The pizza was good, but they messed up the order I ordered a large pizza with half cheese and pepperoni and the other half with olives and onions. It came with half cheese and the other half pepperoni, olives and onions. I had to pick off the pepperoni & place it on the cheese side. It was the first time we ordered. Not sure I'll go back read more

Last night's takeout from Macy's Place Pizzeria was outstanding. The pizza was perfectly cooked with just the right balance of crispness and chew, and the sauce had a subtle sweetness that really set it apart. The wings -- Nashville Hot and Extra Hot -- were absolutely delicious, crispy and packed with flavor and heat. The antipasto may have been the best we've had anywhere in Western New York. Fresh and incredibly well done. Everything tasted like it was made with real care and attention. We'll definitely be back. Service was great too, with the takeout! read more

I had been seeing their posts on social media for a while now and finally had the chance to stop in. I will say it was worth the wait. Ordered a small Nick at Nite Pizza. You get quality pizza with a lot of toppings. Delicious pizza with a nice crisp crust. Warning, trying to eat with your hands will be tough. Also ordered wings with Bison Dip and Franks Red Hot sauce. Oh my god. Was it delicious. Great combo for a wing sauce. Wings were crisp and delicious. Not dry at all. The restaurant itself inside is nice. Cool neon signs to fit the aesthetic. Will recommend to anyone coming to Buffalo. read more

Good food and prices. We opted for assorted sub, Oreo dessert pizza, white pizza, dinner box, half BLT sub. All excellent. read more

Macy’s Place Pizzeria - BLT sub - Pizza Near Me - Clarence, New York

See all

Not the best I've had and will never go back. Pretty boring, but gave them a try. I'll stick to Mattia's or anyone else.

Was hoping to experience the NY style pizza scene. What I got was sauce and mozzarella soup with burnt crust. Oh well. And the "House made" ranch was apparently from Hidden Valley's house read more

Macy’s Place Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Clarence, New York

See all

My coworkers found this new place by work and we are now officially hooked on this place! They have a few other locations but happy they decided to open a place in Clarence. Their menu is quite expansive and the food you receive is all in large portions! Highly recommend checking them out - they have food for every palate! Very popular at lunch time - you can call and ask what their four daily specialty pizzas are too. read more

See all

So I finally got to order more food than just pizza. My son had friends over so I just got some random food to try and share. I was impressed both the regular wings and boneless wings stayed nice and crispy on the way back to my house. Everything was good, but I would say the boneless wings with the sweet and spicy honey Cajun sauce were my absolute favorite! My least favorite were the garlic knots but nothing was particularly wrong with them by any means ... I just prefer mine more coated in butter and parmesan to wear they are a little sloppy. I felt I would mention it because if you like yours a little neater then these are definitely the ones for you! The specialty slice was fantastic as always. I've never had a bad slice here and never expect to. The wings, although good, I think I would prefer a specialty sauce next time. Again, kudos for making them crispy and having containers to go that keep them that way! Although I can't eat foods like this very often, it's definitely a great place with excellent variety and certainly made the teenagers happy too. I'm so glad Macys came to the area! read more

See all

Delicious One of my top favs to enjoy pizza at in WNY. Creative custom and unique flavor combos.

Tried their wing Wednesday $1 deal and the wings were delicious. We got sweet peach BBQ (which has some spice to it FYI), garlic parm and regular barbecue. Made super fast and the wings were nice and saucy too. read more

Macy’s Place Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Clarence, New York

The pizza sucks. I ordered via DoorDash and I never will again. I ordered chicken wings as well. read more

Besides the pizza being soggy as hell and the chicken fingers being chewy...I think it's a crime for a pizza place in Buffalo to sell overpriced shitty frozen wings or fingers without French fries. The only reason I ordered from here was because of the deal on DoorDash and other reviews saying it came with fries. This place is shit do not order here read more

Food was just alright. I wanted to check out this newish location because they have great deals for lunch combos. I got a box with one slice, ample amounts of waffle fries, and 5 wings for $14. That's a great price for the amount of food! The actual food was pretty meh. I did like the pulled pork and Mac n cheese pizza but it was super sloppy. I found myself picking at the toppings with my hands. The wings were not good. Criminally undersauced, I ordered medium and it looked like they didn't have any sauce, and there was no flavor. Might take some heat for this but they were also too big. Yes, wings can be too big. Not to the level of crisp I prefer. Lastly, the pizza. It's not for me. It's a standard buffalo pizza that is comparable to so many more places in buffalo, except I might rather go to those places. Sauce was too sweet for me, and wasn't given an option of sweet or regular. Not an issue if you're a sweet fan but I did not like it. Fries were ok. Overall value was decent to good, food was mediocre. read more

