What a fantastic pub in historic Jim Thorpe, PA! Established in 1830 and connected to the iconic Hotel Switzerland, Molly Maguires combines great food, friendly service, and plenty of local charm. The pub embraces the rich coal-region history that inspired its name, making it a perfect stop while exploring this beautiful mountain town. One of the highlights is their large covered outdoor deck, which is ideal for summer dining. Even better, they're prepared for every season--they can enclose the deck during rainy weather and have a heating system in place to keep guests comfortable during the colder months. The day we visited happened to be Trivia Day, which made for a lively and entertaining atmosphere. It's easy to see why both locals and visitors enjoy spending time here. The pub has a welcoming, laid-back vibe that's perfect whether you're stopping in for a meal, drinks with friends, or just taking a break from exploring town. We started with the Tater Kegs--oversized tater tots stuffed with bacon, cheddar cheese, and chives, served with zesty horseradish sauce and sour cream. They arrived piping hot, perfectly crispy, and absolutely delicious. A great appetizer to share. For entrées, I couldn't resist the Shepherd's Pie. Ground beef, onions, carrots, and peas are simmered in a rich gravy and topped with beautifully piped mashed potatoes baked until golden brown. It was hearty, comforting, and packed with flavor. We also ordered the Molly Maguire Burger loaded with peppers, mushrooms, onions, and bacon. I added pepper jack cheese, and it was definitely the right choice. Every bite was juicy, flavorful, and satisfying. A special shoutout to our server, Abbey, who was outstanding from start to finish. Not only was she attentive with drink refills and checking on us throughout the meal, but she also took the time to recommend other sights and attractions around Jim Thorpe. Her friendly personality and local knowledge made our visit even more enjoyable. Between the delicious food, fun atmosphere, historic setting, and exceptional service, Molly Maguires delivered a memorable experience. If you're visiting Jim Thorpe, do yourself a favor and stop in. And if you're lucky enough to have Abbey as your server, you're in for an even better experience! read more

See all

We had a group of 11 people that came in for lunch after riding on 15 miles on the trail. We came in and there was hardly anyone in the restaurant. We were trying to sit together but they chose to combine tables for our group. The service was a bit lack luster..first they didn't bring place settings until After the food was delivered. When we asked they brought 2 place settings for 11 of us (lol). The food was decent, hot and price was reasonable. A few minor issues which were resolved. Even though they wouldn't seat us together they combined the two groups into 1 bill and wouldn't separate. Overall the servers/hostess seem bothered by our group and at times were rude. read more

Molly Maguires - American Near Me - Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania

Went for dinner after riding the train in Jim Thorpe. They were able to seat us quickly and we're very friendly. The outdoor area is very nice and even though it was hot out the fans kept us cool. The food was great and the drinks were just as good! Definitely a great spot to check out! read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch with 3 friends after our scenic train ride in Jim Thorpe. Sat on outside deck, enjoyed a very good meal and drinks. I had Caesar salad, sister had homemade shepherd's pie. Food good, wait staff attentive, very pleasant to sit outside on covered deck. They also offered yummy desserts. Highly recommend. read more

Rude outdoor hostess. Pet/Dog owners let this be your warning....DO NOT go here. If you notice their google info says outdoor dining but does not mention "dog friendly" that's because they are "dog haters". They even hate service dogs. Yes, they have indoor and outdoor seating. The outdoor seating area is nice. It's big with fans to keep you cool. But you can't sit outdoors with pets? Crazy right? 99% of places allow pets outdoors. This is the 1% that doesn't even allow service dogs outside. They have 3 small tables on the sidewalk that is scorching hot in the summer that are for dogs. Needless to say we did not sit there. I would never give my money to this establishment. read more

