Got their buffalo chicken tender sub. Hit the spot, got it with blue cheese and mayo and I feel like they put the perfect amount. Good amount of seating area inside and staff inside were nice and friendly. Were amenable to changing a portion of my order when I got there even though I ordered over the phone. read more

Every now and then that facebook algorithm turns you to a place that you didn't know existed. Yes I said it. I didn't know about Mikes... I had an ad pop-up for the chicken, finger, sub specials, and being in the neighborhood I thought this would be a fantastic dinner option. I placed an order for two chicken, finger subs, and a three-piece chicken finger meal. The guy who answered the phone was super polite and very helpful. Arriving at Mike's my first initial impression was this place is very well kept. Everything was clean and it had that small neighborhood feel which is exactly what I love. Within a few minutes I had my order and was on my way home to enjoy. Those chicken finger subs really hit the spot today. They were very well cooked piled high and I really appreciated the toasted bun. The little yelper loved the tenders. And despite having several snacks before dinner completely crushed all of the chicken fingers. Needless to say, there was a few additional fans made today in our house, and we will definitely make the journey out to try Mike's again . read more

See all

Because we had a really great experience at Mike's a few weeks ago, we decided to revisit them tonight. Due to their popularity, they can get really busy so we thought we would phone in our order ahead and then pick up our food and sit at the restaurant. We arrived 20 minutes after placing our order and it had not been started yet. We waited patiently about another 20 minutes only to receive a pizza that was not cut all the way through. The simple request for the staff to please cut the pizza all the way through was met with a bit of attitude. After one gummy bite it was determined that it was also not cooked all the way through. The dining room was busy and there was a steady flow of customers at the counter. The staff attempted to do some service recovery by offering another pizza that would take another 20 minutes- they also attempted to offer us a credit but couldn't get the machine to process it. We are hopeful that the credit exists on our account as promised. We know we did not get their best tonight but are going to remain optimistic. read more

Great subs! I ordered a Royal and a Stinger sub they were both excellent. Friendly service too. I like all of the old timey photos on the walls too. Very cool. read more

Yearly Mikes subs trip. BOOOM. Exactly what I wanted and hit the spot. Absolutely great customer service here and the food is incredibly fresh. I can't wait to move back here and have mikes subs at my whims. I just really wish they sold t shirts and hats. I tried to buy some mikes subs apparel so I could rep it but was told they don't sell the shirts. Kind of a shame but it's ok! I'll still be back read more

I stopped in here for a quick bite and didn't want to over eat since we were meeting friends at Condrells after. We ended up splitting the appetizer platter. 3 big chicken fingers, onion rings, mozzarella sticks, potato munchers, and pizza rolls. Buffalo has the best chicken fingers hands down. The mozzarella sticks were packed full of mozzarella. Onion rings were beautifully batter and cooked to a nice golden brown. Pizza rolls were packed with cheese and pepperoni and the potato munchers were fluffy, cheesey, and golden brown. Not a bad thing to say about this spot. Next time I'm definitely getting a sub though. This is a laid back,casual, sub joint. You order at counter, and then they call your name. Staff was friendly and food was served quick and pipping hot. read more

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original - Chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, pizza rolls, potato munchers, and onion rings - Pizza Near Me - Kenmore, New York

There's no way a bologna sub should come like this. If that's the way Mike's quality is heading I'm quite disappointed. Sent email and gave a chance to respond but didn't receive one. Not done with them yet, but this is strike 1. read more

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original - This is what a $10 bologna sub looks like. For the record I emailed them and gave them a chance to respond but I received no response. - Pizza Near Me - Kenmore, New York

I visited my favorite sub shop today. I didn't give them a good rating for their steak sub because i didn't think it was high quality beef but today i got my favorite Mikey's original Sub Fantastic as usual they did a great job with the new staff that they have. DEFINITELY DELICIOUS read more

Another stop at Mike's.Been going there since the 80's. This time we enjoyed a medium white pizza, chicken fingers and a tuna sub. Always good food, reasonably priced. read more

See all

Awesome subs and delivery! Steak sub and steak and sausage sub recommended. Use 1- 1 free coupon on instacart...makes for a great deal!

