I really used to love this place! I have had everything on the menu more than 3x. We first started going in 2020. 100% authentic Melt in your mouth oxtails etc. The last 2 years I have still been going periodically, but I have slowed because I noticed the next day my stomach is terribly f----up. I say the past 2 years because sometimes you just don't know and I haven't left a review because of this. I just returned over New Years weekend and stood clear of oxtails but my partner had them. I had Red Snapper, excellent choice I should have been getting all along. The next day felt fine but my partner stomach in shambles from the oxtails I'm not sure what's up but this used to be our only reason to go. We probably won't be back because of this unfortunately and wish them all the best ! read more

Miss Lily's 7A Cafe - Escovitch Red Snapper - Caribbean Near Me - New York, New York

See all

the place looks adorable and the food really is good. However, the host start/ management? made us feel quite unwelcome. it started with the "we can seat you til your entire party has arrived" which I understand when busy but more than half the tables were empty so seem stupid; we were only missing one person. Food slow to arrive but not too bad. However at 118 minutes they asked us to leave as they said they needed the tablé even though there were multiple empty tables and no line outside. it just seemed odd and could have been done in a more friendly manne. It threw cold water on my birthday dinner. read more

Stopped by again for restaurant week. 3 courses for 35/45 I can't recall. Service was attentive and friendly. Surprisingly the rum punch was weak and so was the pina colada. The food was delicious though. The fish cakes were hot and fresh. My curry prawns were flavorful. And the rum cake for desert was good but I doubt it had any rum in it. Also tried the coco bread bao buns which were interesting but good! My boyfriend had the lamb and didn't like that it was drowned in bbq sauce. Good place for vibes and they always have great music playing. read more

See all

3 1/2 Hadn't been to Miss Lily's in about 10 years and decided to pull back up...let's get to it. I'll start with the bad first. Cons: -made a reservation and was sat at the table right in front of the door(which isn't an issue btw). The issue was that the table seemed to be part of the host stand and I mean literally the host was standing over our table the whole meal lol nice girl but I felt like i reserved a party of 3 and not 2. -bathrooms were a little smelly and could of used a cleaning. -DESSERT. We got the banana pudding which was really disappointing. Lacking banana flavor and bananas. Served in a small glass with 2 hard cookies on top was NOT it. Dessert came off as lazy and really lacked flair!!!!!!! Pros: -the codfish fritters were absolutely tasty. The curry sauce served on the side really elevated a simple appetizer. -Mac and cheese was BUSSSSSSIN. Some of the best Mac I've ever had and I make great Mac. Must get when you pull up -I truly appreciate a place that makes their own juices. I tried the homemade ginger beer and was pleased with the extra spicy ginger in the beer. -Shoutout to the playlist, which I'm big on especially when curating a vibe. Mids: -the service. While it wasn't bad at all, nothing stood out about our experience with our waitress. (menu tour guide, maybe suggest their favorite, table maintenance) things that were lacking that can really amp up a dining experience. -the mains were good but nothing I would come back for. We got the oxtail stew which was served hot but flavor didn't blow my mind. The Pork ribs were also tasty, however the accompaniments (mango chutney and pickled cucumbers) made this dish very mid. Anyways it had been 10 years and not sure if I would go back. Maybe to try out the brunch? read more

See all

Came here for my birthday during Restaurant week. Order from both menus. Everything was delicious the jerk chicken, fritters & coconut cream rum cake read more

