Went there for lunch. When I asked the server, who was apparently the owner, for a DOCG wine he didn't seem to know what that meant. Tipped me off right away it was not authentic Italian but Americanized. Ordered the carbonera and a Margherita pizza with wings. The carbonera is first off, nowhere near authentic, but probably one of the worst pasta dishes we have ever tasted. The pizza had chopped up.. maybe Roma tomatoes on it? It was thick and too cheesy and didn't even have basil on it. Surprisingly the wings were good. I still would choose other places over Modo Mio for wings though (Crazy Mikes is our go to). Weird that an Italian restaurants only good item we ate was wings. Just another mediocre California chain. read more

I want to say I love this place... the food was definitely scrumptious, but sadly, the ordering/pickup experience was so far from perfection (not even close!). We placed an online order at 5-something PM for a 7:30 pickup. We live about 15 mins away so my husband got there in time and went with our 5 year old daughter, thinking this would be a quick and easy pickup. Paid for in advance, had a set pickup time... easy, right? Nope! Him and our daughter waited approximately 45 minutes! They didn't end up leaving with our order until around 8:15 that night. Granted I wasn't there personally, my husband told me no one apologized, no one offered anything to him or our young kid while waiting... nada! Am I overreacting? You to decide, but on Saturday nights, my husband and I have "date night in" so we order and pickup food and the kids are in bed by 8pm.... Definitely didn't work out that way since our order wasn't done until 8:15 and then he had to drive home and we worked to get three kids settled for the night. Not sure we will be back, anytime soon any way. read more

My kids love the lasagna and chicken parm. Easy, quick weeknight meal when you do pick up. Plenty for leftovers. Friendly and fast service.

They have great food. It is a family owned business and everyone is so nice. We have had several different things and it has always been delicious. If you don't try it you will miss out. read more

Oh. My. Gosh. Wonderful, fresh Italian food in Peoria! We ordered from Modo Mio for Father's Day and "wow!" are they great. We had the lasagna and linguine Alfredo. Both were delicious. Next time we'll actually eat there, but this is a gem. read more

Let me start by saying I am NOT a person who leaves a review but our experience last night was great. Walking up my husband asked a man leaving if it was good and he said "it's alright" which I immediately groaned. Most places now days just aren't what they used to be and eating out is already an arm and a leg these days. The man then said "but I'm biased since I'm the owner." So extra points for a man with a sense of humor! We ordered their XL pizza and 16 wing deal (which we were going to order separately but the employee immediately informed us of the deal to save a few bucks), garlic knots and drinks. The pizza was perfectly cooked with light/airy yet crispy crust. The wings we asked to be extra crispy and they were huge wings - AMAZING. My 8 year old devoured the garlic knots without breathing. I also ordered a glass of wine since it was happy hour ($3 off a glass) which came as a very "heavy pour." So for $5 I was happy. All the staff were SO friendly and welcoming even as we walked in at 8pm (they closed at 9pm). Can't say better things about our experience. We definitely will be back! read more

We catered them for my Valentine party & the food was a hit. Everyone commented on how delicious everything was. The customer service was amazing. They brought the food on time & even contacted me the next day to make sure everything was good. We ordered large subs, lasagna, meatballs, spaghetti w/marinara sauce & gluten free pasta with marinara sauce. We are definitely ordering again & use them to cater our annual party. Highly recommend!!! read more

This is fine dining food but you order at the counter. It was our first time so we had a lot of questions about the menu but they were all very patient and helpful. I have a hard time finding baked rigatoni with sausage. They offer it with crumbled sausage or link slices. Tried the crumbled this time and it was so good that we are planning a second trip back to try the link style sausage. Garlic puffs are delicious, fresh with olive oil and roasted garlic. Wife had stuffed shells. Pasta was al dente and the marinara was very flavorful and fresh tasting. Clean tables and restaurant and the portion was right for the price. Can't wait to go back! read more

Great food and friendly service. Will most definitely be returning. Had the meatball sandwich. Its was delicious.

