I've had sandwiches from Mr Pickle's at other locations. This was my first time in Lincoln. Placing an order online for take-out was simple. The menu is fairly comprehensive. Looking at all my favorite deli meat options, beef, pastrami, ham, etc. I was "good" and headed for the vegetarian options. They have salads too. I selected a Deli Veggie Sandwich on my selection of marble rye bread and pepper jack cheese. That was $10.99 which these days isn't that bad for a sandwich. At the last minute before checking out I added the macaroni salad. For $3.69 it was tasty enough but a bit overpriced when you can get much more for slightly more in price at a nearby supermarket, if you want to make an additional stop. There's a small parking lot in back, which is convenient. The place is kinda cute on the outside as it looks like a small, simple shack. Inside the place is rather dark and dismal so I wouldn't eat there. There's a small outdoor eating area as well, and although rather exposed to the elements it might be a better choice than indoors if you plan on eating there. The staff were efficient enough, and more matter of fact than friendly in their greeting. It was pointed out to me to get the macaroni salad out of the self-service refrigerator. Now I know the drill in picking up a take out order. The sandwich itself was quite good. All of the ingredients were fresh and crisp. It was nicely prepared and the bread was also fresh and delicious. I was pleased with the size and tastiness. They have sandwich size options too. I'd go back when a sandwich craving hits. Overall, except for the physical appearance of the place, it's not that bad. Putting it in perspective it is a sandwich shop after all. Overall, I do recommend it. read more

See all

Disappointed again. Not sure why I even tried- Old tomatoes, wet lettuce (which made for soggy bread that was already stale) sooooo skimpy on everything except the salami, Forgot the cheese.... read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - The Italian- wet lettuce, old bread, 1/2 piece of pastrami and 1/2 slice ham 5 pieces of salami. - Sandwiches Near Me - Lincoln, California

See all

Im glad I am observant on what I eat, it is SAD that they can't even take the cheese film off the cheese...... I forgot why I don't come here thanks for reminding me not to come back read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Cheese film!!!!? - Sandwiches Near Me - Lincoln, California

I am writing this review because I live in Lincoln and order from this location frequently for delivery and at least 20% of the time something goes wrong. I have now decided to not tip for any service as it is the employees and/or Door Dash that are getting things wrong. More often than not it is the dasher that fails to read the explicit delivery instructions to "ring doorbell" or "hand order to resident" - when this happens, even though I am latterly 10 feet from the door, I don't know that they have dropped the food off. Whose great idea was it to leave food at a front door without making contact with the receiver of that food???? How is this a default???? And WHY does the dasher IGNORE explicit instructions???? Today, it was about the people preparing the order. My sandwich explicitly stated "No Mayonnaise", "No Tomato", "No Onion" - yet ALL were on the sandwich - what if I were allergic to eggs and I just ate the sandwich (if that were the case they would have had a lawsuit), fortunately this time they only get a bad review. I had also requested to add Pepperoni to the sandwich (8-slices says the receipt) there was one slice and it was only 1" in diameter Additionally, I ordered a side of Au Jus to dip my sandwich, which I paid extra for - but NO Au Jus was delivered. Mr. Pickles you need to put quality control into your packaging, the receipt is correct but the contents do not match! The ONLY reason I have gone back is because usually their sandwiches are good. However, sometime they fail in a bad way. Ironically, in this case the meat and cheese was overcooked and the the sandwich was lukewarm at best - fail. Also, in this particular case, I did not include a tip because the last time I ordered and tipped, the dasher failed to ring the bell - so NO TIP (To Insure Performance and is supposed to happen AFTER service, not before!) Unfortunately, for Mr. Pickles, I have decided that I will no longer frequent this location. I've made a complaint before and they corrected that complaint, but I don't have time to keep repeating complaints or questioning if my order will be correct or not. It's been more than 3 strikes. Between the No Au Jus and the 1/8 of the pepperonis delivered I figure they stole $0.89 for the missing 7 pepperonis and $0.99 for the absence of Au Jus - but really $1.88 does not make up for the lack of service. If Mr. Pickle's wants to attempt to make this right, the order number is #46571 and was made on 8/20/2025 @ 11:16:08 AM. Call me, you have my phone number. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Receipt as delivered attached to bag. - Sandwiches Near Me - Lincoln, California

See all

10/10 sandwich! The bread was great, great portions on everything , including sauce. Very fresh. We also got a side of their potato salad and it was soooo good!! Very Friendly staff! Great service :) if I ever find myself in the area I will be back!! read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Mrs. Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Lincoln, California

The sandwich fell apart. I just was not impressed. I was also worried about the bread felt like it could have cracked a tooth.

