Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Michael Anthonys Pizza

    4.0 (170 reviews)
    ModeratePizza, Italian, American
    Closed 4:00 pm - 9:00 PM

    Order Michael Anthonys Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Michael Anthonys Pizza Photos

    MICHAEL ANTHONYS PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Casual
    Good for kids
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Michael Anthonys Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Half sausage & half pepperoni (ordered well done)
    Matt R.

    This place is a go-to spot to pick up pizza whenever I am visiting my dad in the area. Some of the best thin crust pizza I've had. I also ordered their beef sandwich and that was good too. Beef had nice flavor and was sliced super thin.

    Pizza
    Greg S.

    Great pizza. Very small, but it wasn't very crowded. Broccoli cheese puffs were a great start. Highly recommend the creamy garlic salad dressing. Two of us could only eat half of the pizza, so plenty of leftovers. Pepsi products to drink.

    St. Christopher - Italian beef, pepperoni, mozzarella, ricotta, and giardiniera peppers.
    Chris C.

    Definitely good pizza. Nice menu with a wide variety of choices among pizza, sandwiches, burgers, and Italian plates. I almost got the baked lasagna, which sounded amazing, but really wanted to try the pizza. I ordered the St. Christopher, which has Italian beef, pepperoni, mozzarella and ricotta. It was very good, and I got about 3/4 of a 12" pie down by myself with little problem. The only issue is the pizza also has giardiniera peppers on it, and they really make the pizza pop. If you don't like spicy stuff, you had best order the pizza minus the peppers. They offer thin crust, pan and stuffed. The one I got was thin crust. Not your typical Chicagoland choice, and if you're expecting Giordano's or Lou Malnati's, I don't know that this place does pizza like that. Who knows, they might. As for atmosphere, this is a typical family owned, small shop. Plenty of seating later in the evening. They seem to do a lot of carryout business. I sat down and pretty quickly got the feeling the place doesn't really do a lot of table service, although a server did eventually come out. But I think this is more of an order-at-the-counter kind of joint, which is fine. I hope the place thrives and continues to be around a long while. I enjoyed it and would like to come back and try other menu items.

    Inside dining area
    Lisa M.

    This is one of our go to pizza spots. We always get the 18 inch sausage pizza. The crust, sauce, and sausage on their pizza is absolutely delicious! They have a nice dining room with booths and tables. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. The food quality is great and prices are fair. We would definitely Michael Anthony's!

    I usually love this place! Everything is so delicious. Ordered for delivery and I found so many hairs on my garlic bread it was not edible, half of them even buried in. Gross gross.

    the price of the pizza

    See all

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Overrated. Stuffed pizza crust was a bit too hard to deal with. And using canned/ frozen mushrooms on pizza is a cardinal sin.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Excellent Pizza, meatballs, pasta sauce and salads. Highly recommended.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Great Pizza! HOT and on time. BLT pizza was awesome. Best ribs and meatballs in the Elmhurst area. Thanks !!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 5 of 5

    Ask the Community - Michael Anthonys Pizza

    You might also consider

    Avanzare Italian Restaurant

    Avanzare Italian Restaurant

    4.3
    (243 reviews)
    3.8 mi
    $$

    Perfect setting for date night. Service can be slower on a busy night, but 99% of the time we get…read moresat quickly and staff is always polite. The Carbonara and any of the pizzas are to die for.

    We were in the mode for Italian and asked Google for some help, Avanzare was one of the options. It…read morewas a 30-minute drive for everyone. The price point was on the high side for us but not out-of-reach. We arrived and was immediately sat in the bar; in fact, everyone is sat in the bar. The dining room has about twenty tables, and they were two tables being used; the bar also had about twenty tables and every table was sat. I asked the waiter and they do sit the bar area first and overflow into the dining room. With the bar area at near capacity and all hard surfaces it was very loud. The dining room had carpet floor and a coffered beamed ceiling it was tremendously quiet. If you want the energy of a crowded restaurant the bar is great, the dinning rom is a more upscale experience.  We started with Calamari Friiti, that is the title of the dish. In smaller print the description is Crispy Fried Calamari, Zucchini,  and herbs. What was served was 70% NOT Calamari but thin fried zucchini strips, fried rosemary (literally the twig of rosemary in batter and fried), and fried thyme (the thyme was removed from the twig so I could not even find it., but the waiter said it was there. At $19  expected more Calamari at least 60%, after all the dish was not called "fried herbs and Calamari". Our table had Spaghetti and Meatballs at $24, the Stuffed Pork Chop special (with Broccoli Rabe) at $27, and I had the Eggplant Parmigiana at $20. I get eggplant Parmesan a lot, it is my favorite Italian dish. $20 is high for eggplant Parmesan, I prefer my eggplant thinly sliced and fried. This is more three eggplant steaks with cheese and red gravy. Not my personal favorite but good. The pasta was so unusual I had to ask about it; the waiter said it is made from scratch in house but the shape in an Italian grocery store would be casarecce. I thought $24 for Spaghetti and Meatballs high but my husband said the Meatballs were excellent. Finally, $27 for one Stuffed Pork Chop also seemed high but it tasted great, the garlic white wine sauce made a tasty glaze. We ordered Tiramisu for the table and one person got the blueberry sorbet. I found the Tiramisu traditional and another person thought the mascarpone cheese was whipped too much. I read a several reviews, most of the reviewers praised the service as outstanding; we found our server disappearing for 30 - 40 minutes; we had to call someone over to order desert and another to get the check.