Wife and I ordered drinks, she ordered a sangria. Waitress brought it over and said there was a fly in it. She took it back to the bartender (also manager). Afteral a quick discussion, she removed the cherry and put a new one in it, left it on the counter. Bartender did nothing. A couple minutes later she went and picked it back up and brought it over. I asked if there was a reason it was not remade? "Oh, you want it remade?"... Bartender was pissed and threw it out and remade it. Then we ordered our sandwiches. We both got the hot beef sandwich. After a wait, we were brought rubens. We said this is not what we ordered. The waitress was standing there and "oh, hmmm".. Told them to remake the sandwiches. Needless to say, 1) I won't ever be back and 2) thank God I'm from out of town. And no, she did not get a good tip from me... read more

Stopped in for drinks and appetizers after a ride on the train. Party of 10 was seated quickly and service was great. Tater kegs were amazing, pierogies were tasty - Bloody Mary with shrimp was impressive. Irish martini was sooo tasty. read more

Stopped here for a quick lunchtime bite with the family. The restaurant has a unique covered patio with heaters so we were pretty cozy despite being technically outside on a chilly day. The food was what you would expect, typical sandwiches, some pastas, ect but overall it was done well and came out quickly. Was very happy with the whole experience. We were seated quickly and service was good but afterwards a large line developed so it does seem to get rather busy at times. read more

Molly Maguires - Reuben - American Near Me - Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania

We stopped at this restaurant after visiting the nearby Lehigh Gorge State Park. It was very busy but we were still seated right away and our food came out quickly. I really enjoyed my peel and eat shrimp which was perfectly seasoned with old bay. Our waitress was very attentive and made sure our water glasses were always full. The only downside was that we were seated in an enclosed patio and the plastic wall enclosure was flapping open in the wind and letting in cold air. read more

Molly Maguires - Pound Peel N' Eat Shrimp and Caesar Salad - American Near Me - Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania

Came to MM's on a recommendation from my Cousin. Was a tad leery only because Yelp had them at 3 stars. My friend and I came in anyway, and had the best experience with our waitress, Katie. We ordered the pierogies appetizer which were smothered in butter and onions (spot on!), and we shared the shepherds pie, which came out piping hot and tasted amazing! Hope you enjoy! read more

Molly Maguires - American Near Me - Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania

See all

We came in for dinner as other places were very busy. It was a great Saturday night experience. Prices were good. Food was fantastic. Great selection of adult beverages. Dominic was our server and he did a phenomenal job read more

Molly Maguires - Bacon cheddar chicken sandwich - American Near Me - Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania

See all

Three out of six dishes we ordered were okay. We had the perogies and chicken fingers for appetizers which were good. I had a salad with chicken. Chicken was dry and tasteless. The open faced turkey sandwich was bland. The roast beef sandwich on pretzel bread with fries was very good. read more

Wanted to go here with my family after a day out in Jim Thorpe and it was a bad experience. I walked in with my son in a stroller and the hostess was so rude. At first she sat us right next to the entrance, but made us move once she realized we had a stroller. She asked if we could fold up the stroller but it wasn't necessary at all. The food was borderline inedible. My burger was ok but the fries were over cooked. The kids Mac and cheese was maybe the most disgusting thing I've ever seen. My son barely even had a bite. My wife had the cajun burger and it was disgusting. Both the Mac and cheese and the burger didn't get eaten and the waitress never once asked us if there was a problem with it. In fact, it was only the busboy! who eventually asked us after we had already paid the check. read more

Stopped by Molly's Maguire's while exploring Jim Thorpe. There's a meaningful plaque and statue right outside the entrance, adding to the charm. Molly's offers both indoor and outdoor seating, each with its own bar. A long line formed early, so plan ahead. We enjoyed our time inside, especially thanks to the bartender, who made a delicious cosmo with a vibrant fruity color. The waffle fries were a bit overcooked, but the atmosphere made up for it. With a TouchTunes jukebox available, we had fun picking our own tunes. Great spot to unwind in town! read more

See all

The food was traditional irish and delicious. The service was amazing fast and super polite. Definitely had the pub feel with great lighting and good decor. Can't wait to go back! read more

