Best Philly cheesesteak outside of Philly. Lived in Philly 25 years ago, and have been looking for the perfect sandwich ever since, and it lives in New Braunfels Texas. Soft roll, perfect balance of meat and mushrooms, thank you for the addition of the provolone and the garlic aioli . Fantastic owner, friendly, fast and very well priced. We'll be looking for excuses to try everything on the menu on every road trip now. Thank you so much! read more

We were in the mood for something new and came across this cheesesteak business. It had great reviews so we decided to try it out. The location is somewhat easy to find and the parking is decent. Once inside the small business the board in the back has all the menu options and description of each item. I ended up ordering the Meat Lovers Cheesesteak w/ Spice it Up and my girlfriend ordered the Classic Italian. The price was decent and they offered Military Discount. Once the food came out it looked delicious and it tasted great! A lot of flavor and the sauce that came with my Philly tasted great! Will most likely come back to try other options. read more

See all

The variety of cheesesteaks is incredible and also other types as well. The one I ate, which was the meat lovers was delicious. Very flavorful and cooked to order. The person that took our order was quite lovely, made sure we were good and checked if the food was to our liking. The restaurant itself is on the small side so a large group might be difficult but from what I saw you can order in advance and pick up the food. Overall Marco Polo is a good choice for cheesesteaks. read more

This is our go to Sandwich shop before the river! Locally owned and freshly cooked Cheesesteaks and sandwiches to order. The service is always friendly! read more

We had the meat and cheese and it was delicious. My daughter had a cheesesteak with mushrooms, onions, peppers and cheese and she said it was really yummy. Try this place out. You will not be disappointed read more

Great Philly Cheesesteak. I added extra meat but should have also added extra cheese. Very good but even better if a little more seasoning on the beef. Yummy. read more

Ordered the Wiz sub and we got bell peppers and onions. Only a few pieces of meat! Bread was so soggy like it was mushroom soup with the veggies. First time there and will never be back. Check your sandwich before you leave. read more

I found this little place 3 weeks ago and have had lunch here at least once a week since. I've told friends and brought in coworkers and they all agree these sandwiches are great! Friendly staff and really good Philly Cheesesteak! I keep telling myself I'll have something different but it's hard not to get that cheesesteak! read more

Best Cheesesteak I've ever had!! Too bad we aren't local. Service was great too. Got our sandwiches to go. read more

Marco Polo Philly Cheesesteaks - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

Stopped in here by pure happenstance. From the outside it had some character that intrigued me. I was quickly greeted and surprised by such a large sandwich menu. I had the originally Philly. The garlic aioli was a pleasant addition and took the sandwich to a higher level. The seasoned curly fries were hot and fresh. In the area foe the next two weeks I am sure to stop in again. It was that good I must come back again. read more

Marco Polo Philly Cheesesteaks - Philly steak and fries - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

The service was amazing! The lady who was behind the counter was very nice and friendly. My partner and I decided to eat there which was cozy. I ordered the rosemary turkey panini which was small and just okay. I wished I had gotten the cheesesteak sandwich instead. My partner loved his sandwich and said he would definitely go back to have another. I would not go back to have another panini!!! I do plan on going back to try the cheesesteak! Oh and the soda!!! Wth those were so small, kid sized or half regular size. Definitely not worth it on that. read more

Marco Polo Philly Cheesesteaks - Real Philly Cheesesteak - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

Pretty good food. Trying to do too much in the space. Service was on point. Food was good and made fresh in front of you. Could use an exhaust hood to carry the smoke outside. read more

Ordered this through DoorDash and I was absolutely blown away at how much flavor my sandwich had. The garlic aoli is amazing! I wish I could remember the sandwich I ordered but it was so good! I will definitely be coming here for sandwiches again! read more

This restaurant is a gem! The sandwich I had was incredible - fresh, flavorful, and the bread perfectly cooked. Highly recommend!

Don't miss this gem. This is the best sandwich spot in New Braunfels. We get this to go, but WORTH it. read more

The food was super good and the service was great. Both the chicken panini and chicken cheesesteak were amazing.