See all

The BEST meal I had during my last visit to NY! I had the pleasure of dinning at this gem during restaurant week! Everything about it is a win! Let's first start with the amazing service! Every staff was friendly and provided recommendable service from the moment we walked in! The ambiance : they have a corner spot so it's perfect for those that like to enjoy a meal outside. The patio area is cute as is the indoor area. Think bright colors and carribean vibes! Now for the food- simply put, I was blown away! Admittedly I was not expecting much from this spot, but boy was I wrong!! I started with a watermelon salad and ordered the jerk chicken with veggies as my main meal! Now I know you are thinking what can be so special about a watermelon salad? It was just good! I appreciated every ingredient included ! It was very refreshing. My favorite part of the meal was the jerk chicken. Hands down the BEST jerk chicken I have ever had! It is tender and full of flavor !! When I say I finished this meal and left no crumbs it was that good!!! My sister had the jerk mushroom lettuce wraps. Her entree was the friend snapper and to end it off she had rum cake! I have to admit I enjoyed my meal more ! However her food was good too! I really enjoyed the aioli sauce that accompanied the fish entree. NOTE: for restaurant week you can opt to order off the restaurant week menu. It is 3 courses for $45! The only item I would not order again is the rum cake! It was not your traditional Caribbean rum cake. It is more of a white cake with coconut flavors. I could not taste the rum. While the cake was moist and generally a good cake/ it was just not what I expected for rum cake. To sum everything up, you MUST visit Ms. Lilly's!! It's 10's across the board for me ! I will be stopping by the next time I am in the city? There is so much I want to try! read more

See all

Super nice spot, awesome service. Great pancakes but really the nicest people ever. Will be back and stop to say hello

Second time here and it did not disappoint. Stopped in for a lunch after a walk across the Williamsburg bridge. The neighborhood is not the ritziest but we felt safe. The vibe inside Miss Lily is what you came for. It's a cozy cafe with cool music vibes. The service is top notch from top to bottom. The hostess is always super inviting and friendly. The waiter was engaging and helpful. I ordered a mocktail and when I tasted it I knew someone spiked that thing big time. Apparently the bartender read the drink order wrong. The waiter apologized, the manager came to apologize and even the hostess joined her in the apology. What was more impressive? The bartender came over to explain and offer her apologies. Now, I don't have an issue with alcohol but it was hot and I was walking so I preferred the mocktail. But I suppose if I'd been in recovery or something, that could've been a bigger issue. But we totally took it in stride. Let me tell you the real though.... That jerk chicken roti is massive and it is impressive!!! I'd order that again and again. My husband thought the oxtails were better the last time we stopped in but I couldn't tell. All in all, we love Miss Lilly's read more

See all

Second time at this location. Very happy with food and service. Today Ruby and Junice and the 4:30 hostess, provided great service. The male bartender i have had before was also polite, professional and personable. Today with the weather close to 90, it was the perfect spot. The cold beer and hibiscus and ginger drink were both refreshing. They provided plenty of ice water to keep us.. The music in the background gives good vibes. The shrimp were good, I just thought they would be a little spicier. The corn which was accidentally brought to our table and were charged was yum. The sweet plantains with tamarind sauce were amazing! The Caesar salad was delicious with the salmon. The jerk chicken was smoky and seasoned well. I will return! read more

See all

They switched chefs at Miss Lily so the food definitely tasted different. Jerk chicken is good but a bit too clean for me. I miss the dirty really blackened jerk chicken off the streets of Brooklyn. This is def a cleaner version of the dish we love. Shrimp curry was solid Jerk corn was good too. Didn't love that was on the cob but the flavor really seeped in. Fries are fries. Can't go wrong read more

See all

Miss Lily's is a longtime favorite of mine...10+ years and I'm just now writing a review This spot is an absolute gem. Every time I have foodie friends visiting from out of town, I have to bring them here. The food is consistently delicious and always hits the spot. Also, pls bring back the jerk chicken tacos. The cocktails are strong and well crafted, and the overall vibe transports me straight to the islands. Fair warning: it gets packed on Friday nights and weekends, and the dining area can feel a bit cramped during peak hours. But honestly, it's worth it. read more

Had a fabulous time at Miss Lily's 7A Cafe. Went for a late brunch with the ladies for our end of year holiday celebration and to hear DJ Max Glazer. We were greeted wonderfully by the host and she accommodated us nicely for our party of 6. Our waiter Aaron was also very nice and attentive. The food was delicious . I would definitely like to go back again. read more

