Wow, this pizza place is like California Pizza Kitchen on crack...tons of awesome pizza flavors,…read morefun sides and great service! Inside is homey and has a nice rustic, woodsy yet modern, edgy style. This isn't your average pizza joint...It's a special little nook of heaven. Ordered a medium cheese pizza with sausage, extremely twisted sticks, kickin' chicken (chicken marinated in a spicy ginger Thai sauce, peanuts, green onions, Swiss, Fontina, fresh cilantro, mozzarella, peanut sauce and shredded carrots) and a small baseline garden salad with ranch dressing. Baseline came out first and was a very generous size for a small. Every ingredient, the tomatoes, onions, lettuce, carrots and croutons were fresh and crafted to perfection. The ranch was a nice texture and flavor. Next came the Extreme Twisted Sticks, cheese sticks with marinara. Only downside is that the marinara was cold, but the twists were nicely baked with ooey-gooey cheese inside. Next came the pizzas. Each pizza had a nice thin-ish crust, crispy and nicely salted, with generous toppings on each slice. You can tell that the people who make these items care about what goes out to the customer. We loved our time there and even our friends from New York said that they loved this pizza...and that says a lot! We can't wait to go back.

Food mad great, lots of choices and the salad was fantastic! Prices seem fair and atmosphere is…read moregreat... this place has minimal tables and chairs great for a party of 6 or less! Excellent choice for pizza and friendly great service!

The atmosphere, the wine, and the pizza were absolute perfection. We sat outside on a beautiful…read morespring day enjoying glasses of Tempranillo and Sangiovese - rich, smooth, and perfectly balanced. The pizza was next level, and honestly, choosing what to order was the hardest part because every option sounded incredible. The service was excellent, with kind, welcoming, and knowledgeable staff who made the entire experience even better. A perfect spot for great food, great wine, and a relaxing afternoon.

Service was horrible. Food was sub par. I would never go back. Ambience was great. Took 45 minutes…read morefor a Blt and mini pancakes.

Bad service and food completely overpriced. Don't waste your…read moretime. The owner, waiter, and bartenders are on drugs so don't bother. Every time is a disappointment. Chrissi and Alex are the bartenders I've had the worst experience with. Jared is the owner, he's off the hinges. I live across the street and have given multiple opportunities to see if they change out of convenience, it never changes, just bottom of the barrel

This place would have gotten five stars on food alone but I absolutely HAVE to do a review due to…read morethe service we received!! To start our visit, we walked in and had two friendly smiles waiting! They allowed us time to look over the menu without making us feel like we were taking too long in any way. Ordered our pizza (Everything with some modifications) and got sat down. The atmosphere was inviting and fun! Lots of Bob Marley, Jimi Hendrix and that type of decor all over, music playing but not so loud we couldn't have a conversation with our friends. Even had someone offer us the remainder of their pitcher of beer! When our pizzas were brought out, we noticed that ours was missing the pepperoncinis we had ordered to sub for the mushrooms and onions we removed. Not a big deal-- hubby went and asked if we could just get them on the side. The young man working offered to remake the entire pizza (large)! Told him that wasn't necessary, side was fine. A little bit later, he came to our table and said "I know one of you was mentioning the Monkey Balls (pull apart dessert!). I'd like to give you an order because of the mess up". While that was so not necessary, it was very much appreciated and shows a level of hospitality that isn't seen a lot nowadays! Pizza was amazing and the Monkey Balls were to die for! Both were baked perfectly in our opinion-- oftentimes pizza is way overdone for us when we eat out. Pizza toppings were plentiful and tasted delicious. The Monkey Balls were covered perfectly with cinnamon sugar and the cream cheese icing spread all over the top-- even my picky husband liked them! We live in Boise so this location was about a half hour drive for us, but we WILL be coming back when our kids come to visit!

This might be our new go-to delivery place. Super friendly, service has been quick, and the pizza…read moreis always fresh, tasty and the price point is great too. We also love the pizza twists, and feel like they are a must try if you are ordering. We haven't gone to the location, so can't speak on the ambiance, but we would definitely go check them out in person just based on the quality of their delivery. It's not the best pizza we have ever had, but it's good and a great option for a game night or movie night with the teens for sure.