Food was great but the guy with long greasy hair and the nose ring has a terrible attitude. 6-7-2025 10:45am read more

This review is only for their pizza! Absolutely the worst pizza in western New York. I ordered a medium cheese n pepperoni pie from mikes last week and opened the box and was blown away on how greasy and disgusting it looked I asked it to be cut in squares it was obvious the person who cut it had no idea what a square shape is I had shapes that I have never seen before . The pool of grease that covered the entire pie was gross the cheese melted into a puddle of oily liquid you could not see it was even cut until I picked up a soggy piece. The dough was like cardboard it was never proofed properly or it was frozen dough. I did not return it became I didn't want them to offer me a new one nothing they could do to fix how bad this pizza was!$20 I paid for this crap.Bob(mikes owner) stick to sandwich's you have no business selling garbage like this . read more

Went on the slice app ordered from Mikes They show a pepperoni and cheese pizza but when ordering there's no pepperoni to be added The pizza crust was like cardboard can tell it wasn't made fresh more like a 7-11 pizza ordered it banana peppers and had a total of 10 sliced peppers on a 16" pizza I also ordered a steak sub asked for no tomatoes even though it came with no tomatoes it had that distinct flavor of tomato with means at first they added and finished the sub realized the mistake and just took them off. And the meat was like shoe leather read more

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original - This is what they advertise - Pizza Near Me - Kenmore, New York

See all

My friends and I had a season 8 Game of Thornes marathon and when we took a break we ordered subs from Mike's and I'm so glad my friend told me about this place. I'm gluten free, my friend has celiac, one was a good Catholic on Friday during lent, and one is dairy free. With all of our problems, we were all able to find something that satisfied our appetites. I went with a royal on a gluten free roll. The gluten free rolls are from Kith N Kin, and they are delicious. Such a great sub. My friend got a pizza sub on gf sub roll and she enjoyed it. One friend ordered the white pizza sub and enjoyed it. The last friend ordered a chicken finger sub with no cheese and also thought it was good. When I am in the area, I would definitely order from here again because they make accommodations for dietary restrictions. You can also order online, so that is a plus. read more

Delicious and quite sloppy! Mike's offered. Nashville Hot Chicken sandwich for the past 4 days though today. Having heard about the original Nashville Hot Chicken sandwiches, we decided to try them. We ordered on line with a pick-up in 40 minutes. The pick up was seamless, other having arrived a few minutes too early. The sandwiches were delicious, but quite sloppy as there is a generous helping of Cole slaw under the chicken in the sandwich. I was glad that we ordered our sandwiches to go, because it was so sloppy. I needed more than a couple of paper napkins. I was able to rinse my hands at the kitchen sink! read more

We ordered today after quite a while! As always, YUMMY! My husband got the BBQ brisket sub and ate the whole thing. I went with the roast beef & turkey sub. I cannot say enough about this place! If you are in the area, definitely stop by! (BTW: I've never had the pizza) read more

Gave this place another try because I wanted pizza and HOLY COW! From what I understand, they have a new gluten free pizza crust from Cookie Cutter's GF Bakery and it is AMAZING!!!! Fluffy, thick, and flavorful! Their sub rolls are awesome too - soft and don't fall apart! A little on the expensive side but they had a $3 off coupon code for online orders. Didn't mind though because it was SO GOOD! read more

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original - GF pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Kenmore, New York

See all

Passing through area and decided to return to an old staple when I was a local. Not much has changed. Extensive menu. Decent experience. Most behind the counter seemed to take pride in work. Decent experience. read more

