Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Many Bennies

    4.3 (167 reviews)
    Open 12:00 pm - 9:00 PM
    Updated 3 weeks ago

    Many Bennies Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Many Bennies

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Menu Flavor Combinations
    Sabine P.

    Delicious, cute, great dessert spot for a date or summer night! I love the googly eyes they add to their ice creams. Makes them so unique. The flavors and ability to do combinations were awesome. I got a Banana Mango and my partner got a Blueberry Raspberry with Lemon Curd. They were both delicious and tasted fresh. My only gripe is that it turned out quite pricey. $21 for just 2 ice creams. Kinda pushing it. I'll be back, but definitely more for special occasions.

    Lawrence L.

    Worth the trip, worth the trip, worth the trip. Definitely make this a stop in your dessert travels. Really good creamy ice cream mixed in with fresh fruit, generous portion, benches outside. Totally worth the trip over at Interlake and I will be back

    Outside
    Harun O.

    Great ice cream with fresh and clean ingredients. Uou pick your base and they crush in and blend your mixins. I picked lavendar base with strawberry and blueberry mixins with hot honey sauce on it. Was a fun combo. Staff was kind and offered samples which i recommend before picking your base. The only downside is because they blend the each combo there and will always be a wait time but it was worth it. We arrived around 9 pm and it was still very crowded, popular spot with some outside sitting with a very casual ambiance . Will definitely come back

    Aaron T.

    The service was great as the ice cream is customizable to your liking. In addition to that, they also provided lactaid for those who like to push your limits. I definitely liked it as it wasn't too sweet and the presentation of the ice cream was cute. The candy eyes were a bit hard for my liking but that's about it.

    ice cream
    Shrenik P.

    I apologize to the country of New Zealand. I'm sure your style of ice cream is not as bad as my experience at this place, and I'm sure that if I ever visit you, I will make sure to try your soft serve and experience it firsthand. If it's truly this bad, then I will apologize to this ice cream shop, but for some reason I doubt it. This is a place that had a bit of a line when I went. The main reason for this line is that unlike other ice cream shops, they blend each scoop to order, meaning you can wait up to 10 minutes after placing your order for your cup or cone. The concept is interesting. Blending frozen fruit with sweet custard could create something unique, which is why it's popular in New Zealand and has spread to many places across the world. However, it completely falls flat here. The first thing I noticed is the sweetness just isn't there. The best approximation I can give to this is if you had a fruit smoothie, put it in the freezer for a while, then took it out for about ten minutes. It just tastes like cold and icy fruit. The fattiness, the sweetness, the richness of traditional ice cream - all collapsed into nothingness. If you bought a Ninja Creami you might genuinely be able to make a better product than this. I chose strawberry and mango as my mix-ins, but the mango seems to have disappeared into thin air. Maybe it went to the same faraway place that the sweetness did. It pretty much just tasted like strawberry. I went for graham cracker crumble on top of the ice cream. I was apparently mistaken though, because what I got instead were giant pieces of graham crackers, clearly broken apart by hand just before. The whole point of a crumble is you can get small pieces with each bite of ice cream, creating a textural contrast that works. When you have giant pieces though - that means you're eating ice cream, then one bite of the cracker. It's not even close to the same. What is this, a crumble for giants? The unfortunate hilarity of how bad this was concluded when at the bottom, you realize everything's not fully blended through. There are still pieces of half-destroyed frozen fruit at the bottom, which is just incredibly unappealing. Why I mention the hilarity though - is that the sweet cream ice cream that should've been blended throughout was amusingly the best part to eat just by itself. This goes against the entire point of the ice cream and should have never happened, but the fact that it was the only part of this that tasted good just adds to how truly awful this was. Oh yeah, and this one scoop in a cup was ten dollars. ten. for a single-scoop cup of ice cream. that may be the most expensive ice cream I've ever had. But guys, they have googly eyes!!! Look at how cu- If you line up for this place you should be institutionalized. 1/10

    Anjelica C.

