Stopped by with decent expectations and walked away feeling pretty middle-of-the-road. The pizza itself lands around a 6.5-6.8 out of 10. It's a step above your typical fast-casual chain, but not by much. The crust had a nice bit of browning, which was a plus, but the sauce runs noticeably sweet -- giving it more of that Pizza Hut-style vibe. It's solid, just not something that stands out or keeps you thinking about it later. If I were rating on pizza alone, it'd probably sit at a 4-star experience. Where things slipped was with our order. We did a half-and-half custom pie: half supreme with no olives or mushrooms. That didn't quite translate in execution. That side showed up overloaded with olives -- way beyond normal -- and still had mushrooms on it. Not the end of the world, but definitely frustrating when you customize and it comes out off. We also paid for extra dipping sauces that never made it to us, which added to the letdown. As for the ambiance, don't expect a dine-in experience. It's more like walking into a Little Caesars-style setup -- very basic, grab-and-go feel -- with just a single picnic table outside. Not really a place you'd plan to sit and enjoy a meal. Would I come back? Maybe if I needed something quick and convenient. But it's not somewhere I'd go out of my way to recommend or call a must-try spot. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Half Supreme Half Sante Fe - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Friendly neighborhood pizza place. Staff were courteous and accommodating as we decided to dine in. Definitely will choose to carry out next time as the space is not really able to hold more than one table of four. Space was clean and food was fresh and hot. No ice or cups was the only issue we had, but again not set up for dine in. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Molto meat specialty pizza with crust you will want to finish. - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

After seeing Dave Portnoy try this place, I had to as well.... We ordered a couple personal pizzas. The Big Matt - My son got this one. He said it was like a Big Mac. He really enjoyed it . I ordered the Molto Meat! Yum!! I added jalapeños to it. The big plus for me, the jalapeños are fresh! I'd definitely order again. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - The Big Matt - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

I have been ordering from here almost every Friday for some time now cause Friday's are our pizza night unless we do date night. They are slipping bad. Let me start with saying none of the problems are the staffs fault who are working the restaurant. They are working hard and doing their best. BUT, the owners/ top managers are failing at their jobs. The staff are very under trained. The shift managers are not being directed or taught how to run the restaurant. The manager has almost always been working the pizza line and not paying attention to the rest of the operations. Friday was another great example. The app said 20 minute pick up time and when I arrived, it was pretty hazy inside because pizzas were left in the oven and got burned, and I ended up waiting almost 30 minutes past my pick up time. Granted, they have been getting busier lately but when you are making pizzas faster than you can box them, that's a problem. My order was definitely over cooked, as the crust was darker than it should have been and the pepperonis were also dark. My wife sounded like she was eating gravel with eat bite of her 10in cauliflower pizza. One girl working the register and phone and was completely overwhelmed. One dude placed a stupid large order which sent the staff into shock and they were all very frazzled. Again, they did their best, but this has become a weekly or daily issue. May have to stop coming and find a new pizza spot. Not sure yet. Several more issues that I could bring up but no one has that time to read this. read more

My first time trying a Mattenga's pepperoni pizza was a delight! The thin crust was baked perfectly, topped with the right amount of cheese and jumbo pepperonis. I'm thrilled that I discovered this neighborhood pizzeria. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Best pizza ever we recommend this place my family and I really enjoyed service was good read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Great pizza and great staff! Full transparency, there are plenty of pizza "joints" in the area and each one has its own speciality. I would have to say that Mattenga's is in my top 5, in no particular order since depends on what type of pizza I'm craving. (Ex. Supreme, Margarita etc.) The Supreme and Malto , Hawaiian pizza are my favorite at Mattenga's. I need to try their brisket pizza. My first visit was at their Schertz location. Happy that location at Wilderness Oak(close to home) read more

See all

At first I thought this was a dine in type of pizza joint but it is like a "domino's" or other pizza spot in the sense that you just order and pick it up at the counter, BUT way better. To say this is a neighborhood pizza place where they just make it and you take it home, they are impressive. Their pizza is really good, the crust isn't doughy and heavy, it's thin and crispy. The service was really good, everyone was super friendly and attentive as soon as you walk in. The prices are reasonable considering the quality, except for customizing a pizza the way you want it can be pricy. Each topping is $1.99 up to $5 so it adds up quick. I personally find that crazy for the price per topping, hence the one star drop, but the flavor and quality of the pizza is really good. There really isn't a dine in option, it just has a little bar with some stools for you to wait for your pizza. When I just want something quick without having to go to a restaurant, this is a really good option. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Having recently moved to Texas, I am always looking for new pizza spots to try. I had never heard of Mattenga's, until they showed up on a random list of best pizza places in specific categories. Mattenga's happened to be chosen for best pizza commercial. I looked them up and they looked pretty good. So, I happened to be in San Antonio for the day and thought I would give them a shot, so this location happened to be the one I was closest too. It is not a sit down location. However, it does have counter space along the wall and window, with a few chairs. I think this was a Papa John's before, so you have an idea of the size. I ordered a BYOP 16" and some wings. The gentleman that took my order asked if I would like to try their pepperoni rolls, on the house. I gladly accepted. They have Pepsi products here, so I ordered water, because I would never drink Pepsi. They didn't even have Dr. Pepper, which I would have preferred. He informed me that they didn't have water in the system yet, since they had just opened recently, so he offered the water free of charge. The pizza rolls came out first. We were asked if we would like to try either of the house made ranch dips. The Texas Ranch ( jalapeño cilantro ranch) and Mattenga's Ranch (basil garlic ranch). We opted for both. I do love a good ranch dip and these did not disappoint! Probably the best ranch that I have ever tasted. The pepperoni rolls were very good as well. The wings came out next and they were just the way I like them; crispy and saucy. I am definitely ordering them again. The pizza soon followed, and it looked great! It tasted very good. Crispy undercarriage, and pillowy cornicione. I really enjoyed the cheese pull, as well as the quality of their cheese. They use a conveyor oven for everything, so the wait time wasn't too bad. I have been back to this location one more time since my first visit. So, it's pretty safe to say, I will be a repeat customer. I will definitely try the other locations as well. However, it will be hard to do that, when this is a pretty great location with great customer service. They take pride in the product that they are putting out and it really shows in the quality. read more