I go here at least once a month on my way home from work for a fast dinner night. The convenience of ordering on the app, putting in all my preferences and paying ahead of time make this an easy dinner night for me. My family can go on the app and send me their order so I just have to walk in to pick it up. The sandwiches are perfect every time and you can't beat the choices. The employees are always kind and welcoming. read more

1st time - We ordered a CJ pastrami sammie Surprised - no meat?? Picked up near closing. will bring back tomorrow. Ordered a Hang Loose Surprised - same size as Sammie? Total was over $37.00 Pastrami was dryer than carbon?? What a disappointment and joke. McDonald's would have been better for that price. read more

I was hoping to provide a higher rating. I ordered the Fast Eddy and unfortunately the Dutch crunch bread was very stale. I don't think I'll be going back. read more

Let me preface this by saying. The staff were super super friendly!! However the food was terrible. Two sandwiches, the large ones I guess which are about 6inches each two chips two drinks with tip 50 dollars. The bread was stale on the edges and the meat has a slightly spoiled taste as if wasn't getting used and they just kept it. The chips were good soda good but for that price. Maybe just stay home read more

Ordered two regular sandwiches with the works and one BLT. I was shocked at the size of the sandwich for the price, seems really expensive. Everything was fresh and they do put a decent amount of "the works" on the sandwiches. I think the BLT is way over priced. Four pieces of bacon, lettuce, tomato, and Mayo for $13.99 seems crazy. The staff seemed nice but just took a very long time to finish the sandwiches. A decent experience but nothing to be too excited about read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Mr The Mr. Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Lincoln, California

See all

I love this Mr. pickle's. Workers are generally always friendly too. My only complaint is that they will randomly close earlier than advertised. read more

Great sandwich selection I ate there for lunch 3 different days and everything I had was delicious.

I was warned about the Dutch crunch. Our family got a bunch of subs and they all looked really delicious. Nice fluffy bread, lots of toppings. However I got the Got Beef. It had a good amount of meat but my sandwich was a smushed sad sandwich. Maybe the Dutch crunch is better on a cold sandwich but on a warm one the crunches become very tough in texture and kind of shred up your palate. Like Cap'n Crunch. All the other sandwiches were beautiful and enjoyed, hence the four even though I had a sorry one. read more

As always the ingredients were very good. The problem was the size of the sand which for the price. We paid $15 for a chicken sandwich on a sourdough roll. The roll was so small that when cut in to share, which we always do, one half only equaled 2.5 bites. I don't know if they are now using smaller rolls by choice, or if this was a fluke. It was quite disappointing after being a customer for the past 25 years and eating at Mr. Pickles all over the state. Not sure if it is worth it anymore. read more

I clearly asked for No Onions, No Pickles and No Pepperoncinis on my sandwich. And as soon as I got home and unwrapped it, I saw onions hanging out. Turns out, ALL OF IT was on my sandwich and I had to pick it all off. Of course you can still taste it though, which ruins it for me. Also, there was hardly any chicken, and the bread was slightly damp on one half. If I'm paying over $16 for a sandwich, AND tipping on top of that, I really expect it to be made correctly. Super disappointed. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - I asked for No Onions, No Pickles and No Pepperoncinis. - Sandwiches Near Me - Lincoln, California