    Photos
    Main dining room
    Main dining room
    GNOCCHI AVANZARE Arugula, mushrooms, cherry tomatoes, green onions and creamy black truffle butter sauce
    GNOCCHI AVANZARE Arugula, mushrooms, cherry tomatoes, green onions and creamy black truffle butter sauce
    Outside front of restaurant

    See all

    Outside front of restaurant
    Francesca's Amici

    Francesca's Amici

    4.0
    (402 reviews)
    1.9 mi
    $$

    From the very beginning of planning my family's bridal shower, I knew we wouldn't want to host this…read moremilestone anywhere else. The quality of the food and the beautiful private space made the occasion feel truly special. That said, it's the people who make this place exceptional. Ashley, Lindsay, Maria, Gianna, Odanys, Osmel, Eileen, Victor, and the entire kitchen team--Chef Oscar, Gloria, Laura, and Roberto--are the heart and soul of the experience. From start to finish, they asked thoughtful questions, anticipated every detail, and ensured everything ran seamlessly. They handled the heavy lifting so our family could focus on what mattered most: being together and celebrating. Each course was intentional and perfectly timed, and every guest felt genuinely cared for. Lastly, Nancy's impeccable attention to detail, professionalism, and thoughtfulness made the entire planning process not only smooth, but truly memorable.

    This place was alright. I came here for lunch with a coworker during a business trip since we were…read morecraving Italian food. They started us off with bread, which was pretty standard. I ordered the pollo Milanese. The breaded chicken was good, nice and crispy with decent flavor. The pasta was a bit bland and didn't really add much to the dish. The presentation looked great, but overall the taste was lacking. Portions were filling, though I did feel it was a little overpriced for what you get. It's a decent option if you're craving Italian food while on the road, but I'd probably try a different Italian spot next time.

    Photos
    Francesca's Amici
    Francesca's Amici
    Francesca's Amici

    See all

    Antico Posto

    Antico Posto

    4.2
    (1k reviews)
    2.7 mi
    $$

    A little difficult to find, as you cannot see the restaurant from the parking lot. There were no…read moresigns to guide you either but we figured it out pretty well. Once we arrived, the hostess could not have been more sweet. She was all smiles and was very welcoming. Our server was just as pleasant. She remembered my friend from previous visits. The room is very comfortable. Dark with a lot of natural tones that create the perfect backdrop for a lovely meal. A couple requests were missed by the bar and kitchen, however our cocktails and meals were still delicious. We loved everything. Overall, we had a very nice dinner and I look forward to my next visit.

    I came here for an event, so my review is based only on the service, food, and drinks…read more As we entered the private room, we were offered wine. I had their cabernet sauvignon and it was delicious. The bread was excellent. The crust almost reminded me of a salted pretzel. The chicken meatballs were flavorful. Calamari was ok. For the 2 pastas that I got to try, the spicy rigatoni was good. Chicken vesuvio was tasty and moist. For the grand finale we had cheesecake and tiramisu. Service was excellent. Park in the orange garage as that is the closest to the restaurant. I left around 8 pm and the restaurant was busy. I definitely recommend reservations.

    Photos
    Antico Posto
    September 2025 Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza (it lived up to the name, spicy)
    September 2025 Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza (it lived up to the name, spicy)
    Dinner special fillets over risotto

    See all

    Dinner special fillets over risotto
    Fire + Wine

    Fire + Wine

    4.4
    (1.2k reviews)
    5.1 mi
    $$$

    Absolutely love this intimate restaurant in the heart of Glen Ellyn. The low lighting and warm…read moreatmosphere are perfect for a date night or girls night out with a glass of wine. They have an excellent bar up front and make great cocktails- my husband and dad both love the classic old fashion! I'm a sucker for a nice glass of Pinot Noir. If you're dining in (and you really should!) The pasta bolognese is a must have. Always amazing. And the black pepper shrimp over polenta is an amazing appetizer! So rich and delicious. These are both part of my go-to order here. Recently expanded my order and tried the short rib over polenta for the first time, it was amazing. Tender. Flavorful. Good sized portion. Wonderful. Will absolutely get again. For dessert, and there's always room for dessert here in my opinion, I love to get the rich panna cotta. This past time though we got the butterscotch budino, which was smooth and rich without being overly sweet. It was perfect to share (or not)! Just enough hint of butterscotch and topped with a crumbled shortbread cookie to an add a little crunch to the otherwise creamy treat. The staff is always helpful in making recommendations to suit your tastes too! There is a call ahead wait list and they've also started taking reservations. Enjoy your night out in Glen Ellyn at Fire and Wine, cheers!

    Came in early on a Friday night during Lilac season and decided to relax with a drink before…read moreputting our names in for dinner. Service in all areas was super friendly and helpful all night! Nice selection of their own mixed drinks, wine and good craft beer selection. By the time we were ready to be seated the place was hopping and nearly full, we asked for first available. Were seated immediately outside and service was always prompt. There's so much on the menu, my vegetarian friend had plenty to choose from and loved their gnocchi dish with veggies. I loved my salmon with fingerling potatoes and veggies. Fire + Wine will definitely be getting return visits from us!

    Photos
    Cozy inside dining.  Loud though
    Cozy inside dining. Loud though
    Truffle fries
    Truffle fries
    Asiago Stuffed Gnocchi with roasted vegetables

    See all

    Asiago Stuffed Gnocchi with roasted vegetables

    Michael Anthonys Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...