Food and service is always top notch... Restaurant is run by an amazing couple! whether dining in or taking out they always make you feel welcomed and appreciated. They also have some excellent gluten free options!!! read more

Unfortunately this is the lowest I can give. Used to love this place. Last two orders have been a nightmare. Today's order took 1 hr and 45 mins and once again the food was ice cold, with 3 missing items. This is absolutely our last order, will not give them another chance. read more

THEIR SFINICIONE PIZZA IS OUT OF THIS WORLD!!! It's worth coming from NJ for it! I also loved their sun-dried tomato and olive Sicilian! The other slices I tried were all very good! They excel at making Sicilian pizza! I highly recommend Mangia in Staten Island! read more

See all

chicken Franchise w/Broccoli Rabe was delicious and sampled the Artichoke Petey Boy Style. Will order that next time. Great service and reasonable prices. And they support the S.I. GIVING CIRCLE Veterans Food Pantry. Thank you! read more

Family-owned operations, with Excellent Pizza and even better food. Can't miss a good meal at this place read more

We went here for the first time Sunday afternoon for an early dinner. The restaurant is easy to get to and they have a parking lot next-door. The dining room connected to the pizzeria is beautifully decorated with chandeliers, ceramic tile and black-and-white photos of I believe family members from Italy. The menu Has many different choices for everyone, including the wine list. The food was very fresh and very big portions. You definitely get your moneys worth. The staff was always also very friendly and accommodating. read more

I have eaten here many times food is always fresh and comes to the table piping hot. Try the pork osso bocco it's great. The service is excellent. I Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Excellent food. I had the chicken parmigiana a la vodka which was delicious. A twist on an Italian standard. Will definitely return.

Love it here!!!! Best food!!! the most amazing Vodka sauce! Great service. Cool Vibes.

We came here to eat after my daughter's award ceremony at school . It is a typical pizzeria restaurant with a medium size dining room. We were told to sit anywhere. Decent size menu with reasonable pricing , food was all fresh to order and extremely Hot when it came out. Casual atmosphere definitely a nice place to gather for good food , decent prices and quick service . read more

See all

Heard good things about this place and while the pizza selection is pretty unique here, I have a problem with being ignored by both the owner with an attitude and counter guy because of a large party going on in the other room. Also, guys try to get a handle on the flys that are trapped in your display case. read more

I gave them a second chance after the first time the food wasn't good. I figured bad night. Ordered a big dinner to go. Drove 20 minutes to get it and they put the fried calamari in a box and don't tell us. Never have we seen this done. Just randomly thrown in a box. Then the owner doesn't want to accept the fact that he did something stupid. We've been eating fried calamari for 20 years and it's been in a container. I wanted a credit. He refused to credit my card. The food spilled because no one told us it was boxed. They put the the Caesar salad in with the hot food and ruined that. Save your money. read more

We really loved Mangia! The service was some of the best we have ever experienced. Very warm and inviting, making us feel at home, yet not overbearing. Just perfect. We sat outside and the neighborhood was so quiet and peaceful. We told the waiter we didn't eat meat and they made our food to order: broccoli with cavatelli and broccoli raab with orecchiette (both without chicken stock), but they still had great flavor, loads of veggies and garlic and were cooked perfectly. The special (vegetarian) complementary bread that they bring out before the meal is just....well you have to go to experience it. Delicious. Can't wait to go back. read more

The best pizza its amazing and the service the best the owner make you feel like family I recommend this place 100 percent

Great place for Italian food that has indoor and outdoor dining with very friendly people that will customize anything on the menu to your taste/needs so stop by if you're in the area. read more

BEST PIZZA ON STATEN ISLAND!!! IMO...Family owned and operated. I tried a bunch of different pizza's but i think my favorite is the BBQ chicken pie. the crust on the round pies are awesome and the crust on the Sicilian is out of this world. you should definitely give this place a whirl and thank me later. read more

See all

I fell in love with the personal mushroom pie. Just ordered for the first time using the "Slice" app and I will definitely be a returning customer. Amazing experience and easily one of the best slices I ever had. read more

Mangia Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Every single style of pizza I've tried has been fantastic.. the crust is perfect, not too doughy, nice crunch and taste. The sauce is amazing and the cheese is top quality . I absolutely love the Old fashioned with olives and onion, Sicilian pie.. probably one of the top pies I've ever had in my life.. The Sunday sauce with pasta, meatballs, sausage and braciole is like eating in your own Nonna's house. The spicy calamari, the eggplant Parm, omg.. Honestly, don't miss this for phenomenal food and pizza! read more

I rarely Yelp but I got to say I was extremely impressed with mangia so would love to support. You walk into a pizzeria and the back is a cute restaurant. They start you off with some of the best bread I ever had at a restaurant, hot focaccia bread and a garlic bread. We got zucchini sticks as an app..delicious. Their eggplant pizza was also sooo good. Service was also great, our waitress was very nice and attentive . A little out of way in tottenville but worth the trip. Can't wait to go back and try some entrees !! read more

Pretty good pizza, but not as good as pre covid-19. I don't know what happened. Have never ate there, review is just based on take out. read more