See all

Our daughter introduced us to Mattenga's. One of the pizzas we had was the Honey Bexar, which was unique, and one of the most delicious pizzas I've ever had. The cilantro jalapeno dip was equally amazing!!! read more

We usually get this door dashed to us because it's close by, but today we went in. Amazing service! The guys were super accommodating and helpful. He asked if I still wanted Parmesan on the bread sticks because of my dairy allergy which he remembered with my cheeseless pizza. I know it's weird, but it's how I get to still enjoy pizza. The pizza and breadsticks were great and the him showing us the pizza before we left guaranteed the service and quality! 5/5 read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Delicious!!! Fresh-tasting ingredients, amazing crust texture and flavor, friendly staff, great service, and prepare prepared quickly. Can't wait to go back!! read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

My family's fave!! They are fast and good!!! Always quality and always amazing food !!! The service is fast and always perfect with what they deliver. read more

Very delicious pizza and BBQ wings. The pizza is New York style, so thin crust. I order a pizza with pepperoni, bacon, tomatoes and black olives. The wings were delicious, although I preferred crispy wings. But still delicious. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Delicious pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Great pizza! Love that you can order 1/2 and 1/2 with speciality pizzas. We ordered half Santa Fe and Honey Bexar as well as a plain pepperoni. Unfortunately they forgot the hatch green chili on our Santa Fe, but it was still delicious. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Half Santa Fe and half Honey Bexar - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

this place was understaffed! The employees kept taking orders and they were behind with more than 3 people waiting to get their orders. One of the employees dropped a utensil and continued using it I don't think they noticed people saw that. Was waiting for over 30+ minutes for them to be out of a lot things. Would NOT recommend! read more

Their AI service that they use to take orders over the phone will be their demise!!!! I have had two orders the past two weeks and I'm DONE!! tonight I had an order for two separate types of 6 piece wings and when I got there I was notified there were no wings. This was a significant portion of our order. It would have been nice to know that when I placed the order - I WOULD HAVE WENT SOMEWHERE ELSE WHERE THEY HAVE WINGS!!! Never again!!! You suck!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Booked order an hour ahead to Ensure food would be ready for pick up. Show up and was told it would be another 30 minutes. read more

The food/atmosphere was great! What really made me leave a review though is a worker named Louise. He was super helpful and had a great vibe! read more

We bought the supreme pizza to go. We received Great customer service and care. The pizza is good, and has an authentic taste. It is however on the pricier side, But it is definitely not a 10$ pizza from dominoes or Pizza Hut. Looking forward to trying another, maybe even the wings. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - 16' Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Great food & service. The pizzas we ordered were absolutely delicious! Luis & Christian treated us like royalty! We will definitely be back soon! read more

Food and service excellent! Jason was very kind and ensured our order got out quickly

Found Mattengas while scrolling social media. Best pizza in San Antonio. Many crust options which I love!!!

For a local place their specialty pizzas were the saving grace and pretty good I got the Texas pothole and it was well liked. On the other hand you may want to place your order an extra 15 minutes earlier than you expect to arrive. The personal pepperoni pizza and garlic cheesy bread were a miss for me and I'd recommend to try another specialty pizza instead. Will be back hopefully my other items are good read more

Mattenga's finally made it to our neck of the woods! We were hoping they would have indoor seating but, apart from two barstools, they do not. No tables, just a small counter area with stools. Still wanted to try it, so we had to place an order for carry-out. 16" pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom and an order of buffalo wings with an "extra crispy" request attached. Everything was ready within about 15 minutes! The pizza looked beautiful! It still looked fantastic by the time we got home but, and this is the reason why we don't get carry-out, after riding along for 10 minutes steaming in a box, the bottom was soggy and floppy. Ingredients were fresh and great quality, sauce was tasty and not too sweet. The crust had really good flavor and would have probably been perfect if we could have dined in. The wings also had great flavor but weren't extra crispy. Definitely recommend them if you live near enough to not get a soggy pizza! read more

