Once again this place does not disappoint. The pizza is a true NY style pizza. The cheese is fresh and the sauce has a decent spice. Their garlic knots are incredible and a must have in addition to your meal. They are not over powering but the garlic and butter saturate the bread making it a soft tasty treat. The staff here is always friendly and accommodating. Their options on the menu are diverse and will fit any Italian desire. Tuesday's are the best for buy one specialty and get a cheese pizza for free. Beer specials are always a great compliment to great food as well! This is a must stop when in Orlando. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

On our first day of arriving to Orlando. We ordered a large pie and on the second day we went back for more items such as the calzone and margherita pizza. Everything was delicious. Can't wait to dine in as all the other times we had ordered out. I have no pictures but I will take them next time I go. read more

See all

This place deserves 5 stars ACROSS THE BOARD. I haven't had pizza this good since I was physically in New York City years ago. Put it this way- the pizza is so damn good that I saw multiple people (me included) eating on top of their cars in the parking lot, because they couldn't wait to have a slice. I felt like I was always on a never-ending journey for "the best NY-style pizza" in Orlando for such a long time... And now, I can finally rest and quit stressing... because I've finally found it. My only stress now is that I have to work out more to compensate for all of the pizza I will be eating from NYPD. read more

Found NYPD Pizza while visiting Orlando, thought would be a good spot. Turned out to be great. Found it very easy in the plaza a plenty of parking. Got sat immediately. Had an amazing server, she was super nice. Food was very good. Loved their chicken wings (with bone). Pizza was so yummy. Loved the crust and dough a lot. Did remind me slightly of NY style pizza. If we come back to Orlando we will stop by again. read more

See all

As soon as I walked through the door, the hostess was very rude when I asked if they serve slices or just a whole pizza. I ordered a cheese personal size pizza and when I ate it,it literally was flavorless and barely had any sauce on it. It basically tasted like flavorless cheese bread. The only reason I ate it was because I was starving other than that I would as for a refund. For this pizzeria to call themselves a "NY" style pizza is a total embarrassment and it's disrespectful to real NY pizza. I'm from NY so I know what good pizza is and what I was served was trash. The wings were ok. I ordered half mild and half garlic butter, there was barely any sauce on either one. This place needs better hostess, the waitress was nice and they need to work on making their food taste better. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

I was in Orlando for a week with a group of friends and we ordered pizza from here twice! I really enjoyed it and was able to reheat slices in the air fryer, extremely pleased with the quality of cheese and Meats. read more

Decent pizza, less is more with this place stick to cheese or pep. Mariana sauce not worth it, if you want a side sauce just got ranch.

Staff was nice but fairly inexperienced. Pizza was good. Good toppings OK crust. Wings were delicious, and had great flavor. Beer was cold. And this location's owner had husker memorabilia behind the bar. GBR. read more

A few years ago I came here with my parents and had the convict calzone. (Dad was a cop ). Dad has since passed. I came today with my husband and had the calzone again. It was just as good as I remember and even better. I plan to come here each time I'm in the Orlando area. Edit: I forgot to tell y'all that the leftover calzone I took with me to the airport last time was lost! I laid it down while we waiting to go through security and I left it! I was so upset! A return was absolutely necessary! read more

**beware** if you place online order. The pickup time can be 30 minutes to one hour longer. They cannot add the word "estimated"to the time listed for pickup; of course that would mean no online orders. Otherwise food is good but don't expect good customer service. That's a bad word read more

Visiting from Indiana (during COVID ), and we chose delivery from NYPD pizza. There was a minor discrepancy in the delivery times - I was told it'd be 25 minutes (wicked fast, but possible, right?)... I called them after an hour and was informed I was told wrong but that the pizza would arrive shortly. It did. We ordered two 14" pizzas - one pepperoni, one Hawaiian add BBQ sauce and 1/2 with jalapeños. As well as an order of garlic knots. We are suckers for good pizzas- especially on vacation. This one met our expectations and then some. Delicious. Would order again, if only there was one in Indiana near our place read more

As close to pizza as we've found in fla. Very good and quick. Felt like I was in upstate NY

MUST EAT PIZZA SPOT!!!AMAZING PIZZA! If your in the area you gotta try this place.Their pizza is to die for! Authentic NY pizza, great customer service. They delivered to our hotel! read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

We made a quick stop here after volunteering at the convention center. They provided good take out service. They were running a special for Pizza, Garlic Knots, and 2 Liter. It was ready in 20mins. The pizza is good but the garlic knots was missing authentic garlic and butter taste. The customer service Good and quick. Once my order was ready and I went to the counter to pick it up they opened up the boxes to confirm my order options. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

It didn't fill me so much which i liked as pizza tends to leave me filling guilty and stuffed. The crust was perfect. read more

