Ordered online in advance. Came in and people who came and ordered got their food before us.

To quote Liz Lemon, "I believe that all anyone really wants in life is to sit in peace and eat a sandwich." I believe Liz is right and I believe that sandwich is the Mr. Pickle on dutch crunch. It does everything right. The chicken is tender and complimented perfectly by a few pieces of crispy (never soggy) bacon. The lettuce is fresh. The tomatoes are beefy enough for a good bite, but don't soak into the bread. And who can forget the eponymous pickles? Delicious. Of course, no meal is truly finished without a little sweet treat. And Mr. PIckle's Sandwich Shop understands that! Every one of their sandwiches comes with a gooey, soft, freshly-made chocolate chip cookie. I'm so tempted to buy a half-dozen but usually the singleton does it for me. The next time you're looking for a little inner peace, skip the yoga class and go for a Mr. Pickle instead. read more

This place has gone downhill. I think the management has been changed. The employees just don't care for the food anymore. The sandwiches were a soggy mess and looked just like one from subway just with a higher markup. The chicken tastes like rubber. read more

Food is great but it was uncomfortable listening to the new owner directing his employees. They are learning but it made me cringe for them.

I was hesitant to come here again after reading the reviews. I thought I've been here before and the sandwiches were good. This sandwich shop was on the way to the winery I was visiting. I ordered the Sammie size Mrs. Pickles without bacon on the crunchy Dutch roll. The crunchy Dutch roll was delicious. The top part of the roll still held its crunch, but the bottom piece of bread was all soggy and sandwich fell apart. There were more condiments on my sandwich than meat. Next time I will take the advice of my fellow Yelpers and pick another sandwich shop. read more

See all

The food is genuinely good, but expensive. I don't come here too often but I like their sandwiches. Last few times I came no one spoke english, how am I supposed to order when no one knows what i'm saying. A lady had to translate the entire time. In general their service is just not good at all. Not friendly or welcoming. Hope they can work on this read more

It's been years since I've been to a Mr. Pickles and it's just as good as I remember it. I pass this establishment everyday on my way to work and finally make an effort to stop by for a sandwich. As soon as I saw pastrami on the menu I had to order one! CJ's Pastrami comes with mustard and pickles only. That's exactly how I like my pastrami sandwich. I grabbed a bag of Doritos to complete my order to go. I forgot they give you a chocolate chip cookie too. The only change is the price! Holy cow it's expensive to eat a sandwich these days! read more

See all

I don't like having to do this but i have tried to be patient, I really like their sandwiches and their salads,however evrytime i order potato salad they forget to give it to me and i have to go back and get it, I order online,so i usually just walk in give my name and they hand me the bag, today i ordered extra AuJus and was charged and did not get it!!!! Really when i go in it is not super busy, just don't get it, the employees are always very nice just not very aware. won't be going back, can't afford the gas for 2 trips each time :( read more

Mr. Pickles redeemed themselves. I had the Italian sandwich. It was made nicely and wasn't a mess like the sandwich I had before. My daughter's ham sandwich was made to perfection as well. Thank you Mr. Pickles. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Italian sandwich on French bread - Sandwiches Near Me - Livermore, California

See all

The Livermore Mr. Pickles location used to be a shining star and a great value in Livermore. That has come to a hard stop. They are now terrible. Every since the store changed hands ~two years ago It's gone from great to pathetic. Because I have been their customer for well over ten years I am on their mailing list. Last week, I received an email that said I could come in for their "Sammie" meal for $7.99, which includes a sandwich, a drink, and potato chips, only to find out this location "is not participating." Yesterday, I went in to get "The Italian" sandwich, which was $10 and has become a $15 sandwich over the past two years. I asked, as I have for well over five years, to swap out the salami for a second portion of pastrami. The manager said I would have to pay an extra $1 to do that swap. I explained to her this store has been making that sandwich that way for me for at least five years, without nickel and dime-ing., She wouldn't budge. I walked out. I tried to remain a faithful customer to them but they have made their message loud and clear. They're not about providing a great sandwich at a palatable price, as they used to be. They're are about ripping customers off by way of pettiness and shrinkflation. Read on: Their portions have shrunk by at least 50% since they changed ownership. They will not honor the deals they send in their email (this was not the first time). The last straw was when they wanted to add that $1 charge for making a change to a sandwich that they have been making for years. I am NOT paying $16 for a sandwich! They have gone beyond absurd. Instead, I went to Jersey Mikes in Dublin, where they gave me a sandwich, with plenty of meat, for $9.50 (they were running a $2 promo which they DID honor). Do yourself a favor and go to Jersey Mikes. Mr. Pickles has become PATHETIC. read more