We've been waiting a long while to try this place and we were so disappointed. Got a Philly and the chicken saltimboca and neither of them tasted like anything really. No seasoning whatsoever, not sure how that's possible when everything was on there. Also fries tastes like stale frozen fries and they were so expensive for the tiny amount you get. The only thing that was good was the aioli which I'm glad we ordered to add some flavor to everything else. I don't know if it was a one off kinda day but we won't be giving it a second chance. read more

Went in for lunch today after living here for a year driving by the place and never stopping! If you haven't given this place a try you definitely should! I didn't get her name but the lady behind the counter (I assumed the owner) was very nice and checked on us multiple times, also got the Wiz cheesesteak cause DUH and it was so good! Will definitely be coming back. read more

Great sandwiches, lots of Philly style variations. Hostess that takes care of you with a mom's kitchen vibe as you get drinks from the fridge. read more

I ordered a Panini after lunch rush. Only two employees and no customers were there and my food was still cold. The cheese wasn't melted and the chicken wasn't heated up before they put my sandwich in the press. Also they had it diced up so because the cheese wasn't melted to hold it all together all my chicken fell out. They just didn't put any care not my food very sad. The fries were the worst I've had in a long time. I asked for the sauce on the side and the sauce was delicious but not the pesto aioli that was supposed to come on my sandwich. Very disappointing and I could have spent my $15 with no beverage somewhere else read more

I love this place! Honestly, I don't think there is another phillysteak shop on New Braunfels! My husband and I go here all the time. We typically order over the phone and come by to pick up. Pair your sandwich with curly fries and you are set. The lady who typically takes our orders is super friendly and always gives us a side of white sauce for the sandwiches. They are also quick too. If you call in your order it only takes about 10 mins to make your sandwich and it is always warm when you pick it up. The shop also sells Italian ice. So if you are ever craving anything sweet, this is the perfect place to go! Looking forward to our next visit! read more

Marco Polo Philly Cheesesteaks - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

Happened to stop in here on a whim. The owner was so kind and nice the entire time I was there. I was the only one in the place as I got there right after they opened. Instead of sitting in silence awkwardly, she chatted with me the whole time and shared her story! So this particular sandwich was just a simple, well done staple. Nothing too fancy, but the flavors were on point. The house garlic aioli really made it yummy. The bread on this sandwich was so soft and fresh as well... needless to say, I ate the whole darn thing. Can't wait to take my husband back and get an Italian... seriously I just want to try it all! read more

Marco Polo Philly Cheesesteaks - Mushroom Steak - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

Place is very small. So if you want to dine in, they have maybe 3 tables. Service was excellent. Menu on wall clearly legible. I had the wiz steak. Sandwich was average size but tasted a bit dry. I added some white sauce that came with my sandwich which i think was Aioli sauce and made it less dry. The meat was very unseasoned. read more

Marco Polo Philly Cheesesteaks - Wiz steak - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

Very very good!!!! Done well and fast, a friendly place!!!! I recommend to all. A hidden treasure

Surprised to arrive at Noon on a Wed with only one other table. The interior is small, only five tables. I think they probably have alot of to go orders. The aroma inside of delicious peppers and baked bread already let me know that the food would be good and omg it was! I had the philly cheesesteak and loved it. It has been here for 12 years and I can't believe this was only my first time. If it wasn't for Yelp I would not even know about this place. The owner lady was so nice and friendly. I will totally be going back to try other stuff on the menu. read more

Nice staff! Cool little Restaurant, but the Philly was lacking. The bread was fresh & yummy but the sandwich needed more steak, and better flavor. read more

Reminds me of Genos from back home in Phil. Great Italian ice as well! A true hidden gem in NBTX. read more

Marco Polo Philly Cheesesteaks - a hand holding a cup of ice cream - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

The food was good it could have been a little better but not bad at all. Will still be coming back