I'm a huge fan of Mike's Subs. They're relatively cheap, quick, and the portions are huge! I ordered garlic bread, a turkey sub, and a Buffalo chicken finger sub via UberEats. Everything was delicious! The garlic bread was nicely buttered and full of flavor. The turkey in my sub was shredded which surprised me because I expected sliced turkey. I also took a bite of the Buffalo chicken finger sub and it was also really good! The food arrived a little messy but I was okay with that. read more

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original - Pizza Near Me - Kenmore, New York

Mike's never disappoints when it comes to subs - especially the mixed - one of my all time favorites! This with their crispy French Fries made for a yummy dinner! read more

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original - Chicken fajita sub on gluten free bread - Pizza Near Me - Kenmore, New York

See all

Best chicken finger sub in Buffalo, no one close! I am a chicken finger sub snob, this one is far better than any other place! read more

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original - I'm a chicken finger sub SNOB! This is the best chicken finger sub in Buffalo, no one is close! Try it out - Pizza Near Me - Kenmore, New York

See all

My mother & I used to go to Mike's Subs all the time , for subs. It's been awhile, but yesterday was my son's 23rd Birthday , so I decided to check out their menu & see what all they have now & their prices. Everything looked & sounded good. I ordered a large cheese pizza with 1/2 pepperoni & 1/2 Banana Peppers. My fiancé got "The Knockout" , I think it was called. A packed steak & cheese sub with veggies & cheese. It looked & smelled amazing. My son got a double (12) order of Chicken Fingers. 1/2 Honey Mustard & 1/2 BBQ. Unfortunately they ended up coming plain, but when I called & told the very nice woman on the phone, she started a new batch & had them here within about 25 minutes, plus a piece of chocolate cake for him for his birthday as a way of apologizing for their mistake. She wouldn't even accept the tip money. The food was delicious, the prices were very reasonable & the customer service was amazing !! I will definitely be ordering from here more often. Keep up the Good Work Mike's Subs read more

See all

We've ordered from here many times and are never disappointed. When I'm craving a traditional ham sub done just the way I like it, this is my go to spot. I haven't ventured into much beyond the subs but I can say that every sub we have ever ordered from here has been great! The sub oil is unique to other places and seems to have a nice little zest to it. If you're looking for quality subs, fairly priced and great service, I would tell you to check this place out read more

It's very unfortunate that that the quality of their food has gone down so much. My steak sub was cold and lacking condiment. The bread is not that good either. Maybe Jersey Mikes or Wegmans will be better . read more

A staple in my town, huge selection and variety, nice staff of folks, lots of homemade treats. Clean and efficient.

Have ordered subs, wraps, and salads from here and all were excellent. Hot and cold subs are both great here. This place is always so busy and it makes sense why. The quality of the food they use is better than most other pizza places and prices are reasonable. They also have a nicely sized very clean area to eat inside. read more

11/10 Chicken finger sub!!! Always solid. Their Medium sauce is too good! Fingers are large. read more

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original - a half eaten sub sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Kenmore, New York

Definitely get on their email list to get a heads up about what subs they have on special for the week. We cashed in on their 9.99 full turkey club sub and it was KILLER. As an onion fan, I especially love how superrrrrrr thin they are able to slice their onions. Amazing. Tons of meat on the sub, great texture and flavor. Deducted a star b/c I tried to order on the app at 9:01pm and they said they weren't taking any more orders online (they closed at 10pm). But I called the restaurant at 9:02pm and they had no problem taking my order. parking can be a bit dicey depending on when you go, since it's right on the village of kenmore delaware strip. read more

Mike's sends out a promotional email regularly, I think once a month. Those are a real too good to miss promotions. This month's offer was 2 subs for $15.99 with a choice of chicken, eggplant, meatball and sausage, all with Parmesan. We decided on a chicken and a meatball sub and they were really great. Very tasty with a generous amount of meatballs or fried chicken. I don't know how they do it, but even after getting home they were still really, really hot too. Hungry for a sub, Mike's is the place! read more

