This place is an absolute treasure. They have 4 individual slices that may be the best in town. 1. Zucchini and speck 2. Mushroom mozzarella 3. Grandma's 4. Square The first two are totally unique creations. Those two slices are worth the trip alone. The zucchinis are sliced so thin and they taste roasted. Under the zucchini are bits of speck. The speck is used so delicately in the balance of the flavors. It's incredible. The mushroom is just as good. Two kinds of mushroom and a mozzarella that tastes gooey and just unbelievable. The grandma's is thicker than most grandma's slices. The thickness absorbs the tomatoes well. It's not oily and just a well balanced grandmas slice with top notch ingredients. Have I mentioned that this is a brick oven pizzaria? Yeah a brick oven place that does slices. The cook is a big goofy guy that speaks Sicilian. Complete old world artisan approach. Balance and restraint in all the flavors and textures. Cheers to that guy. read more

First if all, I haven't actually been inside. But I have had delivery from them three times! Each time has been two gluten-free pies. My family's favourite gluten-free delivery pizzas in Brooklyn ever. Second, aside from the g-free pies being yummy, the service is also great. We usually get our order quickly and the pizzas are fresh and yummy. Also, the last time we ordered, we forgot whether we were supposed to order large or personal size and we order large. They called us immediately (because we'd ordered through seamless) to tell us that the gluten-free pies only come in personal size (though to be honest, the personal size gluten-free pies are actually more like mediums). Anyway, the personal size gluten free pizzas are half the price of the regular large pizzas. So we were over-charging ourselves by ordering wrong. We were grateful for them picking up on that and redoing our order so we payed the appropriate price. So, we'll be ordering those gluten-free pizza pies again and again. And I do look forward to checking the actual place out eventually. ;) read more

Veeeery good Gluten Free pizza!!! Great crust, nice toppings (I'm vegetarian therefore can only vouch for such toppings). One pizza can feed 2 people. Custom made. Waiting time around 15-20min. read more

Great pizza! Especially the eggplant with tomato and fresh mozzarella. Potato croquettes are excellent. read more

Nonno's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I thought I'd order at this spot to change up from my usual pizza place. I Was unfortunately disappointed with my delivery order. I ordered a grandma pie and a large salad with grilled chicken. The pizza arrived at room temperature as if it were sitting out for a while before it was delivered. Also, it was a seemingly small pie for what we paid for (especially since I know that for a dollar more I can get a larger grandma pie at the other pizzeria). It didn't taste exceptional either. I was overall kind of bummed. Oh, and I did not receive the dressing that I requested for my salad. Learned my lesson, sticking with my usual pizza spot. read more

What's with all of the 5 star reviews? Owners/friends/relatives? When I opened the pizza box I thought "that looks like a Papa John's pizza" and my 12 year old said "did that come from Chuck E Cheese?". Pizza was awful. I ordered a rice ball nod they cut it in half before they heated it. Totally dried out. Only good thing was the wings. Won't be going back there again. Too many really good places to choose from. What a waste of money. read more

I came across Nonno's after a night out in Bay Ridge. My first time I just had a regular slice. It was great!!! I came back the following week for lunch. The chicken roll was fantastic, as well as the vodka slice. The decor inside is not your typical pizzeria. You can tell the owners put a lot of time and money into renovating the space. Last time I was there I took a grandma pie to go. The curbside service is great. You can enjoy a spumoni from L&B (yea, that L&B) while you wait. Nonno's is a great addition to the neighborhood. Can't wait to grab another slice!!! read more

Did I order from the same place as everyone else? The crust had this weird crumby stuff on it. The cheese was meh, and the sauce was ick. This pizza is from somewhere upstate or in Virginia. Maybe the other stuff is okay, but they really let me down on this pizza. I'd rate it one star, but the service was good. read more

I wanted to like this place because it's very close. They took 45 minutes to deliver a medium pie with 1 minutes away from the store. The guy who pick up the phone has worst attitude I have ever heard. Finally, the delivery guy had high negotiate ability and zero apology for being delayed. ZERO STAR! read more

Favorite pizza in the neighborhood. Also really good wings, our favorite Friday night takeout spot.

