This place deserves better than a 2.5 star rating. I'd say it's a 3.5/4 star, so gave it 4. Pizza is good & Greek salad is on point, kalamata olives to boot. I'd recommend it. read more

Mike's Pizza - I'd say it's a 3.5/4 star, so gave it 4. Pizza is good & Greek salad is on point, kalamata olives to boot. - Pizza Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Great pizza, fast service, awesome staff, clean tables and a clean bathroom. Wide range of drinks, beer included, and while there's a tip jar, the staff isn't pushy about getting you to drop a dollar in. I appreciate that, and given the great service I got, I definitely left a tip and did again when I had it delivered to my work. Thanks for the great food guys, I'll be there again soon. Cheers! read more

Great pizza and do have other kinds of foods, like salads, pasta dishes, Mexican dishes and they are tasty. My boys love their mozzarella sticks. read more

Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Delicious Greek Salad! Their chicken is fresh and well seasoned. Their feta is super creamy and the perfect amount of delicious saltiness. The dressing is a creamy Greek dressing and I love it! I did not eat here, but when I went to pick up my salad it was super clean and the young girl at the front desk was super sweet! Will definitely be back. read more

Very basic pizza shop, nothing out of this world as far as menu options. It's a clean restaurant and fast service. They are clearly very busy with all the tourists who visit the area and all the hotels surrounding them. They offer delivery, online ordering and accept Apple Pay for those who are interested. read more

Food - ordered 3 large pizzas. Cheese, pepperoni, sausage and onion. All of them were cooked quickly and all were yummy. Sausage was sliced thin with a generous helping of onions covering the pizza. The crust is light and crispy and the sauce is your standard red tomato pizza sauce. The place is right on the main road and easy travel in and out. It was empty when we arrived and while we ate a steady flow of customers came through. So far, the best pizza i have had on the cape and the best price per pie. read more

Best grilled chicken Caesar salad around!! When my husband and I still lived on the cape we ordered often from Mike's and I always got the Caesar salad, always...to the point that I crave it! I work in the area now and anytime I have a chance to get one for lunch I do. Their pizza is good. Not the best pizza I've ever had but good. This rating is solely based on the amazing salad! read more

Awful awful place. Wayyyyyy too overpriced for the amount of food you get, The counter person wasn't pleasant to talk to, and the food isn't that great. Be warned people! Definitely go somewhere else! read more

Called to order at approx 7 pm. Food was delivered at 753. Fries and pizza were very cold I called manager / owner told him he said he will send girl to pick the food up and won't charge my card. She came got the food I called my card number money had already been taken out When I called mikes back he said he charged the money back and don't call him again read more

Mike's pizza was the only thing opened the other night when I was hungry and needed to get out of the house... upon arrival I was met by a particularly unfriendly female employee who seemed to just not want to be there and in fact didn't show any kind of expression that she was glad a customer came in.. after I ordered my pizza I waited for it to be made and when it was done she literally threw it at me... shame, because the pizza was flavorful yet I will not return based on the attitude of the employee I encountered. read more

Quick stop for a take out lunch. Got the grilled chicken Caesar wrap and the grilled chicken greek wrap and was NOT disappointed. The grilled chicken is freshly cooked and ridiculously good. Price is great too! Will be back when in the area again. read more

I try to support local businesses but can't do this place again. Ordered at 5:29 and arrived at 7:15. Called a few times being told on its way. Specifically ordered grinder to be toasted crispy and it was ice cold and not really toasted at all. Grilled chicken salad - well the chicken was cold and tough. Will not be supporting Mike's . Too bad. read more

Friendly service and the kids liked the cheesesteak pizza. Would definitely order from here again.