See all

This is such a beautiful cafe with open lighting to enjoy the street vibe when looking outside! The decor inside is so colorful and loved the friendliness of the servers. The codfish fritters was amazing with the curry dip, I would've bought the curry if they sold it. The codfish fritters were crispy and delicious. The juevos rancheros were sooo good! The eggs, beans, onions went so well together and it was so flavorful. read more

Miss Lily's 7A Cafe - Codfish Cod Fritters, Juevos Rancheros - Caribbean Near Me - New York, New York

My friend planned a prefix dinner here to celebrate mental health awareness month and the ambience was just perfect. The music was great and to top it off the food was just amazing. Definitely still craving the corn and jerk chicken! Had me feeling as if I was really in Jamaica! We'll definitely be back!! read more

I've been to Miss Lily's twice and was very pleased both times. The first time I tried their ribs and this last time I had their oxtail which were juicy and tender! Their rum punch is spectacular. It is a small restaurant and their service is good. The staff is quick and attentive. The music and lighting is nice and cozy and sets a nice vibe. Try their food, you will not be disappointed! read more

Miss Lily's 7A Cafe - Classic Jamaican Oxtail Stew - Caribbean Near Me - New York, New York

An authentic experience. We came here for brunch and had such a great experience. Ambiance: Feels like a Caribbean diner. They play great music. The booth were comfortable to sit in and half are right by the window so it's nice to look out. Service: service was fast and efficient. Food also came out within reasonable time. Food: We got all the veggie options on the menu. The coconut pancakes were good but I think they needed more coconut. The coconut part felt like only the flakes on top so once those were gone you were just eating regular pancakes. The pancakes were nice and fluffy. We also got the jerk corn, it was so well flavored. Note, it comes on the cob. The jerk fries were good, the jerk seasoning was yummy but the fries felt a little average. We also got the vegetable roti. That was definitely the highlight of the meal. I loved the variety of vegetables in it and they were all well cooked. The curry was on point and the loved the texture of the roti. They have a great bottomless brunch deal, $25. We didn't try it this time but will definitely try next time. read more

See all

Miss Lily's is a wonderful spot for some Caribbean food. We were in town in search for some Jamaican food, and landed at a terrific restaurant at Miss Lily's 7A Cafe. There wasn't too many open tables in the whole restaurant (both inside and outside), which was reassuring to me because I usually think that means it's got a solid reputation. I ordered the Miss Lily's Rum Punch and the Miss Lily's Jerk Chicken because they both seemed to be signature menu items. Both were outstanding. The jerk chicken was tender and full of that jerk flavor. The Rum Punch was a little sweet for my taste, but still well made. There was a few people who were celebrating birthdays and they did a great performance with handheld flashing lights and songs to match. I would definitely go back to Miss Lily's the next time I'm visiting NYC. read more

Miss Lily's 7A Cafe - Dining/Bar area - Caribbean Near Me - New York, New York

Visited Miss Lily's with one of my friends on a Saturday for dinner as part of Restaurant Week. We missed our reservation unfortunately but there was luckily space at the bar. We got the 3 course meal for $45 and got the corn as an appetizer, red snapper as the main entree, and we both got our own coconut cake or banana pudding. The corn was really good. The red snapper was also pretty good but their gravy was a little on the liquid side. Would've preferred if it was thicker consistency but I put some of the rice in the gravy and it soaked it up and tasted good. I liked the coconut cake a lot and I don't even eat dessert like that. Not a fan of banana pudding at all so I'm a little biased and didn't like it. That rum punch was strong! The spot is super cozy. The bartender and the host was pretty nice. Overall I had a good experience. I definitely recommend! read more

