I love Latin food, so trying out this spot was definitely something I was excited for. The first thing to note is that the location is a pretty sudden turn on East Colonial so if it's your first time going, make sure that you drive slowly and make sure you don't miss the turn! Immediately we were greeted and seated which was a plus for me. The music selection was fitting and very atmospheric and positively affected my eating experience Our waitress was attentive and was ready to take our order from the jump. As far as the food, I ordered the mofongo de amarillo and racion de tequeños for the appetizers, and the bistec empanizado and bistec encebollado.
The mofongo de amarillo was interesting in the fact that I wasn't too crazy about the taste alone but once the broth was added, it made the dish objectively better as more flavors were able to shine through. They weren't the sweetest plantains I've ever consumed, but I think that worked in their favor as they were able to take a backseat and mix with the flavor profile of the broth. I will note that the portioning was small for this dish but I didn't mind because of how dense mofongo can be. My only complaint with this dish was the issue of there being some incredibly hard matter inside of the dish. I couldn't tell what it was because my teeth couldn't even break it down to eat. The dish wasn't littered with this though, so the affect on the eating experience was minor.
Starting with the racion de tequeños, this is how you do an appetizer. appearance-wise I was pleasantly surprised because it looks like it was fried in house and the coloring was very even. The cheese was also very fresh, I could tell by pulling it that it wasn't that regular frozen cheese. I will say though, at $8, I personally would have expected more than 4 tequeños. My biggest gripe would have to be the amount of time it took for our appetizers to reach the table, especially considering how small both of the portions were. With that all being said, taste wise, the tequeños were my favorite thing i ordered.
The bistec empanizado was an entree that I feel as though i did not utilize to its fullest potential. Being a breaded sirloin, it had a great texture and mouthfeel. While not being overly seasoned, it had a fair amount of pepper which made it stand out when paired with the yellow rice. I think if I had ordered the plantains on the side it would have elevated the dish more. Even so, it was tasty and filling enough that I was able to finish my plate and be satisfied.
While the bistec empanizado was good, I found the bistec encebollado to be tastier, more flavorful, and an overall better entree. While also being a thin cut of meat, The flavors were bolder and the caramelized onions helped to boost the profile of the steak. I reccomend to get plantains as a side with either of the entrees because I think the sweetness of the plantains works better than the fries and salad and also creates a more authentic dish.
Overall, Viejo de San Juan is a nice spot to grab a meal that bolsters not only authentic food, but also an extremely affordable price tag. The racion de tequeños stood out as one of the best appetizers I've had in recent memory, but both of my entrees fell to the wayside compared to other beed based dishes I've consumed. While still an overall pleasent experience, There was nothing that convinced me that a second visit was needed. Even so, if you want a full course Latin meal on a budget, this is still a viable option. read more