Mangia Pizzeria - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

We ordered a pie with calamari and when it arrived the calamari was pink. I called the business to let them know that their calamari was possibly spoiled and they insisted it was pink due to being cooked twice. I am a chef in the food industry and can assure you this is not the case. The calamari was spoiled. read more

I did a pick up order and was given the total amount of $44.10 Upon looking on my credit card bill for another reason all together I seen the charge of $51.20 for the pizza order I called and was told they charge 3.75 % on credit payment To not tell the customer is wrong and it's $1.65 fee even if I was told of the charge not $7.10 that they did charge Scam artist shady and pizza that wasn't worth the hassle to begin with read more

Great pizzeria restaurant. Owners are amazing, went for a pre k graduation, all of the kids got to make their own pizza, a great memory and a great meal. read more

Delicious food, new favorite pizza place in tottenville. Nice place to sit down and eat too. People that work there are also very nice. read more

Mangia Pizzeria - Eggplant BBQ Chicken Pie MacNCheese slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This place is spectacular. Never crowded. AMAZING vodka pie. Great margarita pie. Their fried calamari is delicious. Their Caesar salad is big enough for 2 adults and a kid. I have never been disappointed here. My kid calls the waiter, "pizza-man." read more

Easily the best penne vodka I've had...in years! Portions were pretty big--enough for lunch the next day. Delivery was pretty quick for a Saturday night. Definitely looking forward to trying out some other dishes. read more

I've ordered from Mangia many times. I've never been disappointed. The pizza is great, and so are the entrees. It feels like a family owned establishment when you walk through the door. I've run across a husband and wife team behind the counter who are always courteous and attentive. I would highly recommend this place. read more

The service was absolutely outstanding. Hands down amazing service here. However... The food here was some of the worst food I've eaten... I ordered calamari with lemon wine sauce and it had an overwhelming fishy taste along with being soggy. The calamari was also soggy and was like chewing on a piece of rubber. My wife gagged after trying the first piece. I ordered the ravioli with shrimp and that was surprisingly outstanding. My wife ordered the chicken Francese and one of the cutlets was raw.. absolutely terrible. I'm not one to complain in a restaurant and get a free meal so we paid full price for the meal.. Great great service here. The waiter and waitress were super kind and always asking if everything was okay. I think we will just stick to pie from Mangia. read more

Terrible service and terrible food. Had issue with the order and manager has a terrible attitude. Town deli is so much better, don't waste your time here. read more

Hidden gem.......Great food, affordable, and ample portions to fill yet not overstuff you.....Pizza is great as well...Worth a visit....

Comfort Italian Food. Calamari Royale Special was delicious. Never a long wait and great service. Definitely recommend to anyone looking to get authentic and delicious Italian Food. read more

See all

I've been here a few times for lunch. The waiter is friendly and attentive. The food is delicious and the portions are huge! Also, they have Dean Martin and Frank Sinatra music playing in the background. I recommend it if you're in the area looking for a casual place to dine at. read more

Ordered dinner last week and had it delivered. Omg! It was so delicious! Definitely missing out if you haven't had the food from this restaurant. read more

The pizza is consistently great. The dough, the ingredients, the service... everything is top notch. I'm a huge fan!

Great food & great service . The pastas , salads and desserts are fresh and full of flavor . I highly recommend this place

Always the best! Delivery is quick and hot. Staff is always friendly and welcoming. Eat in or take out definitely recommend!

Family owned business , delicious food every time!! When ever I visit Staten Island this is my go to restaurant

Man this is a hidden gem. Everything my family has tried from here is outstanding. Plain pizza is the best in the area, blows away the "other" spot on Amboy Rd. Wings, pasta dinners, etc are all delicious. A friend suggested the "breadcrumb pie" and wow it did not disappoint! The gentleman who I believe is the owner (there all the time) is extremely polite, and actually says "thank you" when you pay. He appreciates your business which is rare these days. Can't say enough good about this place! read more

Great family owed place with very friendly staff and amazing food. I've never had more pleasant experience with both takeout and sit down dining. read more

So turns out I've been ordering from Mangia for lunch at school because they delivered! Everything I ate was delicious! When I found out they did so well & expanded into an actual restaurant, we had to go check it out! It's a really cute spot in Tottenville! They had our table ready for us on a Friday night & our water/bread was already on it...which was good this time because we were starving! However, they are very quick, so it's not good if you want to sit, talk & digest before each course! Also even though you really don't need reservations, I'd call ahead, especially during Covid! The bread was flat with parmigiana & oil...since that was so tasty, we had to start with a pizza! We made our own everything pie lol. It was sooo good! We had to wrap some up, otherwise we wouldn't have room for our actual meal. I ordered the homemade gnocchi & almost finished the whole plate, but saved some for lunch. My boyfriend ordered the meat lasagna but they brought him the eggplant lasagna instead...he knew it didn't taste right, plus he hates eggplant! Lucky for me, eggplant is my favorite & I couldn't decide between that & the gnocchi. Guess what? Since they already made it & didn't want it to go to waste...they let us take it home free of charge!!! Now that's good business! I ate it over the next two days! It was excellent!!! I highly recommend this magnificent restaurant... Mangia! Xoxo read more