I ordered a pizza online, 4 out of 5 toppings in the pizza were missing. When I discovered the error and called the restaurant the lady who answered was VERY RUDE. When I asked to speak to a manager she informed me that she was the owner! Once the pizza order was fixed, the pizza was not very good. read more

Excellent deep-dish pizza -- if you like that sort of thing. I've only gotten take out from here but it is everything that the other reviewers have said...maybe more. The crust isn't sweet, the sauce is very good, and they are generous with the toppings. Definitely worth a stop if you are driving by it at night or at lunch or live nearby. read more

I placed my order online an went to the restaurant to pick it up. I knew something was fishy when the entire place was empty at 12:30pm. I ordered "the award winning" Fettuccine alredo, cheesy garlic bread, and tiramisu. The pasta is just awful, as bland as could be. The alfredo sauce tastes nothing like cheese. I could not finish eating this dish. I filled up on the cheesy garlic bread which was barely decent since it was real tough. The tiramisu is embarrasing, it's almost like a cheesecake. Layer of whip cream over a some kind of creamy filliing over lady finger cookies. The filling tastes sort of like tiramisu but has a waxy texture. The lady fingers are hard and a bit burnt. Even the soda I bought was warm. I havent tried their other choices and I don't plan on it read more

Stopped in here while doing my laundry next door. What a find! I enjoy trying new places and this place was delicious! My wife had spaghetti and I had lasagna, both came with a trip to the salad bar and fresh breadsticks. We enjoyed lunch at a very reasonable price, lower than I would expect for such a great meal. Stop in and enjoy for yourself. read more

Have not been to Nancy's in a while so I decided to go back. To be honest I was a little disappointed especially considering the solid reviews. This is stuffed pizza with two crusts which is different than the deep dish at Lou's and Gino's East. I just felt the pizza was a little bland and the sauce was too sweet and lacked character. The double crust was doughy and thick and I just discarding much of it. Normally the crust is my favorite part. For stuffed crust I liked Eduardo's better but Lou's and Ginos East are much better all around. I guess if you are from out of town and are not accustomed to the other choices Nancy's is fine but I see no reason to go back personally. Maybe I should just go there for pasta instead. In terms of the restaurant and service, pretty low key and dated environment. read more

First of all the guy who took my order on the phone was extremely rude and had an attitude. I ordered a deep dish pizza and Nancy's is usually my fav. It was terrible! It didn't even taste like Nancy's. I will never order here again! read more

This is a charming and very welcoming restaurant. The ambiance here is really good, you can absolutely relax and enjoy the whole place, the vibe inside the place is really great, and their designs and decors are very interesting. Nancy's Pizzeria is exceptional! They are the best pizza place of all time! They have really incredible deep dish pizza, it is so tasty, unique, crispy, thin, cheesy, meaty, and the sauce of it has a good portion. You will absolutely love and you will be amaze how great is the style of their pizza as well as the taste of it. Sensational! They also have other selection of food on their menu, all of it is delicious, and can really make your mouth waters. They have sandwiches, fries, rice meals, desserts, beverages, etc. All of the food on their menu is really worth a try and incredibly delicious. You can also try and order anything you might like on their menu in such an affordable and fair price. They are really great and way cheaper than other pizza spot around the area. You can really save a lot of money here while eating delicious and phenomenal pizza. I really love Nancy's Pizza! Their place never disappoints. The only complain is their counter, customers moving slowly, and the lines are long. You will have to wait for a few minutes before your turn to order. Nancy's Pizza is incredible that is why their place is crowded sometimes. But overall is really good and awesome. Very friendly and welcoming place. I would really love to go back here again soon when I have some free time. Will continue to explore more of their food on the menu. Thank you guys for an awesome service and great experience. You are the best! I am really amazed with your food and service. Thank you! Well done! read more

Four stars is for the pizza only. Zero stars for the owner/manager. Had a local flavor coupon for $30 worth of food. I called in a head of time and ordered 1 medium and a large with 2 toppings. Menu price $35.50 without tax. I figured I'd be out of there for $12 with tax and tip. The owner/manager drops off the bill for $51. I question the prices on the pizza's on the non-itemized bill, pointing out the prices on the menu attached to my takeout bag. He states that those are takeout and delivery prices. He states dine in prices are more money because he has to make up the difference with all the Groupon and such coupons he has out there. I told him he's dishonest as I have never been charged more money to dine in a restaurant. Maybe when you takeout because of the extra time it takes to box everything up. He takes a couple of bucks off. Then I give him my coupon for the $30 off, and he's like I can't take that, I just lowered your bill. I told him to take it off the original price which he did. Bottom line, I paid $36 for my medium and large pizza. Some great deal for my $30 of food for $15. He's a crook and I won't be returning. read more