Macy’s Place Pizzeria - Lunch combo - Pizza Near Me - Clarence, New York

See all

Ordered two slices to go today. Meh. Pepperoni and cheese was just OK and chicken finger was soggy and overly cheesy. 10 bucks for two slices was a little too expensive for what I got. Will not be coming back. read more

Cheese and pepperoni pizza was excellent as were the medium wings. Loved the sauce and both were cooked perfectly. Will definitely be trying more pizzas as the menu is huge! read more

5/29/25: Large pepperoni and Sausage pizza. REALLY GOOD!. This is 2nd one in two weeks. Both were excellent. Toppings were excellent and plentiful. Loved it. I will return for a third one. read more

With the Bills games I expected a longer wait but 3 hours for delivery is absurd. I cancelled the order at the 2 hour mark. The order shows up an hour later. Was told when I cancelled the driver was already on the road. So my order was riding for over a hour. Suggestion if you're that busy/short staffed shut down your online ordering like other places do. read more

Do not get the Sweet and spicy honey Cajun wings. Sooooo salty it's gross. Worst wing flavor I have ever had. read more

Macy’s Place Pizzeria - Sweet and spicy honey Cajun soo salty it's gross - Pizza Near Me - Clarence, New York

Convenient location, excellent food, and good service. Best choice of Pizza in the area. Very happy Macy's Place is a part of the neighborhood! read more

Macy’s Place Pizzeria - Small cheese and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Clarence, New York

See all

I've never eaten here but can't believe what I'm seeing from local corrections officers who act like spoiled child for not getting a pizza one evening. I've always heard great things about Macy's and it's on my list of places to try when in town. It's now gone to the top. read more

Unique offbeat type pizza place. I've tried a few things off their menu and most items are bangers but a few are way too much for me. The half calzone and half pizza is a great item to please the masses. The chicken fingers are super solid and very large. Their regular pizza leaves much to be desired but some of their specialty pies are epic. Chicken finger burrata is a solid choice, steak and cheese is quite rich and tasty, but the hot honey pepperoni was...alot. read more

Macy’s Place Pizzeria - Kids chicken fingers and fries - Pizza Near Me - Clarence, New York

CONSISTENT CONSISTENT! Every time I order whether it's during work for a sub or the 10 for 10 Wednesdays at 8:30, their food is always great and a great deal, pizza is also amazing, The Walter white is worth the tiredness after! So filling read more

Been wanting to try this place for a while as this location has had a few Pizzeria's occupying the space over the years but they never seem to last. Figuring this is an established name in the area hopefully it may last a little longer. With that being said I placed an online order for a Sub as I was going to try the Pizza but didn't feel like remortgaging my house to do so at this time ( I understand the varieties they have but $30+ for a Pizza is getting out of control ) Ordered the Steak Frites sub, picked it up at the time it was promised. First thing I noticed is it took a while for someone in the back to attend to the counter, even though there were a few people waiting for a few minutes to place an order. If you're busy thats fine but when we can clearly see you have noticed we're waiting at least acknowledge and say " I'll be right with you" or something like that. Second thing I noticed is the small seating area had tables that were already dirty and needed wiping down and this was before 12pm on a Saturday. Third thing I noticed was no Bathrooms, make sure you take this into account before you show up if you're planning on eating in. The Sub was tasty, didn't blow me away but tasty and different. I'd likely order again from this location and will more than likely try one of their other Sub creations as I'm a sandwich addict. Worth stopping by, but they lose a star for the first impression walking in. read more

I had a C. And. P. Pizza and it was decent it lacked flavor a little bland i also purchased a Sub a few days later it had a substantial amount of meat to feed two people but again it could have been a bit more flavorful. Overall pretty good read more

The menu is really creative and there are a lot of fun options, however the pizza is hit or miss, and the dough is super chewy. I like it sometimes tho read more

Best Pizza in town. We discovered Macys Place about a year ago and now go nowhere else. The pizza and wings are superb.

Amazing food. All. Of .it. Personable staff , great prices and large portions. Absolutely rocking it!

Awesome pizza every time! The menu is huge, so there's something for everyone. I've ventured into their dessert pizza options, which are unlike anything I've tried before. Get the raspberry cannoli pizza and prepare for a foodgasm followed by a nap. read more

today's pizza was disappointing the dough was small pepperoni was not spread well on the pie the flavor was not good there wasn't enough sauce pieces were not cut evenly read more