Sorry, Mike. Your pizza isn't that good, dude. After placing a phone order, I arrived at Mike's exactly when my order was supposed to ready (15 minutes). I paid for my order at the counter, and waited at least another 5 minutes before it was ready. This wasn't that big of a deal, and my cashier apologized for the delay. I ordered two pizzas, a sub, and some wings. The wings and the sub were both pretty good - they hit the spot. But, the pizza fell short. The pizzas looked great, but they both lacked flavor. The sauce was bland, and the only flavor comes from the toppings. So, my pepperoni pizza was pretty dismal, but the Hawaiian was slightly better. If Mike's was a sub shop, it'd get at least 3 stars. But since it's called "Mike's Pizza", I just can't give it the 3 star A-OK. Palio Pizzeria on Main Street remains my favorite pizza in Hyannis. read more

I order from here fairly regularly. The bbq chicken pizza is bomb and so is the grilled steak salad. Best part is they will deliver to my area and the delivery people are awesome. read more

How can they even call this stuff pizza. Really! Preformed crust. Almost like a boboli crust you buy in the supermarket but not that good. More like a piece of cardboard with pizza toppings on it. Sauce and cheese were mediocre at best. I'm from NYC so I know good pizza. I live in Florida now so I know bad pizza too. This place would stink in Florida even. My guess is the only way it stays open is because you're trapped on an island and you need some junk to order in for the kids while you go out for lobster. read more

We have ordered from them before and it was ok, this time was terrible. We were told 50 minutes to an hour for delivery, it took 1 1/2 hours. Our pizza was cold. fries soggy and sandwich was not as expected. When I called to check on the order after an hour, they were like yeah, it's on the e way. Not impressed at all read more

Yum! BLT sub and the fries were amazing! Pizza was delicious too. We will be back for more!

Great staff! The owner helped spot me when I was doing deadlifts in the dining room. When he saw me carry in 270lbs of weights and did not even question it. He threw on a tank top and said "Let's do this!". The food was great and the flavor was as beautifully strong as the man who served it!!!! Will go again! read more

Went to Hyannis for a long weekend. Ate here when we pulled in and the night before we left watching football. The food is fantastic, quicker than stated, soooo so nice. Decent prices and AMAZING chicken lemon soup. THANK YOU to Mikes for a great find!! read more

Ok first time ordering from here. Families food ok . I ordered a calzone. Basically got cheesy bread not an once of ricotta in it just mozzarella. read more

Food is great however the girl that takes orders over the phone named Tatiana is extremely rude...no customer service skills.

No complaints on meal but very disturbing to see the majority of the people preparing food were not wearing masks and NONE were wearing gloves. Food wasnt for me but still disturbing. read more

Went to Mikes for take out and it was delicious the Buff chicken was off the chains but not just the food the service was great they were so nice and actually suggested the buff chicken and must of been one of the best decisions I have made. read more

After a bad experience with another Area Pizza in the "CRAIGVILLE AREA" we decided to try these guys. Wow night and day difference. Staff was friendly on the phone and delivery didnt take 1 1/2hrs to get food. 30Mins later we were sitting down having a couple nice pizzas. Thanks for serving Cape Cod. read more

I dislike being a "Karen", especially when it's a local business, but our experience tonight ordering delivery from this place was absolute insanity. We have ordered from here before with minimal issues (they have left our food out on the doorstep before without telling us it arrived, but it wasn't a dealbreaker), but the first thing we noticed was that the guy delivering the food wasn't wearing a mask; that would be enough to deter us. However, they also screwed up our order and gave us someone else's, so we called the restaurant and the person told us to keep it. They sent the delivery driver back to deliver our food and for some reason, he asked for the mistake order back, despite the fact that we'd already opened it and it would be cross-contamination for someone else OR the restaurant. Guy on the phone had said that the delivery driver did this 4x already tonight...what kind of business are you running here? Anyone worried about COVID should avoid this place like the plague. Such a shame, because the food is decent. :/ We will never be back. read more

I recently reviewed a pizza place down the street from Mikes and said: "It's a pizza joint - stick to the pizza." Now I'm saying the opposite. It's a pizza joint - stick to the rest of the menu. As mentioned, Mikes serves the standard Greek pizza, and it's not very good. Too much sauce, and that's a problem because it's the worst part of this particular pizza. The sandwiches are very good, especially the clubs. Turkey, roast beef, cheeseburger, grilled chicken(my favorite), comes with a side of fries which are also very good. My daughter loves the chicken tenders here too. I think the best part about Mikes is the woman who works the counter, one of the nicest, most pleasant people you'll ever meet. It's pretty cool to be there at lunch time and see her interact with the customers, many of whom she knows by name. read more