See all

I always end up getting the oxtail at Miss Lily's, and let me tell you, it's exceptional!! Packed with savory flavor and perfectly cooked, it's just the right amount to leave your belly full and satisfied. The rice is always on point, not dry and pairs perfectly with the oxtail gravy. I usually just let it sit in the bowl and soak it all in. I also love that they have daily specials, giving you even more variety to enjoy. While the appetizers are great, I typically skip them because the main course is so filling. The service is always friendly and welcoming, which adds to the overall experience. Of course I love my fellow Caribbean people, I can't help but return to this spot, and support. Therefore I've brought over five different people to experience it for themselves. The music adds another layer to the experience, with soca and reggae chunes creating an inviting and lively atmosphere. The live DJ really gets the crowd going, which is always a good time. I wish it wasn't located in such a hipster area, but I suppose everyone needs a taste of true flavor every once in a while. Reservations are encouraged, as it can get packed, but walk ins are welcome too if you can get one. Plus they stay open late on certain nights, which is a bonus for those late night cravings when you're in the area. Worth a visit to eat some authentic Caribbean dishes read more

See all

Had Friends visiting from out of town and we decided to have drinks at Miss Lily's. The music, the ambiance and the service were so commendable that we decided to return the next night for a sit down dinner Everyone enjoyed their meal and time at Miss Lily's. We ordered the fried plantains, oxtail , stew chicken and snapper. We all had the rum punch and a couple of red stripe. Everyone left happy and full, looking forward to dining here again Something I think they should improve: the bathrooms - 2 stalls for a unisex bathroom is not sufficient especially on a busy Friday night read more

Miss Lily's 7A Cafe - Caribbean Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Super yummy food, super friendly service, super vibrant space. Hoping for more vegetarian main options in the future! The jerk mushroom lettuce wraps were a highlight for me. read more

See all

As a Jamaican, I make it my duty to try every Jamaican restaurant I can in the city, and I finally made it to Miss Lily's after hearing good things. I had the codfish fritters to start, the jerk chicken meal for my main, and a slice of cake for dessert. The fritters were yummy, the jerk chicken was decent, and the dessert was wonderful. My drink, unfortunately, was very watered down, so I didn't enjoy that. Overall, the ambience was nice and it's a great place to meet friends and catch up over a meal. I'd love to come back to try their brunch and maybe experience one of the dance party nights I've heard about. read more

Miss Lily's is a staple in East Village, bringing you vibrant Caribbean flavors to Classic Caribbean dishes. Having been on my "Must Try" list for YEARS, I'm finally happy to check it off! I had to start Happy Hour off with their Codfish fritters and Jerk Wings. The fritters were extremely soft, seasoned, and paired amazingly with their Curry Dipping sauce. The texture reminded me of cornbread. As for the Jerk Wings these are easily in my top 2 for best wings I've ever had! The wings were giving grilled, smoky, spicy, finger licking good Let's just say the wings were there and then they weren't. For the main event I had to get their Tuesday exclusive Jerk Crab Boil. We're talking 3 Crab Clusters, Potatoes, Corn, a side of slaw, and 2 Jamaican Festivals all for $44. I love me a good seafood boil, so I was very excited to see the hefty amount of crab, along with the sides. I've never had Jamaican Festivals before, so I was very excited to try them and damn did they not disappoint. And you can't get Caribbean food without a side of Mac & Cheese. The noodles were cooked to perfection and the cheese was super flavorful. Miss Lily's has one of the best Happy Hour, Specials, and menu in East Village hands down. If you find yourself in East Village for Brunch, Dinner, or even Clubbing, make sure to stop by because I will surely be back for more! read more

See all

Stopped in for happy hour during the week. The rum punch is strong but really good fruity flavors and is on the happy hour menu. The ox tail spring rolls had lots of flavor and the cod fish fritters delicious loved the curry sauce. read more

See all

I'm late leaving this review but better late than never. Came with a group of girlfriends for an end of summer meet up. Food was decent...drinks were better. Our server was attentive and friendly. read more