    Food - huge serving & very fresh feeling. the eyes are little candies. when i got to the bottom of mine i think its maybe the plain cream without the mixed in fruit and i actually really liked it. i wish it came in a way smaller portion though because i was struggling to finish this giant cup! worth the price though, just would want a smaller portion for less. Service - excellent! they even have lactaid which really made me laugh. Ambiance - tons of outdoor seating. its right next door to a climbing gym, so would be such a nice treat to yourself after going climbing.

    Myra Y.

    Love the concept of Many Bennies! My kids loved it and enjoyed choosing their own combinations. It is a bit on the pricey side so I would be prepared to share or pay up for each cup/cone.

    Nadeem A.

    Not sure if Many Bennies was unfairly overhyped, or if it really was just meh. I got the Sweet Cream ice cream, blended with strawberry and banana. It wasn't very creamy or sweet. But at least the ice cream was cute with the googley eyes.

    Strawberry and mango
    Evan Z.

    Everytime I go here, it sounds and looks a lot better than it actually is. Many Bennies is a cute outdoor ice cream shop next to SBP in Fremont. Their signature is soft serve ice cream that is fruit flavored. Their blackberry flavor is the most popular and objectively the best ("good" rating); I've also had the blueberry and strawberry which are decent and the mango which is way too sour and not worth getting. You can also customize your ice cream base, though it doesn't make a huge difference for the ice cream imo because I only taste the base at the very bottom. I've had the sweet cream and London fog and both are ok. For me the primary problem with the ice cream is that the fruit flavors aren't super strong and don't taste super fresh compared to other better fruit ice cream I've had. The idea of swirling fruit flavored soft serve is cool but their flavors don't really mix well to create something better. It's also super expensive for soft serve ($8 for cup before tax). There often is a long line and the service is quite slow, so you can end up waiting a long time. The staff are nice but they're prone to mistakes - I asked for strawberry mango but they gave me some random blackberry mix. They ended up remaking it for me which was nice but it's definitely better if that mistake was not made. Regardless, mistakes like these don't really affect my rating of the place. 4.1/5

    Grecia A.

    How could you not like Many Bennies with those googly eyes!! Small menu, good flavors, great vibes. And let's not forget sooooo cute!!!

    Lemon raspberry
    Alyssa L.

    I am not a huge ice cream fan since I'm lactose intolerant but when I heard this place opened up that offered a twist on ice cream, I was intrigued. Many Bennies offers fruit based ice creams, which was a really interesting concept to me so I had to give it a try. We visited on a Tuesday night and it was quite busy even 15 minutes before closing. The ice cream stand had a few seating areas in a covered area right next to a bouldering gym tucked away in a fully residential neighborhood but there was ample street parking. We waited around 5 minutes to order and the staff were really friendly and accommodating even though we visited close to closing time. We ordered the lemon raspberry and sweet cream base and I added strawberry to the lemon raspberry. The ice cream was very creamy and fruity and the presentation was SO CUTE. They also offer free lactaid too!! It cost around $6.50 for each cup of ice cream and it was quite a bit of ice cream too. I couldn't finish the whole cup by myself since the dairy caught up to me but I really like the concept of having fruit based ice cream. Very unique!

    The blackberry was great!
    Marcus D.

    1. Since Many Bennie's opened last year it's been our favorite ice cream place in Seattle. 2. The way they mix the fruit into the ice cream base for each order makes it so refreshing. The fruit flavor is so pure and delicious. 3. The owner is very cool and friendly and so are the staff.

    Earl Gray Soft Serve with Blackberries
    Helen C.

    Many Bennies had been on my try list for a while, but I ultimately thought that the concept was fun, but the texture just wasn't my favorite. I ended up trying the earl gray base with blackberries and blueberries and what I didn't realize is that everything gets blended directly into the base before they serve it to you. Unfortunately, the berries completely overwhelmed the earl gray flavor and I feel like it also impacted the texture so it was a bit too water-y and not that luxurious creaminess that I'm looking for with soft serve. Logistics wise, you'll have to find street parking, but I've never had too much trouble with the residential neighborhood they're in. I went at 7PM before a late-ish dinner reservation on a cold, rainy Saturday, so there weren't too many folks in line. Their seating is technically out doors, but it's covered with plenty of heat lamps, so it was actually pretty warm to the point that I took off my jacket! I think it's fun if you live in the area, but I definitely wouldn't wait in line or go out of my way for it.

