If I had noticed the "no masks on employees" reviews by Ja k , Diane P and Mari S, we NEVER would have gone there. How irresponsible and foolish. We ordered two pizzas for carryout. Neither was very good. Price was over $40. One was a gluten-free pizza with sausage and banana peppers. Crust was thin, tasteless, and limp. They would do better to buy per-made GF crusts at Costco. The other was a 12" vegetarian pizza with broccoli, tomatoes and banana pepper. Crust again was largely tasteless, the added vegetables were relatively sparse, and the sauce had almost no body to it. Don't think the cheese was that great either. read more

It's okay. Definitely nothing special. I probably couldn't tell the difference between a DiGiorno frozen pizza and their Pizza if I was blindfolded and had to do a taste test. I mean other than the price difference. read more

You can't drive by and not stop in for some of these bad boys. The smell tickles your nose. Oh and they have some of the best pizza I've ever had, and I've been to N.Y. Amazing service every single time. read more

Michele's cuicina - Garlic knots - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Arrived to amazement, not one staff member including kitchen staff had a mask on and 4 staff were huddled together-at the front counter. Guests arriving had masks on. Ordered a pizza togo, the crust tasted as though it had been around for several days. Will not go to this restaurant again. Be very concerned about Covid spread here. read more

When we went to pick up this pizza it was warm and looked delicious, but it took a while I guess we just weren't thinking when we decided to get a quick bite to eat but that's an expected with pizza. Lol read more

Nancy's Pizza has been my absolute favorite pizza in the area since they opened. The taste and cook is perfect - I have gotten many pies from here, and have never been disappointed! Classic cheese pizza is the BEST. I have also had the burrata salad, which was a generous portion and delicious. I highly recommend this neighborhood pizza shop. Yum! read more

I can't say enough good things about this place! The pizza is excellent! So is the buffalo chicken Stromboli!! They are always on time with their deliveries and super friendly when placing an order. read more

For my first time trying Nancy's, I ordered a pepperoni and Sausage Pizza. I was blown away. The pizza had an excellent crust paired with a sweet, tomato sauce and the perfect amount of cheese. The toppings were plentiful, fresh and of the highest quality. I will definitely be back! read more

Really love the food here. My wife and I like to come in and order wings, meatballs, and buratta. Staff is really friendly and we enjoy our lunches and dinners here. Have not tried the pizza yet. Zeppoli's are off the chart. read more

Martin County dispatch thanks you for kindness tonight. Enjoyed a great meal today. Pizza was fresh and delivered promptly.

We tried Nancy's and were very disappointed with their pasta fagioli soup. It had way to much garlic. I haven't tried their pizza but I heard it was good. read more

Best pizza and garlic knots around. The garlic knots have nice big chunks of garlic! The sauce is yummy! The Buffalo wings are also delicious! Cooked correctly and not soggy. I have also tried delivery and was just as happy. Great food, great atmosphere, great service. read more

Nancy's was spectacular! We stopped in for a quick bite of pizza and wings and who knew it was going to be fabulous Italian cuisine, not to mention the desserts! The atmosphere made me feel at home with the family photos and Sinatra style music. Definitely a must if you're looking for a great Italian dinner and a fun night out. read more

Very friendly staff, quick service. I had the stuffed ravioli and my husband had the lasagna. I loved mine and he ate all of his so I have to stay he liked it. Have not tried their pizza yet, but that will be our next visit. read more

My family and I had such an amazing meal while in town, at Nancy's. The staff were friendly and personable, the food was fresh and delicious and left us wanting more! We will definitely be back soon! read more

NOT GLUTEN FREE if you have a gluten allergy DO NOT eat here! I ordered a gluten free pizza and got cross contamination. Also it's kind of expensive. If you are choosing to not eat gluten and it isn't an allergy, their cauliflower crust and sauce is pretty good. If you have a gluten allergy, not worth the risk. Also there's a pandemic and NOT ONE PERSON had a mask or gloves. read more

So good my mouth is watering just remembering my meal here! All we had was pizza and some garlic knots but everything was heavenly! We will be back to try some of the pasta dishes that we saw were HUGE portion sizes. read more

Great selection of appetizers, pizza and dinners. Antipasto was good, roasted wings w/garlic we're delicious. Kids had Hawaiian pizza which they loved! Outdoor seating was great with the cool weather. read more

Great new biz with a really good pie. Very nice staff and a quick and yummy lunch special with a big slice , drink , and a salad. Been in four or five times. Never disappointed. read more

We are recent transplants from Houston and decided to try Nancy's. Small but very clean inside. Hubby and granddaughter split a Sicilian style thick pizza with pepperoni and I ordered a sausage and pepper sandwich. The pizza was incredible and the size was huge, 2 pieces was more than enough to satisfy any appetite. My sandwich was great, the sausage wonderful as was the roll it was served on. Can't wait to go back and try some more items on the menu. read more

This is by far the best pizza in town. The place is just hands down fabulous!!!! The waitstaff is excellent. The place is spotless. I've been here a dozen times and it never disappoints. Everything I've had has been outstanding. You can even bring your own bottle of wine for a small corkage fee. read more

Have never had a bad meal at Nancy's, their thin crust is always cooked with the perfect amount of crunch on the bottom and chewy on the top. Nancy's sauce is the best and my son always gets a Canoli, Michelle, Joe, Eduardo and the crew always make us feel welcome. read more

Wonderful Margherita pizza. Crust is so light. Tomatoes sliced so thin with a lot of them on it. Best we have ever had!