I saw a Groupon for this place, and since I've been to the Nancy's in Lemont, I thought it would be similar. It's not even close. The stuffed pizza was tasteless and the buffalo wings were really bland. I'd rather drive out to Lemont than go to this place again. read more

I phoned in an order for delivery on Sunday to feed a few friends who came over to watch the football playoffs. The delivery was exactly on time, the multiple items that were ordered were all there in completeness. Sometimes if you've ordered from places that forget the dinner salad or that Garlic bread comes with the pasta, you can really appreciate that comment. The only complaint was that the every separate item, from pizza to lasagna, was delivered so quickly that we had to wait for them to cool off a little before we could dig in. And that's a GOOD problem to have. Bravo Nancy's!! read more

This place is excellent! The pizza is a little different from the standard Chicago chains, but it's delicious nonetheless. Customer service at this location is top shelf. Everyone working there makes you feel like family, and they go above and beyond for their customers. There is exceptional value when comparing their portion sizes to their prices. Would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone, and their pizza is one of the best in Chicago. read more

Thank you to Fred for helping me out last minute on a holiday weekend with a catering order. A few extra people turned into 30 and everything was amazing. Your the best. Everyone loved the lemon chicken and meat lasagna!!!! The kids loved the pizza so all went well. Thank you again! read more

If I could give NO STARS I WOULD. Place has such high prices for such shitty food. Pizza has no marinara and comes with a side of grease FOR A PRICE OF 17.99 OUTRAGEOUS. Workers have no respect and get orders wrong. OWNER IS ALWAYS DRUNK AS WELL. DO NOT EAT HERE read more

You want the best deep dish in the NW Burbs... head on over! I do not particularly like deep dish, but theirs is the absolute best! My husband loved it the first time I dragged him there for it and now we order our deep dish exclusively from them. The atmosphere is really comfortable, it's been there for years, my friends and I used to grab pizza there after movies, when we were in high school. I don't think they've changed their decor since they opened, but there's no need to when the food is so good! Seriously, if you like deep dish, you've got to stop in! read more

First of all, Nancy's does not serve Chicago style deep dish pizza, but rather Chicago style stuffed pizza: invented by Nancy's and also served at places like Giordano's, stuffed pizza is deep dish pizza with an extra thin layer of dough between the cheese and sauce. Stuffed pizza should never be used interchangeably for deep dish pizza, the style of pizza served at Lou Malnati's and Gino's East. Second of all, I like deep dish a lot more than stuffed, and I like Chicago style ultra-thin crust pizza better than deep dish. Because of this, I am giving Nancy's a slightly critical rating of three stars, despite being my favorite stuffed pizza. First you have the crust, an average stuffed pizza crust, crunchy and slightly oily/buttery; not the best but not the worst. Despite this, it still has the unneeded chewy, flavorless second layer. Next you have the toppings, a fairly good sausage with the flavor you'd expect from deep dish/stuffed pizza, but lacking the touch in Lou's or Gino's sausage. Next you have the cheese, the same milky and gooey mozzarella slices that cover all deep dish/stuffed. Lastly, we have the sauce, classic chunky, tomatoey flavor, but with an excessive sweetness. To sum it all up, Nancy's serves up some pretty good pizza, my favorite stuffed, despite my dislike of the style. read more

I'm sorry to say that I had a terrible experience here too. Ordered online and was immediately called to say that my order was going to be more because the app had the wrong price for my items. I was told to check the prices before I ordered next time. WTF check YOUR prices before you put put out an app. Waited an hour before I called to see what was going on with my order turns out their delivery person doesn't show up until 4pm and there were already orders ahead of me. The app says order after 3pm and to wait 45 minutes. So far the issue has been the app but that's not all folks. Decide to pick it up myself after 1 hour and 20 minutes. They tried to rectify the discrepancies by giving me free soda (awww) but by the time we got to our room he food was cold and the toppings were falling off the dough. The mushrooms tasted expired and the ribs were smothered in ketchup. It was really bad food! I paid $40 expecting awesome grub and got mulch. To make matters worse the food hat we did try to eat did not sit well and had a bad night fighting for the restroom. Now I'm from California and the Italian food out there is no doubt different from Illinois Italian but there's difference in flavor and difference is quality. This stuff was BAD by definition and I hope they'd treat out of towners with the he same respect as their regulars that seem to love their food. read more

