Good inexpensive stop for lunch. I recommend this place and would return. read more

Not sure why this place is so busy, nor why they're so expensive. They don't have a grill at all which means no Carne Asada and no grilled chicken. There were no fajitas on the menu. A quick lunch for four was $50. And that included kids meals for $6.99 one of which was a single taco and beans and rice that looked like pig slop. read more

A busy, bustling place with average food, below average atmosphere, and average service. It's not bad. It's just not good. The soups- we tried the albondigas and the tortilla- were delivered hot to the table after a 15 minute wait. They were both overly salty. The tortilla wasn't especially flavorful, and I think it's tacky and a bit ridiculous to charge $2 and call it 'Deluxe' by adding a little cilantro and avocado to the top of the bowl. Doesn't Tortilla Soup always come topped with avocado? Never seen it as a $2 addition anywhere but Magaly's. Thechips were stale. The enchiladas were ok, but the soft taco lacked flavor and it was tiny. All in all a very average experience that we won't repeat. The only reason we went was that Mi Casa was closed by the time we got to Benson. We won't make that mistake again. read more

Great food and the price is right. Very clean and great customer service. Shredded beef chimichanga and chilaquiles dishes were both delicious. The hot salsa was our favorite. They also have medium and mild. Everyone's taste buds are happy. You won't be sorry. read more

Every time we travel to Tucson, we stop in Benson to eat at Magaly's. It's a great little family-owned restaurant.

Drove down to Karchner Caverns. Stopped here for dinner. Super friendly staff and great food. Chips and salsa was excellent. My wife had cheese enchiladas and I had chicken tortilla soup. Wife enjoyed hers and I have to say the soup was one of the best I ever had. Big portion with lots of chicken and avocados diced up. If I stayed another night I would of come here and order it again. I also had the iced tea. I am extremely picky about it and this place does it right. Most places the tea is cloudy, bitter and old. They take great pride in there iced tea and obviously make it fresh. read more

There's a couple people who are wonderful at this restaurant, and I only went there because they were so nice, and brightened up my day. One of the employees were incredibly rude. She made a mistake on my order, no big deal, I pointed it out and they credited me and corrected it. The lady I pointed out had some vendetta against me for correcting her. I was treated poorly ever since that experience. I gave them one last chance. I went to dine in, long story short I have a service dog and the owner said my dog is not qualified as a service dog because he's an emotional support animal. I'm done with this restaurant, not worth that headache or poor treatment. Thanks a lot guys! read more

This is probably the most popular Mexican restaurant in Benson. At lunchtime the parking lot is full. Same for dinner. Only open till 7pm (3pm on Mondays). Very attentive staff. I usually get the green chili burro. My only gripe is that I wish it had more windows. read more

If you love home cooked Mexican food, and you find yourself near Benson Arizona, this restaurant makes you feel like you are in grandma's kitchen (if you were lucky enough to have a grandma that could cook like this). We read online that the chili relleno was one of the things they are known for and our entire table was bummed they didn't make sure their combination plate included this delicious dish. Even the cheese crisp with green chili was perfectly cooked. The group was split on green vs red sauce on the enchilada or burrititos. Great food for a great price!! read more

Magaly's Mexican Restaurant - Terrific find! - Mexican Near Me - Benson, Arizona

We stopped here for lunch only because it's open during quarantine and we were starving on our way from Tombstone to Phoenix. And wow were we surprised. Their homemade smoky salsa is super spicy and flavorful and all the food we ordered was authentic and really good. We never even write Yelp reviews but thought this place was worth taking the time to recommend. read more

Just a small mexican eatery in "Big City" Benson Arizona. if I remember correctly, the sign abve the door says maximum Capacity 49. But, the food was Outstanding. The salsa could use just a bit more "POP", but it was tasty. read more

The menu was hecka confusing. On one of the first pages is the list of drinks, and near the top are the margaritas. Underneath that was what I thought to be the flavors (after all, they were indented, and they didn't say "soda" or anything like that above it), so I asked for a rootbeer margarita. I was told that they only have plain. That's fine, but they should have listed the word "sodas" above the list of sodas, and not put it directly under "Margaritas," single-spaced, and indented. Yeah, confusing. The menu contains A TON of options to order from, and yes, the prices are very reasonable. However, when thumbing through the menu, I'd often wonder, "What is that?" "What is this made of?" or "What comes with that?" Many menu items had no descriptions of what they were made of or even the options (like meat, sauce) you could choose. Many menu items were also abbrieviated, so I wouldn't have known what they were unless I was a local (which I am not) and a regular, or part of the waitstaff. Like what I ordered, it was a combo with a taco and two enchiladas, but part of its description was "SC enchilada," which made me wonder what "SC" stood for. I didn't ask, because I really didn't care. I'll pretty much eat anything. I was also EXTREMELY disappointed that my meal did not come with rice and beans. At other Mexican restaurants I've been to, if the dish does not come with a side of beans and rice, the menu will state that. This menu did not. In fact, my boyfriend and his dad ordered from the same section I did (one Special # next to mine), and they both received rice and beans, so I also was expecting to receive beans and rice. But still, at least I still got a good amount of food, and I liked what I ordered. The other reviewers have RAVED about the salsa, and while it was good, I couldn't see what the hype was about. My bf and I both thought that the salsa was a little too spicy, and I can usually handle spicy well. The enchiladas were good. I asked if I could have mine with green sauce, and green sauce they came with, but they were also topped with what seemed to be (and taste like) nacho cheese. Interesting. Not great; not bad, but definitely interesting. As stated earlier, the menu did not do a good job describing items, so the enchiladas included in the combo were pretty much "mystery" enchiladas. After eating them, I found one to be a cheese enchilada, and the other was sour cream (hence, the "SC"). At least I got to choose the type of taco I wanted, and I chose ground beef. I must say, that was the best ground beef taco I've ever had. Our waitress was quick to getting our orders taken, and delivering our drinks, food, and the check to the table, but she didn't do much more than that. She was smiling and pleasant when she was at our table, but she never checked back with us, period (before or after the food was delivered). I would have given this place four stars had the waitress checked back with us, and five had the menu not been so confusing (which resulted in my not receiving beans and rice, which again, I was VERY disappointed about). read more