Having just gone on the Leigh Gorge Scenic Railway across the street, it was time for lunch and we needed to find a place with outdoor seating as we had our dog with us. The place and nearby surrounding was extremely packed as it was Columbus Day weekend. Luckily we were able to secure a seat right outside quickly. My wife got the seared ahi tuna appetizer for $20 as many patrons reviewed and said how delish this appetizer was and they were right. Place like this is unassuming for putting out a delish dish such as this but it was to perfection. Perfectly seared and tasted very clean. My wife also got the butternut squash homemade soup and that too was amazing and just the right about of thickness. My son got the shepherd pie and the presentation was amazing and perfectly blend of meat, peas and potatoes. I got a classic hamburger with vegetable fixings and fries for $14. My only minor complaint is I asked for medium and it was around medium rare. I was able to tolerate it but do check the meat temperature. All in all, I would give this 4 stars and our waitress absolutely rocked! read more

See all

Best burger in Jim Thorpe! REAL beef..... So good! The chili is also amazing! I went in and ate and sat at the bar and was very impressed with the food. That burger was GREAT. read more

While visiting the town we stopped in here for a quick lunch and drink. We had the hot roast beef and a burger and everything was really good. I also had a fancy drink! The place was nice and nice staff. read more

Molly Maguires - Menu - American Near Me - Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania

See all

Fair food at best. Personally, the Shepherds Pie was disappointing. A few wraps (and 1/2 of those went uneaten). Liked the loaded tater tots. Eight of us; the service was ok, but what attitudes:( There was a steak eater next to me and I'm told it was tough. One GF restriction at the table but they had no GF options. A big bar with just ok bar food. About $300 for the 8 of us. One appy and a round of drinks. read more

See all

Ignored at the "middle bar" for 15 minutes. I am sure the experience would have been different if we had a seat at the regular bar or at a table. We ended up walking out along with another couple that was also ignored. read more

Had dinner here our first night of a weekend visit. The inside dining area was closed. The only area open was the outside, but that was okay because it was closed in and it wasn't real cold outside. The food was good, nothing spectacular though. The server was pretty good and attentive. However, the prices are a bit high for all you get. read more

Fun, Irish pub style restaurant in bar. Food was good and Service was as well. I was happy with the overall experience.

My food was good. Service was good. Ambiance was fine. Nothing great but also no complaints.

The food was pretty good, my wife had a burger and fries and it was made well. I had shepherds pie and after it cooled a bit it was great and very flavorful. I tried their special Bloody Mary with shrimp and the shrimp were good but the taste of the drink was really bad. I asked the bartender what their mix was and they said Texas Pete. It was very bland and not very spicy. For $14.50 I expected a lot better. The restaurant was packed and the waitresses moved things along nicely. Wait times were minimal. If I'm ever back in town, food only no drinks. read more

Classic bar/pub vibes! The waitress was really nice and all of the food was good for a very fair price. Definitely a good place to grab lunch or a beer at the bar read more

Food was good, service great, and a fun and friendly atmosphere! We had the pork chop and salmon and they were good. We started w the shrimp cocktail bloody Mary's which was a drink and app in one. Our server was great. Will go back! read more

Food looked beautiful but I was disappointed with the inside of my Sheppard's Pie. It lacked any sort of taste or good filling, and was mainly mashed potatoes. The vibe of the place was really lively. We came on a Wednesday night and we played bingo with 80s songs and songs with heartbreak/love. I would come back for the ambience, but it was also very loud so any conversations with friends were hard to hear. read more

Molly Maguires - Sheppard 's Pie - American Near Me - Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania

Stopped by on a Sunday afternoon and was seated immediately. The staff was super friendly and accommodating. I went with the house salad and added grilled chicken, my boyfriend got the pastrami rueben and loved it. My salad was fresh and piled high with chicken. They have a ton of options for dressings. I tried their apple cider vinaigrette and it was great. It's definitely a nice spacious restaurant with a great bar area. Perfect for a nice lunch after enjoying the town of Jim Thorpe. They also have a nice outdoor patio set up. read more