See all

Review based on 5 or 6 visits since moving to Lincoln last year. Pros: - The food is usually good. (However, see Cons below.) It can be hit and miss, though. Wife usually gets a salad, and while the last one was good, the one prior to that had hardly any of the "good stuff" (meat, cheese, etc.). 2 visits ago, they were out of tri-tip (at 11:00 AM). Overall, the average sandwich is better than Subway, and maybe on par with Sourdough and Co. - The complimentary cookies are a nice touch and are usually pretty fresh. Cons: - As I said, it can be hit and miss. My last sandwich was the BBQ tri-tip (they were not out this time). My fist bite, the meat and fixings tasted very good, but then I quickly noticed an unexpected texture. So I looked and realized the roll was completely stale! Like, I could use it as a door stop. Hard and crumbly. There is NO WAY the person making this sandwich could have thought this was an edible, fresh roll, but they served it anyway. I had to toss the whole thing. Verdict: - We may go back in a few weeks to see if we have a better experience; and honestly most of our previous visits were OK (hence the 3 stars). But one more rock-hard french roll and we're through. read more

Delicious bread, generous portions and reasonably priced. This is our go-to sammie place.

Wife and I were craving some subs. Last week went to another sandwich place down street and it was not good. Went here and was great! The employees were friendly and made you feel welcomed. The bread was really good and the turkey tasted like quality. We both got the meal deals and thought it was a great value. Will definitely return!!!!! read more

Great on-time service for delivery pick up. I highly recommend this establishment due to timing and customer service is very highly and very great. I give them a five stars just about every time I walk in there. read more

I wish I could give a better review I ordered a Tom turkey for my lunch and I was ready as soon as I got it I came home and started eating it and right away I got a stomach ache this is beyond frustrating I would hope they would only use fresh products for all sandwiches now I am sitting here with a stomach ache I got food poisoning at the mr pickles in auburn like 3 years ago and that was not fun and now I am getting a stomach ache again I don't know what products they use but they might want to change them this is a 2nd issue I am having with mr pickle and I was hoping that I wouldn't have that experience again and it looks like I am read more

The employees here are always so nice, like they go out of their way to make sure they understand your order and they are ready with suggestions if you ask. I didn't take a picture of my sandwich because I scarfed it down but they're soooo good. A little pricy (but in this economy everything is) but I think the portions are good. A half sandwich is usually enough for me and they give you a free cookie. I come here because of the quality of their food-- and I love their garlic sauce and baja sauce! read more

Stopped by Mr. Pickles for lunch after visiting a friend, the location is easy to find, parking is good for its size and they have a nice mix of indoor and outdoor seating. Let me start by saying the sandwiches where great, made exactly how we asked and packaged nicely. We got the option and f pickle or cookie (one of each since two sandwiches) and the nice woman at the register let us know about the deal they had going on that day. I cannot express how fresh the food tasted, I either got really lucky or they use really good quality ingredients. No part of the sandwich was over done and it was made exactly how we asked during the lunch rush. The menu has a lot of items so it might be smart to check it before you go. Also they keep the seating clean inside but don't take as much care outside, trash was full and the tables had left over food from previous guests. Overall still a great experience. read more

I haven't had Mr. Pickles sandwich for a long time since the nearest one from my house closed down some years ago. So I decided to stop by this location. I ordered Tom Turkey and did take out. Sandwich was very good! I saw Mr. Pickle's costume at the corner in the shop and brought back fun memories. I will go back there again. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - a green pickle character - Sandwiches Near Me - Lincoln, California

Amazing service and workers! Always get the Cali Tuna! My go to lunch spot. 10/10 would recommend. read more

It seems like every time we get sandwiches there, mine is screwed up! I ordered the Big Jake because it came with cream cheese. Got home, no cream cheese!!! read more

Walked out. Terrible customer service. No hello, had 6 people working with 1 person in the store and was told it would take at least 15 minutes, (which was fine with me) because I didnt order ahead of time. Because I have been known to try and save the world, one business at a time, and because I enjoy excellent service aka friendly people wherever I go, I'm going to give you some free advise Mr Pickles owner ... its called customer service 101: #1) "Hi! Welcome to Mr Pickles (smiles smiles smiles) what can we get started for you?" # 2) "Sounds yummy! What's your name ?" #3) OK dear customer who pays us with hard earned money ... "we will have that right up !!! " Make a great sandwich, tell them " thank you dear customer who pays us with hard earned money " and ask them to "please come back again " (smiles and more smiles) Easy peazy! Hate customer service Mr Pickles employees and owner ? Then get out of the business! read more