Wow, I am proud to say I worked at MIKE'S. I ordered 3 ham submarines today. We each had are our picky way we wanted the submarines. We placed the order on the phone. We got home and the submarines were all marked. We unwrapped them and got what we ordered. The sandwiches were delicious. Thank you for a great memory. read more

See all

We were looking to try somewhere new for subs and stumbled upon this Kenmore staple. Overall, I'd say we had a pretty good experience! I ordered online and was able to select a pick up time which was convenient. The restaurant had plenty of parking in the back and the staff was really friendly when I went in to pick up my order! We ordered fries, a mini chicken finger sub, and a whole steak and spinach sub. My chicken finger sub was delicious and my boyfriend really enjoyed his steak sub! The French fries were good too, but for $4 we were expecting a larger amount than what we got. I was just a little bummed because I ordered my sub with provolone cheese and a side of blue cheese dressing but I got neither of those things. I still enjoyed it, though, and definitely wouldn't let this deter me from coming back in the future. Overall, I'd say this is a good spot to grab a sub, pizza, or just a little late night snack! read more

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original - Chicken Finger Sub and French Fries - Pizza Near Me - Kenmore, New York

See all

One of my fav places in the Kenmore area to get a sub. Any version of their steak sub is fantastic. Decent chicken fingers and a good pizza sub. Only had their pizza once, it was ok but your right next to Jays so go there instead. Mikes always has awesome promotions, coupons and other specials so take advantage. Check out the daily specials on pizza and subs! read more

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original - Steak Knockout. Really good, would get again - Pizza Near Me - Kenmore, New York

I got to say, I had a Mike's steak sub today... later in the day I got sick... I knew something was wrong with the meat... it's very low grade thin sliced steak'ums or something like that... under cooked, I think it was bad and knew the taste was not good but in a rush... I cannot say I would ever recommend this place unless I knew they upgraded their meats... Sad because I used to love Mikes when I was much younger... read more

Since my last review, we've had the pizza and different types of subs and consistently Mike's provides great nice dining options. We go at least twice a week now! read more

Horrible horrible.. went there for pick up and got the wrong order .not only the wrong order but someone else's orders. The person. "Vivian " that answered the phone said " we can remake the order and deliver it to you " Jesus Christ I've had 2 orders delivered wrong and every time they make it wrong. ‍ read more

Buffalo has SO many great sub shops. It's honestly baffling to me that I can go to other cities and have only 1 decent option available. Among my favorites is Mike's. It's been a staple of my childhood as it's located just down the block from where I grew up. Everything is delicious. Bread is fresh & I recommend getting it toasted! Favorites: chicken finger sub. Hands down delicious. Always get hot & add bleu cheese. Then cry of happiness when you eat it. Classic turkey sub- great deli meat. Suggested with mayo, lettuce, tomato & onions. read more

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original - Chicken finger sub on left, turkey sub on right - Pizza Near Me - Kenmore, New York

Everything we ordered today for delivery was made incorrectly. 1 turkey sub had bacon on it when it was not part of the order. 1 turkey club did not have tomato when we ordered it with tomato. None of the subs had condiments on them. One entire order of pizza logs was forgotten and we did not receive with our order. The food was lack luster and disappointing. Did they even read the order? We are not happy customers and probably won't be ordering again soon. read more

I found GINGER hair in my sub, two of them. my company ordered this from Mike subs and when I saw the hair in it I was disgusted.

Ordered chicken fingers, paid an extra $3 for them to be charred. Each (only 3 pieces) had *one* grill mark on them. The cheap foil they use literally stuck to the fingers. I'm not trying to get cancer. I would literally have to rip the breaking off to eat it. One time, I assume it's just something that happened. But twice, no. NEVER AGAIN. read more

First time reviewing this place, even though I was a frequent patron years ago. I always loved their subs, and that fact hasn't changed. My two favorite subs here is, the Royal and steak and cheese. Both subs are made with fresh ingredients and the roll is the best. They do serve pizza, but I never tried it. I am to busy enjoying their subs. read more

See all