See all

This pizza is fantastic. I love trying their unique topping combinations. They're very generous with the local schools which is a huge plus! Just remember to double check your order because they often forget the ranch. read more

This is a take-out-only pizzeria. We ordered half cheese, half sausage, pepperoni, black olives, and mushrooms. The pizza was done quickly, and it tasted great! We have finally found our pizza place after 6 years of looking. read more

Pizza and wings were fresh and delicious and handed to me with a smile. Welcome to the neighborhood! :) read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Family pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

We have ordered pickup twice. Both times our order has been ready in less than 15 minutes and it's been great! The staff is so kind and knowledgeable. We've tried the pizza, calzone, wings and breadsticks. Pizza was DELICIOUS! On par with Stouts and Trilogy. Their marinara is awesome and we love all the special ranch sauces. Highly recommend. Shout out to the staff holding it down on the busy nights and still being so nice! Happy to have Mattengas in the neighborhood. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Cup-a-roni, cup-a-sausage, spinach, ricotta and chopped roasted red peppers! Loaded and delicious! - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Always looking for a good pizza restaurant for Friday night Pizza movie night. First let me say the pizza was actually pretty good however the person taking my order did not listen. First I ordered a 20" supreme without Green Bell Peppers, as you can see by the photo there were a lot of bell peppers on this pizza. Secondly I asked for Crispy, as you can see by the toppings and the limp slice it was not. The young man also hung up without telling me how long before the pizza would be ready, got a text about 10 minutes later that it was ready. (I do like the text feature just unexpected for it to be ready so quickly) once we got home I picked off the bell peppers , then I used a pan with some olive oil heated to crisp the bottom. After making those minor adjustments the pizza was very tasty. With that said the pricing was reasonable and the pizza was good enough that my family and I will try it again, everyone has an off night. Ok read more

See all

Came in late and ordered a margherita the service was fast and the pizza was delicious the workers were happy to serve me I will be coming back soon read more

Very good pizza option around stone oak area. solid food, solid service, solid delivery times. Will continue to keep them in the Mix for pizzas read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

The pizza is delicious. Good flop to the crust but still got some crunch. Carry out wait time was 15 minutes. I recommend the jalapeño ranch. read more

Mattenga's Pizzeria Wilderness Oak - Supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Ordered so many times from them. The pizzas are awesome. (the Santa Fe is a personal favorite). The wings are great. The pizza rolls are soft and yeasty. Their dipping sauces are delicious. And the staff is super friendly. Never been disappointed in anything I have ordered from them!! read more

Ordered to based on Yelp reviews for a pizza/wing place near the location I was visiting. Unfortunately, I did not realize that when I looked at the website, I was directed to the location on O'Conner. When I picked up my order the mix up was when the mixup was realized. Although the mixup was my fault for moving so hasty, the locations did not make it an issue to cancel my order at 9'Conner and replace at Wilderness Oak location. The 20" pizza fed 5 adults and there were slices left over. Slices ARE BIG, so we cut a few smaller to spread out the serving. We ordered lemon pepper, original, and bbq wings. They do not have a boneless option and the wings were small but again, 5 adults and 2 kids ate, with 3 wings left over. The total for a small cheese pizza, large pepperoni pizza and 3 orders of wings was $90. We all agreed that the PIZZA WAS EXCELLENT, wings were very good, food was hot, fresh, great tasting pizza dough and plenty of food to feed the family. Even the kids wanted to know where the food was from. If you have not tried it, give them a try!!!! read more

Had a party with a lot of people. I ordered 12 20" pizzas. 3 each, cheese, sausage, pepperoni, and supreme. Delivery time was 6:00pm. Pizzas were delivered at the exact right time. They were hot and fresh. Great price. Would order from them again for sure. They were all delicious. Sausage is really good too. My favorite of the bunch. read more

Was disappointed I really wanted to love it but I will try again. Crust was basic cheese and sauce were just ok

Ordered the pizza for delivery. Opened the box, the slices were a bit tussled and the pizza was like warm. Crust to cheese to toppings ratio was spot on but I wish there were more of each with this pizza, it just seemed like the overall crust was too thin, cheese layer not thick enough, and toppings layer good just wish there were more. Quality of toppings was outstanding. The cheese was nice and salty, pepperoni represented well, Italian sausage had a nice zing of spice to it, the crust had a great chew but not crispy as one would expect with such a thin crust. Shelf life of the pizza in the fridge is about 1.5 days tops before the crust starts to turn into dried flaky card board. The overall experience was good, I just wish it came fresher, hotter, and had more of everything for the price point. read more

So far I've ordered online for pickup 3 times, and it's always been ready on time hot and fresh. The pizza rolls are fantastic, and the pizza is top notch. Staff has been friendly and do yourself a favor and get a variety of dipping sauces to go. read more

Food amazing!!! The best pizza rolls I've ever had they taste just like pizza the right amount of sour dough to cheese ratio.The service is amazing too he gave us free extra pizza rolls and he was very sweet and fun to be around.5 stars for sure!:) read more