This is pretty much the only pizza place I get pizza from and it's always great! I typically call…read morefor pick and the employees that take my order are wonderful. (Might need to fix the poor call connection)

Went there last Thursday and the pizza was delicious. The atmosphere was very inviting also.read more

Best pizza I've ever had out tastes every spot in Idaho no questions asked so if your looking for…read morea very good pizza spot this is the spot

The veggie pizza needs some adjustments:…read more When I ordered garlic on my pizza, I expected it to be fresh garlic. It was canned, minced garlic piled on to my pizza. It was nasty. I use that stuff for cooking but would never put it raw on my pizza. There are giant pieces of raw tomato and artichoke hearts. These should be thinly sliced and baked in the oven with the other veggies. Instead they were just thrown on so I picked them off to eat the pizza. Please use real garlic and use cooked ingredients for your veggie pizza and I will come back. Thank you!

Good food, pizza loaded with topics. A little on mom the pricier side but still good.read more

Poppy's pizza is decent pizza, better than Garbonzo's. It's pricing is perfect and it's located in…read morea good place

What a great little local place for take and bake pizza! I've been greeted with a friendly hello…read moreevery time I've come here. Everyone has been patient with my questions, they offer a deal every day of the week and their prices are reasonable! I ordered the Viking pizza and one-topping sausage, both medium for $22. I placed my order an hour in advance and when I arrived for pick up, they were ready to go with instructions on how to cook when I get home. Both pizzas baked up as instructions indicated; we pulled off the baking round (that comes with it) for the last few minutes of baking to crisp up the crust. It's obvious that each pizza is made with care, each ingredient looks hand made. We were honestly kind of surprised at the level of freshness we had in each bite. The sauce had a spicier tang than I'm used to, but it was also hearty and a perfect complement to each topping. The Viking is a "must have"! I would prefer a thicker crust but I can forgive that since this pizza tasted great overall. Do not pass this place up.

What a delightful find! My mom recently moved to Nampa so I'm exploring restaurants in totally new…read moreneighborhoods. The Rustic Oven in Middleton is in the corner of a strip mall next to a very clean, organized Idaho Yourh Ranch. But back to the food... They specialize in sandwiches--hot and cold--and baked goods. Since my time with my mom is special, I go a little extra each time. So we started with a Nutella roll. Holy heck. It was amazing. Kinda like the best chocolate chip cookie you've ever eaten. I got one to-go for my daughter too. My mom ate half of her pastrami sandwich so she could have another treat! She picked out a Huckleberry cream cheese pasty. So good, but so rich. I enjoyed my roast beef hot recommended by the delightful hostess, Avah. Her pride in their many offerings was evident. We took home the rest of our sandwiches. But right when she got home, my mom wanted the rest of her pastrami. I know she was full but it was that good that she had to finish it while it was still fresh. That's quite a testimonial. The Rustic Oven will be our new go-to place! PS: In Yelp, it's mistakenly described as a food truck. Avah explained that they used to offer pizza via a food truck, but that was years ago.

Sandwiches are really good and desserts. Love the inside but could use more seating and more…read morecomfortable seating. The service was wonderful. Very kind and helpful. For sure going back just might eat at a park or home.

Great wine with amazing views in Idaho friendly and knowledgeable server. Will returnread more

We were so pleasantly surprised that they served food along with their wine and one our favorites…read morebeer Mother Earth! We came for a Jazz Under the Stars event and had such a great time. The service was good and the vineyard atmosphere was perfect. Watching the sunset while we drank our delicious wine. I recommend the Malbec "Papas"

We usually do deilvery…read more Alawys courteous driver. Amazing pizza. Great cinnamon bites.

We have friends in Caldwell that think their Garbanzo's has great pizza. We decided to come over…read morefrom Star and try the Middleton location. It was a Monday night about 5:45 pm. There were very few people in the restaurant. However, they seem to do a great takeout and delivery business. There were probably 6-7 people working, and it seemed like it might be a family operated restaurant. the Interior is basic wood tables and we sat on a kind of pew bench. Comfortable. There is not great lighting, and the salad bar does not have any light over it, so it is difficult to see what you are grabbing. The young man that helped us with our order was nice and friendly. We ordered a medium pepperoni pie and two salad bars. The salad bar wasn't bad but it wasn't great, either, though I did like the bleu cheese dressing. We sat and ate our salad, then waited for the pizza. The tall, blond woman that brought out our pizza just put it on the table and walked away, unsmiling. Later, we noticed her smiling and joking with the other workers. They all seemed to have a good time, but they weren't paying any attention to the customers. The pizza was hot, the pepperoni ample, and the cheese melted. The flavor was just OK, as was the crust, which is something other reviewers seem to really like. When we finished, we said thank you to everyone working behind the counter, but not one person looked at us or said anything. Maybe they didn't even notice us. We have a few pizza places in Star. I think we'll just do takeout in Star, or go to one of our favored places in Eagle or Meridian.