Would give a 0 star if allowed. This place is a dive. Was waiting on line to get in and the cover charge changed fro $20 to $40. When we got to the front to pay I asked the Troll collecting the money if she would honor the $20 cover since we were on line before they raised it to $40. The bitch answered "don't ever fucking ask me that if you ever want to come back here again" I guess she hates her job so much and obviously never was taught any manners. I will never return to this bar and recommend that no one gives this business their hard earned money. There are many nice places in Montauk to have a good time. Memory Motel must go!!! read more

There is a song on the Rolling Stones' Black and Blue album called "Memory Motel". As a friend of mine and I were rolling around the eastern tip of Long Island, we came across a "worn in" looking place called the Memory Motel. Of course my eyes locked on to the small word on the sign above the words "Memory Motel": BAR. Naturally we got out to take a look. It was a Tuesday, and the place is only open Thurs-Sun. They open later in the evening, and they love to have live bands. As luck would have it the band playing on Thursday is called "2U". Who do you suppose they are a tribute band for? We pull up on Thursday with our lady friends and park it at the bar. We're maybe the 4th-7th customers for the evening. The band is set up, but not in the room. Right after we get settled in, the Memory Motel Softball Team starts rolling in. How did we know? All of their shirts had "Memory Motel" on them, and all of them had the sleeves cut off. Much of the populace of eastern Long Island drives Range Rovers, Jaguars, etc., but the kind people of Montauk trend toward pickups. Since the band du jour was a U2 cover band, we started speculating on which of the patrons was Bono. It started with a couple of the softballers: "THAT's yer man." "No THERE he is." "My bet is on that guy over there." It eventually degenerated into speculation about every soul that walked in the door. Man woman, it didn't matter. It was fun. The actual singer ended up being some guy with a Yankees hat on backward and a large cocktail in a plastic cup. He did the sound check dressed like that, and came back for the show with a straw cowboy hat and the expected wrap around rose tinted shades. To be fair, his singing was pretty good and a decent facsimile of Yer Man's. Let's just say this was a fun night. The crowd was pretty mixed. By mixed I mean people who looked like they were 21, and people who were bragging about being at Woodstock. The bartender was friendly and efficient, and it was good clean fun for the whole family. The bartender did tell us about the "Memory Motel" slash Rolling Stones connection: The place was always a motel, and the bar we were in was originally a little restaurant. There was a grand piano in the corner that Mick Jagger played a few times while he was in town visiting Andy Warhol in the late 60's early 70's. Evidently Andy had a compound out near Montauk at the time. The title of the song was probably inspired by the place. There might have been more of a connection, but as the story goes, the owner of the place didn't like Jagger because he was British, so the story ends there. read more

Memory Motel - Hotels Near Me - Montauk, New York

Is this a straight or gay bar???? I was confused since we had 20+ GIRLS with us for a bachelorette party & the door guy was RUDE to us. We went on 6/8/13 at 11:45pm & the door guy in the red t-shirt was a jerk to us. He tried to charge us EACH $10, but we saw him let guys go in without paying. They normally don't charge an entry fee, but I guess they wanted to "pocket" some money for themselves so they could get some chili dogs & nachos at 7 Eleven? Not only was the door guy rude to all of us, but once we decided we did not want to pay his so called entry "fee", he started talking crap to us by saying "you'll be back, you're a dime a dozen....". WOW, now that's what I call customer service! No wonder Memory Motel was a ghost town and only guys are there. They made a huge mistake because we are the ones who will be spending $$$$$ at the bar & buying the most drinks. We ended up going to Sloppy Tuna instead since they deserved our business & it's the best spot to go to. NEGATIVE ZERO. Don't waste your time here. read more

No security and the girl taking cash at the door had no answers 0/10. If you're an Instagram influencer this place is for you. If you want to have a good time there's plenty of better options. Don't buy into the hype read more

