Great service and pizza .The staff was great and attentive. Will definitely come again!! read more

New York Pizza & Plus - $ 7.99 pizza plus drink also Great staff - Pizza Near Me - Sacramento, California

See all

So this is the best cheap pizza in Natomas. A large specialty pizza is $23.99 and a XL is $3 more or $26.99 that is crazy affordable. Although my fav mainstream pizza is Mountain Mikes BBQ pie New York Pizza & Plus is a great change of pace. We had the CA Artichoke and Supreme Hawaiian yesterday and both pies were delicious. If your hosting a get together and need some pizza this is the place to go. read more

See all

A small pizza shop. Great prices for their pizzas. Fresh and delicious. If they're busy you'll have to wait a bit since there are usually 1-2 staff working. If you pay with card there's an additional charge. Plaza has plenty of parking. Staff are friendly. read more

New York Pizza & Plus - New York Combo (XL) - Pizza Near Me - Sacramento, California

The Pizza is tastes good...if you can get the staff to understand what you are ordering. There seems to be a language barrier as none of the staff can actually read the menu. I pointed to the picture of the CA Artichoke pizza but they still couldn't understand what I was choosing. Failed on the request for extra cheese and also forgot the artichokes. read more

Who knew this would become a regular quick dinner spot... I mean we should have known. It's close to home, fairly priced, quick, and a decent meal. It is a little hole in the wall and it's not gourmet, but it's great for what it is. They offer pizzas, salads, calzones, appetizers and even gyros. Our regular order is a calzone, antipasto salad and potato skins. It's been consistently good, but you do want to make sure you had salad dressing- they've forgotten a few times. There are a few seats inside but it's mainly a take-out spot. The team there is usually friendly and makes small talk, but they're nice and get everything out quickly. read more

We placed a phone order, and pick-up was fast. We order half pepperoni and cheese. I ate the cheese side, it was not your average cheese pizza! It was sooo delicious. I'm not from this area, but this pizza is top notch. I definitely recommend. read more

New York Pizza & Plus - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sacramento, California

Awesome service. Good crust and sauce. The sausage is really good. Very clean inside.

I stopped by to grab lunch and really wanted to try the new Cheesy Fries, but they ran out of fries. Wanted the BBQ Buffalo Wings, but they ran out of those as well. I settled on the lunch special, a three topping pizza, and drink, and paid additional money for a side of buffalo wings. The pizza was good because the toppings were fresh. The wings I received were all flats and a bit scrawny. The service was good and the location was easily accessible and clean. My pics would not attach, but the appearance is a plus. read more

A very small hole in the wall pizza shop, but the flavor is amazing!! Prices are super cheap but the food is excellent quality. The employees are fast and friendly. If you have to wait it's because there are soo many orders because it is that good. Other than that they are super speedy without sacrificing the quality of the food. read more

New York Pizza & Plus - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Sacramento, California

I came in here a few weeks back to give it a shot as it was mediocre in the past. I was in the area getting bogo with coupon boba (teen wanted) at Rare Tea down a few doors. Impromptu. Went in. Nice lady owner, Yupa (?) Helped me and we chatted about past teaching jobs we both did before besides the food and menu. I ordered and waited about 30 minutes and had a lot of time to chat between some phone orders and a few orders inside. She also hooked me up with a free small soda which was appreciated. You guys gotta support this 20 year plus family business! They will take good care of you for sure! I got the sampler $8.99. Out of potato skins. Subbed with more moz sticks. 3 wings and mozz sticks. Frozen previously so skip next time. I also got 3 sandwiches. She said I would like them and I DID! $3.99 for a 3 topping sando was a FIRE value. Ordered 3 sandos. Teen picked her toppings by text (lol), teen picked topps for mom and I got one for myself. I got lamb, linguica and sausage. Super tasty! My go-to wallet saver! They also have a $6 personal pizza and a soda lunch special. I will be back to retry a pizza, maybe a gyro and def a bunch of sandos! I can't believe I have slept on the sandos for over a decade. Rediscovered like an old flame. read more

See all

Great pizza and their appetizers are awesome, especially the potatoes! Will be going back, thanks.