Excellent sandwiches and pizza I have been several times and also done takeout. Ingredients seem fresh and portions are good size. Prices are within reason for what you get and staff are very friendly and accommodating. read more

While their house specialty dishes are excellent, stay away from their Overstated pizzas. For example you can't even find the meat on their "meat lovers" pizza !!! Pizzas are not their specialty read more

Awesome awesome awesome. Have been here several times and never had a meal I was not blown away by. Thank you Nancy's!

I've been here twice, but I can say I'll be back. I've tried the pizza and garlic knots, and those are about a 4.5/5. The service was 10/10. Our waitress was attentive and polite. Super nice staff. Definitely the top pizza place in Stuart. read more

Nice place...but when we were there the woman owner and her friends occupied a table next to us and were very loud and pretty much annoying. The waitress was just so nice and caring.. The gentlemen owner nice as well but . . .the food was terrible. I am Italian... believe me the pizza was a long way from being Italian.. Sorry nice people.... get some good advice and good luck. read more

Amazing amazing pizza! Loved everything about there food and service was amazing! Definitely worth it! This is definitely gonna be my new go to spot. read more

Fantastic thin crust veggie pizza, super friendly service, and clearly a family operation.....support family businesses!

Great pizza, outstanding garlic knots. Wish they had a weekday special, but the quality still draws our taste buds. Friendly staff/ environment. Would recommend to all pizza/knot lovers to try. read more

Loved the atmosphere, and the customer service was on point! GREAT garlic knots and marinara sauce. Will definitely be going back!

Lived in West Palm and had our fav for 30 years. Moved to Stuart a little over a year ago. One of the things we missed the most was Marrio The Baker in Royal Palm. We thought we would not find anything that good here. Well .. it took a year and we found it !! Everything we ordered is delicious.. Highly recommended!! First thing noticed was the smell when we got out of the car .. oh yea. Garlic rolls fist that were to die for. I knew then. Pizza was fantastic along with the chicken franchise .. read more

Nancy herself greeted us cheerfully immediately upon entry. There were only a couple of tables empty and were able to seat ourselves. We were immediately approached by Nancy. We ordered drinks and a large antipasto to share. We made a special request for the salad and were easily accommodated. We then ordered a pizza which was mistakenly packed by staff in a box to go. Nancy made sure our pizza was warmed up before bringing it to the table. Still delicious! As we sat many "regulars" stopped in. Delicious food and a family atmosphere! We'll be back! I hear the eggplant rollatini is delicious! read more

It's beyond my favorite pizzeria. I drive all the way from Orlando just to have their garlic knots. The meatballs..... out of this world and the size of a softball! Their wings are impeccable and the flavors are all to die for, we got the garlic Parmesan and mixed it with hot as Nancy herself suggested and I'm never going back! You're always greeted with a smile and service is quick and easy. 10/10 recommended and 110% will be coming back! read more

Amazing!!! I have been following them on Instagram for a bit now and the pics and posts were amazing and mouth watering!!! We ordered a a white pizza, chicken piccata and garlic knots!!! Amazing! The pizza was thin crisp and delicious..we added meatballs and they were fabulous!!! The chicken piccata was tender and super flavorful, side salad with house dressing was very good and the garlic knot and roasted garlic to top it was amazing! Garlic rolls big and great little crisp on the bottom with a soft garlic loaded roll! Highly recommend to all!! read more

Went here a couple of weeks ago and it was amazing. Ordered a Stromboli and it was huge and tasted excellent. GF ordered chicken picatta and I tried some. Even better and the presentation was out of a five star restaurant. Service on point. Saw some other orders and it all looked incredible. I will be back! read more

The pizza would be good if they used real mozzarella and not some velveeta like nasty cheese. I find it hard to believe a pizza place could even stay in business using that nasty fake processed cheese garbage! Maybe a child or someone with no pizza experience would like this place sorry it's just not right I would find an other place to order pizza. read more

Amazing food quality, quick and friendly service. I recommend trying the garlic knots, white pizza and zepoles! We are in town until tomorrow, but we will be back to Stuart just to eat at Nancy's. read more

We went to this restaurant a couple of weeks ago, they do NOT practice Covid guidelines, we observed people coming in to the kitchen without masks including a Stuart police officer. We had three different pizzas which included the special with cheese and balsamic , the sausage and pepper pizza and a gluten free pie. The pizza in our opinion was nothing special. Our server Drew did observe the Covid guidelines and she was a very good server. read more