Went for a neighborhood walk for a quick bite and the guy at the counter was nice. Ordered a slice , I had a feeling it was going to be tasty. It smelled amazing, the crust is thin and a perfect amount of cheese. I will definitely be ordering my Italian fix from them! read more

Really wanted to like this place. Surprisingly, the pizza in Bay Ridge is mediocre, Nonno's included. Okay, it's 'brick oven' which is a regular oven with a stone base. It's not a coal fired. Nothing special here. My concern is sanitation. I'm not a neat freak but I've seen enough to give me concerns. The trash bins aren't food preparation surfaces. I'm concerned that the Sicilian pie dough is stacked on the garbage bins and not on clean trays. This is symbolic of the cleanliness of this place. read more

Nonno's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delicious pizza, rice balls, etc. Friendly guys. Pizza's not too greasy like some competitors on 3rd ave. Also, this is a comfortable place to sit in to eat. read more

My husband and I have ordered from Nonno's for years. At least 2-3 times a month. The pizza has always been very good and we've always been happy with whatever we've gotten. But last night we ordered a grandma pizza For my husband and I and another couple who was visiting us.We were really starving and anxious to get to it . We each took two pieces and sat down to eat. I took one bite and it was too spicy for me to eat. I saw one of our friends put a napkin up to his mouth and I could tell he was spitting out the pizza. His wife then apologized and said "I don't blame him this is inedible". My husband loves spicy foods and managed to eat one and a half pieces of pizza but agreed that it was overly spiced. We wound up throwing the rest of the pizza in the garbage because after one and a half slices even my husband said it was too spicy. Obviously I am not sure what happened but somebody went crazy with the red pepper and made this a completely inedible pizza. We've always liked Nonno's pizza but this is giving us a reason to start looking at other pizza places in Bay Ridge. read more

There are dozens of Brick Oven pizza shops in Bay Ridge. What makes this little Nonno's Pizza store outstanding is its diversified menu of Italian dishes done for perfection. Reasonably priced, with great delivery speed, Nonno's Pizza compares with some of the better Italian restaurants in the Bay Ridge area. My only criticism - no option for whole wheat pastas or pizza crust. They do offer Gluten Free pizzas. That would make Nonno's Pizza absolutely perfect. We order from them nearly every day! read more

Bf picked up a few slices today, grandma and zucchini w bacon. I have to say it's extremely creative and I was excited to try it but it really didn't meet my expectations. For starters the bacon wasn't cooked crispy. It was placed underneath the slices of zucchini and I'm pretty sure it was placed on raw, which seems odd to me. It should be placed above just to cook thoroughly and get a nice crisp to it. Flavors were on point but I couldn't eat the slice with the way the bacon was cooked. Grandma was pretty good, I enjoyed it. Unfortunately there were garlic knots and he asked for marina sauce and the kid gave him what must be hot sauce for buffalo wings. I died. read more

Still really like the pizza and meatballs though it wouldnt kill them to throw an extra meatball on a meatball hero. The meatballs are not big and the last hero we had there was 2 meatballs (each cut in half) on the whole sandwich. The pasta seems hit or miss. Penne vodka so dry the sauce was just caked on there...terrible. The ziti with meat sauce also dry. Mozz stix are frozen which is disappointing. Fettuccini a month or so again seemed to be fresh pasta but most recently is definitely dry box kind. Hope they don't start tweaking too much or they will be like any other pizza joint in the area. It seems each time we eat here lately there is another disappointment. Not a good sign read more

Awesome food. Not only is their slice great, but their creative pizzas, rolls and knots are top notch. I had a talk with their owner Danny. Good guy. He's committed to running a good restaurant. read more

Great pizza. Crunchy, sweet sauce not overwhelming, amazing cheese. Will be returning read more

Not bad, another typical neighborhood pizzeria albeit with a nicer layout/atmosphere. Food is ok, nothing amazing, (i think the previous pizzeria there tasted better). Service was inconsistent, good one time and below average the other. read more

Wonderful food! Everything I've had here has been great. Highly recommend potato soup.

Eh. I did take out, my food arrived cold and soggy. The garlic knots weren't good. My chicken parm sandwich was cold and super soggy. Sadly disappointed and would never order from here again. read more

I came here for a regular slice at first it was really good but I wasn't that hungry. A month later my crew and I stooped for lunch because we had a job in Bayridge, some of us ordered pasta and some ordered heroes and man every body was happy and satisfied and it became my only stop for a pizzeria in Bay Ridg. Thank you so much. read more

Nonno's pizza is by far my favorite pizza spot, their food and pies are very price efficient and the best pizza i've had. for years now we have been ordering from them i see no bother in trying any new places because no spot does it like them. the people who work there are cool and make great food i strongly recommend read more

My daughter lived at Fort Hamilton for 3 years so my wife & I would travel to see her & the grand kids a few times a year. My daughter loves to eat out & she said Nonno's is the best so we tried it & loved it. Every time after that when we would go to visit them we always got pizza from Nonno's. I have had pizza from all around the world to include Italy & most of USA & they have one of the best pizza I have every had. If if ever go back to that part of NY I will always stop in for a pizza. read more

O.k. I have been condemned to eat gluten free pizza and they offer it. So dying for at least the suggestion of my favorite vice ordered it. Crust of course didn't even come near any edible but come on guys the toppings? Jeez the cheese looked like glaze in a hurry and we asked for sausage that looked like the stuff you shake on salads instead of bacon. Save your money- suffer the loss or better yet lick some sauce and mozzarella off your hand! read more

I honestly can't understand how they have a business. The pizza is dry and basically tasteless. Kind of soft crust, not good with a thinner pizza. Not going back. read more

My other favorite pizza place in Bay Ridge. Great regular, margarita and grandma slices. read more

Nonno's Pizza - Grandma slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

My absolute favorite Brooklyn pizzeria! The employees are always pleasant and the pizza is THE BEST!