Great sandwiches, but they've become increasingly smaller. I've been ordering the same thing here for years (veggie wrap) and it used to be so big that it could be two meals. Now it is hardly one. In the past, the wrap was so stuffed with vegetables that I couldn't take just one bite from top to bottom - Now, I can easily bite into the whole thing, as it is about half the size of what it used to be. Just not half the price. Feels like it isn't a fair deal. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Veggie wrap - Sandwiches Near Me - Livermore, California

See all

Terrible customer service and management. Food was way smaller than back in the day. Super sad

Ordered a Mr.Pickle online to pick up during my lunch, only to get back to work and take a bite and there is no meat. I called to notify them and they said the meat was still there. How do you forget to add the meat?! They were willing to make an other but of course I said no since I was on break. They will refund my money which will take 3+ days to get back. Really disappointing read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Livermore, California

five stars for customer service and cleanliness, but 3 stars for food ( the hero and santa maria on dutch crunch). Ratio of meat and condiments to bread was fine, but overall taste was not on par with sandwiches at other chains ( notably jersey mikes). When a sandwich does not taste as good as homemade, that's when I will make my own rather than spending 32 dollars for two sandwiches at Mr. Pickles read more

See all

Stopped by here with my boyfriend who said this is the sandwich place to go to as a local Livermorian. I opted for the Mr. Pickles sandwich on dutch crunch with everything on it an it did not disappoint-- the ingredients were fresh, chicken juicy, pickles refreshing, and bacon crispy. Not sure what they put in their sauce but it is like crack and the pepperoncini is such a good addition to the fattiness of the avocado/mayo/cheesiness of it all. It is definitely a well-balanced sandwich, but it comes at a $16 price tag which I consider pricey. You do get a free chocolate chip cookie with each sandwich order, but the price keeps this from being 5 stars. read more

See all

C'mon bro, $15 and this is a "full" sandwich. 1/2 a sandwich is probably gone in 2 bites. And no cookie or napkins in the bag. Am I gonna get charged for breathing in the buidling next? read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Livermore, California

Just delicious, service is great as well. The ingredients were very fresh. I went at lunch time and had a wonderful experience. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Dutch crunch, turkey and veggie sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Livermore, California

I've seen the gentleman behind the cash register a handful of time. I think he's the owner. Staff is always friendly quality ingredients. They're pretty quick even though they're busy getting a chocolate chip cookie for free with my order is always a hit with the kids. They're seating outside so if it's good weather, you could sit outside. I usually grab my sandwiches to go. I've been here maybe seven or eight times just went a couple of days ago. Definitely would go back again. read more

Meh. Ordered three sandwiches, two made by one guy, one made by another. The first two had plenty of veggies and were good ratio sandwiches. The single made by a different person had nearly no lettuce or tomato or pickles. Super bare, and half the meat of the other sandwiches. $14 for a large ham sandwich that wasn't large and had nearly no toppings, not a fan. read more

I've been here a few times and those former experiences were fine, I do online orders so I can walk in and right out and make modifications without having to hassle a worker in person and my order is usually correct except for this time. This time I ordered the Big Easy which is chicken salad, I go to pick up my sandwich which was simple enough and then get home and take a first bite to see I was given tuna instead. Big disappointment as I do not like tuna much at all and thank god I am not allergic so I am sad. As you can see everything should've been a Big Easy sandwich but this is definitely tuna. read more

See all

Had the tri tip and Reuben sandwiches. The taste was amazing for both. Had the Dutch bread. Def going to be coming back.