One of the best places anywhere....how anyone could give this place anything less than 5 stars is beyond me. Its rock & roll legacy is unsurpassed in its badass-ness. Not only did the Stones name the song after it but they wrote F-ing Wild Horses here for gods sake! It was the only place in Montauk with (at the time) a piano and a pool table while they were crashing at Warhol's compound out here. Pure Awesomeness. While its legacy is unsurpassed, the place is firmly ensconced in the present and is constantly reinventing itself into all different forms of cool, even in the course of a single day. Take our recent experiences here on a perfect June Saturday. We got word early afternoon that the great Winston Irie was playing a afternoon show here, as he apparently does on a regular basis thru out the summer. When we arrived we were most pleasantly surprised by out total pro bartender (there all amazing but much respect in particular to John) , that we hd stumbled into an hour of free open bar (well liquor and beer) for the next hour out of nowhere! The free beer made the incredible reggae Winston and the boys were serving out even more incredible! Later at night we returned to catch the tail end of a live cover band (super cheesy but in a good way), which was followed by a wild set from a DJ that by nights end had devolved into a fantastically decadent rave type atmosphere. I can't even begin to imagine actually staying in one of the gloriously disgusting rooms at this place but god bless anyone who does! read more

See all

Absolute horrendous end to our night. They added a food charge to our bill because they are not actually serving food but did not tell us about this...in addition they charged us four "foods" for three people. When I got my credit card receipt they added a gratuity which was not represented on their original receipt and I did not agree too. The gentleman that was helping us all night also started screaming at us to leave the minute we paid our bill. He caused such a scene the entire restaurant was looking. He could not give us a reason for telling us we had to leave. We were at a table with a bunch of people and no one had any idea why the three of us were asked to leave so rudely and abruptly. I am currently disputing my credit card charge with my bank because I did not know about the tip. read more

Alll I gotta say, this pineapple vodka with a splash for ants was delicious ! And interesting place read more

Memory Motel - Had this delicious vodka pineapple with a splash of 5 ants - Hotels Near Me - Montauk, New York

Been coming out to Montauk for the past 20 years and have never had a bartender like jeff. Whole heartened, genuine, good guy. Made the weekend. read more

Memory Motel - Hotels Near Me - Montauk, New York

This place is an atrocity. Absolute worst service- a scam on all prices, no menus or listing of prices/liquor/drinks & we were completely overcharged for 3 drinks and then we were sneakily given a price which was not the actual price but included a 20% percent gratuity for the WORST service we have ever experienced. We are industry people and we do not understand how this place is still operating. Someone needs to call the cops on these guys it's really bad they are not practicing safe social distancing they do not give you food as they should and they are illegally charging people additional amounts on their bills never ever go here!!!!!! read more

**COVID REVIEW** AWFUL AWFUL AWFUL. This place has high priced drinks with terrible quality. Make sure to check your bill before you pay because they will add items on there that you didn't ask for! We ordered 2 shots and the bartender came over with 3 instead and took one with us- then had the nerve to charge us for his shot! When we questioned all the items he told us to "lose the attitude". Our bill was $96 for 4 drinks and two shots. This was the worst service we have ever experienced. Don't waste your time!! read more

We were over Charged for 6 shots the bill came out to $200 . The bill was lowered to $50 according to them they are allowed to charge what they want for shots because of covir read more

This place smells like puke and cost $40 to get in. To top it off the bouncer dragged my friend out and then proceeded to punch him in the face, for accidentally being caught in the middle of a fight. Absolutely disgusted with the bouncers in Montauk, especially here. read more

I have not much to add other than the bouncer was extremely rude and hostile toward us. I just wanted to close my tab and leave but he refused to let me back in to pay for some reason and continued to berate my group until I left. An additional bouncer was very nasty and thought I was some kind of threat and told me "I need to learn how to follow directions" and that I needed to get off the property immediately. I guess me being the little brown woman leaving the property was very scary. But the big white man dousing himself in beer on the dance floor got high fives from everyone?? Take your money elsewhere as my group did and continued to drink and party and spend money but not at this crap establishment. Also the music was trash. read more

Terrible place. The bouncer took my friends REAL ID claiming it was false. Then, the bouncer asked to go to the police office, my friend said ok fine, and then he said she could only go alone with him. ALONE. My friend refused to go anywhere with this creepy bouncer alone, obviously, but they refused to give it back. Terrible place. Rude people. Don't go. read more

Please don't go here. Especially if you are from Florida?? So weird they believe every ID is fake, and will not give it back without walking with them to the police station. Being a woman it is dangerous to walk alone with a stranger alone at night (far away from the Memory Motel). I will never be returning. I was treated with such disrespect by the misogynistic bouncer, it was horrible. Left immediately. If you are looking for a place with good people, go to The Point across the street. read more

We were charged $25 / drink For a Dixie cup of well weak vodka vodka and soda. They broke the law as no food was being served, and they didn't even provide an itemized receipt. read more

Terrible experience - the guys that worked there were extremely rude. Don't go here, especially during COVID.