Very good pizza, forgot to take a pic cause I was starving, lol. They have a lunch special but it ends at 2pm for $6.99 for a small pizza and a soda. Y'all it's a small not a tiny personal pizza!!! I ate the whole thing, it was sooooo good!!! I'm so full but happy and satisfied!!! read more

I come here every week and get a lunch special combination pizza the ladies are always super nice and the pizza is delicious

It was okay. We used to frequent this place on a regular. This place is currently operating on a unsustainable formula. Price moving with inflation, yet customer service and quality has diminished throughout the years. read more

New York Pizza & Plus - Pizza Near Me - Sacramento, California

I've been to this place a few times, and I don't know how I haven't left a review for them. Every time I have ordered pizza, they have not disappointed. Each time we spend in there, the restaurant is clean. We always order the Boss pizza with white sauce. This is our favorite kind of pizza from this place. The potato skins are good too. I would recommend trying all of their appetizers by trying the sampler. Whenever we call, the staff are always nice. Hidden gem within the South Natomas area. read more

New York Pizza & Plus - Potato Skins - Pizza Near Me - Sacramento, California

See all

I've never had a bad experience with this place. Most of the staff are wonderful. i love crust and it's always yummy!

This place is literally home in the wall but serves great pizza and the people at the counter are great! They also offer great pizza deals and is our favorite pizza place. The toppings are fresh and never had a single disappointing experience. I would highly recommend this place and if you ever go here, give their artichoke chicken pizza a try! read more

Emma at front counter is rude, rushed me to order hung up on me she's always rude when we call to order and yet my whole staff spends their lunch here food is good. Customer service is trash. read more

New York Pizza & Plus - Pizza Near Me - Sacramento, California

Food was amazing, and customers were great. Very friendly staff! Honestly some of the best pizza I've had

Used to love their pizza but it gradually went down hill and I completely stopped going there for a few years. Decided to give them a second chance recently and it was as disappointing as it was when I decided to stop eating there years ago. The pizza was not good. Globs of cheese which were hard to swallow from the density and lack of meltyness and nothing even seemed to be baked long enough. Had to microwave it just to feel more "cooked". Unfortunately, I would not recommend. read more

Good pizza, great pricing but the young lady working here is very rude. I won't count this place out just yet, but the next encounter I will be done. read more

My friends and I love this pizza place!! We stumbled on it on accident and ever since has always gotten pizza here! I'd like to mention that we are not big pizza fans but after the first time we went back for seconds! The pizza here are definitely worth a try! Not to mention you're supporting a local business! read more

New York Pizza & Plus - Pizza Near Me - Sacramento, California

See all

We've ordered a few personal pizzas on three different take out occasions and we think they taste great. Their crust has those airy bubbles that are perfectly chewy and crispy. The sauce and cheese are just the right balance. And absolutely no problems with staff and service. Every time my husband has gone, they have been courteous and chatty. We will be trying the other pizzas combos on larger sizes soon and update later. Support local Natomas businesses! read more

pleasantly surprised...veggie pizza was very good but pepperoni was a little overcooked and on the greasy side

Burnt my food!! $25 for 2 calzones, mostly bread!! I can't ... Very dissatisfying!!!! Calling for a refund ASAP read more

New York Pizza & Plus - Literally BURNT calzones $25 for this?! Not worth it at all! - Pizza Near Me - Sacramento, California

See all

For a family business this place was HORRIBLE ! I just personally went into New York's Pizza this evening to try it out. One thing I can say they have the front end of their business with signs letting you know to wear a mask but unfortunately the kitchen staff and cooks weren't wearing mask or even gloves. I just happened to want to try a new restaurant but this was mind blowing that we're in the middle of a pandemic and food workers who are fortunate to stay open during this time while others have lost their lives and they're taking their lives and others for granted. I also asked for napkins and they said they have none at all which is confusing because pizza is greasy so why not have napkins for your customers? If you're going to stay open in the middle of a pandemic AT LEAST wear masks. Most definitely have to report this restaurant because you're going to keep the virus going with your actions! WEAR YOUR MASK! I also paid cash for my food and asked for a receipt and they said I'm not able to receive it. It's only for debit cards which I know isn't true. So now I have no receipt so they must be pocketing the cash. Overall this place is bullshit and I would never go back. read more

I love love love love love love love the pizza here I always get a personal size pizza for myself I've brought many friends here and Family from Mexico everyone loves it if you're in the south Natomas area or Midtown area I promise you this place is great the owners are very sweet it's family owned. read more

Good pizzas and chicken wings. Better than mountain mikes or round table. Crew are really nice and professional.

