How do you mess up an easy supreme pizza ? They added everything at the end. Cold vegetables. When…read moreI order a sandwich and I ask for it toasted, guess what. Not toasted and soggy. I'm switching to another place.

Terrible! Terrible Terrible!…read more Everything Cold and no flavor in the sauce! What's worse than cold sauce with no flavor? No one coming by to see if everything is ok.... I guess they know it's not so why ask? Should have known from a restaurant you have to order full dinners at the counter then go sit down. And who hasn't changed their name on yelp because it's Sidney Joe's now.

Happened to pull off the interstate looking for a place to eat and got lucky with Sal's. Fantastic…read morepizza, great service. Don't know if I'll ever be in Bainbridge, NY again but if I am I will head straight to Sal's.

I really wanted to like this place. We were hyped after looking them up on the web and reading…read morereviews.. The garlic knots were fire.. hot, fresh, crunchy on the outside and perfectly soft on the inside. They were served in a boat of melted garlic butter, zero complaints here about that. The pizza was mediocre. Watery sauce.. the crust was good, but nothing to write home about. Toppings were half cheese, half pepperoni. Wings would have been better if they were fried extra crispy like I had asked, but they were cooked through so that's good... I got medium buffalo and it was just mediocre. Ranch and bleu cheese were Ken's brand, so do with that what you will. Mozzarella sticks were just like anything you can get anywhere else. The marinara was watery, but had potential as the flavor was okay. We weren't a fan of the place itself.. customer service was wonky with them still having a tip jar out.. mind you it is young people working there, so keep that in consideration. They were polite, but they definitely weren't running to give you more than minimal service. We were also given a stack of plates, the bottom one was full of dishwater. I'm a human being so I laughed it off, it's not a huge deal, but it was part of the Sal's journey. Overall a very underwhelming experience. Not surprised for the area, but I'm always hopeful and open to trying new places. If I ever went back it would be strictly for the garlic knots and that's it.

We took a pit stop in Oneonta, because it is where I graduated college from in 2011. I have many…read morefond memories of eating pizza from Sals, although it was often at 2am. Sals is a classic small college town pizzeria. Sals employees have always been consistently friendly. You have to try the Cold Cheese pizza, it's an Oneonta specialty and even though it's simple no one else can replicate it.

This was our most delicious fast-casual meal of our week in Oneonta for CASV. The service was very…read morefriendly, especially because the menu was extensive and we needed guidance on the best items to order. We shared the mozzarella sticks as an appetizer and they were good. My husband and son each had the meatball parmigiana sub and it was HUGE! They definitely could have split it, but we were happy to have leftovers. I had a slice of veggie pizza with a dollop of goat cheese and it was really tasty. They gave us garlic knots to try for free just to be nice ;) and that was an added bonus. We all recommend this restaurant and appreciate their kindness!

Absolutely INCONCEIVABLE how amazing this place is! We…read morerecently stayed in the area for a youth baseball tournament in Cooperstown and ended up eating here THREE nights in a row--that is how phenomenal it is. The food is incredible. The owner and chef is immensely talented, serving up fresh, farm-to-table dishes. Because everything is so fresh, the specifics change nightly, but everything we ordered was a huge win. The beef carpaccio was dynamite, and the Prosciutto Pizza, house-made focaccia bread, "farm goodies," bolognese, hangar steak, and caprese ravioli were all absolutely delicious. You can taste the quality and care in every single bite. (Sorry no pics...we were too busy eating!) Beyond the stellar food, the cocktail menu is an absolute blast. They have a whole lineup of delicious, creative craft drinks with "The Princess Bride" themed names! Trying the different drinks became half the fun of our dinners. What truly sets this place apart, though, is the service. We had a server named Beth whom we absolutely loved. By the third night, she knew exactly what my daughter wanted to drink as soon as we sat down! The owners and the entire staff are warm, welcoming, and treat you like family. If you are anywhere near Oneonta or Cooperstown, do yourself a huge favor and eat here. We will definitely be back the next time we are in town!