We've always enjoyed sandwiches here. Recently, Mr. Pickles changed their sandwich sizes for the better. Thank you for listening to our feed back. The new Sammie size is perfect. read more

Food great. Customer service and more accurately accountability is terrible. I just ordered a sandwich and side of potato salad from the Mr Pickles app. I'll say it again...The Mr Pickles app...and chose deliver. Delivery is by Door Dash. Awesome they delivery for everyone. Order arrives and no potato salad in the bag. It happens. I order from this Mr Pickles all the time so cool I'll just give them a call because I've never had an issue. Until now. Explain to the first person. They don't seem to get it. Another person comes on. They said oh just come in and get a potato salad and you can pay them. I'm like uh I already paid and it wasn't deliver. They tell me they don't do delivery and that Door Dash does. Thank you Captain Obvious. Transferred to a third person and by this time I'm steamed because of the lack of accountability. I say you didn't put the potato salad in the bag. They say what's do you mean ME? I'm like you as in Mr Pickles. They also tell me to just come in a pick up the potato salad. I'm like ummm I selected delivery on YOUR app so why would I want to now come in? Don't make excuses. Take ownership of the issue and fix it. read more

My sandwich was not very good, it had a weird smell and tasted like it was " off" like the meat was old. We had ordered it to go so we just tossed them and unfortunately didn't get to have lunch that day. read more

I called to place my order 45 minutes early. I would've gotten it in time if not for the problem of finding parking. Note - try to avoid mid afternoon on a Friday! Their neighbor take up all the parking. In any case, order in advance to avoid waiting. Rest assured it won't lose its flavor or freshness. I love the Big Easy - chicken salad, cheese, & the works. It is not easy finding good chicken salad sandwich so I come here for that. It is consistently good from two branches I discovered. Chicken is moist & mixed in with the right balance of mayo, cheese, pepperoncini. Love it in sliced sourdough so the salad is the focus & its flavor is not drowned in bread. Service is friendly. Quality is great! read more

After coming here I would never go to a subway, the meat is fresh the staff is nice and I've never felt like my sandwich was lacking meat. The parking lot can be a pain because it's so small and they are so busy but you'll put up with it for an amazing sandwich! read more

Great sandwiches and fast friendly service. Love going here. Will continue going here for sure.

Really fast and really friendly. Warning is that the "toasted" definition around here s my melt the cheese on the meat. They don't tell you about it and it's say "ok". Then when you pick up your sandwich, there's no toasted melted cheese. So it's not like Subway. Just a warning if you want melted cheese you might want to ask can you melt the cheese on my meat? And that's what toast it is. To them, toast it is they "tasted the bread in the morning. fYI read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Chicken salad sandwich that was so-called toasted? Said bread is "toasted" ahead in morning. Meaning, baked? - Sandwiches Near Me - Livermore, California

See all

I got to give them 3 stars not due to good taste and flavor just slow prepping time' and poor value. Pro's the food here is really good; it's fresh taste great and isn't small but isn't a full foot long. Con's They TAKE forever to make your order. I ordered on the online app and it took 40 minutes to make 4 sandwiches. I mean they were a bit busy but what a wait. Also when i got there they took another 10 minutes. So 50 minutes on an order is pretty crazy. The food here is great just there wait time and price for what you are getting is a bit crazy; i get it times are changing just know what you are getting into when you order at Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop. This place will have people waiting inside and out side they get busy. They have a ton of orders. The food is good it's taste it's fresh. It's a good place to go. Just note they they are not fast and you are going to have to wait. I would return just hate how long it takes to get your food here. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Front door mask required to get in - Sandwiches Near Me - Livermore, California

I don't typically write reviews, but I am so disappointed in this location. I love Mr. Pickles, but this location consistently makes my order wrong whether I go in person or order online. My sandwich is ALWAYS missing items. Also, if I go in person, it takes at the very least 5 min for someone to even acknowledge me and take my order even though I can see several employees behind the counter doing nothing while only 1-2 employees are actually working. Such a disappointment and will not be returning to this location. read more

My sandwich had no sauce in the top bread so it was super dry and flavorless! The avocado they put on the sandwich was hard and inedible. The quality has gone down and the price has gone up! read more