Picked up pizza and a salad. Very reasonable price. $18 total. Pizza is you usual greek style. Sauce is good, garlicy without being overbearing. Cheese pizza really cheesy which totally wins points with me. My husband got the chicken cesar salad. Good size. Fresh lettuce. Chicken was grilled perfectly, good char and still moist. Over all I highly recommend. I gave it a 3 not because it was lacking. It was very good. But 4 and 5 stars are for fine dining. I would definitely go back. read more

Needed a quick bite to eat after getting off ferry. We split a large calzone which was quite good. Friendly staff too.

I just ordered here for the first time because all the girls do from my work, it's so close to our salon. I was going to get delivery but they said an hour so I decided to pick it up but it was still 35-40 minutes. I set a timer for 25 minutes and still left with 5 minutes on my clock countdown. My food was already ready and luckily not cold. I ordered onion rings and a chicken quesadilla. I didn't think it would come with just cheese and chicken. Anytime I've order a quesadilla it has come with tomato.. Olives... Something! So overall it wasn't a pleasant experience and I won't be going back. read more

We stayed in Hyannis for Vacation the week of 4-15 . Most of the time we ate at local restaurants . A few times we ordered in from Mikes Pizza. The Pizza was quite good in my opinion . Sometimes we ate lunch out and ordered a salad in the late evening, again Mikes Pizza has very good salads . Delivery was prompt and the food was worth it . Thanks for all the great food ! We enjoyed it ! read more

The food is great if you go inside I have ordered delivery here 3 times and every single time when my food comes it's soggy, cold and falling apart! Last time I called to check on it she told me the delivery driver left with it 40 min ago, the lady was super nasty and needless to say I won't be returning, I'm less than a mile from there so that's just insane to me! read more

Ordered pizza from these guys last week, It was excellent! Some of the best pizza I have ever had. I will definately order from these guys again when I return to the area. read more

Pizza was great., I'd give that a 4... Cashier had no personality at all. She didn't smile,definitely was not friendly or welcoming at all. We felt like we were interrupting he texting time. read more

Ordered a chef salad. Asked for provolone cheese instead of the advertised American cheese. The salad was the only thing ordered and I had it delivered. When it arrived at my door in less than 10 minutes, I knew that no one even bothered with my request. Obviously, the salads are pre-made because the lettuce and two thinnest cucumber slices I had ever seen were wilted. The American cheese was still there. No provolone at all. The single hot pepper they put in there was rotten. They are super unfriendly on the phone and in person when you go inside. They are super cheap. Meaning cheap ingredients and sparse ingredients. The prices are not cheap. I have given them several chances and I am done. I will never return. (The delivery guy was friendly). read more

We used to live close by to mikes pizza and they have really great pizza!! We always got the linguica and onion!! The good thing about their pizza was the crust..its my favorite crisp and straight to the point..i hate chewy crust that takes forever to eat cuz its so doughy..i love to actually taste the cheese and toppings n mikes pizza is the place!! read more

I was looking for a quick pizza fix and I found it! I ordered a large cheese, since it was my first time ordering and I wanted to have a decent "baseline" for potential future orders. I was pleasantly surprised by the great blend of cheese that was used. It think it was cheddar, Monterey jack, provolone, and mozzarella. My pizza was delivered within the delivery time that was promised and it was wicked good. Will definitively order from Mike's again!! read more

Twice in the last 2 wks this company has tried to deliver food to my place of work that I didn't order.... once was even my day off! They swear they have caller ID and that I called from the store. I asked them to note that I will never order from them and they showed up again today. Apparently your caller ID is broken read more

The food is awesome!! Russian girl at the counter was a little held back I guess you could say. Didn't say hello or thank you or goodbye but one bad employee doesn't take away from the great food! Will be going back again! read more

I am in town doing training for my job. We have eaten takeout twice. The first time I ordered a wrap and it was HUGE! Today we had pizza. Both meals were delicious and I imagine it to be a great go to for lunch! read more