This was hands down the best Italian restaurant I have EVER been to. We picked eating here because it was close to our hotel but we are already planing a trip with our family to share the amazing cuisine with them. The fettuccine is incredible. The lemon cello is muah! Thank you Nancy's for the best food in all of Florida! read more

Michele's cuicina - Garlic knots with shaved garlic - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

We live out of town in Boca and we are surrounded by great restaurants. We came here merely on the reviews. Great staff. Wonderful food. Welcoming environment. Don't listen to any of the silly negative reviews! This place is a gem little hole in the wall and the best kept secret in town. Great all the way around! read more

Honestly the worst $40 plus tip I've ever spent on delivery. Besides the soggy bread and not sure how to describe the fries, peppers and onions must have sounded like pepperochinis I'm just not happy and don't want a redelivery. Just won't order again. The delivery guy is the only reason I gave a 3. read more

Delicious pizza and kind staff. Love the family photos around the restaurant too. Kid approved!

Did takeout ! NO ONE wearing a mask ! New to area and checking out new pizza restaurants . Food was good . We won't be back .

Great pizza crust is crunchy not soggy , great service..... clean. Will definitely eat again read more

See all

Was in town visiting my dad who lives in Stuart. I read some reviews here and most were dead on. We got the chicken parm and sausage and mushroom pizzas. Both were very solid. NY style with great crust, but the ingredients were all so fresh and tasty. We are definitely believers in this place! read more

Their pizza is very good and there are vegan options. When I picked up pizza today no one was wearing a mask not the counter man nor the cooks nor most of the staff. When i asked about this I was told it wasn't mandatory and the owner did not require mask wearing. I found this troubling being in the middle of a pandemic with a new more contagious variant and vaccines going at a turtle pace. I will not return unless I see better covid precautions. Bummer, i really like their pizza. read more

Nancy's is one of our go to restaurants for take out and delivery. Their pizza is great. We especially enjoyed their chicken parmigiana, their chicken Marsala and their chicken wings. I highly recommend read more

Great service! Delicious (and plentiful) food! Attentive staff! Ate outside (under their tent in the parking lot) and enjoyed the gentle breeze! Only drawback: traffic noise! Ugh! read more

Good food. Fair prices Free delivery on my area. A little skimpy on pasta but good quality and quantity on entrees.

Absolutely delicious food. From the appetizers to the entrees. Even the pizza is amazing. They also serve alcohol! Beer and wine available. Great place I will always recommend it read more

We decided to try the pizza here since we had seen many good reviews, was concerned when I picked up the pizza to see 5 employees, none wearing masks including the man in the kitchen. Since my husband and I are in our 60's with underlying conditions we were disappointed to see this business did not conform to CDC guidelines and seemed unconcerned with the health of their customers. As far as the pizza goes, it was just a plain pizza, nothing fancy and was ok but nothing to rave about. We will not return unless they show more concern for the health of their customers and employees by at least wearing masks. read more

Highly recommend Nancy's Pizza not only for the food but for the warm comfortable feeling obtained because of the way you are greeted and treated. The owners and staff actually care about their customers. It makes for a great place in general. Try it and you see www at I mean. read more

I stopped a few months back price the covid pandemic. I went with a friend of mine we wanted a cheese pizza I forgot to say to the sauce so I told the girl who is waiting on us to bring extra sauce if it was too late to put it on. The pizza was very thin and tasteless the sauce was like water tomato colored it was awful. Is not very good pizza probably the worst Pizza. read more

Always great food,great ppl. Great service. Always enjoy the pizza and of course other food items are fantastic.

Excellent service and one of the best pizzas I've ever eaten. We got the Sicilian with meatballs, sausage ,pepperoni and green pepper. Perfection! read more

I currently live in Delray Beach and this is the best Pizza place around! It is worth the drive! The staff is amazing and friendly and the menu has many options! I recommend!! read more

Absolutely love the pizza and wings in Nancy's way!! The wings are a must for any garlic lover since there's chunks of it used in the sauce. The workers are amazing too! read more

We heard they had gluten free pizza and decided to try it since my husband is looking for a new GF go-to. I went in early last week to pick up our take out order and no one was wearing gloves or masks. NOT. ONE. EMPLOYEE. All 6 employees plus a manager? or maybe owner? all standing in a circle not 6 inches from each other chatting it up and laughing. I'm all for having fun at work but the fact that they could not care less about being socially responsible or even SEEMING to be socially responsible in front of the public, nevertheless new customers, was a huge turn off. Local place not giving a crap about locals. Will not be back. The pizza could have somewhat saved them but it didn't. Step above Dominos. read more