My favorite sandwich shop!! Every single time in town this place is a must! The spot has some parking available on the street and a small parking lot on the side with outdoor seating in the patio. Please do yourself a favor and do it simple- get the Mr. Pickles Sandwich on Dutch bread or sourdough, you'll thank me later. No need to substitute anything, the sandwich is perfect just the way it is. Also don't forget your free chocolate chip cookie:) This shop also has a wide variety of chips and drinks to chose from and a deli salad as well! Mr. Pickles is filled with hard working staff that always have a smile on their face and ready to welcome you on in. Love this place!! read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Outside - Sandwiches Near Me - Livermore, California

See all

I placed an order today for the first time. A friend of mine had told me about how much she likes these sandwiches. Since the pandemic began I have not been eating outside of my home that much so I was looking forward to trying something from a restaurant. I placed an order for a Turkey Hot T, which is supposed to have "turkey, pepper jack, baja sauce and cranberry sauce". Well, I received my sandwich without the Baja sauce and the cranberry sauce! So it was just a plain TURKEY sandwich. What a disappointment!!! The Dutch crunch bread was very good, and the sandwich looked promising but without the sauce it was just a plain no frills turkey sandwich. Sad. The 2 other sandwiches I ordered were fine, and had no errors. Another comment is that I was hesitant to order because I read horror stories on Yelp about the sandwiches taking a lot longer to be ready. I want to mention that the app forgot to tell me that the sandwiches were ready to be picked up. So I entered the store 10 min after the originaly scheduled time because I had no idea if they would be ready or not. Thankfully they were ready to be picked up, but it would be nice if the text messages/emails would actually be sent out to customers as mentioned in the confirmation email when placing an order online. read more

Today I ordered two Big Jakes and was completely disappointed upon unwrapping both sandwiches. Both had roast beef on them instead of turkey as advertised. We also had a few modifications to both sandwiches that were listed on the receipt, but not actually carried out on the sandwiches. For example I asked for no pepperoncinis on one of the sandwiches, but still got pepperoncinis on it. Then on the other sandwich, I asked for pepper jack cheese to be subbed in, and it was not. I don't understand how someone could mess up this bad when everything was clear on the receipt. Super disappointed at the incompetence here. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Livermore, California

See all

I don't like leaving bad reviews, so I'm going to give this 4 stars and note my experience. I received a buy one, get 50% off another sandwich promo today via email and proceeded to download the app in order to enter the promo. After entering the promo, the app came back as invalid code. I called the store and the manager said that he wasn't doing the promo. Fine, ok, I get it. I proceeded to use Door Dash to order from the same restaurant anyways in an effort to help local business owners. We ordered 2 Big Jakes (turkey sandwiches), but when we received the sandwiches, there was no turkey on either! Everything was perfect down to the salt and pepper. We go to Mr. Pickles ALL the time and this is the first time this happened so I will not leave a bad star rating. We reached out to Door Dash and they were able to reimburse us. Edit/Update: after posting this, I read some of the other reviews and some are very similar...missing MAIN ingredients! You are not McDonalds; I view Mr Pickles a local, small business. I'm sure it's not the establishment as a whole, (maybe the kids that are hired?) but you are seriously misrepresenting and degrading your brand by slacking on the quality of your service. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - mr pickles promo - Sandwiches Near Me - Livermore, California

3 stars just because I love Mr. Pickles. Customer service was just ehhhh not it today. The guy at the register was nice though. Sandwich wasn't made with love like back home. read more

We ordered an Italian sub sandwich to share and I have to say it was THE best sandwiches I've eaten in a very long time! There was lots of meat and we were completely satisfied and full. We haven't been here in quite a while and checked the reviews before we stopped by. We decided to go ahead and try it even though what I read was disappointing. We couldn't have been happier with our experience! I don't understand why there are so many bad reviews. Thanks Mr Pickles crew for a delicious lunch! read more

Best sandwiches! Should have more than 3.5 starts. Sandwiches are always fresh and so delicious! We are hooked! My fav is the chicken salad sandwich. Highly recommend read more

I usually eat here when I have work in Livermore. The sandwiches are consistently good..

Great sandwich selection! I like the Mr Pickle and any of their turkey Sammies. Love that they have half sandwiches and they give you a cookie with each sandwich. They have a gluten free wrap. read more