Yum! Fresh salad bar and awesome deep dish pizza. Sauce was incredible. A hidden gem that my husband and I happened to wander into looking for a nice lunch. read more

You want Italian? Do you like a homey atmosphere? Cosey? Does it feel like you walked into "Little Italy?" Well, then you're at this Nancy's Restaurant! Their food is great, and the pizza is fabulous, especially the x-large thin crust, which really isn't thin, by the way! Just a great pizza that leaves you FULL! If you want deep dish, they have that, too. Their deep dish is layered, and almost like a stuffed pizza. Carry out is quick; delivered is fast also. They have a really ethnic Italian salad bar ( you liked pickled eggplant?? I do! ) that will remind you of your gramma's (Nonna's) house. The only thing that can be frustrating is that parking is sometimes hard to get in this strip mall due to the ethnic grocery store at the other end. Marissa and Fred (the owners) have tried everything for their customers for their parking. Just remember that there is parking behind the restaurant and on the sides. It's worth the trip! Don't forget dessert! read more

How do you screw up pizza? I've never had such a bland, flavorless, incredibly dissatisfying pizza in my life. I will never order from this, or any other related, restaurant with the Nancy's logo on it. Such incredibly crap-tactic pizza. I'm still dumbfounded on how they could screw up such a simple meal. How? Please? How?!? read more

This place is top notch. I've been going here for over 20 years and I have never had a bad experience. The pizza is very good, but I usually go for the Chicken Parmesan Dinner which is out of this world. My wife usually gets the fettuccine alfredo with shrimp and she loves it. I am a huge fan of baked clams and I have to say that I have never tried a baked clam anywhere that is better than Nancy's. If you like baked clams, do yourself a favor and get an order. You'll be glad you did. read more

I ordered a carryout from this restaurant some time ago. A Nancy's Deep Dish Pizza and an appetizer. I probably should not compare myself to the people who sit inside and actually eat, but seeing how I live in the apartments nearby I figured that eating it at home would make little to no difference. First of all the pizza was beyond oily and salty. I don't know if it was the excessive amounts of cheese or the way the crust was made. But eating that "small" pizza made a mess on a desk that makes a child's tantrum look clean. Secondly, the appetizer I bought was much too hard to even bite into. While the insides were quite tasty, the fact that I have to feel my teeth being scrapped against pieces of rocks made my experience quite unpleasant. Finally: This is a decent place to go if you are craving something a little more "Chicago-style", but if you are craving actual pizza or finger food; look elsewhere read more

Best deep dish in Chicago! Very family oriented. Love going here!

I am sad to write this post because we love Nancy's pizza, but I am not sure we will ever order from them again. Since moving to the area, Nancy's has become our Friday night dinner spot. Whenever we order, the person on the phone is always in a hurry to get off the phone and we have to tell him that we will be paying with a credit card. The guy is always annoyed that he has to process the card. One time on the phone, my husband called him on his curt tone and the guy apologized. Then, last week, the guy on the phone forgot to put my husband on hold and this is what he heard, "F*****g guy again with the F*****g credit card! Every time!" If is it so hard to process a credit card, then don't offer that as a form of payment. I'm disappointed in the way that we were treated and don't want to support a business like this. read more

Went there for dinner on Saturday night. Had the stuffed pizza which was awesome. It was the best pizza I had in a long time and the crust was really great and the sauce was really good too. People in there were really nice and friendly and service was good too. Would definitely be going back there again to try the other types of pizza. They also have nightly specials and lunch specials too. They are well known for the stuffed pizza but every type of pizza I saw being served thin and pan looked good also. read more

Oh my GOODNESS. I just ordered from here for the first time (delivery) and the food was amazing. We didn't even get pizza; I ordered Penne Arrabbiata and it may have been the most scrumptious pasta dish I've ever had, with the the perfect amount of spiciness. My boyfriend ordered the Chicken Parmigiana and it was delicious. Very good service as well. I will definitely tell basically everyone I know about this place!! read more

