WOW! The pizza here is delicious and the ambience is so cozy…read more You order at the counter here but there is plenty of booth and table sit-down seating. The decor is so cozy, it reminds me of my grandmas house in here haha, I love it. My partner and I split a pizza and it was plenty of food for the both of us. I also got a diet root beer , which is typically pretty hard to find so I loved that. We only waited maybe 10-15 mins for our order. Definitely recommend checking this place out!!

We went to Barnaby's around noon on a Friday and it was fairly busy. Our first surprise was that…read morethere is no table service. I ordered and paid for two small pizzas at the counter, and learned I had to go to bar for drinks. The same cashier came over to take my drink order, where I paid separately. In about 15 minutes, our pizzas were ready at the counter: One with only cheese, and the other with sausage. We immediately noticed the ruffled-edge crust, which looked more like a pie for dessert. We both took a bite of each pizza, and immediately disliked the cornmeal crust. It tasted to me like it was made from Jiffy corn muffin mix, with a cardboard-like hardness. My wife disliked it so much she barely ate one small piece of pizza. I liked their cheese and sauce, and especially liked the sausage. I managed to eat two pieces thinking I'll give it a chance, but hated that crust so much I couldn't eat a third piece. There are plenty of other items on their menu other than pizza, which are the only things we will consider for any future visit. The dining room is large with a dark, traditional wood decor. Parking is free in their own lot. Having no table service, other than cleaning tables, logically results in a tip and cost savings. Now that I know this is how Barnaby's operates, I am not down-voting them based on service.

(4.25) ~ Very good overall food & service…read more DRINKS: ** Pinot Noir (De Bon) = (4.35) Very good ** Doppio Espresso = (4.25) Very good, comes w. rock candy;) ** Water (tap) = (4) very good FOOD: ** Prosciutto E Rucola (white pizza) = (4.35) Very good ** Sausage & Peppers = (4.25) Very tasty & shareable ** Bufalino D.O.P. = (4.25) Very good ** Cookie Dough Gelato = (4.25) Very tasty

When here at 5 PM on a weekday. Not too busy, but still fairly loud (maybe due to the high…read moreceilings?) First, I want to say that our server, Esteban, was excellent. So the food was decent, the majority of them were overly oily. The main problem, however, was that three out of the four of us received our food in a timely manner, while my daughter waited endlessly for her entrée. It finally came to the table when the rest of us were almost finished eating our meals. This is not an acceptable practice.

Recently I visited Chicago for the 1 st for any length of time. This pizza is incredible. 35…read morebillion dollars of art at the institute or Lou's pizza toss up as to what is better.

Very appalled with this location…read more They can't follow simple instructions to have an over $40 pizza UNCUT. They also don't use their own drivers all the time like you think as they've given in to DoorDash which makes things worse! Imagine spending more over $25 for a pizza then with delivery fees and tips over $15 I'll be taking my over 40+ years of business elsewhere even as a local resident of Northbrook BUYER BEWARE

I traveled a long way from California once a year to eat at this restaurant the food,wine , and…read moreservers are awesome !! Thank you all for filling my belly with some of the best Italian food I have eaten. Hats off to the mangers, who actually come to your table and share in your experiences ! This place is above the rest ! Delicious 1/2 chicken and lemon sauce with salad and bruschetta Wine and desserts were awesome

If there is one place on EARTH that I could eat at all the time it would be this place! I requested…read moreMickey she is one of the very best servers anywhere and I've been to 11 countries ! Frank the owner even remembered I have Severe Genetic Food Allergies and omitted what I cannot eat, without me mentioning it ! All the staff are WARM , Friendly , and Fast ! Even the Busboy is very Professional ! This place is Cozy and Romantic . The Food is made to order and fresh , just like my Body Desires . Thank you Frank for giving our Community Superb Meals that even someone like me can truly appreciate repeatedly. Most places I stick to what I know will not give me a Histamine Reaction, but I took a chance with the Lasagna and was very Glad . It was perfectly seasoned and a huge portion . Leave room for Dessert it's worth it !

I just love Piero's! Their service is great and everything on the menu fantastic…read more If you're not in the mood for pizza I'd highly recommend their Italian beef sandwich.

I held on for over 5 minutes Someone answered & then…read moredisconnected me my order would have been well over $100.00 I can't believe how she hung up on me twice

I went here a while back, but pizza was exactly as I imagined. The deep dish was nice and this and…read morehad a complexity of layers too it which I haven't had before. The thin crust was also good and toppings paired well with the dough. The guy taking our order was nice and patient with us tourists lol. Would recommend a try!

Absolutely delicious and must try when in Chicago!…read moreDefinitely recommended the lunch special , best deal in the city!! Service was a little slow but no need to rush when there is a hell of a meal in front of you.

My friend and I were in the search of pasta on our way home (Kenosha) from Chicago. We had a hard…read moretime since most restaurants were expensive but this one grabbed our attention because of the prices. We came on a Sunday evening and it was relatively slow, our server was amazing! She made us feel welcomed and cared for! The food was delicious. I got the eggplant parmigiana, and my friend got the spaghetti. We also ordered some mozzarella sticks that were amazing! We will definitely be coming back to try their pizza!

This establishment has gone down in terms of food quality and service. I was extremely…read moredisappointed. I want to support local businesses, but the last few times we ordered the food was subpar, and whoever is answering the phone and taking orders is one of the most rude and unfriendly people I have ever dealt with. Whoever owns this restaurant really should take a look at the customer service and the quality of food and how it is delivered. I will not be giving my money to this business ever again.

It's been a while since we have ordered pizza from Judy's. We used to love their pizza, something…read morehas changed, the ingredients are not the same. The crust was totally different from the past. It used to be thin and crispy and the flour was noticeably high quality. The crust on the recent pie was thicker, pre fabricated and had a totally different texture. The sauce was different and the cheese not the same quality. It was just an average pizza. Absolutely nothing was the same. Carry out pizza is now expensive and for $30 for a large I'm going to be more selective.

Some of the best pizza around! Will is great! Brought pizza…read moreinto the new place next door because it's much better than theirs....

Wanted one last pizza before we left Chicago and damn I'm glad we stopped here. Steve was awesome,…read moresuper friendly and one of the best pizzas we had while we were visiting Chicago, and we went to a lot of popular ones. Great place to stop by for takeout of dine in.

Great food! Great service! Great atmosphere! Just a little location with maybe ten tables. Felt…read morelike I was returning home to mom for dinner. Even had a great visit with the owner and a couple of the employees that gave great recommendations for when we were in downtown Chicago. I'd go again the next time I'm in the area.

Kind and friendly service and we loved our pizzas (The Best is Yet to Come and a build -your-own…read morewith lots of topping options)! Had a salad too, fresh greens. We will definitely be back.

This place is amazing! I had lunch there with my girlfriend who is a real foodie and we both had a…read moregreat experience. The ambiance is very comfortable and the service is amazing with everyone checking in on you throughout your meal to make sure everything is good. When it comes to the pizza, wow, just incredible. I can't wait to return and talk to Tony the gracious owner again.