Have you tried their Vodka slices? It's the best tasting pizza I've ever had, one of my favorite things on this planet. I miss you Nonno's Vodka slices, wish they had them in Southern California. I actually had two slices every week until I moved away. read more

My favorite spot in bay ridge. Sometimes I order 2 or 3 times a week. Pizza is good. Timing is prefect. Def deserve more than 5 stars.

Consistently good and prompt delivery. I like that you can order through apps and websites. Pizza isn't expensive either. The crust is definitely different...semolina? Lose 1 star because one time I was there eating and the conversations the staff were having were not what I call appropriate plus their language. Be mindful of the people sitting there even if I was the only one there. read more

Two weeks since I ordered my first lunch from Nonno's and I don't think I will grocery shop or cook again. Great food. I think I've ordered at lease 5 times and tried 17 items. This is the kind of food you buy, put into a pot and throw out the take out containers...no lie. Everything is made to perfection. Little different than the usual pizzeria fare...a better difference. Where you would normally get a calzone with a pound of cheese in it. They make theirs delicately with thin layers of ingredients giving it a nice balanced layer of flavors and much easier to eat. So their spinach, ricotta and mozzarella calzone had a thin layer of each and was about a half inch thick. In every bite you get a little of every ingredient. Ziti with meat sauce was made with lean meat and was definitely prepared with the holy trinity of Italian cooking - carrots, onions and celery. Mandarin salad with arugula, goat cheese and mandarins was a perfect combination of ingredients topped with evoo and balsamic. Peppers and onions are caramelized and added to thinly slice sausage for the sausage rolls. The broccoli, garlic and pasta was delicious and the broccoli was chopped small so you get a bit with every bite. Tomato and mozzarella salad needed a little change for me...I opted for no vinegar and an addition of oregano and basil. The tomatoes in this salad were nice and ripe and the cherry tomatoes in another salad were also red and seemed naturally ripened. I don't usually get meatballs, but to me it's a good test of the basics to see if a place is good. I ordered them and the meat was tender, not over worked. There were fresh herbs and the sauce was pretty good too. Spoke to the owner last night and he said his chef, yes, he said chef, is from Milan. A pizzeria with a chef..huh? Good quality ingredients...lean meats, fresh spinach and vegetables, good oil, great bread (I'm trying to guess who bakes it from my knowledge of Brooklyn bread. I'd guess Royal Crown, Cammareri's or Il Fornaretto), fresh garlic, fresh herbs, the arugula looked like they grew it...it was baby arugula, and the basil as well...nice and fresh and firm. And the person doing their chopping has excellent knife skills. Finely chopped fresh herbs, I could see them in everything. Take a look at the photos... and no I am not related or know them personally. They are just really good. One more thing they have Italian Ices from L & B, yes Spumoni Gardens!! even the cremolata!! read more

This place was a disappointment. The ordered was delivered late. We ordered a panini, and received a cold sandwich on a hamburger bun. Their tomato sauce is bland. The manicotti tastes like it was previously frozen. Not authentic Italian at all. read more

Nonno's Pizza - A "panini" - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place is honestly the best pizzaria in the bay ridge area pizzas great and they have the greatest kitchen food would recommend this place to everyone i know nonnos is the hotspot plus the guy tony is a phenominal person!!!!Goooo nonnos!!!!! read more

Our favorite local pizza! The dough is delicious, never soogy pizza and they have a great grandma. The eggplant roll is definitely worth a try! read more

Placed an order with them and the food came an hour and 35 min later..cold and incomplete...called back spoke to tony and was told he will bring the rest right away...almost 1.5 hrs later NOTHING! Will never ever order food from this place again. read more

Good go to place for lunch. Pizza is generally good when ordered to eat there but when picked up its sometimes burned on the bottom. Escarole soup & chicken rolls are always great. read more

A go-to lunch spot! Everything is good but I like their square slices the best. Really flavorful! Hits you with garlic, Parmesan, pesto in all the right ways. Delicious read more

Great pizza. Not too thick or greasy. Great meats and veggies. Fast delivery. Best pizza I had in my short stay in the Bay Ridge area!