We went here back in 1986 when it first opened. Still great!! Had the Greek salad and coleuses…read morePizza on wheat. Salad was perfect and great quality ingredients, dressing was spot on. Pizza was what we remembered!! Lots of cheese and we could not stop eating. Wine selection was great too!! The server made it exceptional!! Perfect service and we had 5 people. We were so impressed. Sat outside on a perfect evening. Wife did say the woman's bathroom was scary. All in all a great place to eat and people watch.

Perfect pizza all around!! The buffalo Chicken one of the best!…read more Service hit the mark too even though it was sooo crowded at 4:45 pm!

Wow! This was some of the best pizza I've ever had! The crust was so flavorful and buttery, and…read moretheir flavor combinations are amazing! I ordered the Thai with chicken instead of shrimp, and the sauce on it was FANTASTIC. My mom and brother are gluten free, and they said their gluten free pizza crust was the best gluten free crust that they had ever had. I would HIGHLY recommend and can't wait to come back!

How I wanted to like this pizza. But unfortunately, I was not impressed…read more The staff is super friendly and the service was very quick. It also has a nice vibe. I plan to try them one more time and hopefully I have a better experience. I do not plan on getting the pizza because to me the crust tasted like cardboard.

Puccini's has great tasting food no matter what you get. I've been going here for years and I've…read moretried just about everything. My favorite is the Diablo shrimp with angel hair spaghetti noodles. It's just the best and it comes with a big salad and bread. The bread is amazing too. If you're looking for something spicy ask them to make it "hot", but be prepared because it's HOT ! The place is very clean and the staff are friendly and welcoming. The restaurant fills up quickly so come early. Don't worry about finding a parking spot. There's tons of parking. Their prices are very reasonable. So if you love good Italian cuisine at a great price, then this is your new home.

Pucchini's was once my favorite pizza place, but my visit this week to this location was…read moredisappointing. I stopped for lunch with my husband. The service was less than friendly. The hostess sat us without a word of welcome. Our server was abrupt with us to the point that I couldn't even tell him that the ice tea was undrinkable. The water is awful and the ice tea tasted like old coffee. The food came out ok. My salad was ok except for the wilted tomato on top. I like the mustard vinaigrette dressing. The pepperoni pizza was ok too. It took 20 minutes to get our bill to check out. Attempts to flag down our server failed. I probably won't return to this location.

We love Bella Pizzeria for neighborhood pizza delivered through DoorDash. It arrived with the…read morecheese still nice and melty.

Idk we used to love Bella for NY style slices with a little flop so you can fold it if needed…read more Tonight the pizza and salad both seemed different and I didn't enjoy either. The antipasto salad was my fave and it used to have cold rolled up sliced ham and white cheese (provolone or mozz?) along with olives, pepperocini, onion etc and tonight it was a lot of salami and pepperoni, no cheese so the salad is now just too overpowering spicy with the cured meats and brined items, there's no balance. The pizza today seemed overdone from how it used to be. The underside and crust were crunchy and dry, it used to be chewy and softer. Bummed bc this was a favorite spot but I'm not excited to eat hard pizza or spicy salad either again as it seems like both have changed.

King dough has very goo food, but it is pretty expensive and they have also forgotten many…read morecomponents of my orders over the time I have ordered with them.

We kept hearing good things about this place. So, we decided to try it and we were glad we did…read more We ordered the Big Boy pizza. It comes with red sauce, aged mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, Peppadew peppers, and red onion. Very, very tasty and the pizza dough was excellent. It reminded me of the pizza I used to have back in New York. The prices were reasonable and the staff were very friendly and helpful. The restaurant was very clean and there's lots of parking. You have to try this place if you are a pizza lover. You can't go wrong. One thing I noticed that's a little frustrating is you cannot access the restaurants menu in the YELP app. I hope someone can resolve this issue.

Why was this pizza crust crispier than the nyc pizzas I've had…read moreCrust 9/10 The amount of toppings is balanced for me. Just wish there was more hot honey and their proteins are on the salty side. Overall, it was yummy, and I like their tomato sauce a lot, very tangy

I LOVE pizza, but unfortunately this one just isn't for me. Visually, it's a work of art, but for…read moremy taste, the flavor didn't live up to how great it looked. The last thing I want to do is disagree with a positive Portnoy (my hero) review, On my first visit, the pizza was overdone. This time, it was cooked perfectly, so that wasn't the issue. Even with the perfect bake, the flavor just didn't click. That doesn't mean it's bad pizza. Clearly a lot of people love it, and I can appreciate the quality and craftsmanship.

Josh was an amazing server and the pizza was amazing!! This location never disappoints!!! Josh…read morerocks!

Once again, Noble Roman's excels at disappointing me. I come here about once or twice a year just…read moreto be let down. I ordered online from the parking lot, and selected curbside valet. After about 10 minutes, I moved into a valet parking space. I was the ONLY car in the valet parking spaces. Not hard to notice the ONE CAR waiting in the valet spots, right? WRONG! I waited... And waited... And waited... I only saw two other people come and go with pizzas. I was watching the guy near the oven and it didn't seem like he was busy. Finally about 10 to 15 minutes after my pizza should have been done, I decided to walk inside. Sure enough, there was one pizza box sitting on the rack all by itself. Someone walked over from the bar area to help me. The guy behind the pizza station didn't even make eye contact with me. I asked if the pizza on the rack was mine, and OF COURSE IT WAS! The only pizza in the building, and nobody bothered to check to see if it was a curbside valet order while a car was parked in the curbside valet area. My pizza had been sitting there getting cold. I told the lady I had been outside for over 20 minutes and she just said have a nice night. Nothing else. I went home after working 17 hour shift and ate my already-cold pizza. This place is total joke. I thought maybe it had been long enough since my last visit that they might have hired some competent people, but I way overestimated this business.

Best pizza in the Indy suburbs! Order ahead online and schedule a pick up, you won't be…read moredisappointed. Our go-to order is the vodka sausage pizza, it's delectable. The pizzas are made fresh to order so anticipate a wait if you go to eat at the restaurant. We find ordering ahead is the best way to get the pizza when you want it.

Firstly, I want to say that the food was outstanding. I ordered $200 worth of pizza for a party,…read moreand every single pizza was fantastic. Our guests absolutely loved it, and the quality exceeded our expectations. Unfortunately, the service during pickup was disappointing. My mother-in-law picked up the order for us and told me there were several employees standing behind the counter talking while she loaded all five pizzas herself. No one offered to help carry the pizzas or even hold the door open for her as she made multiple trips outside in the pouring rain. I don't typically leave a tip on carryout orders, but because this was such a large order, I made a point to tip. It was disappointing to hear that despite that, no one offered such a simple act of assistance. While I wasn't expecting anyone to carry the pizzas to the car, holding the door open or asking if she needed a hand would have gone a long way. I wanted to bring this to your attention because the food was truly excellent, and I'd like to continue ordering from Pizza Uncommon in the future. I hope you'll share this feedback with your team so that future customers--especially those placing large carryout orders--receive the same level of care in service that they do in the quality of the food.