A great authentic Italian spot just a few blocks away from Dorney Park!!! If you want real pizza and Italian sandwiches this is your place! The pizza came out hot, cheesy and yummy. The sandwiches were all delicious! The combination of flavors meshed well in both the cheesesteaks and chicken Cesar sandwiches. The portions are big too so if you're hungry this is the place! My family enjoyed the food and had enough to eat the next day! For a group of 9, they accommodated us very well. I appreciate the service my family received here. Will definitely be returning on my next trip to Dorney! read more

See all

While the taste and ingredients are very good their menu is not quite accurate to the product. The Large cheesesteak claims to be 14" but it was barely 12". Not a huge deal but misleading. read more

See all

We enjoyed our meal at Mario's Pizza Cafe. I had the Philly Cheesesteak and my brother had the Lobster Ravioli, and both were good. read more

See all

Great pizza and fast delivery. Pizza didn't have excess any one ingredient and just the right balance. Definitely would get again if I'm in town visiting! read more

Best pizza in Allentown that I've had so far, hands down. The dough most of the time has a great hold and great bite. The sauce and quality of cheese is on point. read more

Mario's Pizza Cafè - Look at the hold. Look at the thin crust supporting that load. You won't find much better dough construction than Mario's. - Pizza Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

Absolutely the most fantastic pizza in the valley!! Had the pepperoni overload large pizza with the large Marios salad. Got the pizza well done which they do well. read more

Mario's Pizza Cafè - Pepperoni overload pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

See all

Prompt service, great sauce, fresh ingredients. Marios has been my go to place for pizza, calzones and Stromboli for years read more

Called and ordered delivery while I was working in the area. I ordered spaghetti with marinara sauce, which came with garlic bread and a side salad, and I also ordered a few garlic knots. I was able to pay and tip on my card while on the phone. My food arrived sooner than estimated, and I could tell when it arrived because I could smell that yummy garlic when I was stepping out of my office. The pasta was a nice big portion, the garlic bread was good, and the garlic knots were filling on their own. The side salad had the Caesar dressing that I requested, and the pasta had the side of Parmesan that I was looking forward to, as well. For Italian takeout, Mario's is definitely one that I would recommend to anyone to order from. The quality is a bit above average than what I expected from this kind of place. I'd order from them again if in the area and hungry! read more

See all

Spaghetti & beef meatballs in housemade tomato sauce with side salad and garlic bread pretty good. Clean restaurant with good atmosphere. read more

Pizza was okay, but they had BS Fox News on the whole time and the volume all the way up. (Like so loud that I could hear it perfectly over my AirPods on full volume). Talk about alienating half of your customers. And sitting inside listening to those insane lies and pathetic people made me want to barf. So food gets 3 stars, but the fact that they're Trumpie brainwashed brings it down to 2 at best. read more

Great pizza and cheese steaks !! Stopped here on our way home from seeing family in Carlisle. Almost didn't stop here because of the 3 star average. I'm glad I dug deeper and read some reviews. This place passed the pizza test and we consider ourselves experts !! Great find and I highly recommend when in the area ! read more

The food was tasty, the people were nice, it's just a very fun place. Not much else to say, I'd eat here again!

Mario's pizza likely serves the best pizza available in the Lehigh valley. Leftovers actually taste better when reheated in the oven a day or 2. I saw a dozen soccer players inhale 4 or 5 pies in less than 20 minutes. You have to check this place out. read more

Perfection!! Delicious food, order accuracy, nice employees, fair prices, quick delivery. Sauce is amazing. Thank you Mario's.

Have had a few problems with orders not being delivered at the given time. I know Fridays can be busy but it took two hours for it to get to us. Guy who runs it is clueless. read more

Food is solid, always hot. Cheesesteaks are bomb. I also like their garlic knots and pizza

This little independent pizzeria is really good, we are just traveling and heard about it, my son is loving it, pizza Dough is just right, ingredients taste fresh and I totally recommended, service is awesome too read more

Mario's Pizza Cafè - Pizza Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

Very good! The owner is very nice and prompt. Food is great so far. I've been here twice and has been delicious both times. Pizzas are sold by the slice and are heated up and brought to you. My friend ordered the same thing and enjoyed it. We ate outside. Employees all wore masks. read more