    Lemon raspberry base mixed with blueberry and blackberry

    See all

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Best new Ice Cream shop in Seattle! The owner is so friendly and the ice cream is amazingz New go to ice cream spot!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    So good! Very tasty ice cream. Good atmosphere and lots of options. Friendly people. Service was quick even though many people

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 5 of 5

    Many Bennies Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Many Bennies

    My partner and i came around 8:30p and they seemed to have sold out? there was a person at the end…

    yes unfortunately they do. I had to visit multiple times before I could try this place because they would sell out before closing.

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 15,909 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Bottega Italiana - Half chocolate and half stracciatella in a sugar cone

    Bottega Italiana

    4.4(438 reviews)
    2.9 miDowntown
    $$

    Wanted something to balance out the kind of oily dinner I had. This was the perfect refreshing…read moretreat. As much as I wanted something creamy, light & fruity seemed like the way to go. I went with the strawberry fig & they all come with a waffle cookie. Loved that the strawberry flavor was stronger than the fig. So refreshing & it was the perfect thing to end the night.

    I'm visiting Seattle from Los Angeles, and this was the first coffee shop I tried on my trip. I…read moreordered a 12 oz hot mocha latte. About a minute after getting my drink, I took a sip and was surprised that it was cold--not even lukewarm, but actually cold. I didn't go back to ask for a remake because there were several people in line behind me and I didn't want to wait. Instead, I ended up microwaving it when I got back to my Airbnb. The latte itself was decent and had a strong espresso flavor, but the mocha syrup was way too sweet for my taste. I think it would have been much better if it had been about half as sweet. The price was also pretty high for a 12 oz latte. The customer service was disappointing. The young woman who helped me came across as rude and seemed like she didn't want to be there. That's especially unfortunate for a business located in the middle of a major tourist area. As for the drink, I'm not sure how a hot latte ends up being served cold, but it definitely shouldn't happen. I also sampled the tiramisu gelato, which was overly sweet and didn't taste very authentic. Overall, I regret spending the time, money, and calories here. There are too many great coffee shops in Seattle to settle for an experience like this.

    Photos
    Bottega Italiana - Mango and Nutella gelato. Mango was superb!

    Mango and Nutella gelato. Mango was superb!

    Bottega Italiana - Outdoor sitting

    Outdoor sitting

    Bottega Italiana

    See all

    Molly Moon's Homemade Ice Cream - Two scoops. orange creamsicle and matcha strawberry

    Molly Moon's Homemade Ice Cream

    4.2(2.3k reviews)
    2.6 miCapitol Hill
    $$

    What a cute little ice cream shop. I know they have multiple locations, but I still think their…read moreproduct is delicious. I think it's hilarious that they sell lactaid at the counter. So funny. The staff is kind and is more than happy to let you sample to your heart's desire. There is seating both inside and out. I am sure on summer evenings this place is insanely busy, but on a Monday at approximately 2PM, I didn't wait in a line at all. They had fun summer flavors such as apricot crisp, blueberry cheesecake, cherry chunk, and strawberry sorbet. I tried two different flavors, and both were delicious. Both flavors were extremely creamy, even the fruity flavored ones. I started with the strawberry sorbet. It was refreshing. The strawberry really shined through and was extremely fresh tasting. I feel like strawberry flavoring can sometimes come off as artificial, but I did not have that experience with this ice cream. The second flavor I sample, and my favorite one of the day was the honey lavender. It felt like you were walking through an organic lavender field. As always, cities have expensive ice cream, but I am just a girl, so I will get a sweet treat.

    Great place for ice cream!…read more It looks like they make their ice cream here because they have a little viewing window showing them dispensing something into a container (looks like a giant tub of soft serve). Lots of flavors to choose from, including season items that rotate. We all enjoyed the ice cream, especially the kids. It's worth a stop!