In town on business we stopped in here on a recommendation from the lady at the front desk of the hotel. For me the salsa is a good judge of what I am getting into at a Mexican place. Ohhh tasty and just the right amount of kick. The chips appeared to be made in house. I had the combo that came with the Tortilla Soup and a taco (shredded beef). The broth in the soup was quite tasty but I still found myself adding a few spoon-fulls of salsa for a kick. There were tons of tortilla chips topping this cup of broth and some cheese. No small chunks of chicken or avocado or a slice of lime like I get with other authentic tortilla soups. The taco was good the beans and rice good. My coworker had the Veggie Burro it was huge and the tortilla looked homemade. He enjoyed it as he spooned about half the salsa over the burrito. Both of us cleaned our plates. The staff kept the water and salsa coming, the service was quick and friendly. read more

No MASKS and crowded dining. Firstly, I love this restaurant; it is arguably the best Mexican food in Southern Arizona, and I have been coming here from Sierra Vista for years. This is why I was so disheartened to see they were not protecting their customers or their employees by wearing masks. It is such a simple thing to do and protects the people around you. read more

I had the green chili chimichanga and Jen had the shredded beef chimichanga. We got them work the green sauce on the side and they were both fantastic! The tortilla soup was also to die for. The best Jen every had and probably the beast i every had. The broth was fantastic there were chunks of avocado in it. Bam! Jules our waitress was top notch. Age provided the recommendations for both the chimi and the soup. After a long day i was thirsty and age was great on the refills read more

I wish I could give Magaly's a better review. A couple years ago, I would have gone with 5 stars. Unfortunately, their food isn't the same as it used to be. We used to drive from Tucson to Benson just to go eat, but now, even when in Benson, we look for somewhere else to eat. It's OK, just disappointing to me because it used to be so good, now just so-so at best. I miss the way they used to make their chili rellenos which were the best anywhere. read more

The food was bland and watery, the chips were terrible (the thick, cheap, food service grade garbage) and the salsa was lackluster. The restaurant looks like it needs a good cleaning. The menu is limited and somewhat confusing. Portions were on the larger side but who wants a huge plate of tasteless junk?! Not me! Service was so-so. The worst meal I've had in a long, long time. read more

Very middle of the road Mexican food. The only saving grace for this place was the service which was very good and friendly

The food was very good and the staff prompt and friendly.The chips need work. They should be warm and the salsa was just ok. Would go back in a heartbeat. read more

Pros: Large serving size. Tortilla soup is a must order. Cons: Mexican food gets better the farther south you travel. Chips & salsa were not freshly made. Chimicanga was over fried. Had to stared at the waitstaff for a couple minutes before they came over to take the order. read more

My father in law lives outside of Benson..we were visiting for the first time and wanted to take him out for dinner..he suggested this place so I yelped it and saw it had good reviews. You will not be disappointed..we all had something different cheese enchiladas chile rellano tacos and it was all yummy! Three different sauces for your chips..very good. Pretty authentic cooking. Nice atmosphere and our waitress Cassy was awesome. Great place to eat. We will definitely go back. read more

So many things wrong Guacamole was the only thing worth eating kept them from 1 star rating Chips are old & salsa is tomato puree & hot Chile Rellenos - just plain wrong used banana pepper cheddar on top with bad (Italian sauce) Beans - mostly flavorless Rice - sour read more

We stopped in for some good Mexican food on our road trip to Dallas. The service was excellent and the food was really good! I tried a chicken enchilada and the shredded beef taco and they were both good (I preferred the beef). There beans and rice were delish too! My daughter, who is a chicken strip connoisseur, thought their strips were some of the best she's had read more

Amazing food Outstanding Service Tortilla Soup was the best we've ever had. Chile Relleno was light and fluffy and the Chicken Mole was authentic and delicious. Dora was our server and was genuine and warm. Highly Recommend read more

We stopped here on the way back to Tucson from Kartchner Caverns. Nothing too spectacular- but possibly the best option in Benson.

Great price food and service. Senior lunch chili rellenos a hit with with all of us. Does not try to be fancy just a nice place. A long time favorite of the locals read more

The food is pretty decent, and the portions large. The salsa is pretty good. There are a fair number of ala carte choices and combination plates that are larger and more expensive. The people are very nice. I think this is a toss up with Reb's, though. read more

This is very good mexican food - especially for a town the size of Benson.

We had enchiladas, rellenos, two kinds of tacos...so I felt like we had a pretty good sampling of Mexican food. All of it was great and the service was wonderful too. Salsa good and plenty of chips. They made fresh coffee for the grandpa with us and he was thrilled. We would drive back to eat here. read more

Great local find. Want a solid Mexican meal this is the spot. Ordered the smooth red burrito enchilada style!

I had a beef tamale and ground beef encillada. The beef in the encillada was flavorless. Tamale was similar, even withe sauce. My friend had a birra stew which she enjoyed and she said was very good. read more

The food is decent, the staff are very nice. Wouldn't recommend the margarita, tasted like there was zero alcohol in it.

Such a great meal! Very friendly service. Beers we're cold, food was hot & flavorful! Lunch menu was an exception deal. Definitely recommend a cheese crisp with green chili strips to start with! Will definitely be back next time we're in town! read more