I was in town for work and Marco Polo Philly Cheesesteaks was close by so I gave it a shot. I love a good Cheesesteak... This place is small. Maybe seating for 7 to 10 patrons. The food was just ok. I had a Cheesesteak ( see pic I attached) and curly fries. the bread or bun was fresh and to me was th beat part of the Cheesesteak. It was light on meat and heavy on onions and peppers. The seasoning was bland and the cheese whiz was too thin. Lastly was the cost. For the Cheesesteak, small curly fries and a soda it was 15 bucks. Maybe just an off day. The staff was friendly and the service was prompt. read more

Made a special trip because of reviews and name. The lady working there was polite and promptly took our order. I ordered a cheesesteak specifically asking to use "American" cheese and grilled jalapeño peppers. Well, the sandwich came out with what appeared to be mozzarella or provolone cheese, and so many peppers, you could barely see the meat. As far as "philly's" go, this is nowhere near even an average cheesesteak. At best it was a hoagie of some sort that didn't taste very good. Again, the lady working there was very nice and courteous but the "philly cheese steak" was mislabeled (it doesn't resemble a philly to me) and order came out wrong..If you are looking to try out new places for a cheesesteak, unless something has changed, don't go here IMO. read more

They do one thing and they do it very, very well. Served hot and delicious. I would like to try something out of the cold sandwich menu, but the hot ones are so good, I can't actually bring myself to do it. Maybe I can summon the courage up one day. read more

Fresh and made to order! The Philly cheesesteak is amazing on a homemade loaf. A few times they have given me a side of ranch to go with it which is yummy. I finally was able to pull away from the Philly and try the Italian sub. It was very good, but I have had better when in Jersey. I need to try the other sandwiches they offer. Their desserts look good and there are plenty of other sandwiches to try. I just wish they were open for dinner. read more

Love the rosemary Turkey panini! I come every time I'm in town! The location can be hard to get to but it's worth it! read more

This place use to be great but the Philly I just got didn't have near the meat it has had in the past. And be warned if you ask for hot peppers that all your going to taste. We added them to to all 3 sandwich's and it was way to much. Picture below. They usually cut the sandwhich but only cut one this time. Maybe they were really busy. Still good just be careful if you add peppers. read more

Marco Polo Philly Cheesesteaks - Peppers had to be scrapped off. - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

We got the regular Philly cheesesteak & the Wiz. Both were great and the garlic aioli served on the side was awesome. If you're in the mood for cheesesteaks, 10/10 would recommend. Parking & indoor seating is limited. The door at the back of the restaurant is to a skateboard shop, FYI! Go to the front read more

The sandwiches here are crazy good!! There are tons of options. So why the 4 stars and not 5? The french fries were still partly frozen when they brought them out to us. I was pretty bummed about this, because I was super excited about the fries vs chips option. For 2 sandwiches, with fries, a beer and bottled water, it was about $35. A little pricey, but the sandwiches and aioli sauce they serve up with them, is totally worth it. We'll certainly go back, but I'm hoping for a warmer batch of french fries next time though. read more

Excellent paninis, perfectly toasted, great meats. You must ask for the house aioli to put on all your sandwiches. They highly suggest it. There are only two pieces of equipment in this whole place, a small 24 inch flat top with a very small Hood and a small double Panini Press. That's why there are no fries in this place, simple and efficient restaurant. My wedding cake Italian Ice was smooth and creamy. Since this is half-price Tuesdays that's why I got the panini; but while there, somebody got a cheesesteak, and it looked absolutely juicy overstuffed and steaming right off the grill. read more

See all

The cheesesteaks at Marco Polo are very delicious. The bread is very soft on the inside, and very light. The steak is cooked very well and the toppings are delicious! Definitely add the garlic aïoli to your sandwich. I would recommend this cheesesteak shop to anybody in New Braunfels looking for a quality cheesesteak. read more

Loved this place! I tried the jersey sub and it was so good. My boyfriend tried the meat lovers and he loved it. We live right up the road and will definitely be coming back to explore the rest of the menu. The paninis look great too! read more

I got a fabulous cheese steak today! Hot and fresh. Flavorfull beef and green peppers, gooey cheese. I will be going back!