Food was decent for the Price. There was no service, you served yourself. Ambiance was Ok. I will take a group of Kids back, one day.

Placed my order with Door Dash last night, but called Door Dash to cancel the order because we needed to add more to the order. I spoke with Door Dash and Mr Gati's about the canceled order. Both Door Dash and Mr Gati's confirmed the cancelation. Went back on Door Dash and placed another order, 3 times the $ amount from the first time. Later I received a text from Door Dash that the food was delivered. What was delivered was the canceled order. I called Door Dash about this problem. Door Dash customer service person called Mr Gati's on my behalf to see what he could work out. The Door Dash customer service person came back on the phone and said he was so sorry. Since Mr Gati's gave the Door Dash driver the canceled order, Door Dash was not able to send another driver out since the order was confirmed delivered. I called Mr Gati's and was told that I needed to pick it up, there was nothing they could do. He was not very supportive just a matter of fact. Door Dash is for the convenience of people plus other reasons. I was not able to drive. Some of us went to bed hungry!! This was not good!. read more

Old pizza only 4 options for the "buffet" and to top it all off my wife's salad was covered in hair .... Showed an employee and he said I'll take it to the back, he brought it to the back and didn't say another word about it. Like what was the point of that read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

Okay, not great. The food is bland and feels mass produced. They do a good a good job of keeping the buffet full...so, not great food, but lots of it. read more

It's good, clean and the new renovation is nice! Food is great, of course. We love the easy options for the whole family. Workers are always nice and attentive. read more

Pizza was meh. Delivery service opaque and not delivered by individual posted. Appears they forgot to put the cinnamon bread desert in the oven - inedible. Hard pass. read more

I had a broken shoulder when I went there the Staff was incredible they helped me get my pizza and brought it to the table for me I love Mr Gatties read more

Me and Kenn really enjoyed having lunch her today. It was our first time being here so it was cool, laid back and the staff was nice. The prices were very reasonable for an all you can eat buffet. They had a variety of pizzas, desserts and salad toppings. Everything was made fresh and to order. The restroom was clean, the restaurant was clean and the atmosphere was good. We will definitely be back and bring our kiddos they love pizza. read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - Hubby - Pizza Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

Great pizza friendly service Nice to get the one uncooked, bring it home and serve it hot read more

Topping's needs to be cook more inside pizza. But the pizza texture is pretty good. But the toppings kept coming off as I was picking up my pizza read more

The pizza was like rubber. It came from the oven I drove home, a seven minute drive and I couldn't even eat the pizza. A waste of money.

We went here for dinner. The pizza was fresh! The service was great. An employee named Chase was on top of any special requests. He was patient with guests and got the pizza requests out quickly. It was not too busy when we went, despite it being dinner time. The bathrooms were clean. We had a great experience here and will definitely go again! read more

I had numerous orders from here while I door dash part-time and I wanted to try it so here we are and the food is real good the staff here are really professional and the atmosphere is pleasing I would highly recommend this place. The prices are good and there's a variety of food especially for picky children that they will like. read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - Custom made chef salad and spaghetti with spicy sauce, garlic bread stick and pepperoni sausage pizza w/ Sweet tea - Pizza Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

Gatti's is always good. They are always consistent and food is ready when it is supposed to be ready.

Around the pandemic this location closed and was remodeled. It reopened in 2021 I think. Yesterday was the 2nd I ate here since the remodel. Yesyerday around lunch it was perhaps 75%---85% full yet the tables were cleared if they were open, there was plenty of pizza on the buffet and it was clean- All good and positive things. Cost for buffet and drink is around $13---if you are over 61 years of age or under 18 years old, the cost is discounted. The cashier was polite and engaging. The buffet has 3 stations meaning a spaghetti/pasta station, a salad station and a pizza station. As far as I am aware, desserts here are in the form of pizza toppings/crust so dessert items are located with the pizza station. I was there for the pizza only and in my 2 trips there pizza offerings were plentiful---oh yeah, it should be noted when you pay at the beginning the cashier asks you if you have any pizza requests. In my opinion the pizzas choices were varied and many although there were more "pan pizza" type offerings than "thin crust" offerings but perhaps no one asked for thin crust. I was a Gatti's pizza fan before the pandemic and I remain a Gattis pizza fan so I give 5 stars based on that and my 2 dine in experiences over the last 14 months. read more

Don't waste your time. Service is horrible. They ask you what kind ic pizza then they just tell you "it's coming out!" Haha! I was with / children under 3 that were not eating but had to pay for each one to not eat! Salad was gross and brown. Kids threw away some money in game room for rubber ducks and plastic rings. No pictures... I just got my tea to go and left. read more

Reno of location is old news but an excellent job was done plus amazing game room! I have a sentimental love for Gatti's. The staff is SUPER friendly and pizza/pasta/salad bar have awesome options for a very reasonable price! read more

If you are looking for a pizza buffet with a little more character than a chain like Cici's this place is for you. The pizza is decent and they always have a ton of options. Kids will have almost too much fun when going here, especially because of the arcade room in the back. read more

When you hit up a place like Mr. Gatti's, you know it's time make use of those stretchy pants. With Mr. Gatti's fresh off of a renovation, I had a feeling they were ready to step their game up. The customer service is good as soon as you walk in the door. When you pay for a buffet, they even ask you if there's a specific pizza you want made. This place makes me wish my metabolism was way better than it is, but Mr. Gatti's is always here when you need a good bang for your buck. read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - a long line of pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

See all

Kaitlyn is the best manager ever, first time here and she took care of me and I'll most def be coming back ! read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