The pizza was terrific,the place is clean and at this time is relatively undiscovered, that won't last long. By the way the pesto pasta was excellent as well! read more

The food was very good but I was surprised and disappointed that the entree didn't include bread and salad. That is typically offered at most Italian restaurants. read more

The food is good, but they charge for ketchup. I thought that was strange, so I questioned it. After the conversation, they removed the charge...But I was afraid to ask for salt and Pepper. read more

My family and I wanted to try it out. Walking in, the dining space was a wreck, with what looked like inventory for the back just stacked 3 foot high smack dab in the middle of the dining area. It kind of feels like they have an identity crisis, is it dine in, is it fast food, is it a NY sports themed restaurant/bar? We did come in just a few weeks after being opened so maybe there were bugs that needed to be worked out. The digital menu wasn't easy to navigate, and GOOD LORD the prices for what you ended up getting on your plate, outrageous. Overall the food was meh, not great but not terrible either. I will say the manager that evening was amazing, walking around asking everyone how things were, giving refills, asking if we needed anything else and taking attention to cleanliness (as best it could be). read more

My husband and I stopped by on a whim while we were out and about. We asked the young lady taking our order for recommendations and she was very helpful. We tried the garlic puffs and they were delicious! The roasted garlic and olive oil were fantastic with the soft puffs. I tried the rosa sauce with gnocchi, hubs had a meatball sandwich, both were delicious!! Hubs said the sauce and meatballs were both tasty. We can't wait to come back and try the pizza. read more

Great new Italian restaurant that replaced a pizza place. They have a variety of pastas, pizza's and panini's. We tried two of the pasta dishes and both were delicious! One of the pastas was OGT(olive oil, garlic and tomatoes). The dish had the perfect amount of garlic and I will definitely have it again. My wife had the Pesto pasta and also agreed that it was one of the best she has had. My son had a Caesar salad and small pepperoni pizza. He felt the thin crust pizza really nailed the New York flavor and the salad was excellent as well. Almost forgot the incredible Garlic puffs( their version of garlic knots)! They were a great start to the meal with lots of garlic..Mmmmm! This is a small restaurant which is a pleasure to get away from the chains. Hopefully it will continue to thrive as I can't wait to come back and try more! read more

Friendly service, great food, great ambience. Would recommend if you are in the area for yummy Italian read more

Modo Mio - Inside seating - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

We've only tried their meatball sandwiches. Definitely NOT homemade meatballs! Tastes worse than frozen ones from Costco. Step it up with homemade Italian food. We don't need another chain of low end food in 85383 read more

Ordered 3-1-2025 pizza an cheese sticks always the best pizza sauce an cheese. Love this place this is my third review an is condensed in food taste a delivery service. Spend a little more and enjoy great taste. read more

The staff was very friendly. The food ... let's just say I don't know what all the hype was about. My wife had shrimp scampi which she said was mediocre. I ordered the hot honey pizza because of all the positive reviews about it and it was too sweet for my taste. read more

Ok at best,Way too expensive. Went there one time and I assumed it was the owner taking with a customer way to loud for such a small area, or let my say rude!!! Notice there was food on the floor, in front of the owner,I assume it was out of his pay grade to bent over and pick it up. Not impressed They are not lucky the health department hasn't their read more

I had dinner last night at this restaurant. The restaurant was very busy, we still had great service, the food was exceptional. We were both very pleased. The manager was running food , greeting people serving and always with a smile on his face. He took the time to help me with my special request, I could'nt have been more pleased. First and foremost, this restaurant doesn't over exaggerate how great the food is. It's fabulous, don't miss eating here. Thank you, Modo Milo, Beverly read more

Nice, cleanly, and cute place! We got table service and it was amazing. No long waits, fast refills, and fast to bring out food. The employees were all very kind. We got garlic puffs (my favorite), cheese pizza, fettuccine alfredo, ham and pineapple calzone, and their s'mores cannoli (monthly special). Everything was very impressive and tasty. Many of the entrees were customizable, which is awesome. Only slight disappointment was in the calzone, the ham was just the huge slices, not pre-cut so they were hard to eat and bite through. On a normal pizza, they would be cut nicely. But overall very satisfied, we will be coming again! read more

we ate at the bakery and it was phenomenal . Aspen helped us and was amazing and so kind. The gelato was so good and the pastries also.

Amazing pizza every time I order. The hot honey pizza is my absolute favorite. The garlic knots are amazing as well. Definitely recommend. Super friendly staff as well. read more

Tried this the other night on a whim and it turned out to be really good especially for a quick option. Got our food in less than 10 min and it was delicious. We will be back read more

Average food, although workers were pleasant. Needs to be a cut above a processed food taste for me to return again. Maybe pizza is better? I had the lasagna. read more

Very good pizza! Delicious crust and good quality ingredients were used! We ordered a vegetarian and "Da Works" pizzas and both were delicious! We will be going back! read more

The food was less then mediocre. No one in my party is going back. We were hopeful, but disappointed.