    Photos
    Molly Moon's Homemade Ice Cream - Chocolate Joy brownie sundae with a cherry on top

    Chocolate Joy brownie sundae with a cherry on top

    Molly Moon's Homemade Ice Cream - Melted Chocolate and Sweet Cream

    Melted Chocolate and Sweet Cream

    Molly Moon's Homemade Ice Cream - Chocolate Lava Cake Sundae

    See all

    Chocolate Lava Cake Sundae

    Chocolate & Ice Cream Delight

    Chocolate & Ice Cream Delight

    3.7(49 reviews)
    2.8 miDowntown
    $$

    Shakes delight. I…read morewas going to get coffee at Pike's Starbucks and while waiting at the queue I saw the store sign. Everyone gets coffee, I get a shake. Here, they sell more than ice cream. There's one display case that showed nothing but chocolates. Like a See's candy store but without the employees wearing white shirts with black trimming. And it seems all the store on the block sell little things like magnets, carrying bags, pins, or stuffed items. There's a table inside but it's pushed into the corner, so if you're a little big don't be eyeing the chocolates. You can sit with you back facing against it ;p Overall four stars. It's a nice small store that sees plenty of foot traffic. Wish, I could give it five but (and through no fault of her own) service was slow. She was there covering the whole area and it got busy. Don't forget to tip. She worked hard.

    2 girls working and neither wanted to help. I had to ask can I buy something. I asked about the…read moreCarmel. Was selecting was going to get a variety, and asked what is the price per pound or ? Rudely said $3.50 each. So the 2 I started with I said ohhh ok just the 2 I had picked. So $7 for 2 small Carmels. And I guess the 50 cents extra was added for ‍the girl was rude. So 7.50 for 2 very small Carmels. I'm all for supporting small business, but no prices listed kinda made me feel they gouge me on prices. And being it was a tourist location I guess that's what they do. The 2 girls working maybe just having a bad day. I was the only customer in the shop. But neither wanted to look up and help me at first. But at least the Carmel was good.

    Photos
    Chocolate & Ice Cream Delight
    Chocolate & Ice Cream Delight
    Chocolate & Ice Cream Delight

    See all

    Hello Robin - Strawberry ice cream  Seasonal Cherry chocolate chunk    Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies (V)

    Hello Robin

    4.5(871 reviews)
    2.4 miCapitol Hill
    $$

    Cookies and ice cream are some of my favorite treats. Anything s'mores is my number one favorite!…read moreSo when I saw they had ice cream and a s'mores cookie, I had to go. The shop is cute and nearby a park to enjoy it if it's a nice day outside. Staff were friendly and helpful. I love that you can make an ice cream sandwich with two different cookies. I grabbed the s'mores cookie and the orange habanero because it sounded amazing. And it was. I do not remember what ice cream I got, but it was good. It's a meal-sized cookie sandwich, but it's worth it. I will definitely be taking guests here when they come to visit!

    3.5 stars. Hello Robin is a cute neighborhood cookie bakery on Capitol Hill. The location was…read morecalm and quiet with some street parking available, but easy to get to by bus as well. Inside, it was fun to see the more open kitchen floor plan where I imagine it is entertaining to watch the baking in action. As for the cookies themselves, my partner and I got the open-faced ice cream sandwiches, one orange habanero chocolate chip cookie with vanilla ice cream and one lemon poppyseed drizzle with blackberry cobbler ice cream. I felt that the flavors of both cookies were good, and I enjoyed the added crunch of the topping sugar and light spice in the habanero chocolate chip cookie. However both cookies felt fairly dry, with the ice cream doing little to help. The Molly Moon's ice cream flavors were pretty good, but generally this is just not my favorite ice cream in the city. The service was good, nothing much to touch on for that topic.

    Photos
    Hello Robin - Limited seating interior

    Limited seating interior

    Hello Robin - Where the magic happens

    Where the magic happens

    Hello Robin - Cookie dough + pumpkin chocolate chip

    See all

    Cookie dough + pumpkin chocolate chip

    Many Bennies - icecream - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...