NYPD Pizza - meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

The Hotel I'm staying at is filled with cheerleaders and a bunch of people, and all the restaurants are booked to the max, to say the least. I searched up nearby pizza restaurants, and came across NYPD Pizza. I got a Large Pizza, Mozzarella Sticks and Cannolis! So far, it all tastes amazing, and delivery was easy and smooth. Delivery time was a bit tad, but I don't blame them. It's a busy time. Nonetheless, great service and delicious food! read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Hands down one of the best pizza places I have ever been to. It definitely is authentic ny style! The staff is kind and attentive. The vibe is amazing and it made me miss my hometown in Brooklyn. I definitely will be coming back again! read more

Really authentic NY style pizza, very tasty with plenty of cheese and toppings. The only thing missing was the NY water, which makes a thin lighter crust. read more

We tried this place on a whim leaving Orlando. Not only were there people waiting outside for them to open, but service was quick. I got the unsweetened tea, French onion soup, Little Italy antipasta salad, and Patrolman's Pepperoni roll. My husband got the wedding soup and 10" Rustica Salsiccia pie. The best tea I have had in Florida... period. The cause that came with roll was fantastic. Great flavor and nice and thick. The roll was crunchy crust not under baked like some places. Everything was fabulous! We will definitely come back to this place when in Orlando again. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

VERY MID... we only ordered pasta Togo(Uber eats) so maybe the pizza is good but we didn't get to try it. I liked that you could taste the garlic but it was over peppered and lacked extra sauce. Scarce amount of chicken in it too. Garlic knots were good though! I could've chosen many other places to try a nice Alfredo sauce and I wish I did while I visited Orlando. Wouldn't recommend, maybe the pizza would've sold me... pasta didn't. They also forgot our side salad. read more

The regular slice had decent flavor but a little dry. You can't buy all kinds of pizza by the slice; Only regular, and you have to tip a waiter because you can't order at the counter and sit down. Not very "NY style" if you ask me. read more

NYPD Pizza - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Hate to give this such a low rating because they seem like their heart is in the right place. But two big problems: No cell service -- none. And no customer wifi. The management could resolve this by paying for wifi service but they don't. Penny wise and pound foolish. Also -- sadly -- this place has been Bidenized more than others. Not enough staff to do the work. We saw one server for the whole dining room. People waiting for a hostess to even inquire about wait time -- finally left after five minutes and no greeting by anyone. What a shame. When government pays people not to work for a year, good help is hard to find. And this place is struggling because of it. But customers are the biggest losers. read more

Great pizza. Great menu. Great service. This review is too short to post so I'll add this sentence to put it on. read more

We were here tonight because we're from out of town & we're hungry. As one of our family members said, he'd give this 1000 stars! We had two pizzas: one cheese & one vegetable pizza that came super quick and the crust and toppings were delicious! Service was great! Excellent place! read more

Yummy little spot. With the wait. We ordered 4 difference pies and all yummy. Grey at to bring back to hotel pool and enjoy after a day in the parks. read more

Stopped by here looking for a good NY style pizza joint to check out. Saw the reviews and thought I'd check it out. My girlfriend and I walked in and were greeted with a warm welcome and were shown to our table. Interior is decorated with NY type signs photos, and various other décor. A bit cheesy for me (no pun intended). I don't know why, but I kind of dislike when NY style pizza joints over do it with NY touristy décor and i'm FROM Queens. I The staff here are really attentive and friendly. We are simple when it comes to pizza we ordered a plain ol' classic cheese pie. Pie came out relatively fast and was hot and fresh. We both enjoyed our meal. I have no complaints about the pizza but to be completely honest... Nothing to write home about. This place deserves 3.5 stars. 5/5 for service. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Dear NYPD Pizza. Come to Houston. We need you. The perfectly baked foldable thin crust, flavorful sauce, and delicious quality toppings... the wings. Omg the garlic parm and mango habanero wings well done were f'n on point! Followed by a perfectly made slice of pizza heaven - meat lovers & supreme ( extra sauce). even your random fried pickles were friggin delicious! Random bc I didn't expect fried pickles on a pizza place menu. Anyway- EASILY the best meal I had my entire weekend in Orlando! Good price too. So again, my dearest NYPD pizza. Come to Houston. Please and thank you. read more

I wouldn't categorize this as NY style pizza. NY style pizza is know for its crust and dough, this pizza does not have that flavor at all. We ordered a veggie pizza and the veggies were under cooked. The pizza was super bland, literally no flavor and the sauce was not memorable. The slices are also pretty small. Imo, there was nothing outstanding about this pizza other than the fact that it is not anywhere near NY style unfortunately. I am open to the idea that it could be just this location and hopefully the others are better. We weren't satisfied here. However, the staff was nice! read more

Nice team ! Great pies! I went with half meat lovers and what would be a supreme! Good stuff! I'll come back!

