Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    New York New York Pizza

    4.7 (3 reviews)
    Open 10:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Updated 3 months ago

    New York New York Pizza Photos

    NEW YORK NEW YORK PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - New York New York Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Nate T.
    163
    504
    1645

    3 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    26 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 10,028 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Frankie’s Italian Deli

    Frankie’s Italian Deli

    4.1(326 reviews)
    3.5 mi
    $$

    worth the wait! amazing - i had a single chicken ceasar cutlet and we did the 2 slices and a drink…read moreand pasta with meatballs for the kiddos. i would definitely go here again next time we are in town. i was expecting a quiet counter deli but it was slammed and now i know why! with so many dessert options it was hard to choose but our daughter had a mango ice cream with toppings and our son had the tampa mix up. seating can be crowded you may have to wait for an indoor table. if i lived nearby i would do takeout but we ended up getting a seat before our food was ready.

    Generally, I was disappointed. In this case, less would be more…read more Reasonably busy for a weekday lunch time. Interior seating seems limited for how busy they there. I was there with my mom and my five month old daughter in a stroller, which wasn't easy. This was my first time here and the process of ordering and then waiting for your order to be called was stressful. I checked the menu online before going and there was no mention of the slice specials which I couldn't see easily from the line. I also couldn't see the slice bar or flavors available while in line so that wasn't helpful. The fountain for drinks is behind the counter so you can't get yourself a refill. Instead, you have to go through the crowd again to ask an associate to do it for you. Associates were helpful with my questions. No one was wiping tables down between customers. I ordered the Yo Adrian, Bianca slice, cannoli and lobster tail. The Yo Adrian was okay. Too much soft bread, not enough cheese, good amount of onions and some of the meat was chunks rather than shaved. The Bianca slice was primarily burnt on the bottom and didn't seem fresh which is sad considering we were there before noon. The cannoli was good. The lobster roll pastry was great; likely because it was fresh. The ice cream is in boxes, which have had the top cut off and the cardboard was wet and peeling in one of the boxes I saw while waiting in line. I think skipping the ice cream seems like a safe choice. I won't be rushing back but will return at some point to try a breakfast sandwich on a NY bagel and order a whole pie to try so it's fresh.

    Photos
    Frankie’s Italian Deli - 3 foot chicken cutlet hero

    3 foot chicken cutlet hero

    Frankie’s Italian Deli - Pistachio ice cream

    Pistachio ice cream

    Frankie’s Italian Deli - The exterior of the building

    See all

    The exterior of the building

    Box Of Cubans - Black Bean Cuban Bowl

    Box Of Cubans

    4.8(421 reviews)
    0.8 mi
    $$

    Stopped in for lunch. It has been a while since I've eaten here because I don't eat pork or beef,…read morebut my SO wanted a Cuban so I figured I'd get a turkey sandwich. Well to my surprise they have added bowls to the menu so I got a chicken bowl and MAN!!!! It's delicious! My SO got a Cuban and he said it was really good.

    Alright y'all, here we go with the official review for Box of Cubans - 10451 Gibsonton Dr…read more First things first -- the customer service? Absolutely loved it The guy at the front was on point the whole time. Even coming in right after the lunch rush, he made sure everything stayed clean and organized while still taking care of customers. That kind of attention to detail does not go unnoticed They were out of the sweet teas (I was hurt a little bit ), but overall the experience was still really good. Now let's get into the food because you already know that's what we're here for The chicken empanadas? Delicious. No complaints. The Cuban sandwich? It was good... but I'm gonna keep it real like I always do. The meat was flavorful, but it could've been more evenly distributed, and it didn't have that crispy bread texture I look for. Overall, it just didn't hit that top-tier level for me. So for this location: 8/10 Still a solid experience, still worth the visit -- but as of right now, the Wesley Chapel location is still holding that 10/10 crown And you already know I'm not done... Valrico, I'm coming next. That's Just How Life Goes... and of course, Just How Food Goes

    Photos
    Box Of Cubans
    Box Of Cubans - Empanada Beef & Cheese

    Empanada Beef & Cheese

    Box Of Cubans - Banana/Nutella Empanada

    See all

    Banana/Nutella Empanada

    Full Tilt Sandwiches

    Full Tilt Sandwiches

    5.0(10 reviews)
    2.8 mi

    Went there today and got s OG philly cheesesteak and was surprised that my meal included free…read morefries (thanks free fry friday!). The cheesesteak had a lot of meat, seasoned well, and the fries were hot and good! Full Tilt is food truck by the gas station, so bring some outdoor chairs and a small table and you can bring in a nice ambience or go across the street to the playground and eat there. The guy who cooked the food was really nice and i will say, coming from the Northeast , the hoagie half was very good. Drunkin Noodle: get some fruit juices up in there and you geechie but yeah these jawns best in Tampa urreaa

    Didn't think I'd be doing a YELP! review on a food truck, but yes…read more Wife were out a plant and outdoor festival with music and vendors. We were there to see what kind of plants were for purchase, not getting a great sandwich. While walking the rows of booths we were getting hungry, I did see somewhere they were selling Philly cheese steaks, I dismissed it like really a Philly from a food truck and calling it a Philly also. But as I was walking the isles I caught a view of one of those cheese steaks and wow...I could see it was prepared with a proper Amoroso roll too. Okay, I got to check this joint out and glad we did. We ordered a large to split with fries. Perhaps one of the best in the area. Roll was fresh and steak done just right with cheese and onions. I will tell you this, if your ever at an event and see this truck, make it a point to stop and try it out. If you never had a cheese steak from Philly, this will be as close as your gonna get. Peace.

    Photos
    Full Tilt Sandwiches - Special request private catering for Eagles Fans at RJS

    Special request private catering for Eagles Fans at RJS

    Full Tilt Sandwiches
    Full Tilt Sandwiches - Food truck order window...

    See all

    Food truck order window...

    New York New York Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...