Oh my gosh, the Santa Fe salad is delicious. The Baja sauce is what makes it. I really pissed off the girl making my salad when I asked that the chicken and cheese be heated up (she actually slammed the microwave lmao), but her nasty demeanor was well worth the end result haha. Tasty food as usual but the customer service from this unhappy gal left much to be desired. I actually felt sorry for the kid that was working with her. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Santa Fe Salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Lincoln, California

We love Mr pickles take out. I always get the hero and the Mr pickle sandwich. They are quick, the order is always ready when promised and they are friendly. The dining room is clean and cute but small. We usually do takeout read more

We have been saying we needed to try Mr. Pickles for years and finally did early the week of Thanksgiving. We were very happy we came. The Dutch crunch was fresh and the sandwiches were tasty. I read the reviews that say the service is horrible, but at dinnertime (when we came) we had a polite and efficient server who made great sandwiches. We liked it so much and came back a week later to enjoy another sandwich. read more

Food was good, but service was super rude! We were disappointed about it. They better train more how to take care of customers!

Very tasty sandwich. I am thankful that I was offered a non gluten wrap due to need for non wheat in sandwiches. I was given my meal to go which I gladly accepted picnicking in my own car. read more

I tried a Mr. Pickles Sandwich Shop for the first time this week. I was hungry and in a hurry. You see them all over the place ...so I decided to give it a go. It was the one in Lincoln right off the main drag - Lincoln Blvd. I have been watching my carbohydrates so it was somewhat of a treat for me to have a regular (breaded) sandwich. My original plan was to just eat half of whatever I ordered. That turnout to be a joke .. in other words, my plan failed .... the sandwich was really good (fresh, tasty and generously sized) giving me no choice but to eat it all. The Italian (so-called cold, specialty sandwich) was my choice. It included dry salami, pastrami, sliced dill pickle and black forest ham. I opted for cheddar cheese on the sandwich supported by potato chips and an ice tea. Good food, reasonably priced, friendly staff and "fast". read more

See all

The girls are fabulous. And my dude I appreciate your work. Nice shop. Great sandwiches hot or cold. It gets busy... cuz they kick ass. So please be patient. Be kind to staff... not a perfect world. Breath:) they doing the best. read more

I'm only giving a 3 because the sandwich's were really good and fresh. The customer service was terrible these girls who work there clearly have no manners and I used them as a example to my employee who is there age telling her that if she had customer service like that I would write her up. We live in a fairly small town and customer service should be exceptional and this lacked it to the fullest. People couldn't even walk in without a rude comment to close the door because the air is on really not a hello, thanks for coming it was close the door the air is on and wait outside if there isn't room. If I was the owner of this place I would really look at who your hiring. This place tastes so good and the sandwiches were so fresh but I would drive a little father to go somewhere else where I feel Like my money is wanted. Itd sad how little customer service matters to employees anymore especially since they aren't the ones who own the place and there getting paid by who comes in and buys the product/food there selling. read more

I usually call in my order to pick up and never had an issue yet. My favorite is the hang loose. Customer service has always been great! Not really sure why so many negative reviews because I've always had good experiences here. Thank you mr. Pickles staff for the delicious sandwiches read more

Tried to order and was informed the wait was 15 mins as there were 6 orders ahead of us. The cashier then walked way without taking our order. I'm taking my business elsewhere where I am wanted as a customer. read more

Sandwich was good, I asked for a pickle instead of the cookie. I was told "NO"! I'll refer to them as Mr. Cookie now. I'll also wait tell after the deal is complete before I decide to tip. read more

Ordered two half sandwiches online at 12:20, I come in at 1:10 and there still working on the order. They don't allow customers to wait inside for there order, and seem annoyed at there customers in general. Four cars waiting outside waiting for a sandwich on a Tuesday. Do yourself a favor and go somewhere else read more

Best sandwich's in Lincoln or maybe in the whole area of placer. So good, good service, and lots of options. 5 star definitely recommend