I ordered the special (small pizza and a drink). Customer service was nice and quick. The pizza is really good as well, the crust is what makes it. We have been there a few times since and is my go to lunch spot when I'm at work. The inside isn't too big but it's simple and clean. read more

If you live in the Natomas area, you must try this pizza. Best local pizza i've ever had, and those breadsticks are delicious! Customer service is amazing and I feel at home in the environment. read more

Customer service is always great! Prices are very competitive and good pizza and wings.

great service, great food great atmospher. I come here after school everyday and I'm always happy to get my pizza quick And hot!

Save your money. Wish I would have spent a little more and had gone somewhere else for better quality. This place has gone downhill and has stayed there. The pizza was underbaked, and so were the mozzarella sticks; It was like eating a slightly warmed up string cheese with breading on the outside. No sauce was provided for an entire sampler. You will also not be asked which soda you would like that comes included with your purchase so unless YOU remember to request it, then you will not get your 2 liter. Disappointed but will no longer waste my money here in the future. read more

The only thing I can say is that their customer service seems to suck because I tried calling twice in a row and got nowhere with them. Guy answers, immediately tells me he needs to put me in hold, so ok, and I wait on hold for 10 minutes, no joke, then the call disconnects. So I'm irritated but I call back and again the guy answers and doesn't even give me a chance to ask my one simple question,..." Do you deliver?" That's all I wanted to know. Puts me on hold again. This was all on a Sunday night, so I can't imagine they were so busy on a Sunday night at 9:00 PM that they had to put me on hold for so long then just disconnect the call. Well, he lost them a customer and I'll get my pizza better places, I'm sure. read more

FYI, they charge $3.99 for delivery. Even if you place an order of nearly $70 and live less than a mile away. But they don't tell you that. Also, they may change your order without telling you. They xhanged mine and overcharged me by $11.58. Not ordering from here again. Too bad, it's so close to me. I'll update this if I get a response or refund. read more

Fire pizza spot. High quality ingredients good prices and great service. Will definitely be coming back!!! read more

New York Pizza & Plus - XL Pizza half artichoke fiesta with white sauce the other half is the meat lovers with extra chicken added - Pizza Near Me - Sacramento, California

Hey Hey Hey! Don't know what to get for lunch? Come pick up their lunch special, a drink and a slice of pizza for $5! I had their pepperoni pizza and it was scrumptiously delicious! They do have a seating area inside or you can pick up and take it to go. There's ample parking every time too. Enjoy! read more

New York Pizza & Plus - Personal Pepperoni Pizza Deal w/Drink! $5 - Pizza Near Me - Sacramento, California

Good service from nice kids, lots of diced tomatoes, decent mushrooms. But absolutely nothing about the pizza remotely resembles ne York-style pizza. Crust is medium thickness and not thin. Sausage and pepperoni are bland. Cheese in massive quantity but no sauce. Good value for a family w lots of kids. read more

I have to say I'm very impressed by this pizza restaurant. I never thought about going here before because it wasn't a brand-name I've heard of i'm definitely glad I gave you guys a try. The prices are fantastic and the quality of the food is really good.... I am blown away by the value!!!!!!!!! From now on you guys are going to be my go to pizza restaurant for lunch and when I need it delivered....... Thank you for everything you guys do read more

If I could give ZERO stars I would. You would not believe the experience I had here... please do not let the pictures of how good the pizzas look fool you, because they are in fact made unsanitary. Let me start by saying when I first walked in with my family, it was horrible customer service off the bat. Jenny was whispering intentionally so I could not hear what she was saying while taking my order... fine whatever, but then I watched her go straight to making my pizzas with out washing her hands... the store phone starts ringing she touches the phone takes another order and goes back to making the pizzas with out washing hands... repeatedly. I ask her do they have to wear gloves she said no it's not required, so I then asked her if she can wash her hands and she tells me no she doesn't need to because when she puts the pizza in the oven it'll kill all the bacteria... WOW. I then tell her that that isn't okay and she needs to wash her hands before touching the food & that , that is absolutely disgusting. She says "fine I'll just wash them" . That alone was enough for me to leave but no I stayed and waited for my food, I get my food and it's not even the right order. I told her it was suppose to have 2 other toppings she said well when I confirmed the order you didn't answer me... which she lied. I asked her what the Hawaiian supreme had on it she replied and I asked her could she add pepperoni and sausage she said yes and I told her I would take that. This whole experience was pitiful. She had an attitude the whole time tossed my refund to me disrespectfully, and when I asked to talk to a manager she was just acting like a snobby little girl not getting her way. I will not be back, and definitely will never spend my hard earned money here. read more