I went for my first time a few days ago and the waiters and waitresses were very rude to my friends and I!! I am definitely not coming back here. Also heard they took other peoples IDs and would not give it back!! read more

YOUR JUST A MEMORY.. GIRL.. The Stones Song Echoes... As my Car noses over the last Bump in Montauk Highway.. The BEAUTY of the Atlantic Ocean.. Rises up from the Island Shores Below to Greet me.. Then My Friend... YOU know you've reached THE END. MONTAUK ...Home to The Famous "Memory Motel" of The Rolling Stones Fame, Being the Only Bar in the area at the time as Mick Jagger and the Stones were visiting their Friend ,Andy Warhol at his Montauk estate. Where the Beautiful song Wild Horses was written and certainly the inspiration for the Memory Motel song... now the Memory Motel exists as an Adventure in lodging. And a bustling MAD Montauk Motel...Bar.. ( Hey where you're staying?... We're leaning against MY Door..) In which room service takes on an entire new meaning... LIKE... if you leave the Door Open to your room ...it Will become Part of the Bar. The Bar scene is Really Good , Lots of Folks ,Mostly 20's Demo ..Packed in Season. The inside Bar is professionally Managed, As the Large Crowd could easily get out of hand. The outside Court Has a Central Bar which will get you your Drinks Quickly. I Was amazed to see some of the adjacent Hotel Rooms had their Doors open...with the Bar crowd Inside. On the Bright side , They Don't Need a cab to get Home... If You're single if you want to mingle.. AND if your Room is Next Door.. you WON'T be ALONE for Long. Memory Motel where you can stay at the DIVE ...and you Won't Have to Drive Home. JIM D. With a Helluva Memory. read more

See all

My favorite bar of ALL time. I've been coming to montauk since I was 2 years old and as soon as I turned 21 this was my place to go. I've had a ball here every time I went, I came with my friends from home. We all are 23-24 years old & they told my college roommate that her ID was fake. After they had let me in, She is 23 years old (and tbh this is the last place we'd come to if we were underage even). They not only denied her ID & refused to scan but also told her to "shut her slut mouth up". This made me so upset because it's my FAVORITE place ever. I'm so sad that I'm not able to come back but I will not give money to this establishment after the blatant slut shaming & disrespect. I have had a house in Montauk since 2000 & grew up here & have been going to memory motel since I turned 21, came here for my 21st bday. It was my boyfriends 24th birthday weekend celebration & I am so upset. We were doing bottle service and was about to give so much money to them. This makes my heart break, my favorite place ever & I'll never be able to come back here. This type of disrespect towards women made me baffled. I LOVE this place, we currently are about to make a police report because of how disrepectful & agressive they were. I'm never coming back here. I'm so sad, any new bar recommendations? read more

There will be memories made, and memories made go away. You can check in, stay the night. In fact, I saw a gentleman sleeping on a picnic bench the last time I was here. I'm guessing his memories were lost as well. During the summer months it's absolutely packed... with a queue time of an hour plus. Hamptons twentysomethings fill the place and dance their butts off every weekend. It's the nice kind of divey with a lot of rock and roll memorabilia and strong drinks. The insane crowds during peak season keep me from recommending this wholeheartedly but it's most certainly one of the super fun spots in Montauk. read more

While it's a great atmosphere it was very upsetting that they didn't serve White Claws. #HardPass