My go to, close around where I live and affordable. Also the pizza taste is pretty decent for the price, don't know what the other comments are talking about! They appear to be rebuilding in my area and I can't wait to go inside and see the remodeled, new and improved Gattis. Don't know what people expect from a buffet styled restaurant, seems perfect for the kiddies and better than the Cicis Pizzas' and Chuckee Cheeses' I grew up on, adults will enjoy it also. read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

Open again!!!!! May 7 2020 ordered a pizza ready in about 10mins and picked up at their drive through window. Rey prompt service and same great pizza The sampler rules! read more

Kindness of the Staff is always Great. Pizza and Salad are very tasty. I Love bringing my Family out to dine here. Game Room is Excellent. The only thing missing is a PAC Man Game. read more

Meaty pizza but cold and dry! Drive thru is the only perk I can say good about this establishment! Just as you see the pic is how I received it. read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

Couldn't be happier with the pizza, service and arcade. Perfect Friday night with kids. Everyone was so accommodating and it totally brought me back to my childhood at Mr. Gatti's. We will be back! read more

Got there to pick up a medium pepperoni and sausage pizza. Website said it was done 5+ minutes ago. Go in and they say it isn't quite done yet so we wait 10 minutes. Asked again and they did the old your pizza is almost done trick then grabbed a pepperoni pizza (probably off the buffet), threw a pan of sausage in the oven, and then dumped it all over the old pizza. Trash. read more

Went here yesterday and got my husband a lunch buffet to go $8.99 plus tax and drink was additional not a bad price if the food tasted good. The pasta was nasty looking and dry. The sauce was bland the pizza is like cardboard but the salad bars not to bad. And the cheesy bread was ok. Sorry I didn't take any pics. The worker with pink hair was very rude read more

SO UPSET i go here strictly for the max and cheese pizza. Ordered it for the buffet, 20 minutes go by an no pizza. I asked when it would be ready and the boys working the buffet said it was almost ready. Another 20 minutes and still no pizza. by this time i am full and ready to leave. walking out the door, still no max and cheese pizza. i'm very upset mr gattis... do better read more

The lunch buffet is okay. I cannot say that the pizza is high-quality. It is great that they make them fresh for the buffet, but the ingredients are pretty low quality. If you want pizza, salad and pasta for lunch though and do not have much time for lunch, I highly suggest this place for that! I have had far better tasting pizzas around town, but this one serves a purpose - to take care of the lunch rush! read more

Nice lunch buffet! Fresh pizza and salad! Great price! read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - Salad from buffet! Fresh! - Pizza Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

Love this place and the staff! They are very attentive and ready to make sure your visit is great.

Gattis is our absolute favorite pizza! We pick up a pizza in the drive through about once a week, it's so convenient and soooo good! Our favorite guilty pleasure and calorie splurge! No one else has a crust like theirs. Crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and their unique combo of Romano cheese is just delicious! Love Mr. Gatti's! read more

Was in Baton Rouge for the day stopped at Gatti's for lunch. I must say the buffet was great. Salad was fresh , pizza was great ( loved the crust) Shout out to Tim for great service! Making sure we felt at home and making our meal more enjoyable. Outside of building does not give the place justice. read more

Mr Gatti's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

This is the worst Mr. Gatti's I have seen. It's very small, the salad bar was not well stocked. The salad bar is so high up, my adult daughter had to ask for assistance. It is not disability friendly at all. The game room is very small and not really suited for the toddlers. I chose this place over Chucky e Cheese because of my experience with other Mr. Gatti's. Wont be taking the grandkids back. read more

I've been eating at Mr. Gatti's all my life. When I was a kid we used to come here after football/soccer/basketball/baseball season and we would all have contests to see who could eat the most pizza slice. We also used to go to the old LSU location after a night of drinking to get our hangover pizza fix. These days I tend to avoid buffet pizza places due to my not wanting to increase my already ample waistline, that being said, this is as good a place as any to do it. They fill the buffet often and will make any pizza you request. The only place comparable to Mr. Gatti's is Johnny's Pizza, and as I said in my review for Johnny's, it's really personal preference to which you will prefer. It's definitely better than CiCi's though as the quality is much higher. read more

I wouldn't want to eat he pizza here again even if it was free. Little Caesar's Pizza is better than this, and Chuck E. Cheese's is way better, that's how disgusting the pizza tastes. It is all quantity and no quality, but on the upside if you need to gain a lot of weight quickly this may be the place for you. Plus they have a television so you can be entertained while you potentially and realistically inhale 3000+ calories (one and a half pizzas) with the leverage of the dine in only buffet. Yea, they have a salad bar, but it sure does not look appealing! read more

See all

The pizza really wasn't that good and their selection ran out fast! I went up to grab another piece and there was nothing at the bar. I asked if there was more pizza coming out soon gesturing towards the empty buffet and I was asked if I ordered a specialty pizza because the girl didn't hear/understand me. There were not a lot of people there for them to have no pizza available. The spaghetti was over cooked. I couldn't finish it. The cinnamon sticks were pretty good though. Probably won't go back. I'll just grab Little Caesars instead. read more

Best pizza ever!!!! Consistently good pizza. Always friendly service. Only pizza you can get that is not a greasy mess.

The food was just okay. Pizza choices are slim and not fresh. Salad bar was on the small side. I did enjoy the pizza crust quite a bit more than normal joints. That's a big plus. Reminiscent of Detroit style pizza. read more

Worth the 1 hour drive originally from lafayette I now live in new orleans we don't have a good pizza place. I used to got to gattis in lafayette and opelousas I found out there was one in br so after 4 years I finally got to eat it again and it's still the original taste crust and all I don't think they changed anything the best pizza I've had read more