Server Jeff was knowledgeable and charming. The clam chowder was magic - I'll be back!read more

We were surprised at the thought put into the menu. Wine list is minimal which is a downer but the…read morewine was fine. Had the linguine with ahi and salmon and it was off the charts and reasonable. Service was outstanding. Place is a little loud and not much thought into the decor. They tried but could have been better. Bottom line great food and service and a good value on the vineyard.

The place was packed and the day was extra cold but that meant nothing to any of us. The way it is…read moreset up if you are cold outside you might be colder inside. Service was very friendly. I am going to recommend the fish sandwich or the fish and chips which was sooooo tasty. I pleasantly excited.

My first time to the island and also here. We stopped by because they could seat 9 guest, our…read moreparty, and it was immediately. Orders were taken by a friendly guy who had a take for the menu and what was good and was very user friendly. We ordered the drinks and then the food. A look at the menu, I found the prices were on the high side for my taste but we are in a tourist trap and cost are what they are. The atmosphere was beach like and I loved the mix of old beach stuff with a beer bar mash up, The drinks came and for the most part all were good except for me. I ordered a traditional Mojito. Having had plenty of good ones and lot of bad one's this one was on the bad side. Tasted store bought mix and repeat with too much mint. The strong mint flavor is a dead give a way that it was premade mix. Avoid it. You want to pay $17 for a glass of sugar water that has NO ALCOHOL in it. You have been warned. The food, well all were satisfied with it except for me. My niece and her husband enjoyed the lobster roll. It was market price I don't know what that cost but I knew it was out of my price range. My wife had the fish sandwich and she LOVE it. She said that is what a fish sandwich is supposed to be like. My son had the american burger and fries combo. He said it was average at best. That good for him. I had the clam chowder. What a let down. It looked homemade but the broth was watery. Flavor was average better than a can but slightly better. I had the clam chowder at another restaurant in Mystic that was 10/10 this was 4/10. In summary, Three stars could have been better in my book but the others felt it was above average drinks and food. Recommended Yes and you decide for yourself and shoot me a line on what you think.

Great place. Enjoyed the servive, the food and the not too crazy price. We will come back. Hidden…read morejewel.

We placed a huge takeout order for a rehearsal dinner at our house. They had it on time, packed…read morewell and ready on pickup. Food was great! We had mostly Chinese - apps, Edamame, and lots of dishes - all good, all hot, some still good for lunch the next day. Worthwhile!

Fresh seafood here!…read more Pricey for a take out only place. There is some outdoor seating. We got fried scallops, fried belly clams, clam chowder, crab cake sandwich, and a sautéed lobster roll. The fried scallops were fresh! We opened it to eat within minutes but they were already soggy. I think they need to pat dry them out a bit more before frying them. Lightly seasoned. The clams were much better. Whole belly with lots of flavor. The tartar sauce was used for both of them. The sauce was amazing! The clam chowder looked watery upon opening it but it was thicker than expected. Flavorful and full of clams! Stuck my spoon in there and whoa lots of potatoes and clams at the bottom chilling. The crab cake sandwich was great! Good value, fresh, and tasty. Every component of it meshed well. The lobster roll was fresh as well. Hot and buttery. Kinda plain though. Some hot sauce helped.

A true hole in the wall of a fish market with a twist. A truly delicious lobster roll any one of…read morethree ways. Exceptionally fresh. Toasted buttered bun. Kind service. The perfect MV experience. Thank you.

Had some time to kill before meeting a friend at the ferry and really pleased to have chosen…read moreNancy's over the plethora of other spots on the strip! I was a little hesitant given the ratings but I have no regrets. You order at the window and pick up your food so not much service to speak of, but the cashier's were nice and helpful and the bartender crushed it. I had a banana mudslide concoction that was absolutely delicious and perfect on a warm late summer day. I will almost always go for a lobster roll (warm with butter, please) and this time was no different. Price was on par with what you'd expect for a lobster roll on the island and the portions were more than I expected, a lovely surprise. Tables were clean and I snagged a picnic table with a view of the water. Needless to say I was happy as a clam and would absolutely come back.

In this episode of eating my way through Oak Bluffs, I made my usual stop at Nancy's -- a must-hit…read morespot whenever I'm on the island. This place has a little bit of everything, but there are two things you can't leave without trying. First, the fried shrimp. I know, it sounds basic, but these are on another level. Lightly battered, seasoned just right, and cooked perfectly -- no heavy breading to hide the flavor, just clean, fresh shrimp done right. Second, head downstairs to their outdoor bar, Donovan's Reef, and get yourself a Dirty Banana. Think of it as a Mudslide's cooler, smoother cousin. Donovan himself makes every drink, and if you're like me and don't want your cocktail overpowered by alcohol, this is the perfect balance -- sweet, smooth, and dangerously easy to sip. Nancy's is usually one of my first stops when I hit the island, and for good reason. Simple, fresh, and consistent. Verdict: Island staple, no debate. I eat, I judge. The fork stops with me -- your feelings aren't on the menu.

great service and environment. good for families. food was tasty and came out quick. great portion…read moresizes and a nice place to grab a drink. and feta dip is delicious.

This is a year round restaurant that shares space with an adjacent hotel. There are both indoor and…read moreoutdoor seating and it can get quite busy during the Island's high season. Rather quiet and easy to find parking and a seat during the shoulder and off seasons. There is a fire place that makes it feel comfy during the cooler nights. The staff is always pleasant and efficient. many have been there for several seasons so they are full time islanders. The food selection is both American and a nice Asian menu. Plenty of choices. Consistent food and weekly specials.T

My order: Fish and chips (gluten free) and margarita with Tajin…read moreThe Review: I can't pass up a beautiful patio, and Fish was perfect. We were greeted by very attentive staff, who explained all of the gluten free options (which were plentiful). Most importantly, the margaritas were strong and we were able to choose the rim, so we went with Tajin! As for the food, it's not every day that you find GF fish and chips, so we went for it. It was delicious and crunchy, with a great tartar sauce. Why four stars? The slaw was a bit drenched in sauce and thus difficult to eat--I would have loved a crisp and crunchy slaw. Additionally, we got French fries that were still frozen mixed in with cooked ones. Luckily, the staff speedily replaced them. A low key, pleasant night out, I would still definitely recommend Fish to both visitors and islanders alike!

This place is great, love the patio seating and the servers were nice. Food was good too! We got 2…read moredozen oysters and the lobster sliders. I'd say the lobster was a little over cooked but still good. The crispy rice with the spicy tuna poke looked yummy! Gonna try those next time.

Has a little Starbucks in the store and the selection is good but super pricy and can sometimes not…read morecall out your order which can be confusing

I need a sixth star to rate my experience. Shamara and Maurice went above and beyond to get me a…read morelobster roll even though I unwittingly missed the 6p cutoff. What they didn't know is that I just had a tough meeting with a client and came in later than I'd planned. They made my evening. Caring so much about my experience guarantees that I will recommend this store to others.