This is a perfect example of why you shouldn't judge a book by its cover. From the outside, the…read morerestaurant is a bit unusual. It's an older house painted red with black trim, featuring a newer deck that, at least when we visited, had no furniture on it. At first glance, you might assume it's a neighborhood sports bar or a casual local hangout. Step inside, however, and you'll find something completely different. The atmosphere is warm, intimate, and inviting, with a classic dining ambiance that makes it feel like a hidden gem tucked away in the neighborhood. We were in Oneonta for Cooperstown All Star Village and were excited to discover this cozy farm-to-table restaurant. The food was excellent, and the setting made for a memorable dining experience. We started with the Crab Puffs, made with empanada dough, crab rangoon filling, and a jalapeño-green onion emulsion. They were creative, flavorful, and a great way to begin the meal. For our entrée, we shared the daily fish special, halibut served with farm-fresh potatoes and carrots. The fish was perfectly cooked, and the fresh ingredients really showcased the farm-to-table concept. The dish was simple, fresh, and delicious. To finish the meal, we shared the Crème Brûlée for dessert. It was outstanding, with a perfectly caramelized sugar crust and a rich, creamy custard that provided the perfect ending to an excellent dinner. Despite the restaurant being packed, we were seated immediately and received excellent service throughout the evening. The staff was attentive, friendly, and kept everything running smoothly. The drink menu was another highlight, offering a solid selection of craft beers, wines, and cocktails. Overall, this was one of the best meals we had during our trip. Great food, excellent service, a cozy atmosphere, and a unique setting make this restaurant well worth seeking out if you're in Oneonta.

Done with this place. They are raising their prices and skimping on the portions. Several months…read moreago, I ordered 3 Veal Parmigiana heros, sorry, subs. They cut up 2 cutlets and spread them out between the 3.Then, they dumped a bunch of sauce and mozzarella on to hide it. There should be 2-3 cutlets per sub. We stopped buying veal from them. Today, I bought 3 baked ziti dinners at $19/each. Here's what I got, 3 kid sized dinners. 6" tins instead of the normal 10/12" tins. I also ordered 6 meatballs and they were terrible. It was like biting into musty water. The bread was stale. We spent $80 today for garbage. Never again. There used to be good cooks there, but now it's a bunch of kids.

Dealing with their service it seems their staff has a little rude and it seems that there's…read moreconstantly problems with their telephone like either you get hung up on or you get directed to this answering service. That sounds like a fax. I don't know if it's just a they constantly have bad cellular communications, or it's just that the employees don't want to deal with the customer at the time that's calling the phone instead of saying can you please hold they just hang up the phone I don't know what's going on but there's definitely something going on with the phones

We were in town for the baseball tournament at Dreams Park. It was like a second honeymoon. No kids…read morein tow and our son of course stayed in the barracks. It was wonderful. :-) We came here with friends also parents from the team. Easy parking. Fast service. We sat upstairs - it was like our own private dining room. We got a couple of different pizzas and some salads. Everything was very good. Absolutely recommend.

After a rough playoff loss, we came here for lunch. A bit off of the beat and path from…read moreDreamspark. They have a small parking lot and there is street parking as well. We wound up parking a block away as they were pretty busy. You can dine in or take out. Table area was very clean. You place your order and they bring everything to your table. Service all around was excellent and smooth. Everyone went above and beyond. The kid got a small buffalo chicken pizza. I got a meatball parm sandwich. Meatball sandwich was very good. Quality of the meatballs was impressive. Sauce had a nice kick to it. They didn't cheap out on the amount of sauce or cheese. I made the right choice. I snuck a piece of the Buffalo Chicken pie. Chicken was on point. Nice size pieces. Not over powering with spicy sauce. Personal preference, dough was a little too thick for me, but again, that's my personal preference. Kid definitely enjoyed it. Boxed up a few slices for later on. A great alternative if you're in the area.

Excellent wings , great service , comfortable attractive atmosphere . Definitely will returnread more

We had a large team gathering while in for Cooperstown and the place was GREAT! We had called ahead…read moreand got everything set up for our whole team and all the parents. We probably took up most of the restaurant and they had pizza, salad, wings, and knots. Their pizza is New York style and REALLY good. They provided more than enough food and we had plenty for take home. If you are coming in town this is a perfect place to have authentic New York pies!!!

Usually get takeout. The pizza is the best in town! Also love the eggplant parm. Always our go to…read moreplace for pizza!

Ordered a pizza for take out. Fantastic pizza as a whole. Cooked through, not burned, generous…read moretoppings, crispy crust.

Just got delivery from here and had NO idea this place even existed! I absolutely loved the pizza…read more-- and everything else we ordered as well. Worth every penny. Being born and raised on Long Island and living up here for the past 28 years, I've spent a long time searching for pizza that reminds me of home. This is the closest I've found to the classic Long Island pizza I grew up loving! I am on my 3rd slice and don't want to stop.

We enjoy there food. Always fresh when picked up. Serves excellent. Highly recommend.read more