Molly Maguires - Pastrami Reuben Sandwich - American Near Me - Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania

See all

We only had drinks on 2 separate nights, but the bar staff was amazing very friendly and attentive couldn't highly recommend this place enough read more

food is ok !! service the waitress act like shes busy kind of rude , ambience is quite. i will go in another place if you don't want to ruin your day of vacation lol fish n chips for me minus waitress read more

Stopped by this place last week while waiting for my scheduled train ride. The inside had a wait, so we were directed outside to eat under the tint. Food was pretty good. Nothing special but was definitely good enoght to eat. I only had an order of wings. My husband had a burger with fries & veggie potstickers. I tried the potstickers & they were good. The drinks were good too but you could barely taste any alcohol. The best part of our visit was the service we received from our waitress Liz. She was the sweetest & most attentive waitress! She checked on us frequently & made sure we didnt wait long for anything. Such a gem & they are lucky to have her read more

See all

Impromptu, later dinner option, arriving around 8pm. We chose to eat on the deck. There was still seating available despite heading into the peak fall tourist season. I enjoyed a local chocolate peanut butter porter. My husband and I shared the tater kegs & he had wings I enjoyed the shrimp. Service was polite and timely. read more

See all

Always our first stop in Jim Thorpe to warm up with some French onion soup. Very deep beef flavor while a little sweeter than most soups but very very cheesy with soaked croutons inside! Tater kegs were good, nice smokey bacon and the side of horseradish dipping sauce made it. Very busy bar prepping for the fall crowds but the service was kind and drinks were quick. Check out the inside bar it has old wood along with stone. read more

See all

I loved the atmosphere! Was here a couple years ago and loved the inside pub. Went here today for my birthday big 40..extremely disappointed. The bartender who may have been a manager/owner..wow! Entirely rude. Man I'm sorry you hate to serve people because I hope you understand your job is to serve people! Personable, politeness, a smile would help! read more

The food was excellent. Had the pretzel, bruschetta, and house salad. Nothing crazy but would eat there again, . No reservations so roll the dice when you go. Seemed like the line moved right along. read more

We really enjoyed our stop for a late lunch. It was pretty hot out so we opted to eat in the bar area, though the outdoor porch area looked cool. We had a burger and a Reuben and both were good, the mod going to the Reuben. I hope to revisit JT and will definitely hit up Molly's again! read more

Absolutely amazing! The name of the pub is historically relevant to the region and fun, staff was kind with great service and the balsamic chicken was stunning. One of the best dishes I've had in a long time! read more

We ate here Tuesday June 11th. Food was good. I had the chicken wings appetizer, my dad (who is polish) had the pierogies (also really good) and my mom had the tater kings with bacon in them...they are huge (you get 5 on a plate). We all had the Mauch Chunk Lager... I highly recommend it. (We went on a Tuesday, when other establishments were closed so there was a wait for a table.) read more

See all

Overall this seemed to be the cheapest place to eat, so we decided to eat here. We got sat right away and our waiter was very attentive. The food was great besides the grilled chicken. I doubt it was seasoned and really just had no flavor, it was not worth the extra cost to add it on. Overall great atmosphere and dining experience. read more

See all

Not so Unique Irish Styled Pub in an older hotel structure in Jim Thorpe! It's definitely a touristy place! They have a big enclosed deck for accommodation of large crowds but we actually got to sit in the historic inside bar/ dining area which is pretty much a throwback in time except for some of the decorations and HDTVs! I ordered the Molly Maguire Burger Peppers, Mushroom, Onions, Bacon & Cheese the wife ordered Sheppard's Pie Ground Beef, Carrots, Onions, Peas, Mashed Potatoes & Gravy. The food came out hot and the burger was tasty & even though it was supposed to be a 1/2 lb burger I really felt we paid the tourist price on this plate! The Shephard's Pie had a nice amount of Ground beef mix encircled by a lot of Mashed potatoes and again a touristy price! Overall it was a 3 1/2 experience! We'll go up on this one! Not sure if we'll return but you never know! read more