This was my first time here. I had the linguine & white clam sauce which was excellent! I thought it might be a cream sauce but that didn't really matter much to me. I also opted for the salad bar which I also enjoyed very much. I loved that the broccoli was blanched. Very sweet & tasty. I was surprised that they had as good of a salad bar as they did. I guess I didn't have high expectations. I did find that some of the veggies (celery, carrots & cucumbers) were cut in such large pieces. They would've been excellent for dipping. 4" long celery stalks. 1/4"-1/2" thickness on carrots & cucumbers-all just a little large for my taste. We did order the tiramisu....fail. In every sense of the word. It tasted like it came from the frozen food section of Aldi's. In fact, I think my bf did get a bite that was still on the crisp side. For this, I give it 3 stars. I'll definitely go back. Don't get me wrong! As a matter of fact, I believe for now, they have a special on Tues, Thurs & Sun - half price on their pasta dishes. Maybe other entrees. I'm not sure. I'd definitely have the linguine & clam sauce again. Actually, I will since I have leftovers! read more

We dined in and the place is small and not fancy. We tried the pizza and a seafood linguine with white sauce. We took the special Pizza and added whole basil leafs. It was very good we will be returning soon. read more

Best stuffed pizza in the world. The restaurant is cozy, the demographic is somewhat elderly and the wait staff is lax but you will not go wrong with the food. I really like their salad (which comes with pizza bread, no cheese and garlic bread) They have other great items like the Godfather Sandwhich. read more

I've lived in Chicago my entire life & just recently moved to the la area. Out of all the pizza places I've ever tried, this is by far the best pizza I've ever eaten. Both the regular pizzas & especially the deep dish pizzas are AMAZING. Go here (: read more

Nancys is my new favorite place for deep dish pizza! It's such a hidden gem. Omg they put Ricotta cheese on their pizza it was heaven an the ingredients are so fresh and authentic. And it doesn't leave a feeling like you've slipped into a food coma afterwards either lol I love this place! I've tried their fettuccine Alfredo and it's delicious to! This is my family's new go to place for pizza! read more

This place is AMAZING!!! A must stop for anyone in the area wanting real Italian Chicago pizza and pasta. The food was delicious, service was perfect and price was more than reasonable. We will eat here again every chance we get. read more

Great deep dish Chicago style pizza. Don't let the strip shipping center location deter you

I've lived so close to this place for months and now I'm kicking myself for not coming here sooner! Monday 1/2 price any pizza and that was some serious stuff, haven't had good pizza like that since I lived on the south side. I normally don't eat mozzarella sticks, but it was absolutely amazing and piping hot fresh. Definitely going back! read more

Now that's a pizza pie in which what is a pizza pie! I always come in, and have the extra large 14 inch stuffed pizza with back olives. Really quaint, and cozy Ma, and Pa atmosphere. I always love the fact that when I come in Lucy, and Fred always have the oldies playing on their sound system in the restaurant also. Extremely recomended! read more

Ordered a stuffed pizza to go and was pleasantly surprised when I picked it up to find this cute little hole in the wall restaurant! Wish we would have dined in. You can tell it's a family run place or at least it seems like it. Got home and Pizza was phenomenal. Ordered the pepperoni and Italian sausage and wouldn't change a thing. Glad we had an errand to run that night that was a bit of of our way and checked out a new place! read more

The pizza here especially the deep dish is amazing. The sauce is very delicious. The staff is very accomodating. Since I started coming here I have never had a bad experience. read more

The Pizza here is excellent not that fast food junk. Their sausage is so unique tasting and not overly greasy and salty like others. Foccacia bread is great too. Very friendly owner who runs 50% of coupons often and 50% off on Mondays. Next to countryside pub down the road from us, this is next best pizza in town! read more

We visited from out of town and this was my first experience with deep dish or stuffed pizza. I thought it was very good and it was half off Monday which was an added bonus!! The sauce is very good, just like my grandma used to make!! read more

I've lived in Chicago for 35 years and this is by far the best thin crust pizza out there! The make it the way it should be! The salad bar is also always fresh. read more

It's such a shame that I have to give them one star. My sandwich was very good. However, the delivery driver was very very rude. I used grub hub and instructed for the driver to call me when they got here. Currently in my building we aren't allowed to let deliveries in. We have to meet them at the front. After informing me that he had other orders after I told him I was meeting him. He insisted on me hurrying up and then shoved my food at me. Good food... Terrible service. Will not be ordering from here again. read more