10s across the board. It's so hard to say anything bad about this restaurant. The service was great and the recommendations even better. We were on the waitlist and had to wait about 45 mins for a table but it was well worth it. Everything was so flavorful and my family was very impressed. We ordered the jerk Caesar, and cod fritters to start and The jerk corn (different but soooo tasty, don't let the mayo scare you) , extra rice and peas (there's a clear traditional coconut milk flavor, delicious to me) , and seasonal vegetables (seasoned very well) as sides to share. For entrees we did - the run down salmon (spicy and delicious), - the jerk chicken with a side of mac and cheese (a half chicken, super filling and flavorful, Mac was okay) - the bbq Lamb, (10/10 absolutely would recommend.) - and the eschovitched snapper. The restaurant is a vibe, transporting you to Jamaica in authenticity. This restaurant remains a favorite of mine and a solid recommendation to everyone. read more

See all

First the ambiance is everything. Music is top tier. It's hard not to get up and dance while waiting for your food. Everything we had was so delicious. Staff is really chill and I loved being able to eat without feeling like we were being pushed out. I'm only visiting for a couple days, but we are already coming back. read more

See all

We went out on January 8th to celebrate my birthday. I had been to Miss Lily's before, but it had been about seven years, so I was genuinely excited to revisit. I made sure to reserve a table for two, and we arrived about 15 minutes early. When we arrived, the atmosphere was comfortable and inviting. The bar was fairly full, but there were only a few guests seated at booths and tables. We politely asked the host if we could sit at a booth, and she declined, saying booths were reserved for larger groups. We explained that we planned on ordering multiple dishes and could really use the extra space. She eventually agreed and seated us. Once seated, things improved significantly. The waitstaff was absolutely amazing--friendly, attentive, and genuinely warm. They checked in on us regularly, made us feel welcomed, and ensured our drinks and appetizers arrived promptly. Their professionalism and kindness honestly carried the experience and made us feel cared for during what should have been a celebratory evening. Unfortunately, things became frustrating shortly after. We noticed that the booths remained empty for a while, but as more patrons arrived, couples were seated in booths, including groups of two--exactly what we had originally been told was not allowed. At that point, the restaurant was still not full, and it felt discouraging and unfair. That inconsistency from the host left us feeling overlooked and disappointed. As for the food, the oxtail was a bit on the salty side. The ribs were very good, and the shrimp was just okay--nothing memorable. Overall, the food didn't quite live up to the experience I remembered from seven years ago. While the waitstaff truly deserves praise for being attentive, kind, and professional, the lack of accommodation and inconsistency from the host really impacted our experience. Unfortunately, because of that, I'll have reservations about returning in the future. read more

Great food, drinks, and music. Got to try the new menu by Chef Brittney "Stikxz" Williams and everything was the bomb - especially the roti and stew peas. I went on a Saturday night with no reservation and after an hour long wait we decided to just sit at the bar. It's probably best to make sure you have reservations because walk-ins can be tight. A DJ pulled up around 10pm to play live music. read more

Miss Lily's 7A Cafe - Rice and Peas Mac & Cheese Pie - Caribbean Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great jerk chicken and snapper. Loved the DJ and the overall vibe. Server was attentive and always available. read more

Food here is excellent. I had the oxtail and loved it. We didn't realize they have a DJ for brunch so was not prepared for the noise lol. Their frozen drink machine also wasn't fully operational yet, which was unfortunate because I wanted a frozen drink. Food is pricey, but this is a solid choice for Jamaican food. read more

Miss Lily's 7A Cafe - Caribbean Near Me - New York, New York

WOW, where do I begin!!! I think by now everyone knows that Miss Lily's is a 5/5!! Miss Lily's has been on my list for a while now and I've recently decided to give it a try. I'm blown away by just how delicious the food is and the vibes were vibin!! The staff was amazing and very friendly -- even when they needed to flip the tables they were very kind in letting us know that they needed the table. They were also very efficient. Highy recommend! The jerk chicken definitely did its thing. I also tried the Jerk ramen and maybe next time I will try not to be too adventurous. It was okay and not really memorable, but let me tell you.. I still think about the Jamaican curry shrimp!! That will be the dish that makes me return back to see Miss Lily! read more

See all

Love coming here for lunch and cocktails, the food is a little overpriced but still worth the experience. One of the coolest spots in the city. Growing up in the Caribbean, I'm very selective about my food but they do a decent job with the jerk spice. read more