Great food & the Burrata is amazing! We thought the delivery charge was a bit steep ($2.00 every mile outside of a 5 mile radius) but appreciated that they traveled to our condo for delivery during this time. read more

I hate to leave a bad review, but went in 5/20/20 for carry out, had to go into the locations store front, not a person in with a mask, serving or cooking. The tables were not 6 ft apart, and social distancing was not being used. I have a stage 4 cancer patient at home, and felt very unsafe in that environment. I will not be back, I can find my pizza where the establishment cares about their help and patrons read more

Second time I had the margarita pizza ( typo) Very very delicious along with the garlic knots it's not inexpensive but the taste made up for it read more

Came to Stuart for vacation and decided to take a chance with Nancy's pizza. Let me tell you, we were not disappointed. Everything was amazing. The staff was friendly, the service was great and the food was amazing. Even got a chance to meet Nancy herself. She treated us like family and even brought my daughter some fried ravioli. If you're in Stuart you definitely need to stop by Nancy's. read more

Had their pizza for an office party...meh....not impressed!! Won't try them again! Was like a round of cardboard. Sorry, crust was awful! Second chance...two strikes now. read more

Tonight my wife and I ate at Nancy's for the first time with a group of friends. We were impressed by the quality of our food and the above and beyond service of the staff. My Cheese Steak Calzone was awesome. We will plan to return. read more

I will not be going back. I take back my original review, the business told me to write it anyways.

waited 40+ minutes for my food and the crust was over cooked. Gross environment and staff was rude and disrespectful.

On a tempting Sunday we ordered three pizzas. The burrata, the grandma Nancy Sicilian and a bambino. The burrata was very good, we loved the balance of the ingredients even adding sausage to it. However the Sicilian pizza was virtually inedible. The dough was over cooked and having whole slices of sandwich pepperoni on pizza makes it very unappealing and unenjoyable to eat. I wouldn't recommend this pizza. read more

I brake for garlic knots! The marinara is the best I've ever had. Burrata pizza is my favorite and the crust is the perfect mixture of crunch and dough. read more

Very good service and food. I will return. We had the pizza. Next time I will try the hot Italian sub. Salad was good too! read more

Michele's cuicina - Inside pic - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

My new go-to pizza place! I had the Philly Cheesesteak pizza, WOW AWESOME. The garlic knots are big and heavy on the garlic, not reccomended for vampires. Went back the next week for a stromboli and it was amazing! read more

Just had lunch at Nancy's Pizza another great experience awesome garlic knots awesome pizza and Drew our waitress was on point. Joe the manager always makes it a point to come over and say hi makes you feel like family I highly recommend the spot read more

Got a pretty good recommendation and our usual Anna's is closed on Monday's -- so we went over Nancy's for the first time -- pretty disappointing -- pizza was not up to Anna's standard -- chicken Marsala was dry and tasteless -- the caprese salad had some over spicy marinated vegetables added -- all said and done -- not worth the 45 bucks and not worth a trip back -- when Anna's is closed on Monday's we'll just get Chinese over in Palm City Got a call from owner Kristen ... post review -- very nice lady -- graciously offered to comp a future meal -- told her that certainly wasn't the reason for my candid review -- Kristen was very professional -- she acknowledged spicy, marinated vegetables aren't traditional part of a caprese salad -- more often added to an anti pasta offering -- and that maybe the cook didn't do his best with the Marsala sauce -- we'll see read more

the food is fantastic, along with the servic. on our honeymoon we ordered from there twice!

Amazing food and service. The burrata pizza is so delicious. The lasagna, meatball appetizer, garlic knots, eggplant stack...honestly everything is so great! read more

Just delicious! Love this pizza and order frequently. Big pepp slices and soft crust, just melts in your mouth!

Called in an order last Tuesday and it was coming out of the oven as I walked in. Everyone at the counter was super friendly and it was nice to see a new place busy on a Tuesday evening. The pizza was delicious and the size of the pepperoni slices was HUGE. Will definitely be eating here again! read more

We decided to try Nancy's Pizza since it was relatively new and close to out home. What a delicious place to get some very authentic Italian food. My wife is a huge fan of their roasted garlic & oil with toasted bread, fresh antipasto and broccoli rabe. Our son loved the pepperoni pizza and fresh Parmesan. I ordered spaghetti and meatballs- Wow! The size of the meatballs....what a fantastic deal. Fresh garlic knots, yum! We've been back three times in the past two weeks. Friendly service and great food, clean, good parking and convenient location. read more

Got a pizza (Margarita) last nite and although we've had acceptable pizza there before, this was like eating cardboard,,, think we'll go back to Mondo:::I don't mind paying $18, for a 12" pizza but only if it's decent! Won't order from them again... read more