Service was great, staff were so friendly. The Hot Honey Pizza was delicious! We came back the next night for pickup for the Tyson fight.

So we were in the mood for something different when we drove by Modo Mio. We decided to give it a try. ABSOLUTELY THE BEST PIZZA 10/10!!!! I can definitely see why there was a steady STREAM of patrons! We enjoyed sitting on the patio in the beautiful AZ Fall weather!! We're DEFINITELY coming back!! You should give them a try, and you can thank me later!! read more

Simply perfect! Delicious food and large portions. Authentic flavor. Sent as a gift to my friend and everything was perfect. The delivery person kept in communication with me and it was a complete surprise! Success!! read more

Place is FIRE too. I love the fried zucchini here and pizzas. My girl has been here many times, it was my first time, and this place impressed me a lot. Decent prices in food, and a good customer service vibe here. We got some Pepperoni pizzas and all. Nice place to chill and eat after being in the hot sun too long lol. Great spot and good people, we will be back . read more

We arrived for dinner at 4:50. We place our order for calamari and bruschetta appetizers and one order of eggplant parmigiana. We received the order of calamari 40 minutes later. We received the eggplant 10 minutes after that which was over cooked and the owner came to tell us that they ran out of bruschetta. He asked us to pick another appetizer off of the menu that took another 15 minutes. The service was a total disaster and menu items looked nothing like the website photos nor did they taste good. The owners came by our table at least 4 times to apologize for the delay. There were a number of Grub Hub orders for pickup with some drivers waiting impatiently for more than 30 minutes for the orders. The owner promised us that he would send out a gift card to return due to the terrible experience. We were to receive the text with a code for amount the next day. We didn't receive the text. I called two days later about the matter and was told I can't speak to the manager but that I had to wait for the company that sends out the gift card text for submitted. I still haven't received the gift the card text 6 days later. The restaurant was not managed well. Staff was literally running around the back of us and the dinning room. When we walked in the vacant tables were not cleared from the previous customers visit. Many customers were shocked at the speed of the service. My wife and I were in the restaurant business for 35 years and if this restaurant doesn't cater to the customers needs they won't have any customers. Ambiance is nothing to brag about. The first table we sat at wobbled so bad that if leaned on the top your food would be in your lab or on the floor. The second table top was sticky. The one bright spot was the replacement meatball appetizer was very good as was the marinara sauce. read more

Such a killer pizza, I cant recommend it enough. Friendly, professional staff. Great new addition to the Peoria foodscape! Don't be confused this aint the old "brothers pizza" shop, this is special, give it a try. read more

Four of us ordered something different and all four of us were really impressed. Mine was the best chicken piccata ever. The owner came out after dinner and told us about the cannoli desserts changing every month. We assured him that we would return much we liked the dinners. All four of us would recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for very nice meal, reasonably priced and conveniently located on Lake Pleasant Boulevard. read more

Food is homemade and authentic. Would certainly revisit and I loved the pesto! Fan favorite in our house.

New Four Corners restaurant. Ordered the North End pizza and was pleasantly pleased! Wasn't able to look at menu or process online order on my phone but had no issues on my laptop. Order was ready on time and staff was nice when I picked up my order to go. Crust was cooked and not soggy! Sauce was tasty and fresh basil was a good addition. 16" for $32 a little pricy but if you want to splurge on a good pizza, it is worth the convenience. read more

This place is good. Good prices. All the food is really good. I had them make me all meat pizza. Of course the dough was really good perfectly cooked not raw like other places in the middle. I really enjoyed it. What I like about this place, they have really good sides. Even the calzones are delicious. read more

The hot honey pepperoni pizza was spectacular! The dough was delicious and the flavor of the sauce and toppings was the perfect combo. The owner came to our table and asked how it was and explained a little bit about the history behind how he created that pie and where he drew his inspiration. We also got Cesar salads that were really fresh and you could tell the dressing was made in house. Highly recommend this joint! read more

Our new go to for super delicious Italian food and the best tasting pizza in our area!