Mario's Pizza Cafè - Pizza by the Slice. Cheese on left. Right is pesto, mozzarella, tomato, chicken. Delicious - Pizza Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

See all

Ordered food for my in-laws and son on a busy Friday and when I went to pick it up they told me they had lost it. How do you lose a to go order? read more

I ordered from here cuz it was approximately 45 minutes before my lunch and I didn't want to risk being late. I figured since the restaurant is literally a mile from the job and I had an uncomplicated order, that would be sufficient time to get my food. I was wrong. Delivery took an hour and 15 minutes and what I was got was a horrible excuse for a steak sandwich. Plus it didn't have any sauce even though I ordered it with sauce on it. read more

Mario's Pizza Cafè - Horrible excuse for a steak sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

Great atmosphere and people ! Wonderful pizza! They were quick and polite. Price was about the same as most. The buffalo pizza was tasty and the cheese pizza was on point. read more

Absolutely awful. Ordered a cheesesteak and pizza for delivery. I got a burnt pizza and garlic bread. Called to complain and spoke to the owner. His response was to say sorry, it is a busy night and hung up....???? Never again!! read more

One of the worst meals I've ever had. I had three options to choose from that delivered to my hotel, and boy, did I choose poorly. Pasta fagioli soup was completely tasteless, and it had been microwaved in the styrofoam container they sent it in. The container was warped and puffed out, very obviously reheated. This is not only lazy but also potentially toxic. Even if I had wanted to, I could not eat it at all, as the container literally began to disintegrate in my hands and had to be dumped into the trash. Fried calamari was rubbery and the marinara was just OK. I can't really judge a place by a fried item that's been delivered, but I don't expect this is much better freshly made. Mario salad was absolutely drenched in water. They made no attempt to drain it or dry it before putting it into the clamshell salad box. Just gross. I ordered from here expecting your average suburban pizzeria fare. What I got was way, way, way below average. If you're staying in Allentown and it's one of your options, get the Chinese instead. read more

I ordered a pizza with pepperoni, meatballs, olives, mushrooms. It is a great pizza at a fair price. I'm very satisfied with my purchase and it definitely is better than the pizza hut couple doors down. read more

I usually like this place. Ordered delivery for lunch. Came quick - good. Ordered FF, poppers and a cheesesteak pizziola with mushrooms. First I get a call, they have no mushrooms, okay, that's fine, peppers and pickles are fine - no sauce no onions. Gentleman with accent on phone yelling back and forth to someone in shop, then okay. Cheesesteak gets here, sauce on cheesesteak. I can live with that. Poppers were pathetic, dried out and small - for 4.75 - definitely not worth it. One hardly had cheese in it. Note not to order that here again. French fries were good, but seriously can't really screw them up unless you burn or send them raw. May have to take this place off the list of lunch choices. read more

Great Stromboli The size is huge. I thought it was a personal size but it could feed like 5 people read more

We were waiting for our reservation in the restaurant next door but decided to grab a veggie stromboli and garlic knots while we waited. Both were phenomenal; the veggies were really fresh and the crust was crispy and delicious. read more

Awesome customer service!! Love the food as well, garlic bread was so fresh and the pasta and cheese fries are awesome!!!!!! Definitely come here if you want good food and even better service. read more

28 Oct 2018** Went with a group totaling seven. I had a medium chicken steak calzone, expecting to take half home for a second meal. One other person ordered a small calzone. The other five were done eating their sandwiches/ meals before our calzones even arrived. The calzone was mostly bread. I had to cut twenty five percent off one end before getting to the ingredients inside. This was the same on both ends of the calzone. This leaves the middle half to actually eat with product other than bread. The chicken was not seasoned and was in a big lump in the middle. the other ingredients, onions etc., where on either side of the chicken in dense quantities. This was not a properly made calzone, neither mix of ingredients or in flavor. The bathroom was clean but dark. It appeared they had a twenty five watt, perhaps a forty watt light bulb, in the brown/tan tiled bathroom. It looked like a cave. The others in our group had sandwiches and I did not ask about the quality of their food. read more

That girl behind the counter who is tall and has glasses with the anger issues is chill. 10/10 would marry 10/10 would recommend 10/10 great student 10/10 anger issues the food was k. but the service was fine af read more