Found this pizzeria through yelp and so happy I decided to try! Greeted by friendly staff. There's the option of pizza by the slice, but we decided to get a whole pie - especially when we found out you can split the pizza half and half for any toppings. Garlic knots - Melted butter and garlic covered the top, easy to pull apart, and the epitome of comfort food. It was hot right out of the over and served with marinera sauce. Absolutely mouthwatering. Manhattan meat lovers - it was completely covered with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon. Very hearty and filling! If you're feeling hungry and ready to eat, this might be a good one to try. Buffalo chicken - now this was my favorite! Especially because of the blue cheese drizzled on top. This is probably the best buffalo chicken pizza I've ever had and I'd come back to town just to try this. Overall, friendly staff and delicious pizza! Loved it read more

NYPD Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Pretty good pizza! They were on the list of places that delivered to our hotel at the convention center so we gave them a shot. We ordered a cheese pizza, a Margherita pizza and an order of fried pickles. Everything is priced pretty low so that was a nice surprise. Delivery was super quick! Everyone was friendly. And the pizza itself was pretty tasty. The margherita pizza wasn't quite what I'm used to; normally, it's chopped tomatoes, basil, mozzarella and olive oil. This one was more of a tomato sauce, instead of the tomatoes. It's different but it was still good and I ate the darn thing! The pickles were the winners though! Mmmm so good! Excellent batter and the sauce that comes with, so good. Spicy! But good. We are saving the name of this place for the next time we stay in Orlando! read more

See all

My friends and I loved the pizza and the strawberry cheesecake! I highly recommend this place! read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Gross! This is the furthest from authentic NY pizza. The food is overly greasy with its over spiced sauce from a can. If you like cafeteria style pizza and Italian food then you will enjoy this place. Orlando is famous for the worst food in Florida. With a total tourist and transient population there really is no incentive to have good quality food. Go to Publix next door and grab a sub instead. read more

We recently had a delivery order from this location. We had a buffalo chicken pizza and a pepperoni pizza along with teriyaki nuggets in addition to buffalo chicken nuggets. Everything was quite tasty. read more

I've had NYPD many times but I decided to stop in and get a couple of slices to go before work today. So here's how to-go works by the slice: they have a designated slice of the day or you can get a cheese slice which you can add whichever toppings to. I can't wait to order a full alfredo pizza next time I come in. It was today's slice of the day and was so perfect!! Also noteworthy-the staff is excellent and very friendly. I can't wait to go back to this location. Thanks NYPD for a yummy lunch! read more

See all

We were wanting pizza and we had just been shopping for groceries so we needed something rather quick that would allow us to get back to our timeshare and enjoy a night in due to the rain in the area. This place is on the short list to visit again. I wanted a meat pizza but the family likes the Margherita Pizza so I ended up with their sausage roll (with green peppers and onions in it) and my family got their Margherita Pizza. Cost wasn't bad and the product is very good. The pizza is chewy crust end to end (versus the crispy crust you sometimes get) and they use a nice cheese on the pizza. They key is if I would go again - yes, not tonight but maybe tomorrow. read more

Absolutely love this place garlic knots and tomato sauce was amazing. The meat lovers was superb. I've never been to New York but I'd say this has to be close to the real thing couldn't be much better. read more

NYPD Pizza - Meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

The best place for a quick lunch pizza slice deals and always nice staff. I used to live in NY and its always great to walk in and get a Pizza by the Slice this is the closest you will get unless you live DT. Hey its good ambiance, bar, chairs, booth and also great lunch pasta specials. Pizza is NY style of course and I love my cheese pizza Margherita Pizza no complain great quality. Also Its nice for family, kids, they do take out. Mozzarella sticks, chicken strips, Garlic Rolls & Alfredo Pizza. Used to has lunch here before covid once a week! read more

*Pizza snob rating* I came in here to get my pizza fix on a Saturday. I was in the area and had Yelp guide me to a place with decent reviews. I ordered a 10 inch veggie pie. The presentation was unimpressive. I tend to be particular about my pizza. Maybe not so much but I have a low tolerance for pies where the mozzarella cheese does not bake in mix with the sauce. None of that golden/oranging color you get when the cheese and sauce mix. The cheese flavor stood out separately from the sauce. Definitely not what I would consider a 'New York slice,. I digress.. What I did like about the place is that they sell personal pies with a price point of a Blaze Pizza (except Blaze is definitely better). They also sell slices which is also a treat. The staff was friendly and they were quick with my order. read more

My friends and I ate at NYPD the other evening. We sat on the patio as we had a puppy with us. We were greeted and ordered our drinks. Our server came to take our food orders. We started with the garlic knots and ordered our pizzas! The garlic knots came out and they were so good! About 10-15 minutes later, all of the pizzas arrived (a 10", 14" and 18"). They were delicious and a nice portion. I ordered the Carnegie Hall Chicken Club Pie. It had the perfect amount of chicken, bacon and toppings! My mouth is watering just thinking of that. Service was good but seemed a little slow. I would go back to NYPD for their pies! read more

See all