Cautionary tale on this dive bar....Don't ever use a credit card at this shady place with an even shadier owner. I've been here a few times previously, each time as a part of a large group. Memory couldn't be further from my type of scene, but sometimes you just have to take one for the team. However, after my experience this past weekend, I will never return. A few friends and I went out to dinner and then out for some drinks. We ended up at the Memory to meet up with some people who we knew were there. After a couple drinks we walked across the street to the Point. By the time we headed home, it was late and I completely forgot that my card was sitting behind the bar at the Memory. Went back the following night, and the bartender waved me over to the owner who I was told would help me. When I asked him to help, he argued with me that I probably didn't even know where I left my card. He finally relented (but not before calling me some unsavory names), slowly waddled to the bar and picked up a clear plastic cup filled with at least 100 credit cards left behind from other patrons. He then handed me the cup with all of the credit cards, told me to find my card, and waved me over to the side (out of his view). It would have been so easy for me to pocket a handful of other people's cards and no one would have been the wiser. Moral of the story- sometimes you really can judge a book by its cover, as is the case with this grimy bar and its truly foul proprietor. read more

This is the best place for nightlife and music way out here. It is the only happening place off season - but wait until at least 10 pm. We walked in once at 8 and it was dead quiet -by 10:30 we tried back and it was crowded with a live band ant this was end of Nov/ First day of Dec. read more

The bouncer at this hotel is a rude, condescending obnoxious person! They charge a cover whenever they feel like it, even when it's not busy. Do not give this establishment your business! read more

The best dive bar in Montauk, hands down. The crowd is always mixed, often times there is a live band (saw a Led Zeppelin cover band once with a lead singer who looked astonishingly like Robert Plant, down to the hair and his current age) and the drinks are usually poured decent. The crowd is mixed and diverse, everything from typical WASPy East Coast college students to people older than your parents. On a busy Friday or Saturday night this place is usually good to witness a fight as well, watch your girls and plan accordingly. Always a good time! read more

Best spot in Montauk. Spent Halloween here during the pandemic. Met tons of locals and a bridal party. Made friends (also a gf) for life! The said gf made out with the bride to be! 10/10 would recommend. Drunk drove back home. Got a speeding ticket.zero regrets! Gf broke up, after 1 year. Still.. no regrets! read more

This place is a disgusting scam. Only went because it was the only place open with a patio for drinking. $14 White Claws and a mandatory $5 foul bologna sandwich. They automatically charged our party of 3 a 20% gratuity. read more

I went here recently with my boyfriend for a late night drink. We were there less than an hour had 2 house drinks, and 3 shots. Our bill was $110!!! Apparently, they charged us $5 for a bogus bologna sandwich so they could skirt around the new NY pandemic policy where you can't order drinks without food. There was NO food there and we were not ever disclosed about this charge until I had to ask why my bill was astronomically high. On top of that they added a gratuity of over 20% to the TOTAL bill! It was only two of us and had 2 rounds of drinks. How did that warrant a $22 tip. Especially when the service sucked and we had to wait for the server to stop hanging with his friends at the next table just to get his attention. This place SUCKS save your money and go elsewhere!!!!! NEVER EVER AGAIN read more

Bates motel?? Crowded and crazy bar, great music. The place is a dump however, they should use the cover money and spend it on an upgrade for the bathrooms, the inside, well everything. Great for dancing, and going a little cra cra. read more

$10 Admission? It's not very often I give negative star....The doorman asked 30 of us ladies to pay him $10 admission and he let guys go in without paying so it made us wonder why is there admission when there isn't any at other places. He was very rude so we decided not to go in and he rudely said, you girls a dime a dozen. It just left a sour taste in my mouth not to go back to the Memory Motel. Go to Sloppy Tuna! read more

Hamptons dance bar classic. Sometimes electric, sometimes rock, always good vibes. Seems to Always be live music & DJ. Montauk staple read more

Memory Motel - HBO series "Girls" filming a special scene inside - Hotels Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

This bouncer was so mean to me. I was by myself bc I went outside to talk on the phone but asked to get a stamp to come back. They said it would be fine to get back in. I said 'oh it's kind of light can I get another' they said no but I said ok I'm taking a picture (see attached) to make sure you guys remember. But when I tried later that night the bouncer told me no, that this wasn't the right stamp and that I was a bitch. He legit called me a bitch which made me sad bc I'm not a mean person and that makes me feel sad so I teared up and everyone in line gave me money to pay for cover ($20) again. I felt bad so I didn't take their money and ended up finding my friends. But the bouncer called me a birch and was so rude to me I front of everyone to the point that they offered to pay my cover (something to think about). read more