Ordered a pizza here today and it was good. Nothing about it blew me away. The crust was nice and crisp. The sauce was the write amount. I would have liked a tad more cheese and a tad more well done. The service was pretty fast and somewhat friendly. The place seemed clean! I like the use of real dishes. The way things are run leaves an awkward tipping situation if you eat in. You order and pay, then have a seat. After they bring out your food on real dishes. When you are done eating you feel unsure what to do. Ultimately you leave the dishes then feel bad if you don't have cash tip. To sum up, I'd certainly return if I was in the area. It's convenient! read more

Delicious!! Pizza, Chicken Caesar Salad, dessert. Easy to order via Slice app. Great customer service: they were out of the dessert I ordered so they telephoned for an alternative choice. Delivery arrived early. Great experience and food. read more

The food is usually ok, so long as you know what NOT to order, but this last time will be my last. I ordered delivery and when it came they were missing some pizza. The driver told me he would be "right back" 45 minutes later I called the restaurant and got the owner. He gave me endless attitude and said he would send the rest of my order (which I had already paid for) when he had time. It never came. The food isn't good enough to deal with the rude owner's BS. I'm done. Don't bother with this place. read more

You can always get a good slice or pie of your favorite kind of pizza here.. they have a wide variety of topings and specialties. They also have some great cheesesteaks and other subs and sandwiches. I have yet to try any of their pasta. The only negative thing about them is that it doesnt seem like they train their workers on the register well... I have yet to get the right change back (+ or -), and I've gone there maybe about 15 times so far read more

Hi. I am in quarantine. I ordered a pizza and a salad for delivery - approx $30.00 including a tip. The food was perfect. Pizza, exactly how I ordered it. Well done and the salad was terrific. So....I called and told them how terrific the food was. The man who answered was really nice and appreciated the call. (I owned a restaurant in NYC) (Pizza arrived - delivery person wore mask - very impressive.) So, a month later - just this past week, I ordered the same thing - also with same instructions that the pie be well done - same one topping. etc. The order arrived and the pie was not well cooked and the salad sat in a big puddle of water. Just awful. Since he was so "kind & pleasant" I thought he would want to know. He was aggressively defensive, telling me he cooked the pizza and it was well done. NOT...Picking up a slice, everything flopped off and the point of the slice hung down. Only one topping-the dough was soggy & it was not close to hot = which is not a big deal, but the first one was piping hot - He also told me his chef - (makes the salad in the morning - really?) Well, instead of being kind and interested in my second experience with their delivery - he was basically rude. Their delivery girl is great. read more

Had a friend over today and decided to order a pie from this place. Delivery was on time, however, when I opened the box there was a pizza that looked like it had been dropped or taken for a crazy joy ride. Called to get a new pie delivered. New pie arrives... same issue. This place will definitely not being hearing from me again. read more

Mario's Pizza Cafè - Pizza Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

This review is for Yelp itself. How can you say your unbiased when someone post a negative review and you hide it under "Not Recommended" I gave an honest review and it gets kicked somewhere where nobody will see it. I have read the blog where this has happened to many people. Take your site down if your not going to be honest. Makes me think now that you do cater to the business owners. I have found many reviews on YELP, not just from Mario's where family members are giving four and five stars to boost the restaurants ratings so why don't you modify your software to pull those out instead of removing the honest reviews. read more

Mediocre food with mediocre service. There are better places in the area.

First let me start off by saying, I've never reviewed any product, place or event. But after visiting marios pizza I just had to get the word out that this place is worth going to! I ordered the Italian stromboli and the flavor combinations were fantastic. The small size was too much for me to finish in one sitting, that being said I'd say the price was more than fair compared to other pizzerias I've been to that charge more for less. The waitress was very nice and pleasant to talk to also. The atmosphere was very friendly and casual. I have to admit, i'm a little sad i didnt know about this place sooner. It's like a nice little family friendly place and I will be back with friends. :) read more

Been here a few times and I've concluded it's a greasy fake pizza shop that tries to be everything, but can't live up to it. The pizza looks like something from Sbarros, the prices are way too high, the service is slow and unfriendly. There are a lot of other places to eat in the area that are better. read more